Mansions of Madness (2nd Ed.): Discussion
Transcript
viewer discretion is advised hey everyone this video is brought to you by audible audible is offering you a free on your book with a 30-day free trial membership all you need to do is go to audible.com for word /bg unlock the link is in the description below and now enjoy the video everyone welcome to the discussion forum an shion's of madness second edition I've done that discussion previously on this game but I cannot remember if so whenever we did the pandemic one we did a separate discussion for that I don't think I ever told you my videos used to consist of the whole run-through and then at the end of that same video was the discussion so it was just one long video with annotations that led to the discussion but it was still like it's like people wouldn't want to click that they'd rather just click the separate video so so yeah so now it's a separate video on mention to madness and network it's a little bit behind this is one of like all of our favorite games we very much enjoy Manson's madness especially second editions there obviously so in first edition I don't know if he knows it used to be a one versus all yeah I think okay that's yeah and it was it was so really cool because the one person would still control the monsters and he had cards that he could play against the players like if they took so much horror then they could play certain cards against them I remember distinctly if someone took like all their horror you
can actually play a card that made them off themselves oh it was it was still really really neat and they the first edition had the puzzles and they were like actual physical pieces that you had to mess with but 7 edition makes it so much better because the app is fantastic yeah the app takes away all the 5th leanness it still seems still kind of fiddly mainly just that there's just so much to it to so many tokens that you have to find people and take how where are they and stuff to put them on the board but you don't have to worry about placement you don't have to worry about some other person messing it so yeah second edition is by far superior to first edition in every way let's see cuz I figured I figured there's gonna be little things that we like more about this game than what we don't like so are there any things that you guys don't like about mansion to madness I would say just the dice roll randomness can hurt sometimes yeah yeah I mean at the end of the day I think it can be very thematic but in the game it's very frustrating when you need to when you need to do really well right that's something and it's like well we're only doing bad because dice are not going my way this time and I still I do like the fact that there are ways to mitigate that like some equipment can help you some statuses or conditions can help you and include so but yeah I would
agree with that what was your insanity oh it was past him I couldn't disagree with you typically to the person to the luck but we're at a crucial point the game where no one was gonna disagree with it that is so funny what was the theme behind it you do not want to surrender a disagreement arguing now just waste precious time and resource is not like anyone would take your site anyway you into losing out perfect so that's funny that's perfect for you anyway because you wouldn't disagree right anyway well cuz like I said we're at that crucial point them in the game where I was like I just have to be an [ __ ] to disagree nope I want to kill her I'm not gonna attack that yeah so I mean yeah dice dice happen they're very exciting but they also can be very frustrating that's I mean I'd end of the day at the end of the day well it never seems like it I do like dice I think they're they could be fun and sweet happens multiple times and Kingdom death or forwards is awesome I said that I don't have to get high yep it's like handling oh and I still a minor things I don't like to fiddle eNOS you constantly like cuz there is so much stuff I hate them I hate the monsters mainly because it's like where are they like there's real way to organize them I organized the basis by them if some of them are just kind of really shitty you know any games it's so big there's only so much exactly like certain games like I like I
finally got the Kingdom death organizer so it's like how great this hour and you're glue Haven BAM this is easier to play uh I really still really really hate the insanity guards like they're probably my biggest thing I hate about this game mainly because like I like them in theory I like that it's like oh wow what what's your secret thing but in a cooperative game just eject just a [ __ ] knee-jerk that away where it's like we're all trying to figure out like this murder mystery or we're all working together then all of a sudden it's like oh we're gonna start a fire I don't like it like it is intriguing about know what you get but at the end of the day I just really hate how it turns that into potentially a semi cooperative or even if it's one where it's like great oh I can't I can't I can't win like it could be like you lose the game if if the main thing is a pretty you can't do anything to stop it so you're just like great I got this and now I lose even though everyone else wins I don't like them I really don't so and I know a lot people do I just I think they're unnecessary well but you any card specifically hello Hemi orange I don't like about the king say you don't like about the game alright this was fairly high on your top ten right yeah it's one day one factory but yeah and I have all almost all the expansions for missing police one yeah but I mean just little quibbles really yeah I mean
it's it's got a lot of pieces that can be helped you know setups a little bit of a bear yeah it's not terrible it makes it really helpful when someone else knows the game right like you you you and then just like help me instead of one person trying to manage everything right I mean those are my main things yeah totally monsters that are awkward it's unfortunate that they had to you know print some little details for just a little battle circumstance where I teach of this little little cards is this like I may like to slide down a gigantic monster on the thing yeah and then my house underdone doesn't fit mm-hmm I wouldn't preferred I would have actually I would have been perfectly fine with standings mm-hmm like what gloom even does the main characters be miniatures and Sandy's yeah sometimes I actually prefer standees because they're they're colored you can see it you have to like wow this looks like [ __ ] oh if it was paint in though it's like well the Sandy's don't have to be painted and it would it would take up less space right but it was so weird or not I'm your the organized I did you blood like good meetings these are these aren't great many yeah yeah oh and I completely agree so uh a lot of good things in this game question hi oh well I mean I know it's question I've asked before but obviously you guys have no problem with the app know being in board games no no no bug no issue I think that if you have an issue with that your arcade argue against that is
though but I won't be able to play this game in 20 years you go [ __ ] yourself that's the latest argue arguments like with an app only 20 years the apps not gonna work that's so stupid I'm not gonna be able to use my phone in 20 years it's not gonna stop me from yeah first of all you sucking order yeah it's like first of all no because hell some people don't even like will rotate games out and this game won't even be [ __ ] supported in 20 years Oh Fantasy Flight is yeah you think you're not gonna like this yeah we mentions a magnet tents 10th edition and it's Holograms video game yeah I have never once seen like that as a justifiable argument and apps do not belong in board games they they streamline the game they make it atmospheric with their music with their voice over it this this app is awesome the journeys in middle-earth app is better but yeah but this one's still really good well the thing I really love about mansion savantism actually compare this to journey to middle-earth because that game is basically Lord of the Rings with this oh yeah but it's only campaign driven which sucks because if if you want to just play that game you have to start over on the campaign because you can't just jump into a session mansion the madness I love how it's scenario based cuz you could just be like hey let's play let's do this here we've never done this runtime sign we have available yeah talking women to be yeah there you go so
you just you can jump in and play a great game and I I personally have found every scenario to be awesome like I am I have like except maybe the first one I mean because it's the first one he's not bad right but it's and they just gotten progressively better I love how for a how much variety there is like it's not hey this one's a survival one this one's figure out what's going on summers a monster yeah me and others are just or a mystery and then big boss fight if you [ __ ] up yeah or you know if you get it right then it's a you know a mini boss fight not right off because you did it right yeah that's another thing is I love how each investigation or each scenario has multiple endings like depending on how well you do and like there's always a stress like a sense of time to it and I knew we were getting there in this one I was like yep this one is like this shit's really hitting the fan yeah but at the same time I guess another kind of problem is that the scenarios are almost one time play because if we I mean unless and we would have to play this one the one that we just did again to see if maybe it's a different person I feel like we would I think it would be too but I'm wondering if yeah yeah like I said they would have to change the story when we do the team so much because they essentially had it pointing at multiple people to hold and yeah they would have to just change a few key texts and then they could easily make it coin it someone else yeah yeah so I
really like that because in other ones like and a lot of games it's like well we figured it out that's it great experience loved it but we'll never be able to go back mansions of madness especially when you add all the expansions it will take stuff from like different different scenarios like you can go back to like the first one and it will take it could take like a tile from grenades expending a lot of the enhancements and everything else that you've gotten from the others yeah though the more you add the more that they include which which makes it feel fresh I and I still remember a time where cat and I for the the very first recording we did the escape from ends mouth one and we got it we got we've got the ending that we got and then cat and I went and played and did something completely different and got a wild ending that we were like oh my god Oh like with no idea was gonna go the way and I'm pretty sure we still didn't complete it in the way that we were meant to but we got an ending yeah that just came out of nowhere and we were blown away um the one that we just did for the run-through was so atmospheric like I was actually kind of like getting heat away we find this ripped up pieces I'm like what the hell man person in the background were like oh like toddler [ __ ] you [ __ ] so and then we got the ending that we got which was not satisfying I mean it was it was still really cool because we just ganged up and just murders but yeah at the end it was like you wonder how they've been tracking him for so long and I'm like oh yes I do want to know that like I want
to know why why this happened so it makes you want to go back and try and do better and then kind of a feel your way so I really like I really like that what other things what other things do you guys like about the game what's your favorite thing about this game wait favorite thing about this game my favorite is mmm I have to say I like led characters really yeah I like all their unique abilities you know a little backstory you know just kind of find their way into the events I mean I just enjoy the sure plethora of cards and nonsense that you could play I like unique injuries that unique and that's fine I know I'm definitely in like not in the wrong but in the whatever it's kind of like dice it's kind of like they're that little what am I getting it is gonna be something kind of neat where I just have to be quiet the whole game or is be something like pyromania which always seems to pop up somehow which is not fun no that one is by far the worst one I mean some of them are really cool like for the greater good you know when the game is normal and said you win only if the investigation is complete and you have been eliminated otherwise you lose the game you never got actually you take some of these out depending on number of players mmm always yours yours number oh yeah two or more so we're good um but yeah the number of characters I've always loved and they're those staples if you played Arkham or second edition or third edition or eldred's they're all the same people but in every single one that's one of my favorite things about these games these Cthulhu games of fantasy
playmates is they don't tell you the same story like you get I mean it would probably be more similar but you get to know these characters a little bit more an if it and like there's times we're all drawn but yes I got I got this character and I know a lot about him because of just how much story has been driven right um no Rex Murphy in this game unfortunately 89 this one no he's not in son mansions unless he was added in the latest expansion I'd have to look him up yeah yeah I'm gonna [ __ ] once Rex Murphy hey you don't get successes your curse your curse yeah you can't you can't wait well they don't yeah this game they don't really incorporate disadvantages the only way they can incorporate is in their numbers right so his ones this video is brought to you by audible audible is offering you a free audiobook with the 30 day trial membership all you need to do is go to audibletrial.com/preneurcast me to be able to listen to The Wheel of Time series which is phenomenal if you're looking for a huge fantasy world but if fantasy isn't your thing well you can also do romance fiction teens nonfiction comedy science and technology and many many more all you need to do is go to audibletrial.com/preneurcast
everything about this game I like laying out the map tiles you do like that because you like the trail of that was on the hill for that same reason that's probably my favorite thing I like honestly um not only do I like laying off the map tiles I like hearing the story uh really I could do without the combat or the fighting like if they could just wrap up the story like and lay down the paddles I think I'd be fine with that yeah yes I think it's so interesting I I agree combat is to me it's yeah I'm more engrossed in the story that we never combat happens I'm like oh all right hip mechanical about this like kind of like D&D like I get because sometimes like this one this one didn't need monsters and sometimes they just kind of put them in there and it's like I would I would have been fun with the big bad person but the extra monsters I'm like really like they need to be there and then others whenever it's like like the the zombie one or it's like yeah that one's gonna make sense and they can be really neat and you can you play completely different based on the scenario that you're in one thing I do like I love how they handle comp non-combat how they handle handle are they your handle damage and or I really like that I like how it's just not just a token and you add or attorney that you take away its cards them that are somatic right to what's going on I really like have to meet those phase words if every like all to meet those phases and all the sanity
checks and combat pertain to the monsters and the scenario like I really like that like I would sign just some generic one that doesn't make any sense right like you're attacked by a zombie there but there's no zombie there but this one is home swells yeah and some of them can be like terrifying like almost like deep madness whenever we were like we'd really like that madness garden it was like play this for the rest of your your mouth is permanently so and shower yours so they get really if you get into the engrossment of the game and the theme they can actually be kind of terrifying and so I mean my favorite my favorite thing about this game is is the theme like it's it's Cthulhu it's very engaging as as a game and it was almost I can't imagine not being engrossed into the themes like they do such a good job with the app I love the conditions that you can get I love the way and conditions actually came from L rhetoric ultratour are you there are condition cards and there's there's a bunch of them that will affect your character and things that are happening to you I also really like how spell spell have done the same way and Elder tour where it's like in Arkham or you roll dice and just did whatever the spell did I love how in Eldridge and Ann Arkham you have different effects based off the spell like there's a missive roll a deck where
it's like hey they're all gonna be different based off their so you still activate them doing the same thing but they all do something different right I love that just it makes it it makes everything unique and you're like oh well what's the spoken to do this time or what's this condition going to do this time so there's just so much variety in the game in all reality like the expansions really they're probably more expensive than what you get but at the end of the day how many scenarios are there there are 219 and one thing that they've done brilliantly is they can make DLC like there's two two DLCs for five bucks three sorry three deal seats for five bucks and so they can just be like alright well we're done but here there's a DLC Packer mmm whatever your scenario yeah give new scenario and just use the stuff that you got because I mean honestly you have more than enough right all right I mean that's that's pretty that's pretty much it like I can't I can't think of really anything else about like about the game that we haven't already said I mean there's items like so there's so much right so much to it like even though you have 19 scenarios probably most of those you'll have at least two endings mm-hmm so if you do one and you're like ooh let's do that one again and try and
go for this ending or and then you might get surprised and be like oh there's what third ending that we didn't know about that we stumbled upon like well what has happened if we just started this one to be like yeah it was hurt yeah I'm sure there's like there's gonna you know there's the one where you just take too long and then the person reveals themselves and then their scheme goes off yeah there's probably the wrong finger ending oh yeah and then there's a then there's the proper finger ending yep so yeah so at least in this one there's three endings the one we did a long time ago was three endings there's a say the wrong finger ending isn't just the same as the you know she you know performed her scheme yeah yeah I mean so am i it's at least two mmm so I love it I love it and it's it's one that you can get almost anyone to play because since it is that's what that's one brilliant thing that the app does it first addition you had to have someone who always played the overlord or that they called it the keeper and it's like so I control us so it's mainly going to be the person that [ __ ] owns the game I can't bring out for a Sedition be like hey you're gonna control it this time let me teach you how that is because capture I've got ones hmm and it's like well you didn't really know you know what to do so the game's not that fun right a second addition makes it fully cooperative and therefore if you're getting people who don't really know what to do you could help them mm-hmm that's also why don't want paint sandy cards because that puts in an element that now new people don't know and then you have to look into a whole news for the rules that you didn't need before so all the stealing the pushing the attacking other player is
yep when before you didn't need to do anything because you weren't gonna do any of them mm-hmm so yeah that's just another reason why I don't like insanity but love it love this game I can't remember where ranked in my top 100 I believe I can't imagine it was past 53 servers with him my top 50 but it's still on there and the more I play it it's always a blast and and it's a fantastic game so scale one to ten cat always neither yep yep yeah I really am you have any board game I probably have isn't the most yeah it's true well technically oh well you probably played art well yeah I mean with other people this Oh actually I think it's pandemic legacy but I think it was this was your number one co-op game yeah I'm gonna give it a 9 I figured you would give it a 10 because because in my ranking for a 10 is like no game is absolutely perfect I couldn't eat paste stuff right but so probably say for you yeah there are some stuff that you're like yeah but at the end of the day like I'm never unhappy to play it's never like oh like like if you came over the mahram like hey we're
doing mansions again you'd be like cool yeah like even if we did this exact same one you'd be like me like we can play like again and I'm like ok yeah yeah right after another yeah and I'm a mine thank me as high I'm gonna give it a 9 um because I really really do not like those insanity cards and that's the problem is they don't even come up that often but I'm well I'm pretty sure they come from every game because someone is going to go insane unless you have really high every character has really high horror uh it's just I I don't like them when they do come up so that it kind of likes me that much and calm let me comment here's the thing combat is still fun because there it's it's grounded in theme it's not like folklore or almost every other comic game where it's like all right to damage that's it but like it's like they give you a descriptive of what you're doing you deal down to one mean and take aim and then you roll and then it tells you a pass or fail which is also a thematic and it goes all different sense each time yeah yeah and in your different weapons so I love that some unique items that is actually thing about that it's used in the game like hey you've gotten this evidence now you can read it and get more information so that's just more invigorating and more the mattock and more just diving into the story but yeah those insanity cards hate them well I think they've tried to you know it seems like some of the most recently released insanity cards yeah aren't so they don't affect the game they're more effect like a person yeah
like the event this new for the quiet cards that can't disagree yeah I think those aren't terrorists yeah we're kinda like line of fun don't look like I've always liked games that take outside elements and put it into it like stuff like that yeah imagine if I got in the car that set up argue with the person you're like okay you need to go here I was like yeah yeah and and stuff like the NC so and stuff like that is neat and and you're right I do I do like those because there's another game called death of winter that crisis cards or [ __ ] like that can pop up or the crossroads cars will be like if someone scratches their head to read this car at the home so things like that and I've always loved that my problem still with that same argument is that those insanity cards are cute or neat the first time because then as soon as someone that gets that card and is like okay you uh you have to argue with the person to your left then let's say they get that again they start arguing you're gonna know exactly what what's wrong with them so it's no longer thematic mmm you're gonna then sort here in a minute I mean there's no way it's like oh she has that card or someone starts walking away from the thing and it starts lighting fires you're like I know exactly what they're giving you beautiful things candle yeah I mean so yeah exactly or I mean and those are the one the others some in here that you won't really know like forbidden words you cannot speak you win or lose the game as normal you're gonna know that the person's kind of quiet okay they probably have this insanely so all those ones are cute and then they're no longer
needed then they're just annoying so so yeah it's still not an intent for me some of these like I said I like I'm in like in theory but at the end of the day they they knock it down for me but other than that the game is phenomenal it's still a 9 out of 10 it's just that one thing they from being perfect for me you get there anything else anything else that I missed awesome oh so that's our thoughts on matches of madness second edition let us know what you think of the game in the comments below other than that like I'm unsure and subscribe and ever wonderful with every time of day of this for you hey everyone thanks so much for watching this and if you like this video then click the subscribe button below to enjoy any video that I put out and right next to that subscribe button it's a little Bell click that so you get notified of whenever I actually upload these videos if you want to support the channel you can definitely visit my patreon page the link is in the description below other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful with every time of day this for you