Skip to main content
Loading video...
Transcript 21:31

hello everyone and welcome back to the board gaming doctor my name is Phil and I'll be your board game doctor today so in this episode I'm going to go over my first impressions of arcs and this is the latest hotness by Cole Cole worly and leader games art by Kyle faren it is a 2024 game although it was kickstarted a couple of years ago and a lot has changed with the game I remember it being uh talked about back then but not knowing how much of a hype it was until recently since backers have receiv received it it's already in the top 1,000 games of all time it's on the hotness of the number one hotness as of today so I was really pumped and excited to try this game out and I'm excited to talk about it and I know there are a lot of people who have done you know bigger overviews and first impressions who have uh played this game perhaps a lot more than I have as you can see this is a a two-player game that I've played with my friend uh we're partway through we're only on chapter two now but it was enough to get a sense of what is going on in this game and so I just wanted to share my thoughts and uh and display some of the game uh what the game looks like on tabletop simulator so as a quick overview you tell The Narrative of a Space Opera uh there are different factions and people in this game that you play as and over five chapters you uh take six rounds each playing uh trick taking type cards and I can show you by you know being my character here so you

take turns playing a card each turn and in a trick-taking fashion uh you take certain actions based off of these cards and the colors that they comprise to uh battle each other move around build cities take cards uh in the form of of some of these power cards over here and uh whoever has the most points has tracked here by the end of five chapters wins or I believe a few past 33 uh points in a two-player game for example then that also triggers the end of the game and whoever has the most wins so let's go over some gaming highlights first the trick taking aspect of this game so the Crux of this game does rely on how you play these cards not only for actions but also to gain the ability to do extra actions as well so for example if I would play like a five or a six card right here um I would be able to based off of the number of Pips here take two of the actions depicted if I rotate it here you'll see I would be able to move or provide influence so I could do any combination of those if I was the lead player so if my friend had played a similar card the same colored card as a six he would take the initiative the next round and be able to do more actions after that uh the stipulation is if you play cards uh if you play the same colored card afterward after the lead player you only get to I believe do one of those actions uh on

your card uh you could play it face down to copy the abilities mentioned on this lead card but only one of them as well or you can sacrifice a card even from your hand to uh secure yourself the uh lead the next round as if it were a trump card that you would play for trick taking and so there's a lot of tension that revolves around how you play these cards in which order you play them how much you sacrifice and in what order you ultimately want to do them in uh thus leading to creative ways and flexible ways to accomplishing what you want to do in arcs uh despite the initial tightness of how few actions you are able to do if you are not leading in addition uh if you do lead you get to declare Ambitions and these are depicted on the bottom right or bottom left of these cards and these ambitions are kept track of here and if you declare uh a certain ambition based off of a card you will place a marker on that to declare that the scoring opportunity in that particular chapter and if you have the most resources or the most uh captives or trophies for tyrant warlord respectively at the end of the chapter you get those points so another uh layer added onto the whole trick taking and card playing aspect of this game a lot of these cards will allow you to ultimately get these resources but I do want to point out

that these resources are very limited and despite the fact that the collection of these I these resources not only lead you to be able to score for potential Ambitions during that chapter but they are pretty fluid in the fact that you can use them first of all as a flexible means of taking actions yourself as depicted here on your board but also they are uh liable to being stolen during battles uh if someone else is uh you know attacking you and attacking a city or what have you that has those resources depicted and so a lot of the meat of this game the battling and interaction of this game is involving these resources and who has them in higher player accounts three and four players these resources will be depleted pretty quickly supposedly uh you know in my estimation and so a lot of the uh race is to get these these uh uh resources and hold on to them to be able to score big points later on and then in addition to the trick-taking uh cards as well as the resources you know this game features a lot of your typical 4X type of Ambitions uh not these Ambitions but the mechanisms of battling uh you have dice rolling as well which is its own thing you can assign different types of dice when you do battle and pick and choose which combination you would like so there's a lot of decisions to be made there but there's also the fact that you

have these cards available for not just purchase you have to take actions to secure them uh but you also get to play influence to hopefully gain the right to secure these cards and potentially also take other uh Agents from opposing players as captives which may score you for the Tyrant ambition if needed but these cards in and of themselves provide some unique abilities during the game uh they lay in front of your Tableau offering different um benefits that you could utilize but they can some of them can be stolen as depicted here as well and yeah and so there there's a good stack of these cards uh they're not as widely uh played or available uh during the entire game as some other games include like a market of cards are and so uh these cards can be very imp you know I'm I'm assuming that these cards are very impactful even though the deck isn't as big as you know in comparison to some other games U but yeah so in addition to this as well there are more cards and abilities that this game contains not depicted here I might throw a picture of that somewhere uh here as well but there are leader cards and lore cards which add uh setup variability and unique asymmetric Powers respectively during the game those are included in the base game as well I believe there are eight leaders and 14 lore cards and so there are tons of different combinations of leaders and LS

that you can combine as well but ultimately this is all accumulated under a campaign and this is a separate expansion that is not also depicted here in front of me but the campaign allows you to play three games back to back with different uh leaders and LS in addition to cards but also uh different events and and such to make the game feel a lot more intense a lot more complex and all of that is intertwined in a more narrative or storytelling Arc as well with uh some of these cards and not just from from gameplay but there's some actual story that is depicted with the campaign as well and so there are plenty of videos out there and unfortunately I do I have not played the campaign and so I can't really speak to that but that is also a part of this game as well so when you compare this game to others you first have to look at Worley's previous hits and releases from leader including oath and root now I have played root a fair bit I believe I have already talked about root on this channel and podcast I have not played oath but I am familiar somewhat of how that works and so I can see a lot of similarities and comparisons among the among these games including arcs there is a lot of asymmetric play uh more so in rout I feel the the asymmetry is more um you know stand off it stands out a lot more than it does in arcs I believe and the uh the political and kind of

Storytelling narrative aspect is very much the Forefront in oath as well it's more political more negot you know more negotiations are are uh woven into the story as well and so I and and I feel like root both oath and root are very replayable in the sense that root you have a lot of opportunities to uh really dive into a certain faction the way that they play which is very different from any other faction and really mastering that faction can take a lot of time and then you can also spend that time and and repetitious play using other factions as well and then oath since it is more of a narrative repeated plays often bring out an interesting thread of of the game that you start or the story that you start to tell through the game and arcs kind of is a mixture of a lot of those I think I think a lot of these cards especially the campaign aspect of this game uh focuses its uh storytelling uh you know pursuit in a more condensed way that you can you can pull out in in one day versus you know multiple and multiple nights of or or gaming sessions of oath to to tell a story you can accomplish that in a relatively shorter amount of time if you are playing arcs uh the a symmetry once again I I do need to explore some of the leaders that this game has to offer in terms of how as asymmetric the factions are when you do

play arcs but I think that sort of difference in how you approach the game can be seen by utilizing those those leaders and LS as well and so um all of that to say that ARX does feel like it contains a lot of the DNA that is found in root and oath and perhaps other worldly games as well but in a way that it feels a little bit more streamlined and elegant in arcs outside of leader games in particular there are other similarities with Pax games including Cole Worley's PA Premiere second edition as well as Pax Renaissance which is not by worly and you know those games really revolve a lot around card play and creating you know an engine with those cards in front of your Tableau to interact with a main shared board and in this game you do have the opportunity in arcs you have the opportunity to utilize some of these cards uh more so with the leaders and LS but I feel like the card play uh the interaction that you have with the market is different in those packs games it's I think a little bit more in the Forefront in comparison to this game where I feel like these cards add a lot of spice to what you're trying to accomplish uh mainly you know by trying to score Ambitions these mainly mostly try to uh just nudge you in the right direction to accomplish that whereas you need to play those cards right and and purchase the right cards at the right time to build a viable engine and Tableau in

front of you in PAX games to interact appropriately on the shared board as well but so in addition to that too there are other minor similarities that I found in games one is the more storytelling SLO mechanistic Style game names that uh Ryan Lockett has put out such as sleeping gods and near and far I feel like that combination of trying to tell a story and a narrative not just through mechanisms but also through text and Circumstance is a big similarity that I find in games like ARs and so I if I think if you like those games from lockit you would like arcs as well and then the campaign itself is very reminiscent of uber rosenberg's newsford which does include a solo campaign that I'm sure you could do this multiplayer as well but there is a set in stone rule or you know procedure that you can follow in newsphere to play three games back toback and combine those uh scores into a uh sort of a ranking basically B based off of how well you perform throughout those three games and so you can uh do that and and have a campaign style experience with a very much Euro Style game in in news feur moving on to the peer review so looking at the multitude of comments there are a lot of comments on this game on Board Game Geek with both praise and concerns for praise you know as this is

a world cold worldly game this game is very surprisingly easy to teach coming from games like oath which is very much nuanced and root which is a difficult teach because in on top of the base rules you're also teaching the faction specific uh requirements that you need to know and so for those who are maybe perhaps more casual to gaming or not familiar with the types of games that worly does it can be quite a teach in this in comparison ARS is a lot easier to teach it's a more streamlined experience with the trick-taking aspect and the uh the way that you score points and utilize actions in this game a lot of people really enjoyed that the uh the storytelling and narrative aspect that is conglomerated with the mechanisms is very well done as well in in arcs according to people the the flexibility and so this is both a praise and concern I think the uh the way that you can be flexible in taking your actions with the trick taking is very much appreciated and accomplishing a goal in a multitude of ways perhaps some of those ways being harder than others and requiring more effort but the ability to creatively arrive at your destination is one thing that ARS does in Spades and a lot of people really enjoy that overall the comments of how this game comes together as a whole not just the base game but including the module of leaders and LS and the campaign expansion people are

throwing out the phrases of this is the perfect game this is the best game of 2024 for already this is a modern classic Etc that was found everywhere however there are some concerns and some people perhaps made some comments when this game was earlier in development but a lot of these comments were pretty recent as well there is the luck of the draw that you must deal with with the the deck of trick-taking cards that you were assigned if you're assigned a quote unquote bad hand you have a much harder time overcoming that to accomplish what you want to and that can lead to some frustration espe especially with a longer game as this game uh a session may take about two to 3 hours depending on how familiar you are with this game and what modules you're using uh while it is easy to teach and play it's very hard to master and and so for those who want to play this game it's probably not going to unlock its full potential if you play a game a certain game once or twice a year for example compared to having a dedicated group playing this game over and over again unraveling the secrets and the nuances that this game has to provide so that that is a praise in and of itself but could be a concern to certain um folks who might play the this game it's not really a 4X According to some people it's it doesn't have the typical uh mechanisms and approach that a 4X game has it very much leans into the trick-taking uh mechanism and the

abstract nature of the board itself for example in how it plays out and so some people might be disappointed that it is not a true you know tried and true Forex game it's mostly just a Sci-Fi themed uh Euro game with some elements that do share with 4X in you know typical nature and yeah once again the restrictive nature of the trick taking the fact that if you do not lead you're very limited in what you can do for actions can be frustrating as well so going into my first impressions of this game I so first of all like I said I have played uh root and I have played that more than 10 times I really enjoy root I think I enjoy the concept of root a little bit more than I enjoy the game of Route itself it is a game that I am very interested in playing more of but I do see the requirement of really diving into the game to make it you know shine uh through and through it's it's a game that you have to dedicate a lot of time to and I enjoy games that offer that ability such as Agricola such as you know Through the Ages teram mytica all of these games you know are very uh strategic and very uh time dependent to finding success it it takes a lot of rep itions to really get your your groove in those games and I think ARS fits that as well and so I'm automatically very interested and uh enjoyed the concept of what arxs has to offer which is very similar with root but I will say that I

think I like ARS more than root because of the mechanisms and just how this game plays even though I've only played the base game without the leaders and LS I can see where that would take this game and because I do have a good understanding of how this game plays since it was relatively easy to teach I was able to teach my friend who doesn't play games of this caliber very often I we were able to play you know at least a round of it uh starting relatively late at night as well uh I was able to teach the game and and get a round in before we called it good and we we will probably continue this game but I really enjoyed how streamlined the teach and the play was and so for for someone who has enjoyed worldly games even though they are a little bit more opaque I have tried tax premere a couple of times uh I can also respect that design for but but I'm also a little scared to kind of dive into it I feel like I uh there are other games that I would rather dedicate my time to to really understanding and mastering uh so I think arcs would for me personally take more precedence than those other games based off of how easy it is to play and teach so I can have those rules uh in the back of my mind and and really think about this game strategically and and the and the flexibility of the trick taking yes it is it can be frustrating um I think it is more frustrating with three or four players I think this game will shine most at three players because of the balance of interaction as well as the Restriction uh it isn't as restrictive I

think as it would be for four players to uh utilize the trick-taking aspect of that game but I yeah I really respect the hype and the and everything that this game has to offer I would love to dive into this game even more and I think a testament of how great that was is that I was thinking about this game the day or you know two days after I played it uh thinking about what happened with our even our just first chapter here um we had a couple of battles here for example um I I wanted to kind of mess around and see what the combat was like and it was just really exciting to roll dice and and and I like the flexibility of these dice as well being able to choose what kind of dice you role uh to to kind of Target what you want to accomplish with your battle whether it's more you know battle the city play it defensively or to kind of do a high-risk High reward type of approach with the salt dice the red dice here and so yeah it was it was really fun and I you know thought about even you know without even thinking about it in the back of my mind I was kind of thinking about the The Narrative that this the story was telling and I think that would be even uh better with the leaders and LS as far as being able to kind of have a scaffolding to tell a story around what mechanically happened throughout the game but yeah so I really enjoyed arcs I look forward to playing this uh I think I like this game more I would like this game more than root but uh time will tell if that is true or not

uh but I do believe in the hve that this game has had and can't wait to see where it goes so that's uh my first impression of arcs thank you for sticking around with me and hope that you schedule an appointment with me real soon take care

Progress saved