Skip to main content
Loading video...
Transcript 18:12

Welcome to John Gets Games. Today I'll be reviewing La Isla. This is the game about exploring a tropical island full of exotic animals. In this game, you'll be using simultaneous action selection and multi-use cards to achieve your goals. First, I'll go over the rules and then I'll jump into my review. Here's a starting setup for a two-player game. We have white player up here and red down here. In the middle, we have a randomly built uh map with all these little pieces that kind of come apart and come back together again. And then we also randomly dispersed all these little animal tokens around every single region of the board that have these twos, threes, and fours. At the start of each turn, every player draws three cards from the top of the deck. Each player has a board like this in front of them with an A, a B, C, and D slot. However, you'll notice the C is kind of curved, and A, B, and D are rectangular. That's because we're going to be putting our three cards on A, B, and D.

Simultaneously, each player is going to decide which of these three cards goes to A, which goes to B, and which goes to D. To understand this decision, we need to know the three different parts of each card. The top half of the card has a bunch of icons on it and each card has a different set. And this is the A portion of the card. So that means if we put this card down here under A, then only the top half of this card will count. Nothing on the bottom will. The second part of a card is the bottom left hand corner, which always has a cube of varying colors. There are five in the game. This has to do with the B slot. So if we put this card on B, then this would mean we would be taking a yellow cube from the supply and we would be ignoring the top and right hand parts of the card. The third part of each card is the animal in the bottom right hand corner. There are five different animals in the game and they show up down here.

When you put a card in the D slot, then only the bottom right part will activate, not the top or the left hand side. Once every player has simultaneously selected which card goes into A, B, and D, we reveal them. Now, we can reveal A's and B's all together with no particular order. So, each player is going to flip over their A's, and they're going to immediately slide in to the top slot in any of these slots on the top of their player board here. What these A cards do is give you a potential bonus or kind of engine building uh ability that you're going to have for as long as that card is face up. So, down here, we see that for the red player, the tan cubes are now wild. And for the white player, whenever they go for the brown cube in the B phase, they're going to get a bonus brown cube. So, they get two cubes when they go for one. At this point, everybody reveals their B simultaneously. And we see that white put a brown cube down here, but because of their bonus, white is going to get two brown cubes from the bank.

And red got a tan. And red is pretty happy about that because tan is wild for red. Phase C of each turn is not simultaneous. This will go in player order, starting with the uh first player with a starting player token and then clockwise around the table. This is the phase where we're going to take our explorers and we're going to potentially put them out onto the map. When you place an explorer on the map, you put them in these angled colored regions on the board. So, for instance, you would put it right here. You never put them in the region specifically that have the animals on them. The cost to place an explorer in any of these little angled regions is two cubes of the color of that region. For instance, this right here would cost two green for the red player in order to put the explorer down. In this case, red could potentially go right here. They could spend one gray because it's a gray location. And then they'll spend one of these tan cubes because tan is wild for them. Now, it's white's turn. White can place anywhere on the board, including the spot that red just went. In fact, there are many cards in this deck that give you special powers that give you bonuses for going into locations with other players explorers already. In this case, white, for instance, could go over here and just spend those two brown that they picked up earlier in their turn.

What you're trying to do with these explorers is place them down on the map to fully surround tokens. We see these little numbers, a two, a four, and a three. That shows you the number of spots that it takes to surround uh that animal. So, this moth right here has a two on it. That's because it's flanked by these two locations. The moment white places an explore down here, white is going to take this token, and they're going to immediately score victory points equal to the number of uh spots it took to surround. So, white would immediately get two victory points, and then we keep this token for the rest of the game. This means it's also possible to get multiple tokens in one move. For instance, if white went right here, they would immediately surround this frog and they would immediately surround this dodo. They get both these tokens and they would get four plus two or six points. You also have the option to not place an explore out on the map. Maybe you can't or maybe you choose not to, but if you don't, you get to take any cube from the bank you want and put it into your supply for following turns.

You might have noticed all the little icons that are on the angled spots that these explorers can go on. They have no inherent ability, but many of the uh actions in this deck of cards that you slide up here for the A area give you bonuses. You might get a discount for placing in a region with a satchel. You might get bonus points for placing in a region with a rope. Once each player has taken a C phase, everybody is going to simultaneously reveal the cards they have under D. And this is going to be for scoring. So, we look at the bottom of this card and we see it's got a little puma cat animal icon. We look over to the scoring track here and we take the little purple cylinder and we move it up once on that track because that matches the same icon. Anytime a player increases one of these score tracks for the animals, they immediately get victory points equal to the number of that animal they have in their possession. We see that red player here started with two of these puma cat-like animals here. So, red bumped that one up. Red is going to get two victory points right now. And at the same time, white revealed a card with a mouse on it. So, the mouse track goes up once.

But since white currently has no mouse tokens, white will get no victory points for that. At this point, each player discards their last card and we move the starting player token clockwise around the board. And now each player draws three more cards from the deck and they proceed to take another turn. A couple quick notes about the A slot on each of these player boards. When you have a turn so that you are going to place the fourth one, all you do is you just slide it in and you cover up a previous ability. You no longer have access to that, but you're forced to do this every single turn. And the other thing is you're never allowed to have two of an identical ability. So I could not have this ability in here to get a double bonus off of the brown uh cube. However, if I had a color that perhaps got me an extra yellow cube when I go yellow, that's totally fine. And here's a couple more examples just to give you an idea of the actions that can happen. This one right here says, "Every time uh you take a Puma tile from the board, you immediately get to bump up any of the scoring tracks for any of the animals and of course immediately get victory points for the number of that token.

have. This one right here gets you two points. Whenever you put an explorer in a location with an opponent, so that's great. And then here's one of those discounts. Whenever you put an explorer on a spot with a hat, you get to pay only one cube of that color instead of two. Let's look at the animal scoring tracks a little more closely. We see that there is a zero for this whole chunk. Then we have a little 1 2 3 4 and five. And this is the endgame scoring for those tokens that we have. This means at the beginning of the game, each token is actually worth zero points. However, this is also the endgame clock. If we look over here, we see two little uh people and then we have a seven. That means the game is going to end at the end of any turn when the sum of these scoring tracks is seven or more. For instance, here each moth is worth three victory points. Each frog is worth two. Each dodo and mouse are worth one. But collectively, that's 1 2 3 4 5 6 7. If it was like this at the end of any turn, the game is immediately over and we shift into endame scoring. In a three-player game, the sum we need to hit is nine. And in a four-player game, the sum we need to hit is 11. Now that the game is over, we can calculate our endgame points. First of all, you get 10 points for each complete set of the five animals you have. For instance, red here has one complete set, so they would get 10 points. Now, each token that you've picked up throughout the game is worth points equal to its position on the scoring track. So, these two moths right here are worth three points each for six. These two dodos are worth one point each for two.

This one mouse is worth one point for one. And these three pumas are worth zero points. So that probably wouldn't actually happen in the game, but that's the way the scoring works. Players also convert their excess cubes into victory points at a rate of two cubes for one point. And after you've added it all up, the player with the most points is the winner. Cubes are the tiebreaker. For my review of La Isla, I'm going to explain my thoughts on each item of this list, starting at the top and working my way down. So let's start with positive number one. This has to do with how streamlined this game feels largely due to almost everything happening simultaneously. Only the putting the explorers down phase of the game happens in turn order for the most part. Everything else is just deciding on things all at the same time. And what that means is you have this satisfying experience where you're making interesting decisions and you're like, "Oo, this one but that one. Wait, not not that one." But you're not also worrying about everyone staring at you, like being bored because it's not their turn. It's pretty much always everybody's turn. So, everybody's making these crunchy decisions at the same time. But ultimately, the game almost always lasts about 45 to 50 minutes regardless of your player count. So, it it kind of has a feeling of a game that's much longer uh in a very tight compact amount of time. So, it it almost becomes a super filler to me. I mean, 45 minutes, that's pretty quick. You can squeeze that in at the beginning or at the end of a game night without a problem. and I think is a testament to this game that it's a really fun, satisfying experience while at the same time being incredibly time efficient.

Positive number two has to do with those multi-use cards that you draw at the beginning of your turn and that really the whole game circles around how you're going to use them. Now, multi-use cards in general as a mechanic is not necessarily new, but I think this game does a very good job of streamlining that mechanic into a slightly lighter experience while still having great decisions. When you look at those cards, you usually only have three of them in front of you. You're really thinking about the pros and cons over that cube color that you really need versus that animal token, which you already have a bunch of and you really want to score big in the endame versus those actions that are up on top. And they really they intersect in very interesting ways and I really enjoy that decision while you're sitting there looking at your hand trying to figure out which is going to go where. Now, sometimes the game does not provide you with as many opportunities as you might want. Like all three cards might have the same color cube and that color cube is not good for you. But usually you're going to have very interesting decisions to be made with such a very small amount of cards in your hand. And this leads me directly into positive number three, which has to do with the communal animal victory point scoring board that everybody is playing with. Now, this gives great incentives and disincentives for the decision you're making when you're looking at the cards that are in your hand because that token that you're going to be um well, that card that you're placing down into the D slot is going to increase the scoring modifier for everyone's tokens throughout the game. You're not always going to have a hand of cards that are going to have the uh animal on it that you maybe have a bunch of tokens on. So, you're often going to be looking at the tokens that your opponents have, looking at the tokens that they might be about to get

on the player board and deciding how that's going to affect which card you put down to increase one of these because you're going to be increasing one of these no matter what every single turn. So, I love the fact that these modifiers are communal and it adds a little bit of indirect player interaction that I think works really well in this game. And now, neutral number one. This has to do with the tactics to strategy ratio. And now tactics have to do with the shortrun goals and decisions and strategy is more the medium to long run goals and decisions. This game is not terribly long, so you would kind of expect that it would be mostly tactical with not much strategy, but that being said, I wish there was a bit more strategy added in. Now, heavy tactics in a game is totally fine by me, especially when you're dealing with those multi-use cards that you're going to be drawing at the beginning of your turn and deciding on what you're going to do right now.

And you could definitely say that well the card that you're choosing as the power to slide into your little your little pocket board on the bottom is going to be a bit of a strategy because you want to have something that's going to help you out several turns in the future. But often times those powers have to do with very short-sighted goals like uh you get a discount when you go on the spot with a rope and there's only really only one spot in the rope on the board that might be good for you in that specific moment. So you're going to find yourself getting rid of those relatively quickly. They're not going to form a cohesive strategy I'd say. And I wish there was a little bit more opportunities to have that. Maybe if you could save a couple more of these powers in front of you, you could keep a couple of them going a little bit longer and get a little bit more synergy going with them versus having to essentially start ripping your engine apart on the fourth turn of the game, which is an interesting decision, but it's heavily tactical. And like I said, I just wish there was a little more opportunity for strategy. And now for neutral number two. This is pretty simple. I just wish that the component quality of the stuff you get inside the box was a little bit higher. It's not that big of a deal because the game itself is actually quite cheap and I imagine that's part of the reason why. But it could be a little hard to tell some of the cubes apart and also some of the cube colors on the table to the cube colors on the cards.

I've had a couple people play the game say, "Well, is that supposed to be a brown cube or is that supposed to be a gray cube?" And especially also with the map out there, is that the gray or the brown? Once you play, you know, at least half a game, it all sinks together and you kind of get it. But I feel like this stuff should just pop right in the beginning of the game. there shouldn't really be questions about it. And also these player sheets, the player aids, um these are both different. They cover all of the different uh bonuses that go on the top of the cards that you can slide into your little player board. But this is all you get. One side is English, the other side is German, and you only get one. And the first time you teach this game with some new people, they're going to need to look at this. There is a ton of icons that they're going to want to digest. And the icons make sense once you've seen them all once, but the first time you see them, you're definitely not sure how they play out. So, this thing is just getting passed around like crazy. I don't know why the game didn't come with four of these. It just seems like a sillier mission. And now for the one negative I have for Le Isla. And simply put, I feel like there might be too many layers of randomness in the game. You know, you start out by taking that board and kind of tooththing it all together. And then you take animal tokens, you scatter those all around the board, and then everybody takes a little token that has two of an animal on it.

They put it in front of them. It's kind of a specialization that they start off with, and then everybody's drawing cards randomly from the stack and evaluating them. And when you add all of these layers of randomness together, I've seen situations where there are clusters of animals on the board that will inherently benefit the person who started out with the double token for that. Now, you could say, well, everybody can go over there and everybody can try and get in on that. But that doesn't change the fact that the person who had that token has an inherent advantage because especially if people are going over there to get it, they're probably going to keep bumping that one token up. So, they're going to be constantly rising to the top of that little bubble because they happen to randomly get the double dodo token, for instance. I've also seen situations where since the game is relatively short, people just never get good hands. You know, they have these abilities they're trying to make work and they never sync up together and they're constantly well taking this one out.

Maybe this one will be good. And whenever that's happening, this person is doing like second and third rate turns. They're trying to do the best they can with the cards are got they've got. They look across the table and there's somebody who's just this card sinks into this card. and I get a wild card for this and when I place on a hat I get six points for that and then I of course score the dos and I get five points for that and I've been scoring dodos every single turn and it just kind of drives that person who's getting the lackluster cards a little bit crazy. Now ultimately this game is not broken because of this. Not by any means especially considering it is short. So if you have a run of the game where you just feel like you're getting bad luck well good news it's going to be over in 45 minutes and you can try again and maybe that won't be the case. But ultimately, I do wish luck played a little bit less of a factor. I'm not sure how I could really do much about that. I've thought about maybe going down to single uh creature chits at the beginning of the game instead of double, but ultimately it's very inherent in the design. I don't think it makes the game bad, but I do think it is an issue that I can't necessarily ignore. And now, let's talk about replay-ability. Simply put, I feel like the game has a very good amount of it that's not necessarily big, and it's definitely not small. And the reason that's not big is because I feel like after you play the game like three or so times, every time you play it after that is going to be roughly the same experience. Now, sure, the board is different and the animal token disparity is different and the cards you're going to draw are going to be different, but ultimately the game is quite simple and you're going to be doing the same thing in game four as you're probably going to be doing in game 10. Now, that's not

that big of a deal because what you're doing is enjoyable, but it's not going to be a new doors opening up once you've played this game 15 times, I don't think. And on the flip side, it's not low because of all the different random setups that you have in this game. You're not going to feel like, oh, you've solved it at any point. And now, let's talk player count. This game plays two, three, and four players. And I've tried all of those different combinations, and I have to say, they all work really well for this game. The best is definitely four players. Uh, the reason for that is because this game has a lot of interaction when there are four players. Many of the cards in the deck give you bonuses of resources or discounts or or just victory points for going on locations where other players explorers are. And I found in two-player game, you it's a very solitary experience. You might cross over a little bit, but for the most part, you're probably going to be doing stuff on your own side of the board, whereas in that four-player game, you're all in each other's business like crazy. And I think that definitely adds into the value of the game. Also, the fact that the four-player game plays just about the same amount of time as a two-player game means if you have the opportunity, definitely play with more players because there's really no downside. In conclusion, I think that Leila is a good game. I see it sticking around in my collection for quite a while. I came into it very excited and I think that that excitement has definitely fallen a little bit once I realized just how tactical and random the game really is.

But on the flip side, I've also enjoyed myself almost every time I played it. Now, I did have one game where I really did feel like I was just hosed. Like, I never got the cards I needed and I had a terrible score. I pretty much got lapped by everybody else. And this was not my first game. I had won games with huge scores already before this. And I know that that's going to probably happen again in the future. But I do see myself playing this game in a year. I do see myself playing this game in two or three years because it's so easy to teach. It's such a tiny time frame. I feel like there are many opportunities to get this game out and play it with experienced gamers and non-experienced gamers that it definitely has a spot in my collection and I think it's worth looking into. I hope you've enjoyed this review. If you'd like to see more like it in the future, please consider subscribing to my YouTube channel.

Thanks for watching.

Progress saved