Skip to main content
Loading video...

Accidental Heroes Review - You Never Intended to be a Role Model...and You're Still Not!

Transcript 12:30

Hey, I'm Alex from Board Game Co, and today I'm reviewing Accidental Heroes from Lucky Duck Games. Accidental Heroes is a one-to-four player adventure game in which players are going on adventures trying to slowly build up their characters, get more powerful, roll more dice before ultimately accomplishing their quest to find the various dragon eggs. This is a prototype. All of those components are subject to change, and I'll have a link to the crowdfunding campaign down below. Also, this channel is sponsored by All Play, more with them at the end of the video. In Accidental Heroes, you are going to be playing through an app-assisted game. I'm going to kind of show you how to play by just doing things. It's that quickly. You can also check out a sponsored play-through we did on the channel as well if you want to see a full game play run through. I should note on that note, this review is not sponsored, but we did do a sponsored game play. If that muddies the water for you, completely understand. Just want to make sure you have the information. With that said, we're going to go ahead and start off. We're going to play a new game over here. We're going to choose a character. We're going to continue off over here. New game and Accidental Heroes. Okay. We'll put Alex and Alex for character one.

Done and then done and then character two will be Alex two because that's simple enough to do. We'll have that for character two. And then we've created our characters. It's now my turn. I can pass my phone or giant tablet in this case to the player to the left. Where would I like to go? So, on this map, I'm going to go ahead and take my character, Alex over here, and I'm going to move. I can move up to two spaces, and I can pass through market spaces as well if I want to, which will allow me to buy from this market over here using the money I started the game with or got along the way. In this case, I'm going to go ahead and let's move to this spot up here. So, I'm going to go one, two into that location. Then I'm going to grab my app over here, and I'll go ahead and click that I went to that location, and I'm going to draw from the bag. I'm going to draw a token, and we're going to put it out, and it's number 10 over here. We're going to put it down on the board, putting out our number 10. It might go away quickly. We'll see because we're going to return to the app, punch in 10, and then see what happens. On a hill near a village, an old mounted knight is passionately poking a windmill wall with his lance. His squire, accompanied by the miller and his wife, are trying to pull him away. "I desire not one windmill within a league of my home," the knight exclaims, his voice trembling with righteous fury. "It is a monstrous blight upon the land. It frightens the fowls. Green energy, my donkey." It's a knight fighting against a windmill. This might be familiar to you. I can help pull the knight away from the windmill.

Convince the miller and his wife to build a water mill instead of windmill, or join the knight in obliterating the windmill. In this case, because I'm starting off early in the game, I haven't really built up a lot of things yet. So, I'm going to look at my player board. I only have two strength, meaning I roll two dice over here. So, I'm going to go ahead and help pull the knight away from the windmill, needing a success value of two. I'm going to go ahead and roll the dice, and I got three on this dice. I managed to achieve that. Two, by the way, is hard to fail. It's doable. It is harder to fail with two. Uh you're almost certainly going to pass it, but almost certainly is not a guarantee. So, I achieved the success over here. Help pull the knight away from the windmill. Let's tap on that. I passed. "I protest," the knight storms, "while you and while you and the squire pull him off the horse. I shall be back by tomorrow." "Yep, sure will," the miller's wife shakes her head. "Not a week can pass by without him poking around at least once." "Forgive my lord," starts the squire apologetically. "He's a good man, albeit passionate. I'm constantly pulling him out of hot water.

Take some gold for your troubles." We're going to go ahead and move up on our god god tracks. We're going to move up over here. This should be over there. It's in the wrong spot. We're going to move up our Yugaiya. Uh and then we're going to go additionally we're going to move down. We're going to move Yugaiya up two, actually. So, we're going to be able to go ahead and uh roll a die, you'll see in a second. And then we're going to move Loki down one. These are the various god favors. Because we hit one of those white cubes over there, we are going to roll a stat check over here, and we go ahead and we're going to bump up our sword fighting over here. So, we're going to find a three on this board, and we're going to update our two sword fighting skill to a three sword fighting skill. We are slightly better at our uh sword fighting, or just combat, melee, than initially. We're going to take $2 as consolation. Wait, I thought I succeeded. Wait, why is it consolation? That seems like a mistake over there. So, I'll take $2 as well.

You generally get $2 for failing tests. So, maybe the constellation is I didn't really achieve my goals there, but I still did that. The knight is still on the board. Very often, certain interactions will leave a character still on the board that others can interact with if they go there. Other interactions will have you solely getting rid of characters as you accomplish what that character is trying to do in this story. That's the basic arc. I'd now pass to Alex 2. We go back and forth at taking our turns. The goal of what you're trying to do is eventually trying to get up to a point where you can go ahead and move to a spot like this, and then you can interact with one of these challenging tests. I need 12 over here. 12, that's a big step up from two, which means I'll have to upgrade my player boards. I'll have to make this much stronger player board as far as whatever attribute I'm testing, gather a bunch of equipment from the market, and use a bunch of other tools at my disposal in order to power up when you're trying to accomplish those goals. Once you've accomplished two of those uh challenges, which are how you get the dragon eggs, and you have to do them at different locations because different locations test your different attributes. So, it's not good enough to be good at one thing.

If I'm good at uh my strength over here, I can go over here, but I'll still have to be good at either my uh weapons or my my intelligence in order Well, weapons or intelligence in order to accomplish those things because I'll need to accomplish two different quests at those locations in order to get the two dragon eggs and win the game. That is how you play through Accidental Heroes. You're going on missions. You're You're You're guided by the app as far as the stories that will be told. Each character has a different story depending on the location that they're at. This knight over here might have a different location and a different story if it's encountered in a forest. And so, you do have different degree of gameplay experiences you can mix into. I believe the prototype I have right now has 15 different characters times five different types of locations for 75 different types of encounters, and each of those, again, have multiple different choices as far as ways they can resolve, passes, fails, different options. And I believe the final game will have much more as well. This is just a prototype, but eventually, go on your missions, accomplish your goals until you get to the end of the game and someone wins.

Which brings me brings me brings me to my review of what I like, don't like, and can see others not liking. Starting off with what I like. It's easy to get into. I mean, you just watched a kind of how to play and you know 95% of what you need to know. Uh when you pass through a market, you're going to be able to go ahead and buy and sell goods to the market. You're also going to have special cards you can get from various quests. You're going to have quests that have you placing tokens on the board for you to go ahead and wander and explore. There's a few small other things you have to know, but you know most of what you need to play and if you watch our gameplay, you'll know everything you need to play. It's a very easy game to get people into, get people up and started. For sure if you know what's going on, you can get your friends into it by just starting to play. It is that simple and straightforward. The app integration does not overwhelm the experience. I am very critical of app integrated games. As much as I think that they can add a lot to a game system, I think they can take you out of the tabletop experience and so games for me, I'm very picky. I don't think they're the worst. I I think that I often have a lot of fun with app integrated games, but more often than not if a game relies on an app, I feel that's a step backwards rather than a step forwards. This game, I am kind of neutral on it. I still I'm very It takes a lot for me to be positive on app and app integration. Things like like One Night Ultimate Werewolf, I'm positive about that. Something like this, I'm neutral on because I still don't like having a phone or tablet at the table, but I do respect the simplicity of the interactions they give you. They give the story. The gameplay's on the table.

The story's in the app and having that level of of accessibility by flipping through cards or rule book, I just don't think you'll get. So, I think they did a great job with the app integration to the point that I'm at least not negative on it, which is a uh which is an achievement when it comes to app integrated games. Although, everyone's different. If you don't mind app integrated games, then I would say this is probably positive. It's that good as far as what it does, what it adds to the game. The various adventurers and progress you make, there's a lot of different ways you can build up your character from the various pool of cards you can get, from the way you can buff up over here, from the way you're moving up the god tracks to go ahead and get more. There's also going to be different degrees of challenges you can go on and again, prototype. I wonder how much you're going to be in the final game, but there's a decent amount of challenges. There's going to be different decent amount of quests. Like quests are the thing that I probably have seen the least of. There's so many quests. I don't even know how you unlock them all. I've only encountered a handful of those quests.

There's so many, so I wonder what I'm missing as far as the experience goes, but there's a lot of of experience that not experience, a lot of things you can encounter in this game, both gameplay aspects as far as ways to buff up your character, and ways you can build a nice stuff. You can build a good combination of cards. You are limited on how many cards you can hold on to. You can have five cards, but you can build a good combination of five cards that really allows you to do a lot, to be good at those one or two main things, main skill lines that you're trying to work on in order to accomplish the game. So, it's a high degree of accessibility, easy to get into, well-integrated app, and overall just a good time that gives you a decent amount of variability along the way. As far as things I don't like in the game, there's really not that much to criticize. The biggest things I'll say is that this very much does feel like a beer and pretzels game. As much as there's a lot of fun to it, it's mostly run around, uh make choices, roll dice.

There's a lot of luck in the game, uh but as far as it's mostly just build up your character with simple stuff and do stuff until you win. I don't think this is a game that feels very deep. It feels like a very accessible game to go ahead and get into. The other criticism I'll give is I don't like that there's kind of no middle ground. It's easy or hard, not a lot of middle ground. I mean, you can do this test like that two over there. That two is super easy. You will almost always pass the two. I don't think I've ever failed one. As you move up to like the four and the five, like those are a drop more challenging. I think it even goes up to maybe six. I There may have been sevens. I don't recall. I think it's like two through six is the basic starting point. And then once you get past those quests, you go straight into having, you know, nine through 15 on these main core challenges you're trying to achieve. So, you kind of do this arc of I need to power up a little bit to be able to accomplish the fives and sixes, but then after that there's a big gap between when you hit those nine, 10s, 12s. I think the the the the way the game gives you so many different app-integrated encounters, I don't think it would have been the hardest to have a different degree of tiers. Like, sure, have a two, four, and six, but you also could have an eight or a nine, something else in the app that gives you a higher chance of failure, but more rewards. I think that would have given more to the game experience.

I wish there was more of a solid middle ground of difficulty, not just the easy batch of tests, and then the hard batch of tests. I think they could have done more, especially because of the app integration. As far as making the others not like in the game, it's app-driven. As much as I am critical on app-driven games, I don't hate them. If you really hate app-driven games, this definitely has an app in your face. I think it does a good job of adding to the experience instead of taking away from the experience. But, if you are really, really critical, this is still a game that you might want to pass on. And also, I mentioned already, there's a lot of luck in the game. There's luck of the encounters, luck of the dice, choosing a character, being really good at two different attributes, and having the person that you actually encounter that can have their easy test, which has less rewards, being the attributes you're good at, and the hard test are things you're not good at. There's luck on who you encounter, there's luck on the dice you roll, there's luck on the cards you get. There's a decent amount of luck, and especially those final challenges. Some of those final those final challenges over here, they often have you giving something up, not all of them. Some of them have you giving something up before you roll, and you still might fail.

That's a kind of sucky feeling to give something up to to still fail. It's not the best, especially when you're going for that, you know, really hard challenge you're trying to accomplish. So, if you don't like those small little negative moments, this game can have them. As far as final thoughts on Accidental Heroes, it's an easy and accessible game. I do not think this will be a game for any for everyone for a variety of reasons. But, I do think they did a great job with charming art, easy to get into, easy app integration, rule set's very light, the fun factor and the adventure factor is decently high. The variability of what and how you'll encounter both from gear and characters, story elements, all of that's fun. The the callouts to various geek culture, all of that's very solid. All around, this is a game that doesn't necessarily wow me on the strategic aspect, but did a great job on everything else as far as what the game does. For me, I'm going to come in at a 3.5 out of 5. As far as other game recommendations, games that are similar as far as that easy to get into factor, that cutsey art, all those things, well, I mean, there's actually two recommendations here. One's going to be a little more that, one's less so. But, check out Boss Fighters QR for you're looking for another game that will also have app integration. I think they did a great job as well. That's more of a boss fighting game as opposed to adventure game, but I think they did a great job as far as that accessibility, fun factor, and also the difficulty and building out your characters. And if you're looking for an adventure game, that's my favorite adventure game. I think my favorite adventure game. I'll have to check, but probably. Uh The Witcher: Old World is definitely going to be a large step up from this, but if you're like, I like what this game is doing, but I want a lot more agency and a darker tone, The Witcher: Old World will deliver that to you. I mentioned at the beginning that All Play is a channel sponsor. If you go to allplay.com, you can find a variety of games from a variety of publishers. The one I'm going to mention today is Rolling in

Wonderland. Rolling in Wonderland is another game that kind of checks that Baron Pretzels fun game, cartoony style, lots of fun things happen as you go in a variety of different areas and try to uh compete with the other players. If you like that cartoony style and just want a fun, easy to get into game, highly recommend Rolling in Wonderland. In any case, until next time, I'm Alex Radcliffe from Board Game Co. I hope you enjoyed this video, and as always, I hope you have a good one.

Progress saved