Skip to main content
Loading video...

Wispwood Review: Cat in the Forest

Transcript 12:02

Hey everybody, I'm Tom Vassel

and I'm Chris Ye.

Today we're taking a look at a new CGE game called Wispwood. CGE is kind of uh everyone's talking about um the Lost Runes of Arnack and STI. So their other games sometimes get lost in the

a little bit. Yeah,

this is definitely one that did mostly because Wispwood and you look at it and you're like, I don't know what it's about.

There's woods and you better believe they're wispy.

Oh, hang on. Magical lights have lured your cat into the forest. Lucky you. The wisps from the old tales. Now your cat's in the forest. Whatever. You're making a grid and making shapes. All right, let's take a look at it and we'll be right back. In the game, players can be building a grid of tiles in front of them. You'll start with your cat on a tree. And on a turn, you can either take a wisp tile or a tree turn. When you take a wisp tile, you're going to take one of these tiles that are randomly placed out on this board. When you take the tile, that tile is going to be part of a shape of the two that are next to it. So, if I took this tile, I might decide to put this here. You always have to put it next to a tile in your grid. And then I'll take tree tiles and form the rest of the shape. Now my grid for round one is only going to be a 4x4. So I have to be able to fit the shape in. So let's say in a future turn I took this one and decided to do that shape. I could do this and now my grid that way is set. Now, the other option you can do is you can take a tree turn where you will just take three tree tiles and put them wherever you want trying to fill your grid in. When you take a tree turn, if your cat is face down, you can unflip your cat. Well, why would you want to unflip your cat? Well, when you're taking a tile, guess what? These don't refill. The only time they refill is if there's just one type left. Then the

person who's picking a tile can clear those and randomly put new tiles out. on all the different spots. So, you can flip your cat to do that before there's just one type left. You can also flip your cat to say, "I'm going to take this tile, but I want to do this shape here." At the beginning of the game, you're going to choose or randomly pick one scoring card for each of the different types of wisps. When one person finishes their 4x4 grid, then you're going to score. Each person is going to score based on this one. So this one here is pumpkin seed doku which will count pumpkins that are not in a row or com with other pumpkins. So I only have one. He's not in a row or com with any other pumpkins. So that gives me four points. And you'll score for each of these in various ways. When you're done with that, you may move your cat to another tree tile. Then all your tree tiles are going to go away. The wisps are going to stay there. And now you're going to play again, continuing from the last person to go. But you now you can build next to any of these and you're building a 5x5 grid. Then after you score that, you'll build a 6x6 grid. And after that, whoever has the most points is the winner of the game. There's also bonus points if you finish your grid. Everyone has the same number of turns each round.

So that will give you some bonus points. And whoever scores the most is the winner. Now, this is possibly the most overdone genre other than tricktaking in our hobby right now.

Pattern in a grid.

Build a pattern, score points.

So, you have to say, what does this one do that's different than the others? Well, first of all, it has a weird Tetris thing where you're taking a piece of a pattern, building the rest of the pattern, then putting it in your puzzle. So, that's one difference.

Yeah. Only one square of it is like the special piece. Yeah.

Yes. And then secondly, when you're done scoring, everything comes off and you rebuild again 5x5 and come off and rebuild again 6x6. And I and that that that's I feel is different

component,

but you leave the you leave the key pieces in there.

Yes.

Uh and so Yeah. Yeah. There's I I haven't really seen a game do that gimmick. The closest I think I've seen is uh the Guild of Merchant Explorers, right?

Oh, right. That one you pull stuff off and go back on. You're right.

Yeah, but even that this is pretty different from that style of game.

Uh and speaking of the Guild of of Merchant Explorers or whatever it was called, uh this game looks pretty unlike that one. Um it's CGE. They make their stuff looks the same. I would have told you the company who made this because they have a certain style to their games has this thing. And I'll say that I think that this this the colors and shapes very easy to differentiate what's what. You're not going to say, "Oh, is that the pink one or not?" That doesn't matter. They're they're pretty easy scoring cards. There's they have ones and twos on them. They're like, "Don't use the twos for your first because they're more complicated." There are some little bit of wonkiness to them, but for the most part, it's pretty basic. It really is. Uh, oh, and they also, oh, I got to talk about the uh I didn't mention this in the overview because I think they're they have rulers here. In case you can't figure out what a 4x4 grid looks like, you can mark it off here and then a 5x5 and a 6x6.

I guess I think this is I think it's mostly because it's a solo mode thing on the back, but

Sure. But I was still amused by that.

It It was kind of humorous. Yeah. Um, I don't want to keep just drawing comparisons, but I think one of the issues I have with the game is that it's quite comparable to a lot of other things. The scoring cards are Cascadia.

They are.

They are Cascadia.

Each different color scores in a different way and there's like a few cards, some nice little variations for for each of them. Very much Cascadia. Build a grid. Uh, so I've made the comparison to build a merchant explorers. But despite those things, it does kind of feel unique with that little like layout, the the patterns and stuff. One square being special of a polyomino shape is also in Copenhagen roll and right, but to a less less of a

Yes, that's correct. Please do not go by Copenhagen roll and Right. Not a good game. Go by Copenhagen. It's better.

Yeah.

Um

but yes, I mean that not to say that there's nothing unique in here. I think that its package is overall unique. It has some nice unique features. I just don't find it interesting. I get that actually, but I do find it interesting. I think I just like the idea of fitting I like the whole I'm always a big fan of Tetris as is, but I like the idea of fitting this stuff in shape and the game just doesn't go too long. Each each round I feel more powerful than the previous. Like I didn't score many points in round one. Oh, but all that stuff stays there. Watch what I do in round two. Yeah,

it doesn't. If there's a negative thing I'll say about it is I don't think the decisions are particularly hard.

Like this is what fits here.

Hey, look, there's a piece that fits in that spot. Done.

I don't really I have five pumpkins. Should I get six? I should cuz in this game there's no reward for diversity. You really want Well, some of the the one wisp scores for different ones, but if you really focus on one, you do okay. And I think that they all score pretty strong and and I don't think any of them kind of blows the other ones out of the water.

No, but I'm saying if you get a lot of orange, you might as well get some more.

Correct. Yeah. And I think that's my other little issue with it, too, is that my decisions feel uh pretty limited. And it's okay for a game to feel kind of limited, but I as I was playing it, I just thought, okay, I know how to put shapes into other shapes, and I know how to okay, where should the orange go? Where in this like, you know, the little polyomino shape should go? Not not in a way that cancels its scoring. Not in a way that cancels the scoring of a different one. You know what I mean? Like it it it feels too familiar unfortunately.

So what what if though you were looking at as someone who doesn't play many games?

Yeah, I think that it would feel clever. I think that would genuinely Right. And I think that if you I don't know if you if you don't if you didn't have other touch points, right? Cascadia, for example, uh or most other Polyomino games, I think that you would look at this and say, "Hey, that's that's pretty fun." I think that a few complaints that are standard that that I have um would be I think the scoring is not as interesting. You kind of alluded to that. I have a lot of green. I'll just get more green, right? Because green at times green is good. And there's a lot of scoring. The final games in this the final scores at the end of the game could be like in the 200s fairly easily and the range of scoring it kind of feels like it's manufactured to be a little bit close to each other.

Sure.

So I didn't I didn't find a lot of satisfaction out of doing the scoring at the end. Now is it because I've played a lot of games that are si, you know, similar and that bleeds into that? That might be. It genuinely might be and I'm aware of that.

What would you give it? Uh score-wise, I'd give this one a five. I I don't really want to come back to it because for me, it also felt a little rinse and repeat. And so, kind of by the end of it, I was ready for the third round to be done, the 6x6 round to be done because I knew that we're going to have to go through count trees and columns or diagonals. How How are the greens? Do you have a lot of them next to each other? Got a lot of the oranges. Everyone got like, you know, 87 points this round. Let's kind of add those up. And And I hope I don't sound jaded, right? because I think a lot of people will enjoy this. It has a good look to it. It's well produced. I love the the cat tile that you flip over. Cascadia Acorn, you know, it's like a cute little double double uh you know, tile put together. Production on it is good. Uh and I think that it's it's it's competent, right? But I was really checked out by by playing it. So, yeah, a a five. On the other hand, I kept wanting to play it more. Not I'm not loving this game, but I am really liking it. I like the idea of building a little grid, having it go away, but some of it remains, and you build on top of that, and it feels like it just meets the time length for me. If there was one more round, I would despise it, I think,

because I'd be like, "That's way too long." But if it was one shorter round, I don't know. I like the gobs of points. You keep comparing it to Cascadia, and I don't disagree, but I don't love Cascade as much as everyone else does. I think it's fine. I like this better, actually. Um, part of that might be I like the luminescent art on the dark background. There's something about that I enjoy.

But I give this one a seven. I think it's an enjoyable game. I think that if you haven't played many of these games, you should certainly check it out. If you are tired of the genre, I don't think this is enough to bring you back in of the build patterns.

Yes.

But if you do like the genre, maybe you're a big fan of Cascadia, this might be a sideway step for you. You might say, "Hey, this is something I enjoy also. So anyway, check it out. That's Whispwood. I'm Tom Basil.

And I'm Chris Ye.

And we want to say thank you to some of our Game Pound backers. Thank you to Tom Glennon, to Martin Clairbar, to the Bissant family, Kevin Rhodess, and Bob and Anne Arnold. Thank you guys for supporting us.

Thank you.

And thank you all for watching.

Hey everybody, thanks for watching this video. If you like this review or whatever you just watched, wasn't it amazing? Uh, check out our channel, Dice Tower. We have all kinds of things. We review games, we do top 10s, we play games live. It's all about board games, but especially the people who play them. Check out Dice Tower YouTube channel.

Progress saved