Skip to main content
Loading video...

Shackleton Base First Impressions

Transcript 26:41

Hello everyone and welcome back to the board gaming doctor. My name is Phil and I'll be your board game doctor today. In this video, I'm going to give you my first impressions of Shackleton base. This game has been on my radar for a while since Essen last year. If I remember correctly, this was on my anticipated list, the the short list that I provided in a video back then. And so I'm very excited to have demoed this on Tabletop Simulator. I did play it solo and so my point of view will come from that. And so let's get into it talking about the mechanisms first and what stood out to me. So, as an quick overview, in this game, you are taking in total 18 actions, placing astronauts that are different colored workers, essentially doing various things such as gaining resources on the base in this crater of the moon in which you are building up a base. You can take resources from there. You can build structures onto the uh the creator itself with your own faction essentially. Uh you can uh take these command actions that are kind of a free-for-all or kind of a wild uh you know resource type of situation where uh as you progress through the game, you can use these command actions or corporation actions to gain a lot of different resources. And then finally,

you you are interacting with three of the seven modular um corporations that each play a little bit differently. They bend some rules. They have different requirements that you're trying to fulfill. Uh each corporation has their own cards that you can acquire for asymmetric abilities throughout the game. And a lot of these corporation actions that you can take have to do with them as well. And like I said, after 18 turns, after 18 uh bits of placement with your workers, the game ends, and whoever has the most points wins. So, breaking down some of these mechanisms and what is my favorite amongst them. I really enjoy first of all the flexibility of these said corporation actions.

What you can do as you build out onto the moon is you start to not only place your own buildings, which is pretty normal for a Euro style game, but you can also take certain actions to place down corporation tokens on the board. And when you do interact with them, whether you're exploiting the creator, and we'll talk about that in a moment, but also when you take other, you know, different types of actions as well. Um, you know, the way that you can place them on the board. Um, and I I guess this does incorporate the fact that, you know, how you build out your um different buildings onto the crater. Um, create opportunities for you to exploit the resources more efficiently or at least for uh hopefully for free, but uh without much payment to other people.

Because if you do try to, you know, exploit the crater in in which you do, you place a worker down and in the line of view, the, you know, the line of sight from that worker, you interact with the different sectors of the board, um, according to what type of worker you place. And so if you do have buildings in that line of sight, that allows you to gain the resources from each of those sectors in which you have influence. And so there's a lot of thought that goes into where you place your buildings and in which row you activate. It's almost kind of like an engine building type of experience where you want to hopefully align yourself in a way to take advantage of the basic resources that you use to build buildings with and to pay for things that the corporations ask for, right? The titanium and the rare earth metals. But you also get to try to align yourself with these corporation tokens to interact with them as well.

And so there's a lot of interaction, especially I can imagine in a higher player count with uh where you place these buildings and where you place your workers to take advantage of the board state for resources and opportunities. So that aspect is pretty interesting. The worker placement itself on the corporate board which is in the bottom right of the board uh is pretty basic but interesting as well where if you align or you place a worker in a certain row first, it is the cheapest. It's it's free essentially to take that action. Uh and they get more expensive as more and more people place workers on that certain row. And so there's a lot of opportunity for interaction and taking advantage of cheaper actions earlier on.

And the the I guess the tough decision is whether to take that efficiency earlier on or to wait and take that action perhaps later when it might benefit you more, but it might be more costly since someone else goes there and places a worker in front. Finally, I guess two more things that stood out to me is that the there is an income phase, but in addition to this income phase is a um is it a mechanics phase or upkeep essentially. And so maintenance phase is the word I'm looking for. And so in this maintenance maintenance phase, you have to pay money based off of the progress that you've made in the game. You pay maintenance to upkeep the buildings that you've placed onto the crater as well as pay a maintenance cost the higher you go on your reputation up the reputation track. And so, you know, the better you are, the more expensive it gets. And so, it it's kind of a feed your worker type of scenario. And I'll get into some game comparisons later, but I did enjoy that aspect to always in the back of my mind remind myself to make sure that I have enough to uh, you know, work with creditwise, moneywise to maintain what I am trying to do in this game. And then last but not least, of course, the modular corporations. They allow for

different goals to be pursued every game. You mix and match three of the seven. Some of them are more difficult than others. And while I did demo the somewhat easier uh corporations, of course, I think this allows for inherent replayability and variability from game to game and how they interact. Um, more on my thoughts later on what these modules contribute to the game. But, um, a large part of this game is interacting with these modules. They don't feel tacked on. They do feel pretty integral with the game. Now to get into some game comparisons. The first one that I want to compare this to is STI. So STI is a game that has been compared to this quite often.

These came around out around the same time and so I can't say one, you know, copied the other in terms of theme or what have you. But uh the similarity that they share is that they both have modules that are added from game to game to add some different flavor uh from you know in between repetitions. STI obviously has a more of a reveal midgame type of the experience whereas with Shackleton base they are present from the beginning. I feel like the differences between the two are, you know, I I I I feel like perhaps the modules from Shackleton base shake up the base game a little bit more. I feel like you are still interacting with the ones in STEI uh in addition to doing what you're normally doing, but I I feel like there's more of an endgame push towards the modules in Shackleton base where a lot of the points are offered based off of the goals of these modules and so you do want to pursue them.

Whereas in SETI, I feel like you could pursue the modules and the points that they might give you. But there are other ways that you can interact with the game, the base game, meaning the game without them, the aliens. You do have to play with aliens in the in the game, but you could like continue to search planets and explore, etc. Scan and and still get enough points and go for the milestones and points that are offered there rather than just focusing on an alien module or two. And so, uh, I I feel like that's the biggest difference between the two. But, uh, each game, in addition to obviously the the space type of theme, offers the variability in terms of different experiences and modules, which is quite fun. Another game that I want to compare this to is actually my Rosenberg pick, and that's going to be a Gricola. So, anytime I get to uh compare a game to a Gria, I feel like that is a win. Um, and so we'll we'll see how that compares in the final ratings later. But the the main way that I compare these two games is one, um, I didn't mention this in the overview, but you do get to draft workers at the beginning of the game.

Um, or I I should say at the beginning of every round. And so there there is an opportunity to kind of draft what you are trying to plan to do from round to round. similar to the draft that you have of the cards in agricula. Not not to the same extent of course because agricula you're planning over the whole game versus the particular round in Shackleton base. But uh the two things, one the feeding mechanism in a Gria feels somewhat similar to the maintenance phase in Shackleton base once again offering you that uh reminder from round to round that you do need to have enough credits or at least discounts uh available to be able to maintain your um your corporation, your you know your your lab, your research station, whatever it's called. And so um I I believe you lose reputation if you're not able to meet it. And so it's it feels like begging right in a Gulp. And so I really enjoy games that offer the constraint whether it's like a really tight constraint or not. Uh the constraint of trying to achieve points and your goals, you know, interacting with the modules, etc. But also trying to remember to feed your workers, right?

To maintain your stations and make sure everything is up and running. And so that that kind of adds a little bit of flavor and theme to this Euro game that I appreciate. And the the other thing that reminds me of a Gricola is the timing. Both games are primarily driven by worker placement. And I you could argue that in a Gricola you're going to achieve the same thing, you know, every every game, right? you're always looking to, you know, build a a room and then add more family members and then build out your farm from there. Some people say that might be scripted, but how and when you accomplish that is part of the fun of the game. Obviously, with the cards that you get, the the strategy and the efficiencies can be different from game to game, but I feel like the the timing of when you want to try to gather certain resources or to uh, you know, build certain things, play certain cards makes a gula feel different. And in Shackleton base, I get the same feeling of timing. You know, you do want to try to accomplish everything that you want to in the game. You want to build out as many stations that you can onto the board. you want to interact with the corporations as much as you can as well.

And I feel like especially at a lower player count, you have the opportunity to do so. But once again, coming back to the efficiencies and the command center, which is the three rows in which you take some major the major actions, right? You can either build out onto the board. You can acquire the cards which give you your abilities or you can take the command action to or corporation action to uh mix and match some of the resources and benefits that you get. Uh the earlier that you can play on those rows, the better and the cheaper it is. And so you're often once again faced with the decision whether to pursue those uh actions first while it's still cheap before someone else goes and uh takes the cheaper spots of those rows forcing you to spend those credits which you can use to you know maintain yourself as well as build out structures. um you know versus using them now to you know pay for an action that might benefit you now but maybe you won't have enough money to maintain later. And so there's a very tough decision in the timing in which you uh play these workers that you've sort of drafted uh from the shuttle phase at the beginning of the round. So, I I really appreciated that and thought that was a lot of fun and it added some some of the tension that I like to see in these Euro games. So, moving on to the peer review where I compile through AI a lot of the comments that people made on board game

in regards to Shackleton base. Starting with the pros, this game was praised by a lot of people in in terms of the good blend of worker placement and area control, resource management, all those good things that you would find in a Euro game. Uh the area control aspect in particular is interesting because of the the resource management or I guess the resource opportunity that I mentioned before in the line of sight worker placement on the central board. Uh there is an element of that as well as acquiring workers to place onto your board. Um and if you have the majority essentially in in a certain row, if a worker is placed there, you can put it into your own board which gives gives you some benefits throughout the game.

Uh a lot of people obviously enjoy the variability amongst the modules to game to to make every game feel a little different. Uh the game itself, you know, is relatively quick on paper, uh with 18 rounds total. Uh something that I didn't mention in the game comparisons before is one of the designers, Fabio Lupiano. He has designed games such as Autobon. Uh but one game that comes in mind is Zapotch, which I played and reviewed a couple years ago. It felt very similar to that. And I feel like uh MV and Zapotch are games where Liano is trying to create a interesting and crunchy Euro in a shorter play time essentially. And and so I this game really has a lot of his DNA in that. And I think that's what people appreciate of, you know, from his designs, games that do feel quicker, uh relatively quicker compared to your average, uh Euro game. Um, and so every decision really counts. A lot of people really enjoy the components. Um, the game is relatively straightforward once the rules are learned, etc. Now, uh, some people had mixed feelings about the interaction in the in this game.

Obviously, at higher player counts, you have a lot more interaction to the command center actions that you take for your workers. the central creator as well. You know, the line of sight type of actions, those have a lot of interaction at higher player counts as well. It's not so much at lower player counts. It feels a lot more flexible and open to take those actions. And then for some of the criticisms that people had, uh, this game doesn't feel very innovative. It's using a lot of different mechanisms that perhaps are seen in past games of Lianos, but also in Euro games in general. Uh it's kind of fiddly in the sense of or procedural I should say where the game very very much follows a multi-step process and uh and so you know it could feel a little uh janky I guess uh from here to there uh when you go from the shuttle phase to the round phase and the maintenance phase you know it's you're I guess it could be kind of fiddly uh you know at first when you are learning this game it's not as intuitive as some other games are when it comes to like thematic integration and how the theme explains the rules. I think well I'll leave that for my final thoughts but um but yeah you know it there's high opportunities or risks I should say for analysis paralysis.

uh you know it could feel punishing when if you're a new player playing this game as well uh you know not knowing the efficiencies and what to pursue at first. Once again coming back to the timing aspect that you see in games like a Gricola if you're not familiar with the game and the unwritten script as to what to do next. You know it could be uh difficult to keep up uh with your competitors throughout the rest of the game. And then finally, uh some people had some issues with a long teaching time despite the fact that it is uh relatively straightforward to understand once you do uh understand the rules and play the you know play the game once or twice. Uh it's hard to get over that hurdle at first for some. So for my first impressions, I'm giving this game a 7.2 out of 10. I really enjoyed playing this game. It did. It was really hard for me to come to really understand the game and enjoy it as I was playing it. I think it's twofold. One is the solo mode itself and I'll talk about my experience with it. I I felt like it was uh pretty straightforward at uh you know once you understood it. I feel like there was an added learning curve to not only learning the game and how it works normally for yourself, but also to manage the uh the the solo uh bot, right? The AI or computer player, right?

The the way that the cards worked, I felt like there wasn't enough iconography to really tell you exactly how to utilize the the actions differently for the AI. There was a lot of referencing the rule book. I did have some issues myself with the rule book as well. I felt like it wasn't as clear to me um exactly what uh would happen and I felt like even if I wasn't missing rules, I felt like I was missing rules during my first play. And I think that ultimately ties in and so that that was my experience with the solo mode, but also with the game in general. uh learning from primarily the rule book, I just felt like uh there are so many rules within rules and little exceptions or reminders that uh the rule book explains when you take certain actions, which feels good when you're pulling off these uh turns on on the board, you know, itself and being able to do what you need to do and combo a little bit, but I felt like I would forget little things here and there and forget those opportunities to take combos. Uh, for example, you know, the the the solar panels that you can purchase, you know, I I felt like that was a good example for me that kind of felt like a roadblock in my understanding of the game where the different buildings that you put onto the creator need to be fueled by a solar panel. I think it's really cool that you on your turn when you do uh any sort of action, you can

spend a resource to get a solar panel and put it in the middle of the board for anyone to use, including yourself. And and so there's some positive interaction there. And uh you you gain benefits if someone, you know, if if you use one and you know, you gain reputation and energy, etc. But um but I would forget that that was an option sometimes when I was building. And I I think this game would have really benefited from a uh dedicated player aid. Uh there were some icons and gr uh uh aids on the board itself, but um yeah, I I just felt like it was difficult to remember everything as I was playing the game. um always referencing the rule book for the solo component and what certain actions meant uh but then also referring to the rule book over and over again during my play for what I could do personally. But uh and so I I felt like it took a lot longer to get to that point of comfortable or comfort as I was playing the game. Uh but once I started playing it, I had some I had fun. I thought uh you know in addition to the mechanisms that I mentioned before, I I really enjoy how quick this game is, how tight every decision is as well, I appreciate the variability that is offered through the different corporations. Um this game I feel like

has a lot of potential to provide for that agricula type of experience where you really could replay this game and master uh what is going on in the game. I do feel however that despite the corporations themselves having a lot of variability amongst each other, I feel like they don't interact with each other in really interesting ways that make the game feel very different from game to game. And and this is in comparison with a gricula where every hand that you draft or dealt with at the beginning of the game can really dictate the arc that your game takes. It makes for a wildly different experience every time in the different ways that the cards interact with each other. I don't get that same sort of vibe when I play Shackleton base. I do feel like the corporations act very interestingly one with another, but ultimately uh you know I don't feel like you're doing as many crazy things uh to interact with them or as a result of interacting with them. I feel like they are just a part of the natural process of of of this game. You know, you're just trying to be as efficient as you can. And I don't think it would take terribly long to become a quote unquote master or expert at this game. I feel like you could really understand the different corporations pretty well and uh you know feel very comfortable

playing at a high level of play. But I I think the journey would still take some time and it would be fun. That's why I give it an 8 out of 10 for the skill ceiling component or how competitive this game is. Um, I I feel like it would still take maybe about 20 or so games to really feel comfortable in and start to really progress in your skill level. But yeah, everything else just was really solid. I think this is a really good game in my opinion. I think this is Laniano's best game. Um, I know Nester Mongon has a lot of different games as well with a bunch of other designers and so I can't really comment on him, but I I know I have played MV. I've played Zapotch by Lupiano. I've played Autobon as well. I've always been interested in his designs and I think this one has the potential to be his best in conjunction with everyone else involved with this team. I I think the gameplay is is quite good and it just takes a little bit of extra time. It doesn't feel as streamlined as other games are. Once again, comparing this to SETI, I found I found SEI a lot easier to understand.

one in part due to the approach to gameplay. It borrows a lot from games that I enjoy and a lot of people enjoy like Ark Nova, Lost Runes of Arnac, etc. And so approaching that game mechanically is a lot easier in my opinion to understand, but then you you know every card in that game really has a flavor and what it tries to accomplish I feel like is met mechanically throughout the game. And so there's a really good thematic um uh connection between the two. And so uh while I feel like there the modules in Shackleton base offer a lot of that thematic integration, I I did give it a somewhat high score, but it it isn't as thematic as some of these other games are, which is some of somewhat importance to me. And I feel like that's what would help me really I guess play a game like set in space, right? Like like a real game set in space like terraforming Mars or or STI, etc. I feel like those games hit different for me thematically as well as mechanically.

But Shackleton Base I I think is a good really good game. I think it deserves all the praise that it's gotten. I don't think it's going to quite fit my I I guess my desire to really understand and play this game at a higher capacity and level. But I would enjoy playing this game more to one to see the different modules that I haven't played with, but two to experience it at a higher player count to see how different this game feels, you know, from game to game. So those are my thoughts on Shackleton Base. Let me know what you think of this game. And uh thank you for consulting with me today. Hope you schedule an appointment with me real soon. And I'll catch you on the next one. Take care.

Progress saved