Skip to main content
Loading video...
Transcript 21:57

viewer discretion is advised hey everyone welcome to the discussion for red rising which is stone meyer games newest game uh that uh i mean i had no idea it was coming and i knew nothing about it whenever it was first announced and then i'm like oh it's a book series sure i'll take a good ol gander at it um and then it was mentioned that this was basically like fantasy realms which if you're not familiar with fantasy realms is basically a hand builder where you're just trying to build the best hand get the most points uh from just having different uh criteria met on those cards this is basically that uh with a pasted on theme i i do not know how i feel about this game to be completely honest because i feel like i don't know who the audience is for if it's for fans of fantasy realms play fantasy realms because it's ten times shorter uh and if it's for fans of red rising there's nothing to indicate that this is anything about that except that it has names of people well and and i think that the relationships plays a minor part it i mean sure oh cassius wants to be with this person and he gets 10 more points right that is but if you i mean if you're a fan of the the book series you're probably wanting a little more than that than just micromanaging uh

a hand of cards yeah uh i mean yes of course any theme if you're a fan of it is going to make you appreciate any game more like bloodborne for example if you're not a fan of bloodborne uh then uh i mean is the game gonna be as good as it would be to a fan of the actual video game series you know stuff like that uh i mean of course here it's just like oh yeah i know who that is or oh hey i know who that is but yep oh i caught i yeah they do hate each other yeah that's it oh cassius wants to be with these two people because of this reason in the book yeah but none of that is brought into play it's minus 20 points if he's with darrow but not much well it's because him and he and him and dauro hate each other yeah but again it feels like a pasted-on theme right um instead of anything organic to the gameplay yeah exactly so i i'm actually all right well first what do you guys think i thought it was okay that was okay a little long little long for what it is um overly complex but you know that's also just my personality but i mean just getting the right combinations then having to trade them out and then finally i got a good set of cards but the game's not over so i got to throw one of them away exactly yeah i've only got five well now i have six now you have four mm-hmm yeah i it's a huge penalty losing a card oh absolutely twenty percent of your hand yeah when it when the game yeah exactly and it's like

either you have to basically top deck and hope you get something that just lets you take another card so you can get back up um if you're if you're basically down if you're if you if you're less than five cards you are not winning this game it's like hard to say yeah i'm incredibly lucky yeah uh yeah i mean because yeah i wouldn't have gotten half i wouldn't have gotten a third of the points just came from having six cards that happen to be the right combination yeah yeah if you have more cards that is inherently more points i mean you're yeah the morning star is 35 oh it's only minus 15 if you uh if you don't have this other person true then it's like okay that's still 20 points that you get just from having an extra card in your hand i i think you sean he shot himself in the foot by saying he he built this off of fantasy realms yeah because fantasy realms is it's it is exactly this and this this game took about 45 minutes fancy realms takes 10.

yeah like and and there's no weird kind of like what you mentioned of like man i really like my hand well the game's gonna be another 20 minutes so i guess i don't really get to keep it and that he put in that scout mechanic where all you're doing is really just trying to hurry the game up oh i want to keep my hands so i'm just going to do this all right boom going on the institute or boom moving up the fleet just to hit the heat i was going to say meet and hit just to hit the one of the end game criteria that's true so it's not really a clever way to to end it um or i don't think in fantasy realms there's anything that has a take that element and this game does so you're kind of like i'm gonna play this card and oh yeah you had seven helium now i'm gonna take one from you and now that's not one of the criteria met so now the game's going on even longer so it it just has a lot of weird ideas and the theme itself does not shine here and i i mean i i've only read the first book and a little bit of the second one and i really liked the first book so yeah i mean it was nice seeing the art of the characters that i'm like oh this character is really cool um that's kind of what he looks like okay now so when i go back i can kind of envision you know what he looks like but that's not a compliment really to the game itself right cat what do you think it was okay um i mean just

i think the length really kind of spoiled it is really what it comes down to for me i mean like it's produced beautifully it's a gorgeous game um it's just too long yeah it's just too long for what it is like it and i was like oh you know maybe it'll get better and it just it just made me like a little it just it just overstays his welcome nothing really specific other than it just didn't right i mean because you're also in in fantasy rooms you have like 50 cards or something right uh where if you're looking for a specific type of something you're most likely going to get it yeah yeah or if not then you can just quickly burn it and very and even if you don't get a great hand the game took 10 minutes so it's not you're not sitting there with a [ __ ] hand for an hour um and in here i there were literally zero good combinations in a game all about building good combinations like i didn't want any of the cards in my hand i couldn't find any cards that i wanted and whenever it came to sorry go ahead no i finished your sentence i was gonna say and whenever a card did come on that i was like oh that might that might be nice oh i'm just gonna cover it and it's like okay well now i can't take the one card out of these 15 that i want so i guess i'll just you know twiddle my thumbs and masturbate in the [ __ ] corner until hopefully that card's available so then i'd be like oh yay or you're having to draw one of the three or so that lets you take one from

further back exactly exactly so there's there's absolutely too many cards to come up with any type of strategy yes like you basically pick a card from your opening and be like i will try to do this one and hope it pans out i mean my hand wasn't horrible by the end but it wasn't good like i didn't i'm just like oh i have zero named characters yeah in this entire hand like i just have job titles i face the opposite situation sort of in having actually a pretty good hand but now the game has to continue yeah so maybe i can do slightly better um names or certain certain combinations i actually was able to you know get three cards that melded well together right and this one needs one more of those okay okay i got that and now and now when you look at and you're like oh god i only have three in influence and i have the most no one has a fleet no one has helium uh and i can't imagine that this i mean this game would obviously benefit well with way more people it plays up to six i believe um because that just means more people are going to burn through well through actually screw you over but they're going to at least burn through the the deck of 112 cards

and there's only one oh this one card needs mustang yeah well where is she oh she's at the bottom or buried under several other cars yeah and i see her yeah yeah it's like oh that's nice i cannot get to her yeah so the fact that too many they're they're too specific yeah like they're too specific trying to replicate something of the theme right and i just i don't think i don't think it works i don't feel like this has anything to do with red rising besides named people what i initially thought this game was going to be was a area control like kind of like maybe like a euro style game of the different factions like or at least the main factions uh and then you hire other people from from different oh you know i'm gonna hire you know the subsidiary because he's a soldier and he gives me a benefit to fight or something like that that's what i thought this game was going to be not re-themed fantasy realms or or something more political negotiation time yeah you know like i i'm trying to collect something different from you so we can trade yeah but do i really want to help you out this much right because on the back of the of the box it's uh it says enter the futuristic universe of red rising based on the book series by

pierce brown featuring dystopian society divided into four uh castes yeah you represent a house attempting to rise to power as you piece together an assortment of followers will you break the chains of the society or embrace the dominance of the golds neither because you don't do anything reflecting that yeah i didn't feel like i was and it looks like even on the back it shows like the different characters like i thought these were all gonna be different standees oh yeah like oh like you move around the board and you try and gain like like they have like special abilities and you're trying to collect something like you mentioned so you can trade and it's like oh yeah i'm a red so i'm trying to overthrow something you're a gold you're trying to stop me you surprised me when you said that this was a card game exactly i was very surprised it wasn't an actual board game i mean it's it's a bloated card game um yeah like and that's not to [ __ ] on like jamie for loving the source material and wanting trying really hard i just don't get where he's like man i love this book series so much you know what it reminds me of hand management it's like uh what like like i what i would envision from something of this source material is something like scythe like a big grandiose you're actually building mm-hmm um or some kind of society or game of thrones maybe not as heavy or as long but something like you can do cool like different different types of decks of cards if you want to go to card the the card route um but

i mean then again red rising itself is kind of really just the reds versus the golds and everyone else is kind of in between they kind of work like basically the hierarchy is split in half almost it's oh hey this half follows the reds and this half up here follows the golds maybe you're really just following the main character uh for the first three books uh it's just an absolutely missed missed opportunity it's it's yeah i mean the the theme doesn't do the books justice doesn't seem like it and and mechanically the game is just overly long and complicated for what it is yeah yeah i mean that basically that that boils it down i mean halfway through if this game was 30 minutes that'd be i'd be like oh yeah okay like there's enough different like like enough you know unique abilities from the factions the the allure of the theme doesn't wear off immediately right in 30 like in a 30-minute game uh but i mean it's like okay well you know we're all gonna go for the institute uh that ended up being a complete wash so one of the main ways of getting a bunch of points is just kind of like oh all right well uh we all tied so it's not gonna matter if we scored or not i mean yeah there are cards that have end of game abilities uh that it's just like

yeah gain one helium advance on the fleet check or place one influence on the institute so it's like oh if i had that in my hand then it's like oh haha now i have the moves so that's gonna be eight times four thirty-two which is again just one more screw you guys element exactly it's like oh i know this game really means right i oh i know you were hoping that you were gonna win but yeah i actually get 30 more points which makes me win uh i will say though this game does not because in fantasy realms the scoring takes longer than the game itself pretty much this is not this is not the case right uh it's just gotta have something simple i was really excited for this one i know because i really really like the first book and i'm liking the start of the second one i'm hoping it doesn't just turn to [ __ ] uh which apparently we're all playing cards for three books wow okay never mind no i uh if i it it's gonna it's gonna do exactly what hunger games does and hunger games [ __ ] just hit the fan everyone's dying uh to overthrow whatever the the government pretty much i'm guessing the exact same thing is going to happen so it's just like ah it's like i like a lot of these characters i don't want most of them to die but they're gonna i've already spoiled one thing for myself because i i i had to know he doesn't as far as i know he does not die oh i for yeah i mean i guess he could with the third book well it's the the second saga yeah because there's three or there's

six total um as far as i know he is still alive because mustang is still alive i don't know [ __ ] about anything i don't know [ __ ] about buck so nice but yeah the sixth book is not out but i believe that ends it uh that ends the the saga unless the game makes it so popular that they need to he just wanted something he just keeps trying yeah i hope not i hope not um it's hard when stuff is based off things that you like and you're like i'm gonna like this and you don't you're like because if you think about it there's 112 cards there's one two three four five six seven eight nine ten eleven twelve thirteen fourteen different casts oh i already read that on the back of that wow so they're trying to so that that means you only get five cards and you only get five cards for your entire hand yeah uh and guarantee you every time i top deck i was getting rid of a green i drew another green and i'm like i don't want any of these oh yeah the brown i got rid of that needed a red i got rid of him and i drew a red and i was like yeah i mean it is interesting that you can get rid of a person go grab from somewhere else and then you potentially get that person back like i the diana like that's how i cycled helium yeah the entire time but yeah the fact that there's so many different colors uh does not do this game justice because you're never gonna find someone unless it's a very vague one oh this one wants to be with a violet right sure but you know there's not going to be a ton of violets in the game there's

going to be like i i don't know what the the differentiation is like i don't know how many golds there are to whites to silvers to um i mean if you assume that it was all evened out i mean it's it's uh what is it it's 112 divided by 14 that means there's eight of each faction but that's probably not the case because we didn't even see half the deck yeah so yeah uh it it just this one this one's super super flopped yeah that sucks but i like the art and i like the uh i like all the production quality myself sure i mean even even the red copper cubes are fine with me but yeah they don't fit the color of the oh these yeah they do have that quality where if they're out of a good light or they're just at a weird angle that yeah you're kind of like oh what yeah it's like i couldn't tell yeah colorblind people would not be able to no not at all i like how the golds have like that that little foil that's really pretty yeah it is really pretty now to be fair colorblind people they do actually say what color the faction is what color the card is on every card yeah but i'm thinking of like these cubes and these markers the finer things no color differentiation is is going to be a serious problem i mean and these really serve zero purpose except they're oversized cards

yeah so i feel like i gave a very good example of how uh poorly well because like i had them all fanned out and i was like oh i kind of gotta read what these are so i'm just gonna hold them in my hand yeah i could yeah yeah yeah but it's a nice tray well made heavy plastic smack somebody with it yeah all right i'm stretching i love this dice uh it's big it spins nicely scale of one to ten i'm gonna give it i'm gonna give it a five five yeah um just to kind of put it like uh i mean yeah if somebody asked me to play it again i would um but i'm not gonna be like oh man we should play red rising um i had no expectations for this game i have a feeling i don't know about how i don't know yours could go lower i don't know who that i don't know who the market's for i don't i don't know who it's audience is also that i'm going to keep it at five you'll kind of keep it just neutral um because i didn't hate it but i definitely was just like okay sure so uh i say four for largely the same reasons just slightly below it's give or take this is one i'm fine never playing again but if somebody really wants to i'm sure okay it won't it won't hurt me yeah uh i'm kind of i'm kind of where we're breaths at same exact reasons but i feel like that actually hurts it more i'm gonna give it a four slightly below average um because there's already a superior game that is also like 15

is the game and then this is like 70. and much smaller like a pocket-sized game as well yeah i mean and it does the exact same thing uh if so it's like oh well i don't really like fantasy i want more sci-fi it's like oh and i'm a huge fan of red rising well you're not gonna get that here either like you're gonna get that you're going to get to see names of people that you know you're not going to get to reenact anything from the first book you're not going to get to reenact anything from any of the later books uh the abilities of certain characters named characters which are few and far between uh are not they're they're so loosely themed that you'd have to stretch to to read you would have to read all the books and be like oh i know why this one wants to be with this one it only gives me 10 more points like no special abilities no nothing is literally just mid maxing victory points so i i think that absolutely hurts it i don't really want to play this again because i can play an identical game it's so stupid i don't get that thought process man i've busted my ass trying to make a red rising game fantasy realms and that's it that's that's what i'm gonna do he really likes fantasy roles you know you can like games and make different games he should know that like i i i don't know i don't know the box art is

awesome though yeah so i mean that was where i was kind of towards was okay well the production quality is really nice does that bump it up but no i don't really care yeah i like about the production quality i think the art is great but the game itself is seriously flawed is yeah so so that's our thoughts on red rising let us know what you think of the game in the comments below other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful weather time update is for you hey everyone thank you for watching and i really hope that you enjoyed the video if you would like to see more of my content go ahead and click that subscribe button and the bell to be notified whenever i upload any new content if you feel like supporting the channel you can go ahead and click that patreon link to be taken to my patreon and any help is truly appreciated other than that stick around for any any other run-throughs or reviews or cool top tens or whatever i feel like putting on other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you

Progress saved