Skip to main content
Loading video...

When Does Your Game Collection Collect YOU? - Lost In The Shuffle

Transcript 19:52

Today we're going to be trying something a little different while having a discussion about things that are near and dear to every board gamer's heart, which is collection size.

Is there a point where the games on your shelf could sort of box you in

and leave you lost in the shuffle?

I How many games are in your collection? And the answer is surprising me actually. I was not expecting it.

Yeah, I have somewhere between 60 and 70. It always fascinates me because I know there's going to be some people watching that's going to be like, "Oh my gosh, that's a huge collection." And others are going to be like, "Oh, wow. That's just like a starter pack."

Great.

Yeah.

It made me realize that I actually catch myself when I make videos. I don't blurt out how many board games I have. And I It's not shame, but there is a reservation to it. Yeah.

And a 700. By the way, the point is that I think part of that reservation I have of blurting that out

is because it's not necessarily a source of pride for me

is sometimes I wonder is this collection of things actually owning me? And what's interesting is well at least in the circles that I find myself gaming in the size of your collection actually seems to be the atypical one. So, it brings up the question of does the number of games in your collection at your disposal change the amount of fulfillment you can get out of these games? So, let's let's start with the easier to manage smaller collection. Tell me about the games you have in your collection, what you've chosen to keep, how often you call, and why what's in there is in there, and why you are or are not tempted to increase the size of it. Just that. God just that just just the starting with the simple question. Fantastic. Wonderful. First thing I want to say is there is absolutely no right answer for this.

It's going to be up to everybody, individuals, needs, space, resources.

Oh, absolutely. I absolutely agree and I think that is a very important point to establish right off the bat.

Yeah. It's not like 67 is the perfect number of games. That's not a thing. for me getting to my personal collection. Um, actually it's been interesting one because it's been more a matter of controlling the acquisition. I like to quote Warren Zeon in this case because he once said we buy books because we buy we think we're buying the time to read them. I feel the same about board games. I feel we buy board games because we feel we are buying the time to play them,

right? So when we see a board game, something shiny or new or the theme speaks to us, it's got all this potential. I can see myself playing this with these friends and doing this and having this good time and I and I want that. And a lot of times, not all the time, but sometimes you get that home and the game sits and it never fulfills its potential. And so for me, part of me is, you know, not wanting to clutter up my space is is I limit my acquisitions,

right? Um part of that also is having a bunch of board gaming friends who have much larger collections. So, I don't need to own them all. If I want to play them, I can call somebody who has them.

Fair.

There's no need for me to own them. So, I greatly appreciate everybody out there with the 600 to 700 collections cuz mine's onetenth of the size.

Yeah, I'll be honest with you. This might seem like a strange episode to promote a new game in, but the sponsor that helped make this one possible is actually a perfect fit for this topic because it's the smaller box game that packs a lot of content in it, the second edition of Logic and Lore and its new variance expansion. In Logic and Lore, mice and dragons organize the stars of the night sky by solving logic puzzles. Now, this game, after selling out of its first print run in five months, is now returning to Kickstarter along with a brand new expansion, Logic and Lore Variants, which features the same tense, satisfying deduction gameplay and shiny foil components, with expanded examples in this rule book to better teach this cozy but competitive two-player deduction game where rivals race to align their hidden star cards numbered 1 through nine, without ever seeing them until a climactic reveal at the end of the game. There's over 350 puzzles in this to discover with varying levels of difficulty. And now the variance expansion adds two dice driven modes, introducing probability based decisions for deeper chains of logic. You can follow the link in this video's description or right here on screen to back Logic and Lur's second edition and its new expansion on Kickstarter right now and then start reaching for the stars. And then when it does come time for me to find a game that I do want to buy,

um I really put it through the limus test of like, okay, what's the reality here? Am I going to get this to the table? Uh am I going to actually sit down and play with folks? Because I'll certainly exposed to a new game, I'm like, "Oh, this is great. I want it."

And but I also know that my wife or my home game team is not going to play it. It's it's not that it's too complicated or it's not their style or whatever. So, I try to be realistic about its potential. That's how I have such a small collection to begin with, right? I mean, again, I worked at a game store. I received a good discount and most of my friends are like, "Why aren't you buying everything?" Because I don't need to buy everything. You guys are buying everything at the store and I can come over to your house and play it, you know. But the other part of that is that for me and I think this is also another human trait is that if I purchase something because I think it has this potential to it. The longer I don't act on that potential,

it starts to build dissonance in me.

H

it's that project you never finished, right? Like so let's say you buy an old car, you're like, I'm going to fix it up and it just sits in your yard

and you never work on it and you never fix on it. But every time you open your door, you look at it and you go, God, I need to do something with that. So instead of having this joyful expectation of the possibility of the potential of this game, now it's starting to make you feel bad every time you see it.

Right. Right. And in and that whole spectrum, you haven't played it yet.

Right. You've gone from from overjoyed to disappointed and not actually played the game sometimes.

H

So this really is about, you know, I mean, potential, fulfillment, enjoy. So I see why people go out and buy more and get big collections. I'm gonna I'm gonna weigh in on this because I really like what you said about what like when we buy books and board games by extension, we're buying the thought that we will have the time to play it and we have we're buying the potential of that experience. Many if not almost all of the games on my shelves are because when I had that game in my hand

thinking of whether or not to purchase it, I had a little thought come in my head of a little thought bubble with someone in it of like, oh yeah, I would like to share this experience with this specific person or group of people. And that's always the trigger for me of like, oh yeah, oh, I got to get this cuz I I want to have this experience with them.

Yeah. And of course, you know, not all of those games get played,

but they still when I see them on the shelves, still unplayed, they still trigger that thought bubble in my head, and they still trigger that feeling of hopeful anticipation of playing it. Right. And that and it's it's a good feeling, right? Right. Well, let me ask you this. Are there any games on your shelf that have gotten to the dissonance part

that you see and go, I've been meaning to play that for so many years?

Yes, of course there are is a short answer to that.

Okay. Twist on that though is to be honest. It's not when I look at the game. It's when at the end of the day, I get this sometimes overwhelming feeling of not using the time I had today to play one of these games with my family to I have it sitting there and I let another day go by where I didn't do that thing. I didn't live live up to that potential. That's when the uh disappointment hits of, oh, I wasted this potential of this day. That's how it hits me.

Oh, interesting. These are hopes. That's what we're talking about. I hope to play this game and have this experience with these people,

right? And the opposite of hope is despair.

Despair, right? And that's a really strong word for board games. It's an interesting roller coaster ride, emotional roller coaster ride. People go on in in the the excitement about getting something, the getting of it, the holding on to it, the maybe using it, and then the end disposal of it, you know. And that's where a lot of the coing I think comes from is people like I have it's taking up too much space. I need to do something.

But it's always interesting to me people like well I need to get rid of more.

They rarely think well I should buy less.

The buying part's easy.

You know I'll I'll sell you you know 20 anvils at half price. [gasps] Half price. Half price. I have fallen victim to oh my gosh I don't know if I would ever play this game but it's 75% off. Why don't I just grab it for the potential that if I do play it, I'll have it available.

We've all done that. Absolutely. Right. Um yeah, there's there's several things that apply into that. You know, scarcity is definitely one of them.

You find a game and you're like,

"Wait a minute. I don't know if I'll find this again. This was a Kickstarter is all about scarcity, right? Like this may never be published again."

You got this limited time to procure it. It may never be published again. These stretch goals were a one-time thing. That's all about scarcity, right?

Yeah. Right. And and this is just a major marketing mechanism to increase something. But scarcity has not been a real thing, especially in entertainment realms for quite a while.

Oh, well, yeah. Comics in the '9s, you know, when the speculation Yeah. speculation took over and all the comic book companies started just overprinting all these collectible issues and now they're barely worth the pulp they're printing on.

If it says collectible, it's not worth anything. Just look at the Franklin Mint.

Yeah. But it is something that inspires this primal urge, right? It's like I may never come across this again, so I should get it now.

And that in part leads to this psychological phenomenon. I went I bought this game and I haven't played it, but I did invest in it and there is this potential. So maybe I'll hang on to it just in case even though two years from now I'll probably be having the same conversation with myself.

We have this desire to appear as though we have commitment and consistency. It's like no, I I I I buy board games.

That's who I am.

That's who I am.

That's part of my identity.

Exactly. Right. And if I give up on that or don't do it, people are going to think I'm inconsistent.

Well, that also leads to what a lot of the games on their shelf are is, oh, sometimes there's games like, oh, if I want to be a board gamer, I better have this game available in my collection or else I'm not legit.

Right? That's going to scale up with everyone. Right? If you start hanging out with people who are just getting into the board game thing, you can have 60 games like me and they're like, "Oh my gosh, this is taking up half a bookshelf. How do you even have time to play this many games,

right? But again, that scales up.

It's all relative. It's a very very relative thing, right?" Again, that's why there's no right answer to this,

right? It's it's where you're at, where you your resources, what your needs are.

Um, but it's Yeah. But then the coing part,

that's the part that's always interesting me. That's the part that comes up on BG forums a lot.

Like, how do you choose what to get rid of?

When you have that emotional attachment to a product, especially when you create that mental connection to a physical object of the potential that you see in it, it can be very difficult to dispose of that potentiality.

Yeah. Right. because you're you're basically sending your hope to the resale market.

Yeah.

And and hope that somebody else finds joy in it. That that I mean that is my view on it is when I do call a game,

I'm releasing it free range. It's going out to the world and hopefully somebody else will find it, give it a good home, and enjoy it.

You know what I've started doing for myself to circumn that problem of not being able to let go of some games is I have a special section of my shelves. It's like, okay, these are the games I'm considering callulling.

Okay.

I'm going to put them on this shelf, and if I come back in one year, and they're still sitting here unplayed.

Yep.

I I know that I'm probably never going to play them.

Yeah.

And or at least it's going to be so long from now that, you know, something else will come up that will be brighter and shinier and will prevent me from playing it anyway. And I know I can let them go. And every time I've done that and let them go, it has never been regretful. It's actually the closest I can compare it to is it's has felt like getting a haircut. It's like, "Oh, I feel all all light and free." Oh, yeah. It's like taking your backpack off after hiking in three miles. You're like, "Oh, I can float." You know, it's just right. It's that kind of sensation. And yet, you think of how long

you held on to that stuff

with that weight,

right?

You know, I I can't remember now who the author was. wrote a book on um it it was like the burden of free things,

right? Cuz you there's stuff everywhere. You can get free stuff, but if you clutter up your whole space with all this stuff, then is no longer functional, right? I like to say an empty room is full of potential. Um whereas a full room, well, it's full. [clears throat] And again, I want to reiterate that having a large board game collection and maybe even one that spills out over your available shelf space, that in and of itself is not a bad thing.

Not at all.

So, I don't want to say that a certain number of board games in your collection is an unhealthy thing. That's not what this is about. Not at all.

This is this is more about just those connections we make and why we acquire and why we have trouble letting go sometimes.

Yeah. Right. Right. Yeah. The the meaning behind things. The meaning behind things. That's Yeah. Yeah. That's that's what you said the very beginning with off camera all of this. That sparked all of this. Yes. The meaning behind things.

The meaning behind things and the meaning that we assign to things sometimes,

right?

I think especially as board gamers since board games are a thing that we are they're social. We share with other people and the board games themselves many of them tell a story. Yeah.

We very easily attach additional meaning to these things.

Absolutely. Absolutely. and whether in advance of playing it or or after playing it.

I mean, certainly some of my favorite games are the ones where you walk away with that wonderful story of like, oh my gosh, we almost got to this point and that happened. And you know, it's not about the rolling the die and

Oh, no. It's always the moment, always the story,

right? You know, that's a reason enough alone to keep a game.

Oh, I was just about to say there's some games on the shelf that I've had that same experience and then as I'm putting it away, I'm going, well,

I'll probably never play this again, but I'm going to keep it because wow, that was so much fun that I had playing this.

Yes. Yeah. I mean, it's it's it's kind of like a photograph out.

Oh, sure.

Less an antiquated reference point, but it's like you you have this collection of memories

that you have taken snapshots of.

It's no different with the board games.

Yeah.

Though some of these are snapshots of things potentially yet to come.

Yeah. Absolutely.

That reminds me of another thing that we talked about this is that the different seasons that board gamers seem to go through.

Ah, yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. I think both of us went through this phase of when we first got into board games, there was that discovery phase of oh my gosh, I didn't know there was a game that did that mechanism or this genre or wow that type of game, right?

And so you just go and you are trying to acquire as much as you can to kind of just have all of those different experiences available to you.

Yes.

Then you kind of go into the next phase where you start to refine. So you discover what you really like and you start to refine. Okay. Oh, I really like worker placement games. So, I might not get this uh area control game, but I might get these three other ones that are similar to this other worker placement game I have because I know I like that.

And you start to refine your collection.

Y

then you enter kind of this latter phase of I don't think I need to go out and actually hunt for more things. As things discover me through the people I play with or just other things I encounter, sure, I'll evaluate. But you kind of reach that point of okay, I've settled in to where I am comfortable and that that number of games to reach that point is going to vary for everybody.

Oh, absolutely. Absolutely.

Mhm.

Yeah. I think there's another phase in there to be honest.

Okay. I I think there is a time you you have the the initial then you have the refining and I think there's an additional refinement sometimes where people are learning their like style of games

and then they start at least for me and a couple of people I know they start getting into like specific designers or publishers.

Oh,

that is another level of refinement where you're like I really like Steinfeld games, you know, and so you start following that. Who designed the game when you're first starting out? I remember being at one of our local community gaming sessions and for the very first time recognizing the names of the designers that were being said,

right? This is making me think a lot of uh Paula has done that wonderful video in the past where like the the beginning board gamer, right? And and it's just hilarious. I think it's a one of the funniest videos she's ever done.

But it is that kind of evolution of that and and so it's almost like you're getting your your your belts.

Yeah. Your white belt and your yellow belt and you're working your way up. There are multiple different ways to get joy out of these things. There is playing them, of course, and sharing them with people and having those moments and those experiences. And of course, having an unplayed game on the shelf and that feeling of potentiality in it,

that also does give me a certain type of joy.

Yeah.

I have another friend who says that he likes to just walk by his board game shelves and look at the artwork sometimes. and he has said, quote, "Just looking at the art of these games gives me joy." So, just appreciating them for the craftsmanship and the artwork that goes into them is another way to appreciate them.

Oh, absolutely. Yeah. Absolutely.

So, if you're not necessarily playing every game on your shelf, I don't think that that means you're doing the hobby wrong.

No.

No. Yeah. Again, there's there's no right way. And I, you know, certainly don't want this to come across as we think there's some sort of opinion on that. It's just it's an interesting open-ended conversation and topic because it's like yeah what is what is right for you um whatever makes you happy but at the same time you got to be aware when it's causing dissonance in your life

you know this is a very open-ended discussion which I think is why it's hard to you know find a closing point. So really it's more about you know continuing that conversation. I'm always curious how people go about this. Again, I worked at a board game store for a year and a half, and you know, I got to see a lot of people's stories. I got to just watch how a lot of people would come in and buy or what they put on the consignment shelf, what they get rid of, you know, the agonizing decision they would make of this over this, you know, and it was always just fascinating from a psychological standpoint to me, like how does each human go about evaluating what's going to bring them the most joy from this particular thing.

So, would love to hear from our viewers.

Yeah. What's your experience been with your own board game acquisitions and storage and culling and what gives you joy about the hobby? You know, let's let's continue the discussion down in the the comments because I believe that this is probably a topic that we will revisit more than once, probably even. I

I imagine so. Yeah, we'd really like to know what you think about all this.

Yeah. Okay. Well, in the meantime, thanks for joining us for this part of the discussion and we'll talk to you again real soon.

Progress saved