Anno 1800 PC Game VS Board Game - A Quick Comparison
Transcript
i know 1800 board game versus the pc game coming up
hi it's tyrone and stella from nipple university so today we are going to make a little bit different video we are yes we are going to talk about the board game and or 1800 but i'm particularly me i'm going to talk a little bit more about the pc game because i have played annual 1800 pc games very popular which this board game is i believe is taken from the pc game based on the pc game yeah so the anno series of pc games little civilization building games sort of industrial civilizations um i believe that 1800 is the seventh in that series so it's a lot a long-standing series through various different eras 1800 came out a couple of years ago so it's set around that early industrial revolution going backwards sort of thing rather than you know there's like they had a couple of deep future ones and they had a couple of uh i think there was some renaissance era ones so this is 1800 early industrial revolution and yes they've taken that sort of free form open civilization building style of game and put it into this board game so in this video we are not going to talk about more the overview of android 1800 if you do want to watch that we have another video uh with our review and overview of anno 1800 board game in this video just comparison and if you really want to know even more of nr1800 1800 support game we
have how to play video i'll link it in the description below so taran you haven't played it have you played any civilization games um off online civilization not so much skyline i played city skylines a little bit um and i back in the old days i played a bit of transport tycoon those are probably the two games i've played that are your big open map did you play free form sort of thing did you play goat scene no that's a different one it's just a goat running around head butting things so this is i play like starcraft star wars sorry warcraft star wars i'm not world of warcraft because i try to stop myself from playing that it's gonna take a lot of my time um and then like less and less i play pc games now the board game so i play annual 1800 the pc games is probably not as much as um some of you out there already um and i want to share what i think so android 1800 civilization game you for those who have played civilization game you can probably expect the similar thing of building your civilization from building your your people the market the police station all the facilities around it and then you want to start advancing on the industry does it feel like the board game i think it has it captures a good feeling although the pc game is so much more complex but you don't expect that to happen in
the board game i think this actually simplifies everything um one this card on the board game this is the um what they call this the population card this is basically the population that you need to sacrifice the need of um in the pc games and you would build a particular industry so that your population grows um so this is a bit like that i feel um like your population you you know soap and coal or in in the pc games you would advance you know in order to advance from farmer to more advanced workers you need to accept it so make them happy and then they you can upgrade and then they can grow um so obviously slightly different you can't probably capture everything in the board game yeah that's it but that is sort of i mean it's one of the key things you're trying to do that's crazy game right is keep your population happy yes so you have to to grow and that's really your main way of getting points in this game as well is each population has its own couple of resources that it wants and when you satisfy that you will unlock that that population points so yeah it's all about getting the population and then satisfying their needs with industry that's correct and the advanced one needs more and more and more things you do need to build this in the pc game you need to build the industry you need the you know you need the correct goods and the correct amount of workers which
represents on the board game as well uh like this one unit would um it's actually skipping the forest free which is fine but also then there's wood here somewhere yeah and then there's weeds you know potato makes schnapps there what's the snaps over there over there yeah so this is snaps as well it's one of the basic things that you do um in earlier in your season stations um i feel the difference is that money so money i think in a in a pc game money um actually plays more part rather than here in here you can you know utilize it to make your workers more efficient but money in there you needed everything to build building like like maintenance money um you don't play your games right you can probably run other runs out of money you have to do quests as well to be able to earn money you can sell ships in the pc games to earn money which you can't actually do in here which i think it's got to be a good thing right i mean a board game with endless micro transactions yeah just frustrating it's what i don't like about monopoly that's right but it does have the exploring new world as well because in the pc game there are times where you can't get certain resources like the land is not fair to say fertile enough to make red pepper for example it's not red pepper in here so therefore in the board game there's
you know exploring the new world and then getting the resources that you usually can't get over here you can drive it freight with others um in the pc game there's a straight route agreement where you can start trading also earning money and that's actually captured well um like similarly in the board game yeah the trade is a critical part of this game you need to know what industries your opponents have made because you are going to be trading with them because you can't build everything and there's not enough tiles for you to build everything uh if you can pass me that cart list so um is um i will i don't know how you play quest is quite a major part at times like you know you want to do diplomacy with others and traits and get more money in this is probably the one that could represent that um as an endgame objective it's it's not really a quest sorry it is a um what is it it is objective in the board game their objectives and they'll give you extra points for certain types of things yeah which is that's that's how it works with board games as an part of things and the other thing is um this actually landed two different scenarios of the pc game so what's your scenarios you need to do this okay so you aim to a certain direction on the board game uh by looking at these objective cards which you know as you say earlier in the other video that it drives you towards certain strategy yeah and in same in the i guess
in a busy game where you you know drive certain strategies in there so these like i look very from everything's look familiar all the icons are lifted straight from ano 1800 it's the same heart yep um quite easy to play i think uh obviously there's a learning curve so i i went bankrupt on my first game because like i didn't know how to manage my money i was like oh yeah i can just build this this this but then went bankrupt that was the solo game by the way so it you know it's easy solo game unfortunately this one does not have solo variants i think so does with other martin wallace's game i don't think they i don't remember any with solo maybe they are maybe not maybe it's a fan base so yeah it does have that feeling of upgrading and then these populations um as well you need to yeah satisfy the need and that's really hard sometimes because it's easy to build but then you know when and you have to balance it you need this many workers to work in this so that you can produce enough goods to satisfy this population but then when you have said goods and then oh no no and then you need more population to actually it's kind of like the same thing like you need workers you need workers to actually activate the industry um you can also expand you can explore you will uh sorry old world and is it called old world yes and to expand to build more industries from so do you
think it captures that um do you think the board game captures that free-form world building vibe it does because it's similar you started with certain industries not in the in the busy game but um this helps you with you know telling you what basically you need with a pre-printed industry but apart from that it does capture with um it's more freeform where well actually it's it's kind of like it's more um it's similar it's kind of like though it's kind of like free form but kind of directed it's this one as well right you want to get the basic ones first and then directly to the more advanced one and then if you don't have it you trade it with other players as well so it does capture it in that way yeah i reckon it would be i reckon the first time you play you can sort of go really free form with it and just do stuff and see what scores points oh yeah i reckon once you know the game really well um it is largely a race to score the objectives because most of the other points will score in a pretty similar way yes it's a race to like take all the cards out of this deck because that's where points oh yeah i don't know if a high level multiplayer online anno 1800 pc game is like that it probably is i probably haven't played as much as i want to because i mean what's
fun about those online games is that it's a good way to sink seven hours of a lazy day yeah yes that's the thing like this will take probably like two hours to play well a two to three hour game yeah um and the yeah i guess the free falling is depends on the objective as well of of the pc game you play scenario or you play sandbox obviously you start with sandbox probably at the start you just want to see what's going on just learning the ins and outs of the game so i do like to play sandbox because it's like sims as well the sims video games and that sort of thing and sandbox is that style it just lets you have fun building something mm-hmm that's why we used to get given blocks and lego when we were yeah we all like building any like certain objectives so it doesn't capture i think it does capture pretty well obviously as terence say you cannot possibly capture every single one because pc game is quite complex to have something that that that's that open it would have to be a um a seventh continent style of yeah exploration and stuff but then you don't have this industrial center yeah you don't have that kind of like the feeling of getting this you know building your industry and workers workers inside and that maybe not as tight as this one but it is represented quite well in terms this is quite hard to get the right amount of workers it's like sometimes the industry and the pc gives oh this insufficient amount of wear
gears like again you'll never go bankrupt here though because there's always an action that lets you reset that's true bring all your workers back and ultimately that's i guess you you won't get into that permanent bind but you might end up resetting so much more often than your opponents that it leads to defeat so that's basically what i think so i would love to um hear as well what you think if you play the pc games i assume you play more than me please run the comment sections below i'm still playing that right now not very good at it i don't think it's it's you know it's very again it's it is i have that satisfying feeling of building civilizations um eventually maybe you can go to war trying to do a treaty with other players so let us know in the comment sections below and thank you so much for watching if you somewhat find this video useful please hit that like button and please consider subscribing to us that will be really helpful you can also hit the meeple in the corner there not karen's head but in the corner what um to help us hitting my head now no but they can like click their head nothing happens anyways i'm also on social media i hope someone clicked at that moment ah oh yeah okay instagram for my board games journey so hopefully i'll see you there as well and i will see you we will see you in our next videos bye