Winning Arcs in ONE turn . . . Why is Shut Up & Sit Down missing this?
Transcript
on a single turn in arcs in Chapter 2 of the game I went from having zero victory points at all and not looking very competitive on the board to scoring 27 victory points closing out the chapter ending the game and having a blowout win against the other three people sitting at the table and I really don't believe they had much opportunity or ability to prevent it this video is going to be titled something along the lines of like my worst experience yet or a major problem has been exposed I don't know I I'm conflicted as to what exactly this issue is so I'm filming it I'm talking about it I want to run you through a general approximation of the scenario and show you the sequences and the steps that went into a blowout Victory and then I also want to talk a little bit about why I think this matters why it's consequential to the overall Arch and experience of the game why this is going to create a hate it relationship with some players and as we've seen a love it relationship with other gaming groups I I will say this I've sat down and I've played this game now with my lovely wife Shira and one of my best friends West and both of them absolutely disliked it neither of them want to play it again
in our gaming group so far I I only have one player he's played in four of the five games that I've played and he's gung-ho he's interested compelled and even thinking about purchasing a copy for himself now everyone else is either mixed conflicted interested in continuing to experience it or have completely backed off at this point and it really has to do with the thing that I'm going to describe and what I'm going to break down here in this video it has to do with the fact that the ability to just Dominate and the ability to be completely bottlenecked or thrown to the curb is extremely wide so far in this game for the record I've played two two-player games one three-player game and two four-player games making it a total of five games we were at a Thursday night game group here in Cleveland Ohio tonight it is currently three uh 20 a.m. and I am filming this as fresh as possible to walk you through and break down the scenario that happened so you can see how that I how I scored 27 points in just chapter two of the game and I understand I get it there is a lot of things that have to go right for this to happen there's a lot of context there's the right cards in play the board set up so I can maneuver and position around and by the way this is not exactly how the board was set up it's similar ilar but not perfect so
don't nitpick the actions that I take here you're going to have to believe that they happened as I'm describing them and I wasn't the only one sitting at this table that had experience actually there was only one new player at the table this was the third game for one of the players this was the fourth game for another player this was my fifth game and this was shir's first game so we had one person we were coaching but everyone else knew the rules were able to AP check pay attention to cards knew it was in the market and understood how to approach the game how to score and how to maneuver around arcs again I get it this seems like a scenario that really shouldn't happen so often but in the five games I've played up until this point I have always seen a blowout Victory and a crushing defeat I have not yet had a single game of arcs that has resulted in a close scoring game where one player is within the realm of possibility of winning and bringing home Victory they just needed a few extra points from second place in a different position I think that's a problem I think it's a major problem with how my group is going to experience and want to continue playing arcs I can already categorically say I have no interest in teaching new players how to play this game the level of sophistication complexity and Nuance when it comes to
the strategy is the thing that is going to make people fall in love with it but it's also the thing that makes the first two three four five plays of arcs really hard and really hard to to balance and manage and control the game state if you have a game group like many people do and I think this is one of the reasons why shut up and sit down loves this game so much if you have a game group that enjoys uh the overhead conversation and strategy that goes into board games the you know Cosmic Encounter style don't don't ruin me don't destroy me let's work together let me share planets let's talk discuss and have a broken engine that we actually balance as players the Twilight Imperium wheel and deal and negotiate the blood on the clock tower uh social deduction game that is conscripted through a uh lying twisting deceitful host who knows all the information and it has one job which is to make the game as interesting and compelling as possible if you like a game that requires you to balance it through conversation through negotiation through wheeling and dealing I think that is why people are falling in love with arcs and all the power to them but if you're looking for a game reflective of something like root you're
looking for a strategic puzzle a victory Point scoring game that you can solve and squeeze and everything's going to be tight and perfectly fit together or not even perfectly fit together but at least balanced enough that you can rely on the game to be responsible for itself and not other players around the table having to go kneecap the Vagabond just so they don't win with a runaway Victory arcs isn't that I scored 27 points on round two or chapter two of the game and this is how I did it so start working through here is it an approximation of what we have and by this point in the game I've not only not scored any victory points but I don't look very competitive for the other two objectives on the board the game state is built out similar to this someone has declared Tycoon the person who declared Tycoon is the person who owns the fuel cartel over here to the side the fuel cartel is a card when played or when in on someone's Tableau all the fuel is stored on this card it's not there for you to use but it counts towards your scoring so the fuel car cartel is sitting out there in the uh Tableau of another player they also have a few resources and they have declared Tycoon they want to score that warlord has been declared warlord has been declared because everyone else is fighting many people have been fighting me as you can
see down here in the corner I don't have many ships left but not everyone has been fighting me I mean in fact you can see with the movement on the board here and this is about how it was set up blue has completely left this location they've swung all the way up here to start picking on the red player and we have over here red has left this location and they have zoomed all the way over here to defend and fight with the white player everyone is doing their very best to collect and secure uh points they're trying to go for warlord it was the first one declared it is the highest victory points for this round of the game you're going to be scoring five so right now I believe the highest out there on the Tableau is someone has three and then everyone else has maybe two or so it hasn't been epic battles there's not a lot of Destruction happening but there's definitely destruction happening on the table the last one is empath now now I did initiate empath it's the only one that I put into play here and no one's really been competing with me for it the reason being is cuz I have two uh cities built over here on this planet uh it's the second highest scoring one and I have no Victory point so people aren't really looking to minmax me necessarily and as you can see I've already collected quite a few of these resource these psionic resources because well I was able to harvest them and with my ability which will go through the empath Bond I was actually able to harvest them really effectively so over the last turn or two knowing that I could use these
for just extra bonus abilities and actions when I needed some flexibility I didn't have cards that could follow very effectively I got them into my Tableau and because I'm sitting here with one on the loyal empaths card and four sitting here across the front row everyone's kind of left me alone we are playing with leaders in this and the leaders that I have is Noble now Noble uh has the keyword connected when you declare an ambition that's not declared draw and secure the top card of the Court deck you can't use its Prelude action now because there's always a delay for Prelude actions I also have influential when you copy or pivot to influence you may influence twice and then finally I have proud when scoring you can only gain power if you get first place not tied so if I want to score any of these I've got to get first place in light of that and trying to get as many resources as I can I have went ahead and built almost all of my cities I don't have my last two out at this point in the game but I understand that if I get them out there and I score I could get some extra bonus victory points I also have drafted the lore card empath's Bond while empath is declared you may tax any cities and build ships and catapult SL move with any starports like they are loyal you don't take captives you don't you build ships that are damaged if you're in a blockaded system so the rules apply but it's as if I can take advantage of other people's resources throughout here I
convince them through mental mind games to work alongside of me and then I also have currently the loyal empaths card the arms Union card and the Elder broker card the Elder broker card's key ability that I'm going to utilize is the Prelude action you may discard this to gain one material one Fuel and one weapon the loyal empaths is the card that interacts with uh burning your empaths or putting a what a disrupt or rolt or whatever the key term is an outrage on your pic ability if you provoke the outrage this card will stay you may also spend any resources as psionic uh you ignore outrage when spending psionic for this Prelude action so I haven't outraged psionic but it's a nice little bonus to have because other resources could be used to give me another action of whatever the lead card is which is going to be important and then I have arms Union arms Union allows me to place this card next to a face up play aggression card when the round ends draw that card into your hand and discard this card this is an extremely powerful card and you will see why this was essential to how I well disrupted the game and flipped everything on its head so that's the general breakdown that's like where we are right now in the game I haven't played any of these out yet I haven't played the one out yet uh we are going through phases and I'm starting to maneuver and figure out exactly what I want to do I do something along the
lines of spending a bunch of these resources to get bonus actions for whatever card was here now and whatever card was here before I believe the last card was a conflict card and so I spent a lot of these doing both move and secure actions I know I spent one getting the ability to go up here through a conflict card and secure during Secret order when you declare keeper or empath do not place the zero marker that's not going to matter right now but I got that because it's going to secure my lead on empath there is one other player out there who has uh one on empath already they have one empath token sitting in their Tableau so if I spend all of mine I knew that if I got a second card from the marketplace whatever it was that gave me a point towards it I would have it locked down as long as I went into this last phase as I'm about to describe I go through the process I spend you know most of my resources here they all kind of come out of play I'm harvesting pulling I'm I'm doing stuff that's getting me stuff but the key things that I do is I look for locations where I'm going to be able to attack and build I I want to be able to get my buildings out there onto the table now again I need material in order to do that and I was was able to utilize this card to go ahead and my powers and abilities to go ahead and get some material onto my sheet on top of that I
was also able to use this here my Elder broker to get a material a fuel and a weapon again giving me just a little bit more flexibility so I would have discarded that material Fuel and weapon is popping over here so I've went through the process now of cycling all of these little tokens through whatever card I had available or whatever card uh you know the other players had available I have changed my board from having a lot of these psionic abilities to having quite a bit of quite a number of these build abilities at least two of them possibly three of them at the time again it doesn't really matter it's not a perfect reflection of how the game worked I then take my actions I begin moving right I'm spending some of those to reposition my ships looking for the opportunity to build I want to be able to fight and build because if I can fight I can steal if I can steal I can steal this cartel giving me seven total counting towards that Victory which is more than any other player at the table along with that if I fight and steal the cartel I'm also going to have the opportunity to potentially secure warlord so what's the rest of the puzzle the rest of the puzzle is being able to put out and build with these two little cubes that I have here my buildings on to the table so I went through some process that has allowed me to a turn before this or so reposition down here to an open space
port and uh do a similar thing over here maybe I move one of these ships or something along those lines again everyone is focused on securing their own Victory the thing that they put out that they're going for all three of us are kind of focused on one different thing and then two of them are squabbling over one of them and in the last phase of the game when we start playing down our cards it turns out that no one really has any violent actions and there's not military available out on the board so being able to react to the fact that I've moved into these empty zones that people had shifted out of in order to fight to secure the warlord isn't something that people are really able to do there's not a lot of flexibility there by the time we're at this stage in the game I also have held my one power card my one fighting card because I know that the arms Union card is going to pair very nicely with that so we're playing through the game we're moving forward we're progressing I've destroyed these things some way somehow again we played the game right we had people who knew how to play the game watching and being rules lawyers these have come off the board I've opened up those slots I've secured for myself two of the four total that I need in order to take warlord and people are starting to realize that this is a problem this is where we come into the setting that we have now here's where I shifted this number seven comes out giving them one action someone plays down a copy giving them one action I believe they just taxed in order to get resources to move
on to chapter three so the first two actions of the game were more or less wasted uh I then come I play down my number one aggression card and I start taking my Prelude actions I of course spend my two cubes to build I get two buildings out in zones that I just destroyed and opened up so I now have the ability to score additional points as long as I get first place in any number of these objectives uh on top of that I begin maneuvering and repositioning I don't know exactly how many resources I had but I begin getting in position to fight and I go ahead and play arms Union on top of my one because it's a Prelude action so my card goes down first and the abilities that I get for my cards aren't spent yet so I have time to put arms Union down into play meaning I'm going to be drawing back my number one aggression card now yes other players around the table could have should have would have been paying attention to the fact that that is a possibility and maybe if they're counting cards they could see maybe that last one hasn't come out but there's not really enough known information at the Tableau that people would expect that that could happen and even if we were at this stage and they thought that was going to happen what are they going to do with the last cards they have in their hand it's really not going to be the most effective turn so I play arms Union meaning at the end of this round I'm going to be able to draw back my number one I will be the only person with that
one card I will be able to play it down I will be able to take three actions with it and I'll be able to utilize some of the other actions I have on my Tableau I don't have fuel at this point so I I know I went into this last round with only four actions because I had my one little rocket over here to the side it's about where we are something along those lines again I can't you know it's not too specific but that's the theory up here this white player is the one that owns the fuel cartel and I am trying to rip it from their grasp I take my one single action I think it was something along a move you know something along the lines of a move action it might even be that at the time I had ships over here over here or in here and I I moved them into the position that I wanted to really focus and de damage at the moment the last player goes they play down a card they aren't able to really respond to anything that I've done sure they could reposition a little bit but they don't have any ability to be violent and they don't expect that I'm going to be closing out the game they think maybe I'll score two of these but 27 points clean is not something that any of us have ever seen before blowout victories yes 27 points on round two or chapter two of the game no so they play they get set up they tax they get ready for the next phase of the game and I pull this card back into my hand only one person has been able to respond to the fact that I've put this out and that I will be getting an extra bonus turn
and this is where it becomes a major problem for the table I place this one out I now have three actions corresponding to my militaristic aggression I'm going to spend this one ability because uh I have my loyal empaths card meaning I could spend any Resource as a psionic giving me one additional action so I have four total actions attack or move or secure of course but I'm not in a position where I need to secure anymore I'm focused on trying to take down my opponents and go ahead and get at least two more victories here in order to score uh that warlord track so this is where I start trying to steal fuel cartels we come up here to this location we've got two ships I've got four we've got one city now the problem is I do not want to destroy this city because this city is fuel in and of itself so I pop up here I grab uh I forget exactly what number of dice that I grab but I grab some number of dice I think I went heavy red to start with or maybe I went with you know two orange a red I think maybe it was like two orange a red and a blue or I might have even played it super risky not paying as close of attention as I could but either way I roll and the result that I get results in a little bit of damage on the table but it doesn't result in this being destroyed so this takes one damage
flipping to its backside one of these ships gets damaged I believe at the time one of these ships came off but we won't harp on that too much and of course my ships are going to take a bit of damage but I can spread it out fairly evenly I did end up getting when I rolled the two uh keys that I needed in order to go ahead and steal the fuel cartel and so this wibbly wobbles its way over onto my Tableau I now have primary on Tycoon and there's nothing any other player is going to be able to do to react or prevent it that was one of the actions that I needed to take the next action that I took was a move action shifting over here into this Zone where red and blue had been fighting horrendously and I begin fighting here I lost one ship to White somewhere along the away I even think they possibly had two ships left and I wanted to steal one of them before I moved on so I think I did another roll but I only rolled a total of two red dice instead of the four that I could have because I specifically didn't want to destroy our little chapel here so this would have taken one ship and destroyed another I'm now at four I need one more in order to secure the victory I've taken two actions there I move over for an action and I have one action left well what am I going to do with three ships and a need to steal some resources well and have warlord I roll all three all three is yeah sure possibly going to do some damage to me although their ships are already flipped because they've been fighting previously uh so I'm not getting any from that Circle and I'm able to hit enough to wipe out two
or three of them and suddenly I have the trophies necessary because I had four fighting actions in the very last phase of the game I have the psionic necessary because people haven't been competing with me in it because I had so much initially and I utilized that to leverage and draw cards and do more and I have with the fuel cartel that I've stolen by battling I have secured Tycoon not only that but I've positioned and placed out the plus two and the plus three giving me a plus five to every single one ambition as long as I come in first so up here in Tycoon I'm going to go ahead and score eight points warlord I'm going to score 10 and here at empath I'm going to score nine moves me from 0o to 27 a few of the other players score second place moving them up just slightly and that's the end of the game chapter 2 done three players left completely in the dust in the background and all of us kind of feeling mixed about it all of us having really conflicting emotions I haven't played a game yet where there hasn't been a blown out Victory and yet I really don't like the fact that with some degree of experienced Gamers I mean we're all for the most part I mean no not for the most part we're all good at
board games we understand the logic puzzle behind them and almost all of us at the table have played this multiple times and at multiple player counts so we have a good sense of the puzzle that we're approaching and we're not playing cruel I mean we're really trying to win we're all trying to go for victory we understand that keeping other people at Bay is a possibility holding back that line not letting it be a blowout Victory is something that you should be paying attention for and still we're not able to stop that and through yes the right cards and convenient timing and some good strategic play I'm not bragging on myself here this isn't about me it's about the fact that Mars as a game allowed for something like this to happen I just have to contrast it with root for you all CU I mean we're coming from a leader games property a cold worldly design and a game that also has that race to win Victory mechanic that push the end of the game and yeah there are moments in rout where you can score 10 12 points in a single swing which is a third of the points you're looking for but it's never until later in the game the big problem that that I have here is in order to keep the timeline which this by the way was a 2hour long game at this point maybe an hour 45 we're talking a little bit but in order to keep this game interesting and timely is they've set this scoring track this Ambition track as a giant scoring puzzle that has
a lot of room for swinging we're in root you're scoring from your various factions in a slow modulated prog ression the same thing in another race to win game like viticulture you're taking turns you're playing actions you're getting one two three points at a time and you can see when another player is pulling ahead or Shifting the dial but in a four-player game that we've all invested two hours in for a scenario like this to happen where the floor despite everyone paying attention the floor has been left open for someone to go from zero victory points to immediately winning the game it it doesn't seem like a thing that should happen I could be wrong I I don't I don't I don't really know and I can't imagine many players who upon having Victory won without much ability to gauge or control it I can't imag imagine many players wouldn't find that to be slightly disjointed broken Andor at least anticlimactic the end of the game you know left one player absolutely hating it left another extremely convicted definitely now I asked I
asked did you have fun and their response was I I'll have to think about that and yeah the other player is enjoying arcs he was looking up ways to buy it it's right for some people absolutely of course it is and it's brilliant in so many ways I mean I love the card play here I think the dice and the way that you draft them is awesome I just I have a really big problem with the fact that the game is requiring players to balance the parts and the elements of it that seem broken I have a big problem with the fact that so far in my play experience I have never seen a game with a close second place I've only ever seen blowout victories one person's left in the dust sometimes there's a person round middle you know which theoretically in this could be close second places if you have a 27 point swing but it doesn't I mean it doesn't feel like that when you look at the board and so the way that it closes out the way that it it finishes is really hard to justify that being said we're still in we're still playing we're still exploring we're still going to have a pile of content continuing to come out on arcs and we're committed to doing a three part campaign I've got you know my
friend who's very excited about this that's four games in so far ready to hop in and I have another friend that's going to be driving up which will teach run through get a few games under his belt and then swing into a full recorded campaign of this I want to get that 20 25 30 plays of arcs under my belt and I want to be able to talk to you all about it and explain and document and share what the journey is and what the experience of play is like as we're evolving and as we're learning how we relate to this title this is coming from an extremely notice noticeable notable publisher this has been reviewed by multiple people who are highly highly respected in the industry and well-deserving of that respect who do great quality work and are declaring this one of if not the single best game of
2024 that's hard for me but I'm interested I'm intrigued I'm still excited I do think two players might be my favorite balance of the game and uh I'm looking forward to continuing to explore it and understand it and uh make some more content so thanks for watching thanks for chatting with me as I break down the odd events that has happened during our fifth game uh let me know your thoughts let me know uh you think I overlooked anything again you can't judge the board because this isn't this is a setup abstracted example it's not the the actual play state but these are the cards that were in play and the way that the shuffling happened and uh it went on like it went on all right thanks for being here thanks for watching whatever the case though whatever you do remember to do the important thing I I don't know what I mean you're going to have to you probably know what the important I assume you do what the important thing is so you just go you do that bye