Return to Dark Tower Review - Dredging up the Past
Transcript
this is how the tower wanted to see it and i hate to disappoint you but it's not doing anything
wow and that's the review done another successful youtube fake out ending here's my fake call out for you to subscribe a fake patreon plug and fake thumbnails superimposed onto the image you can try and click on them but they won't work because it's not the end of the video the first question that comes to mind is why why does this exist is it fun do people actually want it and most importantly what the hell is it well it's the dark tower reimagined for a modern audience and if you're old and american enough you'll know exactly what it is and if like me or not then let's face it this looks tacky as ships but i bet you're still curious so let's talk about return to dark tower who amongst its many many many designers lists isaac childress who also owns a board game publishing company that paid us money to design a scenario for a game called frost haven so take what i say with a lick of salt whether you're a horse or not to begin our journey i have to take you back to a far away mystical land called the 80s where the dark tower comes from and i'm not going to waste your time with toys were different back then we did not have minecraft or whatever but i do want to contextualize things just a teensy bit dark tower came out in 1981 and this was before most of the popular plastic comparatively transformers came out in 1984 that's three years later and
also fantasy games were still pretty new dnd was just starting to climb out of the basement into public consciousness warlock of fire top mountain hasn't even been published yet hero quest came out in 1989 that's nearly a decade apart when it came to brave heroes going on an adventure against unspeakable evil this was one of the only options and it came in hulking black marble and with a mind of its own the tower clicked and hissed and moved and schemed against you it had ill intent it did not care for you it was an adversary it was imagination here's a problem in 2022 you just can't have that in return to dark tower one to four players will take on the role of fantasy archetypes like not conan or not corvo or not the gunslinger or the uncomfortable realization that there isn't a familiar trope for the female character because fantasy hasn't done them justice and set off on a quest each time you play you'll pick said quest and also an adversary maybe this time the not nazgul from famous intellectual property elden rings is trying to get into the tower to i don't know make more nazgul eggs and you have to stop them finally if this shopping list of options wasn't enough you also get to pick all the monsters that you'll be fighting which is bizarre because i don't exactly remember frodo
saying actually if we could not have any trolls in this adventure that would be really nice i don't mean to generalize but trolls they talk about nfts a lot and it's not really a topic anyone cares about you know what i mean and then you are ready to go and input all of that into the
companion app hello return to dark tower is an app based game here is my opinion on app based games they're fine there's nothing wrong with them but ever since their debut all the way back in 2014 that's eight years ago a certain portion of the board game loving hobby has decided to take on a purist mandate to be very weird about it any video made about any board game that has a mandatory companion app will inevitably include comments like what if my app runs out of battery or what if app not work or what if in 70 years time my great grandchildren want to play an all game i bought in 2022 they won't you yourself have already forgotten about the game you just bought two weeks ago come off of it also the way the world is going in 70 years time there won't even be grandchildren much less abs there are other hills to go die on pick a better fight anyway we've all heard these regurgitated speaking points that don't make any sense if you spend longer than two seconds thinking about them and no one's making you like board games with apps just don't leave that comment okay stop typing that the game won't work if the app stops working stop that stop it right now back to the game you've got your characters you've got your boss you've got your monsters what next the answer is obvious it's skulls everybody it's skulls alas poor yorick you had a tiny head and now i will drop the
carcass of your tiny head into a big plastic toy and it will be fun basically in the land of the dark tower there's a skull problem and your job as a hero is to go about the land picking up skulls and putting them in your knapsack you start the game collectively with 24 skulls and on your turn you get to wander around kill monsters go into dungeons complete quests buy gear or treasure but also collect skulls and then every time your turn ends you get to drop the skullet in the gullet by the power of grayskull get it cause the skulls are gray that's not gonna get old when your friend says the line every time they drop the skull anywho if you ever run out of skulls that's it you've lost because the nazical eggs have hatched don't ask me how that works how do you get the skullet out of the gullet well actually you don't remember me mentioning the tower having a mind of its own each time you drop a skull to end your turn which let me just add is an immensely satisfying and clever way to end a player's turn you also activate its innards you rouse it from its slumber sometimes it'll just go back to sleep other times a seal will be broken
meaning you'll have to physically remove one of the tower's doors there might be just a hole behind it or there might be a glyph and if it's facing you then you'll get a penalty or an event might happen like the villain stripping you of loot or a companion you recruited earlier might miraculously offer you aid that was very very needed and finally through these holes the tower might literally spit those same skulls right back onto the kingdom once it does any skulls that fell into your kingdom meaning your side of the board you'll have to place onto buildings that you possess any time when a building has more than three skulls it gets destroyed if you're thinking skuldemic you're on the right track this is the crux of your turn there are so many interesting things to do you could find monsters you could go to the bazaar to get some cool treasure or you could take one for the team and spend your time cleaning up skulls actually i'm doing the game at the service here your turn is never quite as boring as having to tidy up your room you in fact have two different groups of actions you can do the first group is either fight a monster quest or the aforementioned skull cleaning the second group revolves around the four buildings that you can visit and there you can do the reinforced action which depends on the building you are visiting so for example
doing that on its own i'm not making it do that you could get some gear or treasure you could upgrade your character giving them a new ability you could heal a nasty corruption or you could get some warriors which is this game's version of hit points best bit you can do each of those actions in between any of your movement meaning you can always come up with something more interesting than uh i guess i'm just gonna spend my time cleaning two skulls again if it's okay i would like to talk about these three things in more depth now i'm asking you it's not like you can stop me oh you want to stop me all right all right let's see how many advantages you got so fighting monsters in this game is kind of cool and it all happens in the app also it's a bit like drawing tarot cards and also a bit like blackjack anytime you fight a monster you'll pick the type of monster in the app then the app will deal you a tableau of cards and you have to survive a number of them based on how scary the monster is once you've selected the cards the app will flip the first one for you and it'll tell you to lose things in this case it's telling you to lose warriors but it might make you lose other things like spirit which is this game's currency or gear or treasure might even make you drop skulls in the tower as long as you're able to complete that you just press confirm and flip the next card and then you complete that and then if you're able to do that you press confirm and then you flip the next card and if you go through all of
them you win thing is there is no tangible reward for winning the fight so that's about as much fun as buying a bouncy castle purely for decoration purposes there's no xp or loot or even a well done you flip the card and live to tell a tale here's a medal but there are advantages advantages are basically your stats there's magic advantages humanoid advantages undead advantages and so on let's say you're fighting a bagel monster well it's susceptible to bagel advantages at the start of the fight you will calculate how many bagel advantages you have and that's your tally and then when you flip a card you can spend advantages to make it better better better wow now it's actually giving me something instead of taking it away and that's your reward basically spend your bagels wisely and you'll come away from a fight with more than you had when you've entered it except there's no wisdom you're just flipping cards and pressing the button and maybe the casino pays out is it crunchy no but neither are bagels is it fun well i'm wearing this one on my finger and that's at least entertaining then there's treasure i won't dwell on this long it's just cards that give you abilities i just wanted to mention that these are really good i've played so many dungeon crawlers where the items you get are kinda bung and these are not a lot of the time they give you advantages plus a cool ability so
anytime you get a treasure it feels like a double whammy of awesome like here's a bonus oh and also you get to do this totally broken thing now which feels really nice i wish more games had items that felt powerful but didn't make the game more boring because the strategies become road it's a tough thing to balance and i think return to dark tower lands this particular element perfectly and finally questing which is also a double whammy because it's two entirely separate whammies under one wham one side of questing is going into dungeons a sort of spin on fighting where you go from room to room in a randomly generated mini maze until you find the exit this uses the same advantage mechanism as fights go into a room bad spend an advantage good find exit you won your prize not having to do this anymore because the writing is poor the dungeons feel procedural in the worst way and the whole thing stinks of regurgitated design not a fan of this wham the other wham is the actual quests which can be seasonal quests or the main quests your game of return to dark tower will be split into six months or rounds each month apart from the first one you get two seasonal quests one of them says complete me or bad things will happen the other one says complete me and good things will happen either way you need to collect chochkies to spend on the quest a slew of warriors or maybe some gear and this is enough of a distraction
to actually distract you from doing things needed for survival like collecting skulls or killing monsters completing quests is good or so you think because the rewards aren't always tangible you might be told what you'll get like a companion that much like treasure will provide you with a really neat ability but also they might just do things that the app deems on its own and that's hard to quantify same for the quests that punish you if you don't complete them you might get a hint at what will happen but you won't know what the damage is until it's done i like this it makes dark tower less mechanical less procedural and more mysterious but not to the point where it's annoying after all make it predictable and it's just a cheap plastic toy instead it introduces real stakes maybe there's just five skulls left in your knapsack are you gonna complete the quest instead of clearing some skulls and risk losing the game five skulls might be enough maybe or you're gonna ignore the quest and then who knows what happens finally there's the main quest something that you will spend many months doing our first adventure asked us to collect four treasures of a specific type our second wanted us to amass an absurd amount of warriors once you complete the main quest you will unlock access to fighting
the adversary the final whammy defeat the adversary and you win you can say that we're more jaded in 2022 but i'd argue that the world has just moved on maybe the old tower was really neat in 1981 but we tell better stories now and frankly we have better toys i know that half of this game is directly catering to nostalgia but honestly i haven't got a lot of nostalgia for nostalgia i need this to be the best game that it can be not just a toy for the old boys and in some ways it is it's simultaneously that same dorky tower with so many new bells and whistles that are not exactly surprising yet still manage to be entertaining but it's also actually a game that's fun in a showy kind of way return to dark tower is not crunchy enough to completely wow me but it's silly and bombastic enough to ask my friends if they want to spend an evening having a toys r us shelf item spit tiny skulls at us for two hours and not feel completely stupid except there's just one problem you know how they say you can't put a price on childhood well it turns out you can and that price is 189 pounds and 99 pence recommended retail so you want me effectively a child to take a ring into an active volcano two thousand miles away past armies of murder goblins and with sean
bean in my party yes and you can pay my consultancy fee in six easy installments 189.99 for this look i get that this was work i guess this is big intricate with room spinning inside and lights and things and the app i get it but it's still 189.99 for this just no the more i looked at it with that price in mind the more it felt like a pound shop toy shop reject it's just so much money for something that is clearly less return on your investment than almost any other game in the genre with that price tag you could buy gloom haven you could buy the new descent so many games actually cheaper than this and then one trip to ebay later i figured it out turns out the original dark tower fetches an even more demanding 200 pound price tag on the secondary market and when you factor in the fact that online board game shops frequently introduce heavy discounts to recommended retail then this becomes a bargain and look i don't want to judge you if you want the dark tower back in your life if this is nostalgia for you and you just want it then this is better and cheaper it's a total slam dunk it pains me to land on this recommendation because there's a lot of connective
tissue here to reinvigorate this idea of an evil narrator sticking mud in your shoes maybe you don't have nostalgia for the dark tower specifically but you might remember playing atmosphere or some such as a kid wouldn't it be great if this was the game that brings that whole genre back to the table but with a price tag like that return to dark tower becomes a much wider field for criticism i need this thing to be rock solid and it is at best custard solid first the obvious maybe the reason that they never made games with giant towers again is because when i play board games with friends i like to see my friends and failing that at least the other side of the board instead i have this what's the word for this shape obelisk this giant obelisk sit between me and two-thirds of everything not good then there's the fights which remember i liked and that's still true but i really dislike how the monsters are integrated as a thread because they just sit there on the map and you can get rid of them or not what do they do who knows like i've played the game enough to know what the consequences are because in reality what happens is if you leave them alone then the app will eventually make them do something maybe i've had games where monsters had no real tangible impact and
this isn't so much a problem with mechanisms but rather how mechanisms are telegraphed to the game's players i know this is true because there's multiple threads on bgg where people are just going so what do the monsters even do so you've got a cool mechanism that you don't know why you're engaging with because the benefits aren't clear until you've played the game enough and adversaries are an even bigger misunderstanding the combat mechanism is great for fighting minions but terrible in a boss fight there's no stakes no sense of danger you just need to come at it with more stuff worse yet the corruption mechanism if fighting anything or dungeoning or just doing whatever you're told to pay something but you can't you have to take a corruption these impose penalties but the scary part is that if you ever get free you lose the game meaning that on the last boss fight only three of the five cards are dangerous if you come at it with no corruption the other two you can just safely ignore by saying whatever we take one corruption and then move on some adversaries will attack all players but even then it's a matter of preparation rather than the actual fight and since corruption won't have any effects afterwards because the game will end you can ignore a portion of the boss fight as inconsequential that's terrible icing on the cake what happens
when you win these villains are so bargain basement it makes me want to give jeremy irons an oscar for his performance in the dnd movie there's just no story in this game and i get that this is a board game but when you win you get the same boilerplate winning text like congrats the dark tower sleeps for now dun dun dun please give me something anything else it's like this game was made with acute awareness that whoever buys it is going to apply it once and then leave it to gather dust on the shelf it's anticlimactic in the worst way in the way that feels lazy and that's disappointing which is where you say there's an expansion yay this should make my job easy that is too expensive surely paying more isn't going to save it right the alliance's expansion for return to dark tower i regret to announce was an experience i had a genuine blast playing ships ships ships ships it's still pandemic plus plus plus the bosses are still just very naff whimpers they're still the same boilerplate you won't yay but did you end screen but something about this just makes it a tighter crunchier experience that walks that tightrope of anticipating threats and putting out fires in a way i really enjoyed also when i played with
alliances the presence of monsters was a lot more tangible they just did more things and i don't know whether that's because i've added in the expansion or i just chose a better scenario or a better set of monsters or whether that's something they just updated in between my plays into the app some of return to dark tower will always remain a mystery guarded in the gardens of code and that is part of its charm but also makes it kind of hard to review there's also different kinds of skulls now these are called power skulls so now you can say things like by the power of lime skull when you drop them in the tower and they have different nasty effects add to that guilds you need to please so that's another thing you need to baby there's an extra monthly quest and even two new characters everything feels dialed up to 13 there's so many more threads so many more things to take care of so many ah there just isn't enough time to do everything started getting the sense that this was the way the game was always meant to be but i also started to understand the split this is for when you want to show the tower to your friends to have a dorky time and this is for when you want the crunch it all kind of makes sense so here's my verdict i'm not gonna tell you how to spend your money if you've got that many dollar dues and you really want this you're not going to come away from a disappointed much but if you want
like a really solid 10 out of 10 sorry this review ran out of batteries if you want to watch the end of it um hit the subscribe button and that's going to recharge our batteries and then when you do that it'll automatically just put you towards towards the end of that review uh if if you really want to make sure that that actually works uh this patreon.com included um and that's that's where you give us money because um we review board games and that's not really a job unless people give us money uh big thank you to everyone who already does and um that's it thank you goodbye