Space Base Review - JonGetsGames
Transcript
welcome to John gates games today I'll be reviewing its pace pace now in this game each player is gonna start off with a basic fleet of ships that are docked into their base station now on their turn they're gonna roll a couple dice which will allow them to activate their own ships and they'll also be spending money to buy new ships now they only have a certain number of slots in their base so they're going to send their old ships out to make a new room for the new ones and those ships that are often in other sectors are gonna activate on their opponent's turns now first I'm gonna explain how the game plays in more detail and then I'll jump into my review but I'd also like to briefly request that if you enjoyed this video you consider clicking the like button and the subscribe button down below also if you'd like to directly support the channel please check out jungus Gamescom slash support just see a variety of ways with which you could do so and I'd really appreciate it all right without further ado let's learn how to play at the start of the game each player is going to get a board just like this which will track in their victory points income as well as money and they're gonna get 12 of these player color ships now these are gonna get organized from 1 all the way to 12 and then they're also gonna get a random level one ship in this case we got a six so we're gonna go ahead and take the previous six and put the new one in flip this over and tuck it just like that so only the red is showing and I'll explain more about that pretty soon here now I'm not gonna go into the rest of setup but this is about what your player board is gonna look at at the start of the game so now what happens as a starting player is gonna roll the two dice and they now have two different options available to themselves they can either some of these dice together and evaluate that ship that is in that spot in this case that would be eight so they could go over here and take three money or they could
use that these two dice separately so they could do a two and a six now two would give them one money and a six we give them a two money so in this case it's three money or three money so it doesn't really matter so they would go ahead and get the three money going one two three and now they would have an optional shipbuilding action in the middle of the table we have this market of cards and there are four different main sections now these up here are the level 1 cards which in general cost between about 1 and 5 gold and you can see that in the top left corner we have these level 2 ones right here which cost from like 7 to 9 goal or so and then we have these threes which can go all the way up to 14 or 15 gold the last section are these colonies and with these you immediately get victory points but you don't get any activation so these are not the kind of things to do in the early phases of the game and currently we only have four money which means the only things we have the option of buying are up here in the one area now that we've zoomed in we can see that we can afford all of these right here because this one costs five and we only have four money so what happens is we could purchase one of these ships and there's a few different things to pay attention to the first is the number in the top right and that is going to be the slot that you can be putting the ship into on your main board the second thing that we should pay attention to is this area in the middle now a lot of them have a blue background and some of them have a green background like this now blue background means that you're going to get that bonus when you activate that ship on your turn the green background means you can get that bonus whether is your turn or your opponent's turn and lastly the red down here only happens on your opponent's turn and I'll explain that in a little
more detail in a second so if we look out here we see this one right here gives two rockets which are victory points and this game is a race the first player to get to 40 victory points is gonna win so the fact that this two points happens on a 7 which is a somewhat common role for two dice seems like a pretty good ship this one right here goes into the six line and just gives one point one money that is this one right here is a little bit different now you see this little square that is a spot where you can put these little charge cubes now you'll see that the square itself is blue which means you only fill in this slot on your turn and the way these charge cube chips work is at a later point in the game once there is a cube on here by activating that to a specific area like when we got at 3 in this case then later on and you could pull this off whether it's your turn or your opponent's turn because it's green in order to evaluate the ability here now in this case what that does is it takes the sum of the two dice whether it is in front of you or in front of an opponent on their turn and then you activate the spots to the right of that one given ship now you have to sum these together and this replaces the regular die activation for your turn or whether it's your turn over your opponent's turn but what this means essentially is you're adding one to the summation of the dice on your area so that's a pretty good card next up this gets points and this gives on to money and lastly this one right here which we can't afford gives you the option of when you activate an eight you can actually do the ship to the left or the right of the actual eight slot right there which gives you some extra flexibility so in this case I think maybe we would go ahead and grab this one right here
because victory points are certainly good and now let's go ahead and dock it into our base now you should already know how to do this because we essentially did this as part of setup what you do is you take the card that was already in that slot and you replace it with a new card and then the card that was just taken away while you flip it over and then you slide it in just like that now right before I mentioned that the blue areas happen on your turn and the red areas happen on your opponent's turn and that's because we did roll this eight on our turn but at the same time all of our opponents on our turn are going to get to do the same evaluation they can either take an H or they can take a 2 and a 6 but in this case all they're gonna evaluate are the red cards on the top of their tableaus so that means in the future if one of our opponents say rolls a 3 and a 4 getting a 7 then we could look over here and we would see that well we have no Reds on 3 and no Reds on 4 so we would not want to split this up but we could sum this together to make 7 go over here and activate this red card on the 7 area because it would be their turn so we do the red area and we would get to money on their turn so that's a pretty nice way that all works now the last thing we have to do when we actually build a ship is we have to pay for it of course this one cost three money and we have four money but whenever you do a basic ship purchase action you spend all of your money so effectively this means you can only do one at ship purchase as the basic action on your turn because well even if we had 10 money and we spent 3 we would still lose all of it once the active player has chosen to buy a ship or not then at their turn is gonna be over we're gonna go ahead and refill all over the market slots and then we will
pass the dice to the next player now at this point you may have noticed these symbols over here on our player board and they are green which match up with the middle track down here now this is income and that means if in the future we got a 9 10 or 11 or 12 with these starting chips we could gain an income as opposed to money now the way money but income works is you move up this green tracker right here and at the end of your turn if you ever have less money than you have income then you actually bump right back up to it so that means if later on the game we had a 5 income and we spent all of our money for something else we essentially automatically generate 5 money at the end of our turn which makes it easier for us to buy some of the more expensive ships and speaking of which let's go ahead and see what some of those options are well we come back to the main market we can look at some examples of level two and a three ships the first thing to note is that the cost to buy them goes up but to the rewards that you get can increase as well if you look over here this one right here gets you three money and this one right here gets you six money which seems kind of crazy because of the same cost but this is on the three spot which means it's a lot easier to activate then this one over here which is on the nine spot now there are many of these ships that have these little charge cube spots on them for instance we have this one right here which is similar to the one we saw before but it allows you to activate it one or two to the right but then you have more complicated ones like this one right down here you'll notice these little pips have a 2 and a 3 now this shows you how many of these slots you have to fill up because some of these you have to do multiple charges in order to do the spot and again the way these charges come down is for this one
we would have to activate a nine on our turn because of the blue background to put this right here so if it was a three player game we would actually need to put all three of these charge cubes down but if you look at the specifics of this one you can pull off these cubes to do the ability of swapping your level one hand at level twelve sector cards which is a huge ability also every time you put a cube down on this specific card you're gonna get six money so this is a very powerful card because if you're able to swap something from the 12 section to the one section then it's probably gonna be a really nice ability because 12s happened very rarely because you have to get two sixes on the dice to actually make that happen now there are other options like this one just giving you a straight amount of victory points and a kind of crazy card right here which actually just says you win now I mentioned that the main way you win this game is getting 240 victory points first but in this particular instance it's a level 12 card and if you fill in all of these slots and you just automatically win and you don't even need to account everything up now the last thing to point out is that the red signs of these cards also get better so you'll notice for instance this one right here if you get it tucked in on your player board suddenly you're gonna be getting two of entry points every time somebody else rolls a five and so in this way you can definitely build up an engine to activate a lot of these different things and get a lot of different good stuff now the last way that you can spend a lot of money is by grabbing one of these colony ships now you'll notice they just have victory points on them and when you spend at the large amounts of money in this case like 30 but dollars right there you're gonna immediately generate to the points that are listed on that spot and you're gonna put this into the slot so for instance
this goes into the 8 area but since this is yellow and it's not blue green or red that means every time you activate a 8 for the rest of the game you get nothing this is just a one-shot thing that's gonna clog up your area but 10 points is 1/4 of what you need to actually win the game so that might be worth it to you now the last thing that I'd like to mention is that even though you can only ever have one of these cards in the main activation slot you can have multiple of the red ones so in the future if we were able to buy another one of these sevens then we would take it this card right here put the new one in flip this one over and tuck it just like that so suddenly if somebody else rolls a 7 then we're going to get 4 money in a victory point if we did it yet again we could take this one off put that one back in slide this one under like that and now whenever anybody else rolls a 7 we're gonna get 3 victory points and 4 money so in this way as you get deeper into the game you can get these larger and larger stacks of red activations and you can get a ton of stuff sometimes even more on your opponent's turns then even on your own turns so as I said you're just gonna keep building your tableau each player taking their turns in clockwise order until somebody gets to 40 victory points at that points you're going to keep playing around so that everybody takes the same number of turns you to the person to the right of the starting player and then whoever has the most feature points is gonna be the winner let's now begin the review for space base by starting with a couple positive points for the first of these I'd like to discuss at the act of tableau building in front of yourself in this game and how it was satisfying I found to be now from a decision standpoint I think the act of choosing which one of the ships you want to buy and trying to figure out how that's
gonna work with all the other ships you have in front of yourself is quite good but also I like the mechanical basis and restrictions that this game puts on the player for lots of tableau building style games you will just take a new card to kind of stack them up and maybe when you activate that numbered you're gonna get a lot more stuff but in this base space the game just says no you only ever have one main card in each one of the different slots but the thing that upgrades is your ability to do stuff on your opponent's turns so at the start of the game you have a very weak set of red cards you only have one that's out there and you might go many rolls of the dice on your opponent's terms without getting anything but as you were trying to build up your tableau and trying to replace your ships with better ships you are also putting those old ships into the red stack and making those activations on your opponent's terms stronger and stronger to the point where there's almost this tipping point where suddenly you can do a lot better on here bonus turns and you actually can on your own turn and that kind of just scales the engine as the game is actually progressing through so I really enjoy the act of piecing together the right ships at the right moment to combo together and I just like the way that the red cards a pile up to have those really strong endgame situations for positive point number two I'd like to talk specifically about the variety of ships that come in the game and even more specifically about the vast number of them that get activated with those little charge cubes now this is a really great idea because it means that when the die gets rolled and you activate that ship by putting the cube down you don't have to use that ability right then so you're not locked into the random moment when that specific number got rolled you just can charge up this
ability and then use it at the specific moment when the card says you can whether it's your turn your opponent's turn or either/or and I really enjoy the control of this game gets you allows you to have over the actions that you're doing you can have all these different charge cubes on different spots and at the right moment pull them off like you don't have to roll those numbers again to activate them you're in control so you're not as bound to the luck of the dice in that respect and the variety of different types of ships that do the charge cubes is surprising I figured it would have certain things like you know thanks manipulation and you do have those where you can like activate a ship one or two to the right of the specific guy that got rolled with some of the dice but there's also crazy ones that let you like swap the number one and the 12 on your board obviously the twelves are super powerful because that's almost never gonna get rolled and ones get rolled all the time so that's a huge move and then if my favorite card in the whole game is one that just says that you win if you get it charged up enough like you don't count victory points or anything and I actually pulled off a win with this and the last game that I played and it was incredibly satisfying because this card is on the twelve and that means you have to hit a certain number of times based off the player account and that's just not gonna happen with you're just hoping to roll two sixes on your turn so I got a variety of other cards so that I could load charge cubes over there and then move that overhears that could activate it better with arrows and I felt very satisfied with the ability to piece together something to actually use the literal I Witten I would button in the game and it was about one term before my opponents were gonna win with the basic way so anyway so yeah I just really like the variety of different cuba activation
ships in the game i think it really brings a lot to the space okay let's now move it into the next section which is a neutral points and for the first of these i'd like to talk about the possibility for runaway leader type situations within the game now this is an engine building race game so the reason this is a neutral point is because you should kind of expect that there's a possibility that somebody could build a really good engine and then just kind of run away with the game but the reason this is a neutral point is because the main endgame trigger is as soon as any person hits 40 victory points and what that means is if any person gets into a dominant position where they have this really great engine that's working on a bunch of different die rolls that are quite common or maybe they're even seeming like they're getting a little bit lucky with the die rolls and that really good car they just got keeps getting hit over and over again well the game is gonna kind of run itself out anyway like if a person is kind of bleeding and they will kind of run up to that endgame condition and the game and this does mean that you could be in a position where it is you know five or six turns before the game is over and you're like I really don't think I'm gonna win this one but also when I've seen those situations it seems like there's usually a hail-mary possibility where you like well let's try to get this one thing you know if this happens if that happens then maybe I can get that one colony ship after you know saving up for a turn or two and that big jump up is gonna be the thing that I need and I have seen situations where somebody appeared to be running away with a game and then somebody else got a couple cars together that worked really well and suddenly they actually grabbed the wind from somebody else who seemed like and they had it locked down so it is a possibility that you could see somebody across the table build a much better than engine than you and realize that you're totally out of contention but you really kind of should
expect that in this sort of game next up we have neutral point number two and for this one I'd like to talk about the surprising amount of downtime that can appear in this game now I've played this game a bunch of time so far and I've played games where there was almost no downtown where we're just you know rolling a dice taking our money into Anna activations looking out to the ships and then choosing one in like ten seconds and the next person takes our turn and it just kind of goes around the table at a really nice pace but I've also played a couple game where it has been glacial and this has been at higher player counts like 4 & 5 but even it with the higher player count there been situations or I've been sitting on the table and I'm looking across I'm like this person is taking two minutes to figure out which one of these ships they should buy and they really should not be taking two minutes to figure out which one of these ships they should buy and I think part of that is the fact that you have 18 cards available in the tableau and I think for some people it is gonna be a little bit analysis paralysis inducing with the vast number of different options they have available to themselves especially at the later parts of the game where they might have enough money to buy any of those different cards now I find myself suffering from analysis process in lots of games but personally I have not had that happen to me in space base like every single time I played this one I feel like the decision about which ship I wanted to get has happened in like 10 to 15 seconds but for multiple other people that I played with they have taken significantly more time than that and unfortunately that kind of saps a lot of the fun out of the game when it takes that long to get back around to you so I don't think it's necessarily a problem with the game because it's gonna be an issue with some people and not an issue at all with other ones because I've seen both cases but it is something that you should know
going in like there's a possibility that it could be a strangely down time filled experience in certain settings alright it's now time to move it into the negative section and I do have a couple of these I want to talk about and the first has to do with the complexity of the cuba activation carts now I've already talked about them as a positive because I love the fact that in the game I love the variety that comes with them but from a rules clarity perspective I had quite a bit of trouble with figuring out how some of these specific ships worked though again the ones where you put the cubes down and figuring out the exact timing as to when you could pull the cube off like between the rolling the dice before after in a variety of different settings for each one of different cards it seemed like there were lots of questions and I don't feel confident then I play the game entirely correctly until like my fourth play of the game and even now I feel not 100% certain that I have played every single one of these cards correctly I feel like if you read through the rules and the rules look great as you're reading through reading through them and I felt like I understood but I was consistently amazed at how many times we had to go back to the rule book to try and get clarification and figure out wait how does this want to actually work and I've gone online I've done a couple ugh through a couple different resources to figure out how best to do this and I just feel like with the the clarifications and examples for a lot of the more complicated ships in the rulebook could have been done a little bit better but also I feel like pardon that's on me because there have been times where I then go read the book a little bit more carefully and I realized it's there it's like written out it's fine it's obvious and I just misinterpreted it but at the same time it happened way more than the average
game with this kind of cookie timing and whatnot things so I have made some mistakes with it and I feel like other people are probably gonna have a lot of stumbling blocks with some of these different cards but that being said I was really enjoying the game even as I was playing some of these ships incorrectly so I'm glad I'm now playing it right and I'm glad this variety of things is in there but I'm hoping they're gonna have a nice strong FAQ to make sure that people really do understand how all of these more complicated ships work and specifically the timing with which you can actually activate them next up we have negative point number two and this is gonna probably seem a little bit overly specific but I really dislike a single card that comes in the game now it is a ship that is in the third tier stack it cost thirteen money to make it so you're gonna be getting it in the middle parts of the game you have to have quite a bit of money to make it happen but it activates on a7 and it causes all of your opponent's to lose for victory points and gains you the ability to buy one or two cards now the issue that I have with this card is it feels overly powerful and it feels anti fun because of the fact that you are causing your opponents to lose feature points means they're getting farther away from that endgame threshold and my first pass with this card I felt like oh that makes a lot of sense it's a way to combat somebody who is maybe kind of running away to the game he just caused them to lose points to kind of put in their engine and check but what actually happened with this card is that when it would come out it would be on the 7 which is the most common die roll between two dice and every time I got hit and it happened somewhat often everybody was losing all of their victory points the player who had it was not very high up in victory points and
it caught the single card caused the game to stall out by probably like two or three rounds at least making the game going you know and much longer than it should I mean I'm not sure of the actual specifics but it didn't feel fun when it was happening and it felt like the game probably should have ended by now and at one point we counted it up and like yeah we've all lost like you know points at this point because the thing got activated so many times because it gets almost worse when it gets you upgrade that ship because now it goes up to the top and now whenever anybody else rolls a seven which happens quite often then everybody's gonna lose for victory points and slowly this car just kept getting hit over and over again and yeah we just really didn't like it like I feel like the money cost for it is probably okay if it was activated on like a 10 or an 11 or something so that if you wanted to get to that really good ability you had to work around with a variety of other cars to combo together so that it felt a little bit more special as opposed to having a situation where once that card gets filled suddenly everybody else dreads rolling a 7 which happens all the time in the game for us we've just decided to remove it from the game it's really not gonna impact the overall thing but I figured if I go to that extent with one card I should probably mention it in the review at this point let's down discuss the variability for space base and I feel like it's a bit more than I expected going in I figured there be a variety of different ships which give you like points and money and that kind of thing but I did not expect the variety of different activatable ships that are in the game there's a lot of one-off copies of a variety of different effects and as I play the game multiple times certainly for the first couple games new ships would come out and like oh I never seen
that one that's a crazy ability I mean for instance there's just that single ship that is an eye wind button if you're able to hit it enough times and there's just one of them and it took five games until it actually came out and for me I was so excited when it did come out in that fifth game that I bought it and I actually made it try to turn that into a victory and so I really enjoy the fact that you can go for these things in slightly different orders in slightly different ways within each game but at the same time you're still almost always trying to get to 40 victory points I mean that one game with I win button I had very few victory points because I completely changed my strategy around to make that one a particular one happen and maybe it would be nice if there were more wacky type of things like that in the game but I guess having just one of them kind of makes it feel special in that respect and overall the variety of the different ships I think it comes together to be a really good package from a variability perspective when it comes to player account space base supports 2 to 5 players and I've played all of those counts except for 3 and oddly enough I feel like three is probably gonna be the best way to play the game now starting at the bottom I was surprised at how well it worked on 2 player experience because well you only have one opponent who's gonna be rolling their dice when it's not your turn which means in that situation the balance of power between the ships in your dock and the ships that are kind of flipped over onto the red side is gonna be significantly different than in like a five player game where there's gonna be four different die rolls trying to activate those red cards before you get your main action again the big thing I enjoyed about the two-player game is that it was just so snappy because you just take your turn and go back to them and to come right back to you and I
think we played yeah we played two games of this back-to-back in less than two hours I think and those were the first two games that I actually played now I have played it at full players a couple times and I played a five player game once and I don't really recommend the five player game unless you know you're playing with four other people who are gonna be taking quick turns the one play of it we did went well over 90 minutes because some people were taking ferry a very long time to figure out which one of those ships they want to buy and when you add that into the fact that there were so many turns to get around to until you had your next turn down time was definitely an issue with that situation four player is good and again I think it's gonna be significantly better with people who don't take too long to pick out the ships that are in the middle but at three you're gonna have a situation where it's gonna come back around to you quickly probably whether or not your points are taking a while to produce their ships and you have a situation where there are gonna be two opponent die rolls to every one of your own dive rolls which kind of bounces out I think the the interestingness of building up those red stacks but as I mentioned before the two-player game worked way better than I even expected going in so yeah that's all of those different player counts I do think that three is gonna be best even though I haven't had the opportunity to play it yet in conclusion I've played space base five times at this point and I'm honestly pretty enamored with it right from the very beginning when I first saw a demo of it I was like I think I'm gonna like this game and as I played those first couple games I was like yeah this is a really cool system to come together the way that you only have one of the main ships and activation at any point time but you can build up these escalating stacks of red cards to activate on your opponent's turns is very satisfying the way that
you can combo all of the different variety of activatable ships and a variety of ways to kind of like get better die rolls or move the little tokens around swap entire cards on your tableau can be really exciting cool stuff that you're doing as you're building up this engine the game goes on and I think the Achilles heel for this game is that for some people they're just gonna take way too long when they're trying to figure out which one they ships to by and that really does suck a lot of the fun out of this game because you want this one to be snappy and for many of the people have played with it has been a quick great experience as we're going through and usually in those situations a game takes about an hour but there have been other situations where people kind of fall into analysis paralysis spending it well over a minute to figure out which one of the ships they want to buy on each game in turn especially in the later stages of the game or they might do an activation so that now they can like take a couple of chips for free and then buy one or two ships based off this that one thing and you can have these massive turns that take multiple minutes for certain players and not others and that can cause the game to drag out to over 90 minutes which is not a setting that this one necessarily should be in so as I mentioned before I have really enjoyed this one and I am actively looking forward to playing this one more but I do think I should mention that not everyone I played with this game with has had the same opinion several people have quite enjoyed it and wanted to play it like again right after we played it right there but many other people have left it pretty lukewarm and all of those situations were when the game went on a little bit too long because people are playing too long and taking too long to take their turns I think part of that is the downtime and also part of it is this is just not going to work for some people because of the die roll luck
variants you know you might build a really nice thing for really good numbers and just it's never get rolled and you're like well I've got a bunch of mates maybe I shouldn't have done that I lost because of it and that's going to rub some people the wrong way but in general this is one that I recommend and yeah like I said I'm looking forward to playing it some more as always I'd like to thank everyone who's been supporting this channel including all of these producer level patreon backers if you two would like to directly support the channel please go to John gets Gamescom slash support to see a variety of ways that you could do that and I'd really appreciate it also if you'd like to see more in depth board game reviews like this one as well as full game playthroughs and vlogs please subscribe to the channel thanks for watching