The Hobbit: There and Back Again Review - Creature of Hobbit
Transcript
Hey there everybody. I'm Mike Delisio.
I'm Joey Evans.
And I'm Camila.
And today we're going to be taking a look at The Hobbit. There and back again. a new Rolland Wright style game from designer Riner Kenitia and publisher Office Dog. So, uh, I'm not the biggest Lord of the Rings fan. I like it, but I'm not like crazy with the lore. How about you, Joey and Camila?
I really like it, but I It's definitely one of those IPs that I'm hesitant to ever tell people that I really like because this, as Joey always says, that's the moment you find out you really don't like it as much as the rest of the world. Uh, so I really do tend to gravitate towards it, but I I've uh I don't get lost in it necessarily. So it was it was exciting to me for sure.
Yeah, I like it a lot. I mean, but again, I don't like go to War of the Ring and all that stuff, but I like and I love Rolling, right? So when I this was announced, I was really excited about this.
All right. Well, the reason why I asked is that the game is supposed to kind of follow the major story points of The Hobbit. So maybe you guys can talk to that more than I can because I read the book when I was quite a bit older or younger, excuse me. But regardless, Tom's going to show us how this game plays and then we'll come back here and we'll let you know what we think.
This game is made up of various scenarios which you'll go through this book and pick which scenario you're going to play. You can play them in order for the story, but they're all going to be resolved in the same way. This is a game in which you're going to be rolling five dice and then drafting one of those dice and going around a table and when there's no dice left then you pick up the dice, roll them again and keep going. The many so the dice are not the same. This one here is going to let you draw different paths on the board and other ones have to do with various resources. How you draw the paths and how the resources work is going to be different based on the map. So, in the first one, I'm just going to tell you some of the rules for this one. Sometimes when you take resources, you're going to actually take physical resources. And in this particular one, for example, when you roll swords, you're going to be collecting them. And then at the end of the game, you're going to get points based on how many swords you've gotten. Also, wizard hats, when you collect them, you can cross off these to take certain sections of roads that you need or bread or swords. And each section always has basically wild cross off some stuff to get some whatever you need to get there. Then here you're going to be drawing lines on the board. You'll be drawing trying to connect these dwarves to Froto's little hidey-hole here. And you know you can connect Oh, now I got two connected.
As you connect these dwarves, you'll be crossing off here. But you need to have food for them. And you need to get the food first before the dwarves. If not, then the dwarf's going to score points, but not for the food. And you can see the food points get pretty high. The same here with Thoren and with Gandalf. Getting them in there will get you bonus points. And that's pretty much it. You're you're for this particular one. And then each of the different sections in the rule book has their own rules. We have roast mutton and overhill and underhill, riddles in the dark, out of the frying pan into the fire, a dark way through mirkwood, on the doorstep, and then there's hard mode for each of these. So if you want to make it even more difficult, you can do that. And then some rules for solo, but basically it's going to be a lot of what you're doing is the resources, but that's backing up you drawing kind of a journey through the board.
All right. So, that should give you a general idea of what The Hobbit There and back again is all about. It's a, as we mentioned, a rolling right style game where you're playing uh there are eight chapters in the game. They say you do not have to complete them uh starting with one and going through eight. But, I will tell you that's the way I played it. I just kind of went through uh from one all the way across. Um the way I kind of looked at it and I'm interested to see what you uh you two think is that I felt like other than kind of like twist to the formula, there were two basic types of puzzles that were included in this game. You had kind of the path building and then you had the polyominos. Do you feel similarly?
Yeah, I definitely do because the whole thing is it is mainly that route building or path building, but it's nice to get that variation when the polyominos show up. You're like, "Oo, doing something a little bit different this time, you know?"
Right. Yeah, it definitely does feel like that's you could categorize all of them into one of the two of those. And it really but that doesn't detract from each one feeling very unique at the same time. It feels like the categorically it's either the path building or the polyomino, but there's still really neat ways that each scenario handles that and tackles it.
That's that's one thing that I want to mention, the fact that this feels almost like eight different games, which makes me feel like this is fantastic. You're getting pretty much eight different rolling rights. And again, you can, like you mentioned, you can jump into any chapter. You don't have to know anything before or after. So you're getting eight different scenarios that you can play each of those again and again and they feel different. So you're getting eight different games in this box which is incredible.
Yeah. And the basic rules for the game, you know, essentially what you have is a basic rule set that they talk about and then anything that is unique to that particular scenario is on that kind of pages uh off to the side there somewhere. But within that simple rule set, um, as you mentioned, you can get some very different feeling, uh, puzzles that that add some unique twists, that add some restrictions, uh, that that add, uh, just little things you have to kind of consider that really do change the feel of the game. Um, did you have any particular element of the game that you liked the best? I mean, for me, um, I think I liked the the idea of progression through those particular maps where you had to kind of do something first before you can go into the next one. Before you can go into the next one, before you can go into the next one. I think that was one thing that really sung for me as well is is when the map is broken up into different areas and not necessarily the ones where it's like you have to do this before you can go, but more you have that choice of when do you go into the next one. Uh there's one specifically with the polyominos and it's like once you cross over this line you can't go back. So if you haven't def defeated that goblin yet then you're missing out on that opportunity but ultimately you are trying to get to the end first and collect as many points as you go. So, I really liked that decision point, specifically the ones where it's like once you cross cross this threshold, you can't go back. You're saying I've gotten everything I can out of this one and I'm
leaving it behind now. I think that that made for some really interesting um kind of racing throughout it. And I think that's what that's that's the one that really sung for me.
I agree. That's the thing I I enjoyed the race, but then you have sacrifices. You're like, I'm getting too far behind. I have to sacrifice this. I'm not going to get it. I love those ones where you can't do everything and that really gives it. And again, I love the progression of this because it doesn't do what I think I think a lot of rolling rights and things that do these chapters things, they fumble in a way that they add layers of complexity every time. So when you get to the last chapter, you're like you're at a totally different game that is so much more that to hit the table. This it's a perfect I think every chapter is a perfect side step. Sometimes a bit more complexity, but not a lot. That's what I really love. I think that's a good um point to make there is that it does feel like that side step because at the end of the day there's very few components in here. Yes, there's the bread, there's the swords, there's, you know, a couple dice. I mean, there's very little componentry in here, but what they've been able to do with these feeling unique and different without raising complexity. It's like this time you're using everything. I mean, there there's some where it's like you're using nothing but the dice, and that's okay. I I think that feels just as good as the one where you're collecting bread, you know, or or whatever the different scenarios may be. So, I think that's really where it sings is it does feel like a lot of side steps without increasing componentry, increasing a lot of rule set. It's not getting in its own way of getting to the table.
Yeah.
Yeah. I agree with that. Although, I will say, Camila, how dare you leave out the pine cones. But, but without getting
the one component, there's only four components. I had to choose one to leave out. without getting too too deep into the pine cone uh you know snubbing. Uh yeah, I agree. I agree completely with you guys. And since you kind of brought up production, maybe we'll talk about that for a moment. Um it's a really nice package. I mean, I first of all love the way they handle the art in this. It's not quite comicbooky, but it has a little bit of that. It it just is a really neat look throughout the game. I think that the uh kind of the the baby books as I've called them. Yeah.
Those board books, right? That that are dry erase I think was a brilliant choice. And like you say, Camila, there's not a lot of components and they've been able to kind of utilize them in multiple ways that all make sense where it doesn't feel like they're cheaping out. It feels like they're being efficient with their components and keeping the price point at a reasonable one for a roll and right game that as you said Joey is essentially eight different games. So, uh I really think the production and the rule book is good. The production is topnotch in my opinion.
Yeah, I agree. The production blew me away. Again, the artwork is so different. Almost gives me that vintage Hobbit feel cuz I grew up on that old the old cartoon. It gave me that feel again.
Absolutely. But it it's also standing apart from so many of the Lord of the Rings things that we're seeing that are coming um out here recently. So I think it is tap still tapping into nostalgia
but also standing on its own and that's a very very hard thing to nail and I think it did.
Yeah.
Who's ready for final thoughts?
Yep. Absolutely. You
who wants to go first?
I'll jump in here. Um I'm going to come down at a 7.5 on this one. I really enjoy my time in this game and I' I've very much enjoyed the progression and it's one that you play that first one and you're excited to see what's next. You're excited to see what's next. Um and to the point that after eight I'm like but I want five more. It can't be done yet. So I really enjoy it. Uh what kind of brings it down for me is I do think that you're quickly going to outgrow a couple of the scenarios. They're just too simplistic almost. That being said, that's balanced. There's other ones that I'm very very much enjoying. So I think once you go through all eight games once, maybe twice, you're really going to go from like I have eight different games probably down to like I have four that I would really enjoy at any time. Um, and that's that's what I have found with this is I get excited about playing those games again, but maybe not going through everything because some of them are just too too simplistic. You know, you play the first one and and people that have shown the first one to like, oh, I'm like, okay, well now let me show you what this game can do. So you immediately feel that need to step into it. That being said, I think it's a a great production.
Absolutely. I love the direction they went with them. I'm very much enjoying this and I think it is going to hit the table quite often, just maybe not in the full not even a campaign, but full story scope. So a 7.5 for me.
Yeah, I'll go next. I I agree with that, but I think I see that more of a plus for me because you're right, there are some I wouldn't go to. However, this box will come out so often because there are people right there that will not they do not want a larger a more in-depth role and write. So, there's a couple scenarios I'm like, "All right, you will like this one." Like the first one, it's pretty simple to say, "Here's what you got to do, you know?" So, I can see myself playing with different people, different scenarios, and it's got such a wide wide birth of which ones you want to go. I'm coming at a nine on this. I really really enjoy this. I love rolling rights. And this right here again is the production on this. I really enjoy this. I love the theme. The Hobbit was probably the book I read the most in college. And I love the production of this. And
sorry Mike, but this doesn't feel like a kigia to me. I hate to say that, but just everything about this is different. I really really enjoy this game. So that's a nine for me.
Wow, that's impressive. I I'm splitting the difference a little bit. I'm coming in at an eight. Uh what I would say is this. I think the reason it's it it it dropped from an 8.5, which is right on the edge of quite honestly, is that I don't think you're ever going to have a better experience than the first time you play through it. So, I would say my first playthrough of the eight chapters was an 8.5, but after coming back and revisiting some of them, it does lose a little bit of its luster because it has to be expected that that sense of um, you know, discovery. Thank you. Is not going to be there the second, third, fourth time you play it. But it is a rock solid game in a genre that I really am kind of done with. Uh, Roland Rice, this got me excited again.
I played through all eight in the course of a couple of days because I just kept wanting to come back to it. I've enjoyed experiencing it a new with players that that I'm teaching it to or or playing for the first time. And so, it's something that I easily recommend. It's really close to an 8.5 for me, but look, Joey's given it the seal of excellence anyway, so I don't even have to worry about it. We all certainly recommend it. Joey really recommends it.
I really do.
All right. Genius.
Exactly. Well, that's going to do it for us. Until next time, I'm Mike Delisio.
I'm Joey Evans.
And I'm Camila.
And don't forget about the pine cones.
Hey everybody, thanks for watching this video. If you like this review or whatever you just watched, wasn't it amazing? Uh, check out our channel, Dice Tower. We have all kinds of things. We review games, we do top 10s, we play games live. It's all about board games, but especially the people who play them. Check out Dice Tower YouTube channel.