Skip to main content
Loading video...

Dead Reckoning Review: A Brilliant Pirate Adventure Far Greater Than The Sum Of Its Parts

Transcript 16:59

hello i'm farrell this is tallah we are bored of it and welcome to our review of dead reckoning the exciting new 4x pirate game with a really intriguing card crafting system at its core and this for one to four players is a real sandbox experience because the card crafting system allows players to decide how they want to play and this is because everyone will start with a basic deck of cards but they can buy action upgrades for those cards and also once per turn they will level up a card to give it a better version of his action and together by deciding what they want to buy and what they want to level up they're going to become better in specific areas of the game and thus they can decide their play style and it's quite cool because everyone's going to end with a completely unique deck of actions thematically you've got a ship you've got a crew and you set sail to gather as much treasure as possible will you gather that treasure by attacking everything in sight like a true pirate or maybe you'll go for area control and build an empire of production or maybe you just want to be a friendly merchant out for the best deal all are possible in dead reckoning

everyone will begin the game with the same deck of 12 sailors all level one and an average turn will consist of you drawing four cards and playing them in front of you and then you will use the actions on those cards uh but there are actions that aren't on the cards that you can also do the most common being set sales which is where you look at all the sale icons in front of you including on your ship and then marking it on this track and how many sales you have is how many spaces you can move that turn and move is another action terms of the actions on the cards a common one is going to be produced barrels where you get barrels and you put they go in your dock another one is going to be to deploy cubes and you deploy cubes to try and take over control of the island and then there's also a car that will let you produce on the island and usually this will be barrels and money or one or the other now barrels are the most common resource in the game it's how you buy upgrades um and you can only pick up barrels of money from islands that you control which is why you'd want to control them but you also get end-game scoring for controlling islands so in terms of more advanced actions you're going to be able to battle other players you're going to be able to build ship upgrades and you're going to be able to build buildings on islands you control and lastly another common action you'll be doing that you don't need a sailor for is just to unload and load money in barrels where the game gets interesting

is that you can also buy advancements which are usually actions that you add to your cards which make them stronger and on top of that once before your turn you can upgrade one of the cards in your hand to their next level therefore again making them stronger and adding new actions because of the uniqueness of the cards there are several different play styles that players can pursue depending on how they develop their cards like becoming a pirate and having a lot of attack actions available or perhaps focusing on area control and building an empire players will also be focusing on these achievements and the game end is triggered when one player achieves four they're your typical do x such as build five buildings win four battles have four ship upgrades and so on at the end of the game you'll count up the amount of money that's in your treasure chest on your ship how many advancements you have how much you get for completed achievements there's some money for area control buildings and ship upgrades whoever has the most treasure wins honestly dead reckoning is a brilliant game and we're gonna end up raving about it later on in the review but it's not without its issues although the thing is none of these are so big that we wouldn't still recommend the game but we still want to address them so we're just going to get through them at the start and then we'll move on to the good stuff first things first the battleship uh it's an absolute nightmare to put together and it's very low quality cardboard and it

seems like the holes that the tabs go in are the exact same thickness as the tabs which means you have to force them in and then often because it's such low quality they warp and the tabs bend up and then you can just never get it in so many aspects of our ship look like absolute garbage on top of that the box they give you to store it when it's put together is slightly too narrow so then the prow of the ship ends up pushing against the sides of the box and now this is pretty much destroyed and warped as well having trouble with these as well it's just kind of low quality cardboard and i've heard other people say that they had issues with it so hopefully i'm not just being an idiot our biggest complaint is that it seems that the publisher has really skimped on tokens and components here and this leads to player rotation and just a lack of general flow to the gameplay particularly at three or four players so barrels these are the number one only resource in the game and you pretty much are using them to buy anything you want to buy but they've only provided tokens up to a value of 60 barrels which is ridiculous because on a given turn you could be producing 12 15 or more let alone what you and everyone else already has in a two player game me and tally pretty much ran out of the high value barrel tokens so imagine what it's like a three or four players next money they haven't printed enough wonder balloon tokens and money's just weird anyway because they're like oh it's secret keep it in your church says shh don't let anyone else know but there's an achievement tell everyone how much money you have so which is it

and then this meets with the lack of tokens to create issues because what people tend to do is when they battle or they produce they tend to want to take them in once because you have limited storage and it's easier to manipulate if you need to shift things around if you have a one so they come into harbor they dump them all in a treasure chest and then you have a bunch of ones there and there's not enough ones so then it causes issues the problem is yeah you could break for a higher denomination except remember money secret and the only way to break because of how small this is is to dump everything else out on the table in front of everyone and let them see you count it out so even the denominations are just annoying because they've done 1 3 10 30 and i understand they've probably done three because it will fit in your hold and a five wouldn't but just do one two five ten it's so irritating not having a five and the denomination is just kind of irritating to work with in general carrying on there's not enough buildings for a building of the same type to go on every single island in the game and one of these types of buildings has two less pieces than the other types i don't know why either of these are true most importantly the player cubes they limit you with these at 30 but they're arguably the most important component in the game because they tell you to use them to mark achievements mark actions you've done the battle the area control and they seem to be limited in gameplay because it says if you don't have enough to say do a battle you have to take them from islands you control so firstly if they're limited i don't understand why one playstyle is being

punished because area control will require you to spend more cubes so why can you then not defend yourself and have to weaken your position if you do want to defend yourself next if they are limited and it's important for gameplay why tell people to use them to mark everything because inevitably when you need to actually mark actions it's going to be late game when you're playing multiple cards with multiple actions this is inevitably when you have the least amount of cubes so first just make more and second if they are important for gameplay balance just you know tell people just count out how many they need or mark them or something and you might think that these are all trivial right but every game you play these are going to be irritations and that's going to build up now our only actual gripe with gameplay is that in every game on occasion you'll have dead turns what we mean by this is a turn where the cards you have are just they don't allow you to do much you're not making a decision and it's kind of just a bland boring turn early game is generally just because the cards are basic so maybe you'll get three barrels and then the fourth card just you can't do that action really so it's pointless late game because you develop a strategy you upgrade cards you level up cards generally your dead turns are when you end up drawing all the cards that you've kind of ignored that don't fit with your strategy which then means you'll have a turn where you're not really progressing forward with what you're trying to do which can be obviously quite disappointing in the crescendo of the game because this game does have an arc

lastly the randomness of the deck can be a bit irritating because it can take three full turns on average to cycle through your deck so if you upgrade a card and level it up and use it it might be the next turn you see it or three turns you see it and that can make a big difference to how valuable that is and how close you are to getting an achievement oh what's this a mid-review turnaround time to sing the praises of dead reckoning to the community the card crafting system that's at the core of the game is truly brilliant it's fun to engage with it gives players control over their play style and it constantly provides tough decisions about which advancements to buy and which sailors to level up it's really tough because sometimes you don't want to play a card because then you can level it up at the end of your turn but then you also do want to play it because you need the action this system provides an arc and a sense of progression in the game because you begin with 12 basic sailors who can do one action each but the game evolves and by the end you and the other players will be having these epic battles in the different spheres of the game where both of you might be playing cards that have maybe eight actions on them and leading on from this the advancements are all really varied and interesting and that adds to the game's replayability and in particular what we like is how the best ones are down here at the bottom of the board which then means you have to weigh up the effort and time it takes to kind of ferry barrels back and forth down there versus everything else you could be doing in that time and in general we really like the merchant

ship advancements because these give you a choice they basically you can trade like normal or you could attack them and if you attack them the reward's better but the problem is you don't know how heavily defended they are until you decide to attack them and if you lose you take a lot of damage and you don't get much in the way of reward which means you get a great risk reward scenario and it's just generally very rewarding playing this game to sail around the the ocean get advancements synergize the advancements and then you have this late game explosion where all of these cards you've built are just coming to life and you're dominating the board now another thing we're going to all dead reckoning for is how well designed it is at enticing new players and making them comfortable now the actions are complex they're actually all pretty simple and nothing here is particularly fiddly aside from maybe trying to get your head around raising the sails when you have goods on board in different locations the symbology is excellent some of the best we've ever seen and the game does everything it can to help new players from absolutely brilliant player aids to very clear concise descriptions of every possible action in the game in the rulebook it's just masterfully designed to provide a sandbox that isn't intimidating to new players and you know you might not win your first game but it's very likely that very quickly you'll understand how to play and you'll be having fun which is important just generally this has great gameplay design all around one of our favorite things about dead reckoning is that it

provides player agency but also unique experiences through different play styles the rules mention four ways to play the pirate the privateer the merchant and the explorer the pirate is all out combat and will gain their treasure through attacking other players ships buildings and also merchant ships now this one does have the ability to annoy your fellow players because if you do enough damage to their ship and sink it all of the treasure on that ship will go to you which is obviously pretty harsh and may cause some bad blood the privateer is all about island control while the merchant will focus on boosting production and farming high value islands the explorer will aim for maximizing their movement and therefore will focus on using their excellent maneuverability to reach those high-powered level 3 and 4 advancements at the bottom of the map each one is fun to explore and feels distinct but you're not just locked into these four you can mix and match abilities and be no worse off for it the battle system is fun exciting and dramatic it will have all of the players up out of their seats and crowding around the battleship in anticipation essentially both players in the battle will count up the number of cannon symbols that they have in play and drop that amount of cubes into the battleship at the same time where they land will determine if the players take damage get rewards or get battle points the bonus of this system is that if somebody attacks you you'll likely come away with some more barrels

and treasure for the hassle but we can see that this system will likely annoy some players because it's inherently random so it does stand out in a game that has very little luck aside from which cards are drawn when whilst it is likely that the more cubes you have the more likely it is you'll win the battle equally other players with half the amount of cubes could just get super lucky landings and destroy your ship or win the battle but hey that's the risk of being a bloodthirsty pirate one thing we'd be interested to see is what kind of game different groups will make this because the game ends when a player nabs for achievements it can become an efficiency puzzle like scythe this is exactly what happened in our first game which was also our quickest game the more we played the less we cared about the achievements sure we were ambling towards them but we were much more focused on maximising our current strategy and play style and using that to fully engage with the game and the achievements just came naturally which prolonged the length of the game i guess we just wonder if this could cause some friction if one player is racing towards the achievements as quick as possible whilst the other players want to experience the game when it comes to player count we do like it out too in fact we were surprised that it didn't feel too different when we added more players but we both did prefer it with more players you get more interaction there's more going on there's more competition etc our favorite player count was three players just because already out three all of the islands

were being fought over and every player was engaging with each other if you add that fourth player you're still going to have terrific fun but it will get more chaotic because you've got more players essentially fighting over the same amount of space plus you'll get the additional play time which for us is just a little bit too much in a game that we already feel like is maybe teetering on the edge of overstaying his welcome final thoughts it's important to note in the context of this review that we did back dead reckoning on kickstarter but we mainly did it because it was popular and we thought it'd be a good review for the channel we didn't really know too much about the mechanisms we weren't particularly excited about it and when it arrived we just you know there was zero hype we didn't really weren't bothered about it but having played it multiple times we are so hyped up on dead reckoning it's just got this brilliant core system that and this is important it's fun to play around with the theme and the mechanisms combine masterfully and the player interaction mixed with all these different play styles is going to keep us coming back time and time again it should also be noted that aside from the battle system which is very american trash the game is pretty euro esque and may become an efficiency puzzle in some groups so that's just worth bearing in mind also it's not without its faults the issues with the components will likely annoy us every time we play the game plus the occasional dud turn is unavoidable but we would 100 recommend dead reckoning if

it sounds like something you would enjoy to play and we're super thrilled to see what content will become available for the game so aeg if you're watching this please give us the saga content please we really regret not getting it in our pledge if you enjoyed this video i would really appreciate it if you could give it a thumbs up and subscribe to our channel if you're not already and see you next time

Progress saved