What Makes Dewan and Carnuta So HOT?
Transcript
Carnuda and Daywan are in the hotness right now. As of time that we're recording this, they're also on BGA. Uh if you pay attention to BGG at all, you'll notice these things have been on there for a few days. So Ryan and I were wondering why are they in the hotness? A lot of people ask themselves this question all the time is like, you know, you'll see a game in the hotness and then you go to the game and in the comments there'll be comments like why is this in the hotness?
Sure. Um, and there's a few reasons. Generally speaking, there's a few reasons. Some of those apply to this, but we wanted to talk a little bit about the games themselves because for the most part, these things aren't out. I think Dewan is out overseas potentially. I think it was maybe soft launched or at least demoed at Essen last year. Uh, but it's not yet out here. I think Carnude is coming out soon, like in the next month here in the States. Uh but uh the big answer to that question most of the time is is there a contest being run on BGG? And yes, in the case of Day One anyway, there is a contest being run that always spikes it because people want to win a copy of the game, right? Um but also with these two, I think they both pretty recently launched on BGA and we both have experience on BGA. You way more than me.
Sure.
Um but these got me interested because these are the kind of games that uh appeal to me. Well, first of all, Day One is designed by uh Johannis Goopy uh who did Far Away.
Sure.
Also a little game collect from Sean. Shameless plug. Um and it and I had a chance to play Carnuda actually behind closed doors last year at PAX which I liked. So I knew I was going to like that. Uh but Day One is an interesting game. So Ryan and I played it. I've played him a number of times on BGA now. and the games the game play backs up the fact that they are getting a spotlight in my opinion.
Well, I and I think we can't really ignore the the connection that BGA and BGG have as far as the big ven diagram of people who like us who do pay a lot of attention to BGG are probably among some of the biggest BGA players. So, I'll say first of all, if you want a chance of your new game getting on the hotness, throwing it out there to BGA and letting everyone play it and start talking about it to their friends. I mean, I've heard about Carnuda not just from you, but from people in other BGA centric discords and groups where they're, you know, discovering it maybe for the first time, even by accident. And then, yeah, the gameplay has to back it up because once somebody plays it on BGA, then they go, I want to start games with all my friends. I've had multiple people starting games of Carnuda with me since you taught it to me. I had two more people start games
really
within the last 24 hours of Carnuda randomly just started those games. So, I think that that that's a number one huge way of getting people talking about your game, at least for this size games, right? It it's maybe not the best for the giant 4Xs or some of the 4-hour long euros, but this is like the perfect style of game that you'd want to play on BGA.
Yeah, I think so, too. Uh they're very simple to play. They're not like lightning fast. They're not like over in the blink of an eye, but they don't overstay their welcome. I think both of them, like you said, uh you play it and oftent times you want to play again. Side note, I don't play as much BGA as Ryan. And I've largely had zero games on BGA going on at one time. Sure, maybe one, maybe two. Right now, I have like at least two games of Carnuda going.
Nice.
And at least three, if not four games of Daywan going. And I will say this, that's a lot.
It's a lot to process.
It's a lot to process when you're bound when you go when you log into BGA and it's your turn on all of those games and you have to check
the things that you like in day one. There's a lot of like, okay, uh, what was I working on? Oh, I need this. And it starts to get cloudy between the two games. You have to definitely check all your things because it's very easy for me anyway to go into a game and go, "What was Oh, I need to get on a red territory." And I've I've thankfully checked myself before I did that. But you could very easily do that and go, "Oh, this isn't that game. I'm not working on red territories."
Well, yeah. It's I mean, it's the designer of Farway, you said. And to me, it it gives me Farway vibes in that same way. It's it's very it's a different game, but if you're far away, you're you know, you're you're building out your tableau of icons and you're saying, "Okay, this scores icons." And actually, Carnuda does this a little bit, too, but it's like, "This scores a particular icon. How many of those icons do you have in your tableau?" Uh, Dewan almost flips it. It's like your goal is to collect a certain number of icons and those icons are out on a board, right? You're going to place your camps down to fulfill the requirements of these cards. So, if you have one game where you're like, "Ah, I remembered. I just needed one more desert." And then you go to log in and you're like, "I claimed the desert." And you look down at your display and say, "Oh, wait. I don't need a desert in this game." Like, it it has that same kind of feeling. Again, I don't want to say it's just like Far Away. But for me, I I almost when you said it was the same designer, I wasn't surprised though. I guess I can see that
the way that it kind of operates with uh the the the way that the card fulfillment works and you know when you get into those situations in Dewan where you're like I can fulfill multiple cards with you know with one camp or whatever it has that same kind of satisfaction that far away does.
Yeah. And just so to back up for a second to give you an idea if you're not familiar with the game what it is they want they call it I think an area placement game which I've never heard that term but that's what that's what they call it. Uh, in the game, everyone has a dashboard and there are going to be story tiles that you're going to get throughout the game. Everyone starts with one. And like Ryan's mentioning, those story tiles have these various icons on the bottom that you're trying to fulfill. Some of those icons are various territories. There's like four different colored territories that you can get where you're building these camps. And then other icons are little icons that are also out on this big map. It's kind of hex based, although the hex's are very oddly shaped hex's. Um, so on your turn, you're either taking cards from this display, you take two cards from the display side by side, and those cards almost in a ticket to ride sort of way will then allow you to do the other thing you could do on your turn instead, which is to place a camp.
And to place a camp, you're going to be using cards of the appropriate colors to connect from one camp you've already built to an empty space where you want to build your new camp. Yeah,
that is all you're doing. And then as you complete those story tiles, you're going to achieve things. You're going to be able to get more story tiles. You're going to be able to tuck some of those cards under your board. Um, and it is very satisfying. You could kind of slowly do each story tile and achieve them to score their points at the end of the game. Or you could really orchestrate things so that you kind of have them all cooking
and then towards the end make one move that gives you everything you need at once on all of them and get them that way. It's which is very very satisfying. And then also again I'm going to say it feels very similar to Far Away to me in certain it to the just to the point where I think if you really enjoyed Far Away which you did I think it makes sense that you would like this one too. I think it tickles some of the same parts of your brain where you're trying to build out these patterns. You're trying to collect these icons. You're just not doing it like Far Away. Use that timeline in an interesting way. And I think Dwan uses the board in an interesting way where the symbols you're trying to collect aren't necessarily all on your cards. It's funny. I find myself in a unique situation right now. I'm usually the one that's drawing connections between games and Ryan's going, "What? Those games are nothing alike."
This is the vibe I got from this.
And I find myself in every time you're saying, "I want to go back to Far Away." And I feel like people in the comments are going to go, "This is nothing like Far."
Maybe I would see what people say.
I hear what you're saying.
I'd be interested.
The other game, Carnuda, which is actually coming out sooner. This is a card game that I feel and this is I want to be careful like we were just comparing to Far Away because I don't want to bring up this game,
okay,
and have people go, "Oh, it's like that." But to me it is in if if you're a gamer who likes games like Splendor or like say Castle Combo which I know are two very different games but I think Carnuda pushes a lot of those same buttons because you're again it's a very simple game where you're either taking cards or you're playing cards and then manipulating some of the way things that you have. They're not really resources, but there's this method of playing your cards where you're having to flip over these little sun and moonstones that you have into your tableau. And then all those cards have various scoring elements on them. Like a card might give you an icon, but it also also might say and score two points for every one of this other icon. So then when you get more cards, do you get more of that icon so you can score it or try to build?
You're building all these scoring things which is very satisfying.
It is. Um, it's not like a race to a certain amount of points. You're really just trying to build as many scoring opportunities as you can. So, the drafting, there can be some, especially in a two-player game, you might look at the cards and go, "Oh, I can't let them have that." That's because it's like another six points for you to get that card, stuff like that. But it feels like I would say if you like games like Splender or if you like those quick snappy games where you're just kind of like boom boom boom, take cards because you can play this game way fast
and you're playing like 11 cards, right? you play 11 cards 11 cards in the game over.
I we so we've seen games kind of like this. We we've seen this idea before of taking a card and you have to kind of weigh this card scores a thing but also provides a thing and the thing that it provides might score for other cards and you're going to kind of have to balance that. I mean, I've seen that done before in other games and and I think that's a cool way to to balance scoring. But what I really like about this is what you just touched on a little bit. Suns
the sun and the moons. the the way that you're interacting with these res there's only two resources in the game, suns and moons, and they're double-sided. And some cards have you discard them, some cards have you flip them. And when you take actions, one of your actions could be to take a card, one of your actions could be to take all the suns from the discard pile or all the moons. So, you can get some really satisfying combos where you're like, I take the moons now. I have four moons. When I play this card, it flips all four moons to suns, which now means I can play this card that requires four suns. that kind of like planning and pulling off that kind of succession of turns felt very satisfying to me.
The other thing that's important to remember is you don't have unlimited number of those. Everyone starts with just four spaces for those stones. So, you can only have four and I think everyone starts with like two moons and two suns and then there are two additional spaces that unlock as you play your cards at like you know the third and the seventh card or something like that. So you could have a total of six of those stones at a certain point and you're just kind of like, okay, oh, I could take this card because it's easy to play. So what this does is it introduces yet another variable on top of like, do I want this for the resource or do I want it for the scoring or do I want it because I can just play it.
Yeah.
Like and then I'll figure out if there's another card I can use to score this thing because sometimes you're just wanting to try to piece together or at least I find myself doing that. It might not be the smartest play, but I'm like, "Oh, I'll take this card because I can play this. It'll flip my stones and then I can play the one that I've been wanting to play because otherwise you could burn like inefficiently play a little bit by spending one of your actions on your turn to flip all of your stones." That
sometimes feels like
a wasted turn, wasted action.
Kind of like a wa. I played with my wife the other night on BGA and I spent one of my actions to flip just one stone
so that it matches the other four that I had. That doesn't feel great. But otherwise, the game feels very rewarding.
I love those stones and and we said this like we've only played these games on BGA. They're not even out.
And I have not looked at Carnuda uh like what the production or presentation of this game is going to be like.
Oh, I've seen it. It's
Are the stones cardboard? Okay. See, that was my fear. If
the stones were like little, I don't know, like resin or plastic. I feel
I want That's what I want. I was afraid
engraved with color.
That's really cool.
Yeah. At least the the copy that I'd played, it was probably a prototype or pre-production,
but both games look really nice, and I think the artwork, too, is what draws me personally to it. These are like scream sort of French design to me. I don't know if they were all French designers. I know Dewan has a French designer. Uh I don't know about uh Carnuda, which is a I think Repost Productions game. Um but yeah, both are really appealing looking. And one of the things that uh Day One doesn't even have on BGA is uh this scenario content.
Oh, I haven't seen that at all.
Yeah, there the the actual game is going to have these scenarios where you can play cooperatively.
Oh, that's interesting. And there's some where like there's a volcano and certain things happen such that lava is spreading on the map which is kind of wild as well. Like I'm really excited to see where the game does.
Like if what we're just playing on BJ is just like a base level there there's a lot that you can stack on top of that game too. We were already talking about I mean that's another game that feels like it's infinitely expandable too.
Yeah. Well, honestly both of these you could have so much going on with these things. So yeah, we wanted to share today our experience playing it because I think that was our big takeaway. It's it's not often that you see games hitting the hotness and they're not even necessarily out yet other than like crowdfunding, right? These are not bigrow these are games that are just coming to retail. They're sort of very probably modestly priced games. These are not
small box hourong experiences. Yeah. Um, so we wanted to dive in and I also kind of wanted almost in a New Year's resolution sort of way to just play a little bit more on BGA. Do it. It's very very convenient way to play games and there's so many games on there. Not to mention,
my wife just quit Tik Tok recently.
Uh, she deleted the app. So, she's looking she's looking to fill the void of the doom scrolling. So, I said, "Oh, get on BGA." and we figured out how to like kind of load it on our phones so that it worked very nicely uh and gave notifications and everything like that. So, it's kind of filling that gap. So, she and I have been playing quite a bit.
Also, this is a little bit of a shameless plug, but join our Discord. The link is down below. We have a little BGA chat where people coordinate BGA games. I've learned a bunch of games from just people in our comments in our in our community who really like to play games on BGA. I mean, there are people in our in our MVM community who play an astounding amount of of
Oh, yeah. We have a whole channel dedicated to it. And I don't care if it's a shameless plug or not. Join our Discord because yeah, all those games of Day One that I'd mentioned, most of those are with groups of people, various groups of people from our Discord. So, definitely get in there and get on BGA, check the games out, let us know what you think yourselves. Uh, and we'll probably have more content on these when they actually release because we do like to get them on the table and show show you what they're all about.
Uh, but until then, get down in the comments, let us know what you think. And of course, until next time, make sure everyone has fun at the table and we'll see you then.