How to make money designing board games - Jamey Stegmaier
Transcript
and that really wasn't the right call I learned rather quickly that um this person despite their best intentions what didn't have the passion for it that I did they weren't there to put in the time that I was putting into it and so I wish I hadn't been so scared of failing financially that I made a dumb decision but let me ask you Jimmy if you were to start over today right if you're going to do things you know still Mark games falls off into the ocean never to be seen again wingspan sales dropped to zero you got to start over yeah but I mean how would you do it if I built something up and it crashed and burned and failed I think I would be I mean honestly I think I would so Jimmy we're talking about how to monetize creativity one thing I've noticed both personally and just talking to other creative people it is so incredibly challenging it is just so hard to make money to make a living off of Art in any form it seems like first of all have you noticed that too or have you found like the golden ticket and you're like hey this is easy for me but you know have you noticed that too and then why do you why do you think it is so hard for so many people to monetize creativity I think part of it sometimes our passions don't align with what is actually lucrative like I for a long time I wanted to publish a book I wanted to write a book and publish a book and I wrote the book um maybe I could have gotten an agent for it I didn't go that far with it but to actually turn that passion for writing a novel into actually making money from a novel is
they're almost two completely separate skill sets have you experienced that oh 100 you know one thing I've noticed is people who are really good at Art are typically really terrible at business and then oftentimes vice versa right the the odds that you were born with both sides of your brain really good at those things is very very rare uh you might be able to be really mediocre at both I've I've met people that are like fine you know at both sides but yeah I think there's something and and history is is just full of incredibly artistic people who got screwed over by really smart business people right and so I think that's another thing is that it makes it challenging as an artist or as a Creator or an inventor is it's kind of easier to take advantage of you because you don't want to deal with the the taxes and the profit and loss sheets and like all that stuff and then unfortunately if you run into the wrong kind of person you know I think the Elvis Presley movie they came out recently with somebody like his manager like stole so much money and had him doing all these projects all this stuff and he just wanted to make music he just wanted to be out there on stage and doing that and so I think that's another challenge because in today's world like you have access to everybody you know back in the day there were so many Gatekeepers you had to go through but now you can go online and you can build an audience you can do it all yourself but even still you know we don't have this over abundance of of people making money creatively especially considering how many people are are doing art so what else do you think it is well and to touch upon what you're saying there a little bit is yeah we have access to everybody we also have
access to so much information if if you wanted to be an expert at something you as something specific that you aren't already an expert at you could probably gain expertise in that subject but we're limited by our our own time our own resources our own priorities our other projects example of this for for stillmeyer games the company that I that I helped to run is uh we have a game actually you're wearing a shirt right now uh that for one of our big game side and for a while people were asking us to make a role-playing game for scythe and it is possible that we could have made some money making a role-playing game for side but I realized after people started showing role-playing games to me for in the Scythe world that I knew I'm not a role-playing gamer right I played tabletop games I don't play role play games so I knew nothing about whether what makes a good role-playing game nor did I realize this is the bigger thing I realized I don't know anything about selling role-playing games it's a completely different distribution model than tabletop games I I you know the market is I would have to do so much market research to understand how that system works I could do it when I'm already successful at selling board games so why pivot over there if I already know this so it's kind of this limitation of like the information is there but do I actually want to access it do I want to spend all that time to figure out how to do it versus something that I'm already doing decently yeah that's a good point and especially when it comes to time it's a zero-sum game like you only have so much and if you're gonna put in a bunch of time and ever effort and energy and money and all this stuff into something like that then that means you're not putting that same
effort all that into the next game that you're working on and which one are you going to make more money at and that's the thing like account with your going back what you're saying earlier is like you might be really excited and passionate about something that's not particularly lucrative that's not making a lot of money I remember one time years ago I was when I was working with homeless folks in Atlanta and there was this guy who was an intern at one of the organizations and he was going through law school and as part of his law school program he had to work for like a non-profit or something like that for a certain amount of time and so he was working with this homeless Ministry downtown and he and I got hooked up at one point and we were going under the bridges and doing different things I'm talking to them about all the different stuff and I said oh man you're gonna be a lawyer that's that's cool uh you make make good money doing that right he goes yeah yeah you know in the type of law he was going into was like super lucrative and I was like man you should you should think about homeless Ministry though like make a lot of money doing homeless Ministry you know a lot of big checks he goes really no no man I'm just messing with you like there's no there's no money in this you know it's just something that if your your heart's not in it then it's not gonna work and I feel like that's a lot of art like it's hard to it's especially because of scale let's talk about that one thing I think you've you've kind of cracked the code on is you've been able to sell millions of games that is a very challenging thing to take art and then scale it up so talk to me about your experience in because you didn't just wake up and do this like you started off with a pretty humble Kickstarter campaign with ziticulture way back in the day but now you've managed to sell ridiculous number of
games especially for our side of the industry how did you do that tell me some insights as far as scale well I think you you used a word that I think of often when I think about a first project for whether it's my first project or someone else's network is humble um start it really helped that I happened to start small if that campaign had really blown up I think it raised around sixty thousand dollars there's a lot of money it felt like a ton of money at the time um but if that had raised six hundred thousand dollars and we were making 15 000 games instead of 1500 games I think we made 2500 in that first print run uh even 2500 of a thing is a lot there's a lot of copies of a thing to make but scaling up would have been difficult to do it off the bat I'm glad that I was able to get my foot in the door see what we're see what didn't work see what did scale well um before having some bigger projects come along and so I think that can be that could be intimidating I think for any any Creator if you're making one copy of something you know it the first copy is depending on how you look at the math can be very expensive but it's also just one copy of it compared to an unknown quantity if you're if your project really takes off is daunting I think yeah and it's a good point in that success can ruin you right overwhelming success especially when you haven't built up the foundation of understanding because I know I made so many mistakes with my first project and then the next project I made a few less mistakes and they tried a few less you know and so in my first project I think I had 300 backers you know nothing crazy
and again I printed just a handful copies like like you're talking about um but then I noticed that in the manufacturing that they had there was a misprint it was my fault I had sent them the wrong art file and the layers were messed up and so some of the information on the card that had to be there was underneath other information so you couldn't see it and so I had to go back to the manufacturer print the correct cards and then mail those out to everybody now luckily I was only mailing out 300 of those and not 3 000 or you know five out like that would have changed the math of everything and so like you said like it's it's okay to start humble I think a lot of people they they see million dollar campaigns they're like oh that could be me it's like it could be are you sure like be careful what you'll wish for like it might not be what you want like wait five years then run a million dollar campaigner or something like that um yeah I think that's yeah good point now speaking of crowdfunding a while back you pivoted away you know you ran several campaigns that were very successful the South campaign made in millions of dollars you did a lot of really cool stuff on crowdfunding you have a Blog devoted to crowdfunding like you were a crowdfunding OG like you were one of the main people that the internet would go to for information and advice and best practices but then you decided that you wanted to do something different so tell me about the process the mindset like why you did that and kind of the the Insight behind it yeah I mean there are there were a lot of reasons for the switch over um part of it was kind of personal slash emotional slash psychological and that we uh it was after the Scythe campaign
was delivering and we were delivering early and we were delivering really the thing that everyone had hoped that we would deliver on the game that has done very well and people were happy to get it and yet there was uh we were talking about passion earlier there was a passion from the buyer side and and how that kind of manifested in some ways that made me a little bit worried it also made me worried in terms of scale when one of the Fulfillment centers didn't really follow through on their promises they they weren't packaging the games well I'm rather lucky really that a number of those games arrived in good condition and that was a one fulfillment center covering Europe like the entire region of Europe and made me get a little scared for a little while to use fulfillment centers versus going to directly to retailers Distributors I've now pivoted back to also selling directly but just some things like that especially given the scale of side that made me nervous and made me want to to try to improve our relationships with retailers and Distributors which is another thing actually about this discussion about monitor monetization like are you just selling to individual people are you trying to get into stores around the country or around the world um yeah so anyway we we switched over to that uh that that method with our next game Charter zone of of uh primarily selling to retailers and Distributors and seeing how that went and uh it it went fine uh but it was it was definitely it felt a lot different than getting all that money up front we were kind of making something in the hopes that it would sell in hopes that people would want in the Distributors would want it and fortunately they did but there was a lot of risk there to try that yeah absolutely but I guess in a
lot of ways there's always risk no matter what you do right it's just a matter where is the risk in the times you know timeline but uh go back to what you just said as far as like Distributors versus retailers versus uh direct to Consumer things like that that's a whole different marketing plan like which way you're going to do it if you're going to run a campaign a crowdfunding campaign that has a very specific marketing plan that you have to come up with versus if you're just going to try to get into stores and Distributors and things like that so tell me just some of your the things you're seeing nowadays right with the market being a little bit bloated like there's so many companies there's so many games there's so much going on it's hard to cut through all the noise so what are you seeing marketing wise that someone listening to this show could kind of take away especially if they're on the newer side right they're just starting out they're just trying to figure out what are some marketing tips you would effle well Gabe I don't know if my answer will be all that encouraging to someone watching this because unfortunately I think the answer often that I'm seeing for retailers and Distributors is that they are defaulting a lot more to the things they know they can sell within a few months and those things things are often either a perennial best seller an evergreen game that they're getting a requests for at least a few requests for every month or they are a hot new game and those are two things that you have you don't have that much control over like if we're trying to make a product whether it's a game or something else you're trying to make the best version of that product but you can't really control if it's going to be a hot new game you can't control if it's going to be a best-selling game especially from the beginning so in terms of marketing I
think you could do your best in terms of the marketing of the product design itself to do the best you can and it has helped for us at least that from the beginning we were trying to forge relationships with retailers and Distributors so even on our earlier's campaigns we had a retail pledge level or a way for retailers to back the campaign and so we started to form some of those relationships early on and they've paid off in the long run because those games have continued to sell but those two things go hand in hand have you on your campaigns I don't know offhand have you have you done direct retailer uh uh pledge levels things like that yes but it's never been more than like 20 backers at that level like it's never been on a grand scale I think part of that is most of my games are very Niche I make solo games I make you know 20 minute playing 20 type games and honestly I don't like that much money at a retail or pledge anyway you know if you're selling it at 50 and then you're also giving some kind of subsidy on the shipping like I'm not making enough money off of those to really make a difference and so I think that's another thing to think about as far as the math and the scale because I know when I did Robo mine now you're talking about an 80 gain now there's a margin versus the games I was doing before which are 20 and now I've got in fact it goes into marketing like all of a sudden I had a lot more money to play without the right word but like to to be able to put into the budget because I was like okay if I can get a backer that's 80 that then there's you know more to do with versus if I get a backer it's twenty dollars and I have a very tight margin to kind of mess around with and so I think that's another thing when you're
thinking about scale can you can you be the button shy of the world that puts out 18 card games and and you're not making a lot of money per sale but then you maximize you have a lot of backers you don't have 3 000 backers on the campaign and still make money yes but what would be your thoughts like if I'm a new creator do I start off with a 20 game do I start off with a 50 game maybe not 100 maybe that's a big ask I think if I've got a 100 game with a bunch of Miniatures I've never delivered anything before I think maybe that's not a great idea but when it comes to like the low range versus the mid-range what are your thoughts coming at 20 coming at 50 what do you say I will going back to the like the humble idea I would I think me from a few years ago might say to go for that 20 game now I think manufacturers know how to make a fifty dollar sixty dollar game because my main hesitation the reason I would pull back from from uh encouraging someone to go for a kind of a medium weight or a medium priced game like that would be that they haven't learned how to make the game beautiful yet or how they haven't learned how to make the all these different components that would probably go into that game because a 50 game is probably going to be more than just a deck of cards or something like that but at this point the project managers at any manufacturer are going to help you get there I think and so having that expertise hand in hand with what you're trying to create I I generally like to think uh to go with their passion you mentioned passion or if you're more passionate about the 50 game uh I would go for that I would
go for the one that you're more passionate about that's it if you're more passionate about the 20 game or the 25 game and that's the one that you really want to share with the world I would I would go with that doesn't necessarily mean that you'd be profitable like you said you might you might have lost some money on some of those retail sales but you never know some of those retailers might come back to it in the future some of those early backers there's 300 backers that you had some of them I'm sure are still sticking around supporting you or at least hanging out and hoping for the next thing from you that they want you get that sense yeah absolutely and that's something I've talked to a lot of new creators about it's like understand that your first campaign to Camp three campaigns maybe it's really about Foundation it's about building an audience building a group of people that they learn to trust you they become your raving fans they're the ones that are on the social media groups and whatnot talking about your stuff without you having to pay them or ask them to or you know spend money on it uh that's that's really what you're doing and so yeah you might want to come in at a cheaper price point just because you know you can manufacture it for cheaper you can get it out in the world it's going to be probably cheaper to ship like the the problems are going to be cheaper right the mistakes are going to be cheaper everything's going to be a little easier to handle when you come in on the low end but if you're really passionate about that kind of middle you know around 50 game that's another thing to take into consideration I was talking recently about how hard it is to finish anything small large enormous tiny like it doesn't matter the size of the project it's so hard to finish anything and so the more passionate you are and the more excited you are about the thing maybe the more likely you are to actually get
it across the finish line so there's that to take into consideration too because if you're just doing something to start off with just because you know it'll fund and you you know this is a good way to do it but you're not really excited about it it's like if you're selling something because you know you can make money I mean that that works but I don't know that's something to to really think to really think through any advice on that side of things I you mentioned earlier that that time is scarce and precious and if for me if I'm gonna spend my time on something it's going to be something I care about um it's gonna be it whether it's a video I'm excited to make a conversation with someone like you that I'm excited to have or or I'm going to spend 100 hours working on a new game I it's got to be something that that I'm excited to put out there in the world not just for me but for other people too because I'm putting it out there I'm creating something for people to consume and to use and hopefully to bring joy to their tabletops and so I don't want to waste their time either so I yeah I for every Pro every project that I make it it essentially becomes a passion project whether it's my design or someone else's design that we're publishing that's a good point you know we're talking about monetizing creativity but I feel like if you're getting into this for the monetization over the creativity you're going to run into a problem and I would have to really just ask you the question why don't you just learn how to code websites for insurance companies or something like that they're going to pay you a a large amount of money you're going to be able to do something that is kind of creative like you're bringing something to life um but go be a plumber go be an electrician go build stuff like you're
going to make 100 Grand a year doing that where if you're going to be a writer a game designer an artisan like the odds of making 100 Grand doing creative stuff is very low so if you are coming in thinking monetization over creativity you might run into uh into some challenges there have you noticed have you noticed people doing that though like I feel like I've seen people that seem to be getting into the business of games for the money sometimes like they see a million dollar campaign they're like oh okay this is a way to make a lot of money without knowing anything about the margins the background how much goes into things so what are your thoughts on that side of things as far as you know just encouraging people I guess as far as the creativity versus the money I think you've said it really well their Gabe I it's it's a little bit of a red flag whenever I hear someone who talking about something they want to create and one of their motivations for that is to make money whether it's a game whether it's anything that they're even just a little bit excited about if they're already starting to Jump by the money before they've started to actually create it that to me is a little bit of a red flag and just partially on a personal level because I I feel for them like I don't want them to fail in that way but if you've determined that the gauge of success is that you are financially successful that you have made money on it they're just some other and so many other ways that you can be successful like uh if your goal is to make a game that makes some people happy you could just design a game and play it with your family play with your friends and that can make those people happy but if your goal is to make a million dollars on a game and you don't meet that goal that's
something that's relatively out of your control and so you're setting a goal that you can't even control at all whereas you can set the goal of putting the game on your table at some point so yeah that it's a big red flag what I hear about that whether it's for Designing for creating a new product or creating um a YouTube channel a podcast if you're getting into that for the money you're probably not going to uh gonna have that work out yeah that's a really good point I mean there's one thing to be said about like paying your bills and get to a place where you're stable enough you know but if you're really getting into this to be rich and famous good luck you know because most of the people I know that have gotten to that place where they are you know doing a creative thing and they have a lot of money in their bank account they drive a nice car big house all that for the most part they got into it because they loved it and out of that love they got really really good at it and the thing about being really really good at something people will pay you to do that thing you know and maybe you go into movies where you make a lot of money or maybe you go into game design where even the top end is not making crazy but you can still make a very good living I think that's something to think about because like like you said what does success look like and really stepping back into finding that because if success is monetary in your mind especially if that's in like the top you know one two or three priorities go do something else and just do this stuff as a hobby because I mean it's just the odds of of selling millions of games like you have the odds of becoming Alan Moon and having a ticket to ride type game that sells a zillion copies every year forever uh it's very very low and so yeah go do something else on
Saturday morning play test and prototype but on Monday you know go back to the office and and make more make more money doing that and because you can use that day job to fund the creativity so that's another thing let's let's think about that because you did this for a long time you had a pretty stable job and you were doing all the the stonemar game stuff on the side so tell me tell me about that because your monetization was not necessarily games it was like you were monetizing your other time and then bringing that over into the tabletop space tell me about your experience there yeah in fact I would say this was crucially important to build that Foundation that you talked about earlier because I was not relying on money earned by stillmeyer games for my income to pay the bills um so I had this project for viticulture and uh it did like I said it did okay and then we sold some retail copies of it and I had a full-time day job at this time and uh all that money that I was earning for viticulture was going back into viticulture it would eventually go back into a second print run of the game uh opposed to me counting on that money for my own personal funds instead I I had another campaign for another game Euphoria and at that point I I was working so much for both jobs my my hobby job and my full-time day job that I asked my boss if he could pay me 20 less and I could take one day off a week just to focus on on my my company that was working on I did that for five months and things were going well enough at that point that I had enough saved up that I could go for a
year basically I could I could just make still my games my full-time job for a year and see if that worked out and so I ended up quoting my day job at that point but tiptoeing into it and not relying on those funds it might have been the make or break point for the company because I was I was able to put all that money back into the company instead of using it to pay my own bills did you would you when did you have that Tipping Point how did you do that well I had an interesting scenario because I was living in Honduras where cost of living is basically nothing and I was working for a school that provided free housing and so I'm not paying rent I'm not having to pay nearly as much for just normal living expenses and so that allowed me more flexibility even though I have a bunch of kids you know I've got four kids and a spouse like that changes the math on everything but because of where I was living and so I think that's another thing to think about if you're going to try to monetize creativity is what are you willing to sacrifice are you willing to move to a cheaper place like now I live in the middle of nowhere in Alabama it's still relatively cheap nowhere near as cheap as Honduras but still pretty cheap to live where I live and my mortgage is very low you know it's it's just easier to monetize creativity when I'm not paying three thousand dollars a month for rent like I might be in big cities and things like that and trying to have enough space for all these kids and that's another thing just to kind of think about is also do you have a spouse or like you know partner or something that makes really good money so you can take a step back and make less money you're trying to start things off trying to get into creative you know something even if you're not starting a company
even if you're just trying to pitch to Publishers to you know write a book to make a game but do you have somebody else that can kind of make more money that allows you to do that like I've got a friend his wife is a doctor she makes a ton of money so he makes games because he's able to do that now if his wife wasn't a doctor he probably wouldn't be able to be in this space because he just wouldn't be able to pay his bills and so I think that's nothing what are you willing to sacrifice and do you have the people around you that can kind of all come together as a team to make it all to make it all work and so what would be what would be your advice there as far as like how do you because it's really not about creativity as much as your entire life it's like how are you willing to build your entire life tell me some of your experiences you talk about the corporate kind of world and then slowly moving in but what else as far as like a life because you're not you're not driving a Range Rover as far as I know like you're not out there going crazy like you said like do you still live in the same condo that you've lived in forever like even though you're making a lot of money now uh no I don't know I I lived there for around 14 years and I drove a 2003 Camry for for a long long time my girlfriend Megan and I moved in around three and a half years ago and I I did eventually I I got a different color I have a slightly nicer car now that I have fun driving um but uh I do I try so what I do is I'm glad that you've tied this um the the hobby the passion or if you don't want to make a career out of this I'm glad that you've tied it to all these personal things that factor into whether or not you can actually monitor monetize something because I do a monthly budget like I look at it's not a
tight budget I don't say I have this much money to spend on something this month in the back of my head I kind of had that but I don't do that on paper but rather I look at how much money I spent in the past month in different Pockets how much did I spend on food how much did I spend on investments on things that are going to help me 30 years down the road and how and I to look at that total how much did I spend on things this month and did I do well should I have spent less uh can I can I trim that and even just the awareness of seeing how much I spend month and month has been really helpful for me to be better at living within my means and hopefully preparing a better future for for me and my family um do you do anything like that do you help do you look at your personal finances um and have that impact decisions that you make on on the business side of your life yeah so I don't know how healthy this is but I checked my bank account pretty much every day and I just stare at the numbers now there's also you know I'll sit down and think through the budgets and you know I've got a game coming up and I've got shoes to buy for kids like there's all those things that also factor in but like if if I was trying to lose weight I don't think I would look at the scale every day I think that is super detrimental from like a physical mineral thing but when it comes to money I like going in and looking at those numbers because it's a motivator it's like hey this is not where you need to be you know you got you gotta you got a lot of college you might have to pay for you got cars you're gonna have to buy for these kids you have some health things that that these that your children so like that's one thing it's almost like a a fire you know I mean like it kind of puts it in me to go I gotta get these numbers have to go bigger and how do they go bigger well I have to make more
content I have to put more games out into the world I have to there's a million things that I okay now let's channel that burden into activity now I think it's it can be dangerous because some people they get that burden and then they sit on the couch so it depends on who you are like you have to find what motivates you right I've got motivators walking around my house daily I go I need to I need to go back to work because I got to do some stuff to make sure you're you're gonna be taken care of you know and and that's a balance though to not go crazy and not work 18 hours a day and be like Oh I'm doing it for my kids it's like well you're probably doing it for yourself too like it's not just for them at that point you know so I think there's some things to to think about there when it comes to motivating factors tell me about you though because I don't think we've ever in all the conversations we've had and to be to be honest part of why I started this new podcast was to be able to talk to you I enjoy our time together so appreciate you being here but tell me about some of the things that have motivated you over the years and just how you continue to keep going how you continue to come back and have new ideas new games what works for you the mission at my company is to bring joy to tabletops worldwide and I do come back to that a lot I know it's you know a mission statement whatever weight that actually holds but I do think about it a lot because I see people talking about our games like I'm on social media I see if people are excited about our games I see if they're not excited about our games and it really does uplift me when I see someone having fun with one of our games or when they've connected with someone especially someone unexpectedly about about through one of our games or through any tabletop game so that is still a major motivator on a personal level I I mean I would say
money is fairly low down on the list money is and pretty much throughout the 10 years that I've run so our games has been can I make enough to live and you know have a house over my head have food can I can I do those things and maybe over the years it has become a little I've notched that up a little bit and wanting to live uh generously I guess there's a way to put it and sometimes that means charitable or for people who are have uh have needs that aren't met um but part of it is also about my friends and family like I I want to be I want to be someone who can pick up the bill at dinner from time to time and just make everyone at the table a little happier because they don't have to worry about that that type of thing so money has gone up a little bit in that way but in between all that the the the the meta of bringing joy to tip tops worldwide everything below that is I I I'm really trying to make other people around me happy and that's not always a great motivator because I can't really control other people's emotions around me but it is a motivator for better for worse do you think about that uh with yeah what do you think yeah so as you're talking about the generosity thing I think it's a Dave Ramsey quote or he says live like no one else so that you can give like no one else and the idea being you know sacrifice especially early build up your savings build up your Investments build up this life pay off all your debt you know live within your means like we're talking about that way you can get to that place where one a crisis doesn't blow up your whole life right where something bad happens and you're like I don't have any money to pay for this because no you've been planning a hit but also you get to a
place in your life where when someone has a need you can you can help them out right small or large so that's something I also think a lot about it's like I want to get to a place where it's not just about me and mine having enough it's like how can I help other people have enough as well and I think I think we're creativity too though you're also doing that but not necessarily from a money standpoint I think you're already thinking through how can I bring joy to the world you know I think the table is a very sacred place and the more we can bring people to the table to have fun experiences and you know live some life together the better the world gets so you can already be doing that with creative you know things but then also to get to a place where you can do it money as well it's just a beautiful beautiful thing uh let me ask you this though when it comes to monetizing creativity is it easier to become a publisher and do that especially in games it's hard to make money in any aspect but just in general if someone really wants to make a living at this can they do it as just a writer as just a designer as just a creative person or are they going to have to get into the business side of things whether they want to or not because that's just where more money is if you want to make a career out of it I think you almost have to be you have to be the Creator you have to be the publisher I think there are very you mentioned Alan Moon earlier there's Alan moons there's there's a uh I'm like you know the designer pandemic he's done well Natalie yeah uh who in fact I think Matt has actually started a publishing company at this point but for a long time he was just just a designer
um there are outliers I think that can make a career um and uh and a really wildly successful career out of being just a designer um but I think it's pretty rare I think it's pretty rare even for Publishers that try to be generous with their their royalties um you have to sell a lot of games for that and a lot of games on an ongoing basis year to year month a month uh for you to for you to pay those bills a year to year month to month so I think it's pretty rare what do you think yeah I think again over some of that it also depends on the industry you know if you're going to get into writing you know if you're gonna write a book well you might be able to sell 10 million copies potentially you know and all of a sudden you can just sit down and write and let the publisher take care of the marketing and all the the graphic design and the type setting and all that kind of stuff and you just sit down and write at your at your keyboard but yeah if you're in the game Space publishing seems to be the the better option if you want to make a living now a lot of people don't care they want to do their day job they want to have fun you know doing this on the side but for me personally you know I was talking to a publisher this years ago uh about you know I was pitching a game to them and and I asked him I was like well you know if it does work out give me the percentage like what's your normal rate and they said oh we pay six percent I say dang where does the other 94 go you know and then so later on when I got I was like I'm gonna get into the publishing side because I realize the Publisher's not keeping 94 like that's no they're not just being stingy with you know like the margins are crazy and all that but I but I at least want to be the one who determines where the 94 goes
or if I'm designing the game to 100 it's all on me and I want to have the ball in my hands and I want to decide the things I'm going to make a lot of mistakes I'm not really good at a lot of these things I'm gonna have to learn and grow and figure things out and I'm gonna have to find other people to bring on to kind of help fill my gaps and then people who are really good with spreadsheets and really good with Logistics and really good with the math because really I don't know but I was super excited about that and I think that's another thing to think about if you're gonna try to monetize creativity what are you excited about if you're only excited about the creation aspect then maybe stick to that part but if you're also excited about the things you're going to have to learn and the ways you're going to have to grow as a person the skills you're going to have to pick up then maybe it can work out for you to go into the other side of things but I think you just have to assess yourself and I kind of know know who you are but let me ask you if you were to start over today right if you're going to do things you know still my games falls off into the ocean never to be seen again wingspan sales drop to zero you got to start over yeah but I mean how would how would you do it because I mean you already have the skills to be able to do it again you've done it once the evidence is there to say you could do it again why not and so talk to me what would you do especially you know someone listen to this or thinking okay I want to get into this space what should I do how would I do it what would you do if I built something up over yeah I built some of our games up over the last 10 years and uh edit crashed and burned and failed not that it's inherently a failure to build something up and have it have it
slowly die out or suddenly die out you still build something you still hopefully made some people happy along the way um I think I would be I mean honestly I think I would be a little hesitant to jump back in and start something new again right away I think I might I might need to take a break and work for someone else for a while use use one of the skill sets that I've earned from my experience that I've learned and hopefully help out another company with that for a while and I might get that itch later on I definitely have my whole life I've had this entrepreneurial itch I'm very lucky to be able to run my own company but I think it would be it would be tough to immediately jump back into that and I think that would be my my inclination yeah well let me rerun the question of it what if you you bumped yourself in the head you got amnesia still my art games in your mind doesn't exist anymore you're just going to start over yeah it's not that you burned it to the ground you didn't I seriously say a bunch of things online and get canceled nobody wants to buy yourself anymore let's just pretend it's Day Zero you're starting over you know yeah you didn't go through this traumatic experience you're just you're just starting from zero how would you do that okay how would I do that well can I mention I'll mention one thing that I'll do that I would do differently let's tie the money um early on I I was really worried about pretty much every dollar that I was spending on anything on on prototypes on on the ten dollars that would cost to mail a uh a sample to a reviewer every little Cent seemed to be everything because I
didn't know if we would actually sell any copies of the game I didn't know if it would fund on Kickstarter and I had to invest something up front and so I made a good call on a bad call the good call was that I partnered with a friend um my friend Alan was excited to to be a part of that design process that play testing process is really helpful for me to have a friend along the way but because of the money side of things I also wanted a financial partner to help out in the early days um and it wasn't that I didn't have I I had a small amount of savings at that time but I was I was really worried about failing and I was worried about losing the money that I invested so I thought okay if I have another someone else who has some some skin in the game um then it's not only my money that I'm losing I didn't want to lose their money either but basically I brought in an equity partner at a very low level but at the time it seemed like a lot of money talking we're talking hundreds of dollars but it seemed like a lot of money at the time and that really wasn't the right call I learned rather quickly that um this person despite their best intentions what didn't have the passion for it that I did they weren't there to put in the time that I was putting into it uh I think they just saw it as any other investment that they could toss a few bucks at and hopefully get a decent return on it and so I wish I hadn't been so scared of failing financially that I made a dumb decision in terms of equity uh and an equity partnership at the time um so that's something that I would do differently
absolutely would you get it would you do crowdfunding again to get going yeah yeah absolutely if I started here from scratch yeah I would yeah I think the math it just makes too much sense like you just need that big investment if you're going to bring something to Market and the art the graph design everything is expensive things are getting more expensive by the day um and so I think yeah crowdfunding I don't know of very many people who have been able to do it without it I know plathead games they started out not having to need crowdfunding but that was years ago and so I don't know and also I guess from a marketing standpoint crowdfunding campaigns bring in people they they put your stuff out into the world so maybe even if even if you didn't need the money necessarily just the the marketing aspect and just having people talk about your game and getting excited about it and building up a community I think even from that standpoint it makes makes a lot of sense if you're going to start over to start there at the very least it's a huge part of the gaming industry I can't speak as much about other Industries anymore I'm sure there are some that thrive on crowdfunding others that don't but gaming yeah working tabletop gaming uh it's it's been it has long since been legitimized as a a way of bringing something to life that people look to and get excited about so absolutely I would start there but Jimmy let me ask you this kind of Switching gears just a little bit why do you think people should design games right what are the skills that are involving even if you're never going to try to get it published you're not going to try to you know start a business or anything but just the skill set just the everything that goes into creating a game why should
people do that in your mind so when I was a little kid I designed some games just for fun and at the time I thought I was designing games what it meant is that I would I would usually take another game and I would make my version of it and that process in itself was really helpful for me as a kid to put my creativity and and actually put something on the table I wrote little Rule books I I you know had little game components things like that that I drew out um but what I didn't do is I didn't play test I usually with these games I played them one time and I that was that was all they ever got to the table as an adult now that I'm actively playing designing games and developing games I've learned so much about that play testing process that process of um learning constructive feedback from other people and taking that feedback and improving the thing that I'm working on and that skill set I think can be applied to anything putting something out there that You're vulnerable about out there to the world to share with people and taking that feedback and actually making it better going through that process step by step day by day I think is uh it's a it's a universal skill set to have even if nothing else comes in that game yeah I definitely agree the confidence that you have to build up to be able to say hey I made this thing I want you to see it try it out let me know what you think that is not a small thing to overcome you know and there's so many people that are afraid of like public speaking and they're afraid to like put themselves in front of other people and I feel like game design because of the play testing process really does that and then also I
think the process of creating a game is has so much problem solving built in that's why I love that you were doing it as a child because I feel like as a kid you're having to develop all these things that are like problem solving this doesn't work how how do I make it work this is a broken mechanism whatever how do I fix it and I feel like that's maybe the best life skill you can learn is problem solving so do you agree is is that something else you you've kind of thought about yeah absolutely and that's why I go back to that story where I I wish as a kid I had actually played it more than once because I could have developed some of the skill sets of because a lot of the the reason that I didn't go any further is that I had put it on the table and it wouldn't work all that well at all and I'd be so discouraged that I just move on to something else I designed something now starting to play outside and I wish I had played it at least one more time taking that feedback and played it one more time because you read it it's an amazing interface for problem solving yeah definitely and then also just to be able to scratch that creative itch I feel like humans in general are creative I feel like that's just part of how we work and even if like you're an accountant and all you do is numbers all day long I feel like there's still like a seed of creativity in in you because I've never met a non-creative child I know like I've worked with kids I've worked with kids in an orphanage going through like terrible trauma like very difficult situations even they in all their crazy you know the crazy of their life the chaos of their lives were hyper creative they wanted to draw they wanted the color they wanted to come up with stories they wanted to make up their own games but somewhere along the way that falls off and I don't think it's
because we you know grow out of it I think I think life maybe pulls it from us maybe the way we do school maybe the way you know we kind of build relationships and we're afraid to like like you're saying be vulnerable and put ourselves out there we're afraid to be rejected or discouraged and so I think the creativity in US is killed not that it you know just doesn't exist anymore uh and so man what are your what are your thoughts on that as far as like creativity and people in gym I was thinking about this the other day because I was at a game day and a friend brought their kid and um the four little four-year-old kid was just having a ball by himself building like a magnet block structure and he was telling a story while he was doing it he was just off in his own little world I could I could hear him because I I was playing a game on a kind of nearby and and it made me so happy that he was so freely creating this thing that where this there were no Stakes at all like he wasn't thinking about if he had enough time to finish the story or he was thinking about his family he wasn't thinking about if he could monetize this story or this structure that he was making he was completely free in that creativity and we've talked a lot today about monetization and I think it's absolutely important to think about those things if you are trying to make a career out of uh out of game design but uh you also mentioned the idea that sometimes you can just have a hobby for the sake of having a hobby for the sake of creation and I think a lot of great things can come from that a lot of creative ideas and solutions can come from not having the burden of monetization sometimes and not having
the burden of paying the bills based on this thing that you're creating and I think that's how sometimes I I want to be able to tap into that inner child a little bit more with those types of projects and maybe give myself permission to to make something not for publication but just for the sake of creating it yeah absolutely I agree I love that I think that's a good place to end our conversation but Debbie where can people find you you got any projects you want to talk about or you know tell people to where they can find you online yeah the the hub for everything that that we make I'm lucky I'm wearing the shirt today is it stillmirergames.com um where I have a Blog about crowdfunding and Entrepreneurship I also have a game design YouTube channel right I share games that I enjoy and the uh the mechanisms that I that I've learned from them and I have Instagram social media all those things the best way whatever's the best for for someone watching this um that they want to stay connected we have it on our website awesome well Jamie really appreciate your time thanks for being here thanks again