Assault on Doomrock: Discussion
Transcript
Some viewers may find the following video disturbing. Viewer discretion is advised.
Hey everyone, welcome back to Board Games Unlocked and today I'm doing a discussion over Assault on Doom Rock the ultimate edition. Now I've actually covered this game relatively recently. It's probably been over a year at this point and at that time I was actually kind of singing its praise. There was a lot of the in the game that I had had a lot of good things to say. I have no more good things to say about this game. I that is mainly because the last time that I played this was such a cluster [ __ ] I don't even know if the at the time I reviewed this if we were playing it correctly cuz I don't think we were cuz we were having fun. And if you play this game correctly, you're not having fun.
It is it This is random the game um and man I just don't know what it was about the the first time I had covered this game to now cuz I remember the first iteration of this I did not like. And I wanted to give it another shot when I got the ultimate edition and then I liked it. And then I played it again and now I really don't like it. I did a video covering the games that we played on this trip instead going to Gen Con and in that video I talked about how everyone's least favorite game of that trip was this one. And I had high hopes cuz before we were playing it I was telling them, "Hey, it's a rogue like as a board game that does it really well."
No. No, I mean it does do the roguelike elements uh correctly. The problem with the game comes down to the fact that it is so incredibly unbalanced of an experience that researching this game and what other people are saying is, "Oh, haha, no, it's a brutal game. It's not about winning, it's about playing." And to some extent, sure, you could you could say that. It's about roguelikes are about the build, but the point of roguelikes is to get a good build to then beat the game. And no good roguelike is designed to be impossibly difficult so that you never beat it.
That's why they have different challenges for Dead Cells, Hades. All these games have a or Slay the Spire, Ascension, I I think cells are what they're called in uh Dead Cells, heat. All those games have a system designed for them to increase the difficulty for when you are naturally beating the core game. This game has none of that. It's basically max heat the entire time. Um and to make things worse with this game is its rulebook is so incredibly bad that you even if you have questions or need clarification, it is not there. They There's just nothing The rulebook might as well be blank and say, "Figure it out."
So, let's go with the positives cuz I have more negatives about this game. The positives are that there are a lot of There's a lot of [ __ ] in this game. And with all the different abilities, as far as I can tell, there's and I mean, with this many, I'd be surprised. Actually, let me double-check. Now, um I think there are any duplicates. And that's the cool part of this game. This game does have a lot of build variety. Just for starters, whenever you are setting up your character, you are given a class. So, hey, I'm going to be the fairy. And then you're given a kind of like an adjective. I'm going to be the flying fairy. And that will determine an initial ability that you have and you know what class you are.
And that's already cool cuz these are pretty comedic. You can be the the overly heroic fairy. You can be the sadistic fairy. You can be the oiled fairy. Mm. And over the course of the game what you're going to be doing is you're going to be visiting various locations. You essentially will create a deck, a journey deck, out of these locations to go and investigate to get more loot. And you have two types of loot. You have your commons and you have your rares. Uh and there's a ton of items in this game. That's one of its biggest, probably its its only redeeming quality is all of these. This entire stack right here, these are the common items. And then you have this stack right here of the ep- I think epic of the epic items. And they have attributes that you need. So, to get the snake shot crossbow, you need two agility and one intelligence. And how do you get that? Well, this massive stack Now, not all of these are are abilities.
This massive stack right here these are all the abilities that you can get and they will give you attributes and different actions that you can take. Um and then while you're investigating, you can have uh what are these? These are the events. Uh you can draw you can draw events and there's this massive stack of events and then you can come across secret locations. There's not that many but these don't come up all that often so it's a lot for when they do. So this gives you a a dramatically different build every time you're playing and everyone is is building into something different.
The problem with this is it's just pure it's just pure randomness. I would I guess chaos is also the thing but you have no control over the type of build you're getting. In a rogue-like setting, you are given yeah, random boons or random attributes or random something but eventually seeds itself in a way that you can kind of manipulate and get something going. Uh you and sometimes you have some control over that. If you take Hades for example, you can put on a trinket that makes the first god boon you find. If I put on the Zeus trinket, it's going to be a Zeus boon that I'm going for. And all of those are are built in a different type of play style. Here, it's up okay, getting a new we leveled up time to draw certain one of these and oh do we want heroic wave, use the force or whoosh? And you'll just pick one of those to give to someone.
Usually it's actually the lowest level character who is getting to pick it. And but it's still fun. It's just see what you get and and then just hope that it kind of has some synergy and that can happen and it and it is cool. The main issue of having all this stuff is that it ultimately means nothing when you get into the actual combat because the journey phase is actually kind of fun. You have various locations you're going to go to and see what happens and then your next after you beat if you if you beat the enemy, you kind of keep track trucking on towards Doom Rock, which is your ultimate goal is to get to Doom Rock. But the way that this game handles its combat is unique. I'll give them that, but it it is just it feels like the most low effort way to design combat in a game I've ever seen. You could actually just roll dice and even odds determines if you win or lose would be more effort than what this is.
So, combat is there's three acts over the course of a game. Not counting the wolves, which is your tutorial. You will randomly shuffle the act one and put that away and you can figure out what it is, but let's say it's against the shadows. Well, depending on number of players, we'll say three, there's going to be four chip stacks of of enemies. They have eight health and they start with two shield. On the back, well, in this case the shadows actually don't have any armor. This game for some reason decided to use shields and armor as two different things because there's a lot of ways to bypass armor, there's nothing to bypass shields. So, if there's ways for them to stack armor or stack shields, oh well, you just got to kind of kind of got to chip through it.
And whenever it is their turn to go, you have a deck of Oh, in this case you will see this as with a two, three, ace, joker, and in the three player game another two. And you'll shuffle those cards and then you'll draw them, and whichever one you draw is the action that they are taking. Now, feel free to correct me in the comments. I would love to be wrong about this. But, from what I have gleaned, they will do if you draw a two, they will do everything that the two says, and one person will pick one to activate, and then they'll do that. So, they will, unless they're surrounded, move to an empty group, which in this case, again, combat is your either in a group or you're not. There's no movement, there's no tactical whatever, all that out the [ __ ] window. You will either move away or move to something.
Um they will then deal two damage uh to the primary target, plus one if the target has no uh uh what is it? Heroism. So, it'll be three that you might do. You only have six health. So, in one use, one enemy will uh will just rip through half your health, and there's basically, unless you got really lucky, there's no way to heal. So, you have six health, they all have eight eight health. And uh not only that, so that's actually a relatively simple one. Okay, they'll just do an attack. Neat. Okay, but then if it's an A, which yeah, there's only one in in the deck, unless it's engaged with someone, it will move to the primary target, then it will remove a heroism from the primary target, then it will deal two damage to the primary target. Now, again, what you could interpret is it will do the first thing available. I would again, let me know in the comments, and uh I'll probably if you tell me that the way I initially thought it worked is how it actually works, I'll probably just delete this video. But, to my understanding, it will do everything that the card says. So, but the way it could be interpreted is it will do the first eligible thing. So, if it's if it's not engaged, it will move to the primary target. Done. Boom, that's manageable. You can actually survive that. But, if it's A and the one you picked is engaged, then it will remove a heroism from you.
And then let's say A happens again and it's not or it is engaged and there's no heroism to remove, then it'll deal two damage. That's how it should work. As far as everything I have read in that rulebook, it will literally do all that all those things. And it's just they you have to get insanely lucky with your items and your abilities to be able to manage that. Oh, and also for the record, you can't even attack the shadows unless you're in the same group as them. And they have a stealth ability that says, "Gain one heroism and deal two two shields to yourself. You can ignore the stride of darkness for your next attack." So, if you are able to have if you have a stealth icon, then you are able to do this ability. The problem is you do not gain a stealth icon unless you have a way to gain a stealth icon either through an ability or through the journeys. And there are so many enemies that have busted abilities that unless you just locked into a specific weapon or token, you just cannot win.
And that is terrible terrible game design. Um it's funny when we were playing this my friend while we were playing, he's like, "Oh, yeah, they don't have to balance it if they say it's a roguelike." And yeah, that's 100% true. You make a you don't put in any effort to try and balance all these items. You just threw [ __ ] into a box and it's like, "It's a roguelike." So, yeah, you have to random You have to get the random build to go your way. And if all that wasn't enough, let's say you could de-manage the shields, or you could get a stealth icon to be able to manage This is just an Act One boss, by the way. You still have to rely on luck of the dice.
So, to activate any of these icon or uh abilities you have to roll specific numbers. So, I mean, just to add insult to injury, you know how I mentioned that you are either in a group or you're not, uh and even to attack the shadows of a level one Act One boss, you have to be in the same group, otherwise you can't. You have no natural actions. All your actions come from die rolls, and everyone has the same action. It's maneuver. It's a way you can move. You have to roll a three to do so. If you don't roll a three, and you are given uh two reroll opportunities. So, first of all, those cute little adjective abilities that I was talking about, you know, where you could be oiled or stanky or naked or whatever, uh you take a damage if there's not a die on these.
So, not only And I mean, these can use any die. But, not only do you have to use one of your dice to put on there, otherwise you'll take a damage. To even move, which I mean, what is moving really in this game? But, to even go next to an enemy to potentially attack them, you have to roll a certain result. That's worse than roll to move. Roll to move is at least I get to do something. Yeah, I might move one space or six spaces, but at least I get to go in the direction of where I want to. This game has the potential of you never moving. Um, and then let's say you do get to move, but you didn't roll, you know, a five to do your sparks or a one to do your parry or a six to do your shock or a six to do your ghostly strike, you just don't get to do anything.
Uh, and it is it's just atrocious, honestly. It is it is laughably bad game design. Uh, that I don't know. I must have been smoking that night or or on heroin or doing something to think that this game was fun. I'm I'm almost convinced we just were playing random [ __ ] or we weren't actually playing this and we reviewed some other random game. Because yeah, the way that the enemies function where they just swarm you and just completely riddle you unless you have a way to give yourself shield, uh, not only if you even have a chance to beat them, you have to roll well. That is is so, oh my god, it's so [ __ ] bad.
Um, and even if the enemies didn't do everything on what their card says, uh, you still have to be able to roll to deal damage to them. And that's in the act one. Uh, whenever we were playing, which we were playing incorrectly, uh, as we as we figured out. So, we made it to act three and one of them, there it is, the iron maidens. So, six health, two shield, that's what they all start with, and they start with an rage. But, they have armor. So, they have six health and one armor, but here's what they do. They essentially can snare you, which means you just don't get to move on your own, so someone else has to have ways to move you, but they will um enrage is is a keyword that will tick up, and so they'll deal enrage damage.
So, if the Joker, for example, and this is what actually made me realize, oh, we might not be doing this right, is because the top their two is if they're not engaged, they'll move to the hero with the most shields. Then they'll deal two damage to an adjacent hero. If no hero has snare, they'll they'll then snare them. If no snare was dealt in this activation, and draw new activation card. Oh, and then they gain uh four shield. Four, not armor, four shield. So, those have different steps on what they're do, but the reason that I thought, oh, wait, maybe they do the whole thing, cuz we were playing it as if they would do the first eligible one, is their Joker. Their Joker says deal enrage damage to a target. But then the bottom says gain three, four, or five shield.
And I was thinking, well, wait a minute. The top effect is something they would always be able to do, it's just dealing rage damage to someone on the map. So then, if if they're always able to do that, then when would they not be able to, and then they'd have to resort to gaining shield? Oh, that's because they'll always do this, no matter what. So, you'd have to just have some OP shield obliterater uh uh build going on to even have a chance. And the fact that they snare you, and then while they're snared, they deal a [ __ ] ton of damage to you, cuz it's Iron Maiden, and then you're trapped in there, and you're getting pierced. It's it is so believably unbelievably busted that it's not even, hey, this is chaos, have fun.
Uh it's this is, hey, this is chaos. Uh you wasted your money. Um, so it's it's just it's just so so atrocious. Uh, and I don't know. I I've heard uh, that the terrain expansion uh, or [snorts] that actually having terrains cuz you have terrains on the map and they you can go and activate them and that has helped because it gives people natural ways to move, uh, which is huge so you don't have to waste a die on as a three or hope you roll a three to then move. You can allocate your resource elsewhere. Uh, and there's a world where this game can be fun.
I mean, there was some world uh, maybe a year ago where I thought this was fun because I was having fun. But, this last time playing it was oh god, it was so so bad.
[snorts]
Um, yeah. I mean, and I don't really hate the way you level up. It's money. That's kind of the only thing you spend money. I mean, you spend a little bit on shops, but typically you need depending on you know, what you're leveling to. So, if you're leveling to level four cost four money and you're always leveling the lowest uh, player. So, it uh, yeah, it is just an abysmal experience. Which somehow they're I think he's doing or he was supposed to be doing a new expansion to it. It'd be cool if it was the balance expansion where he actually put effort into it and made it made it manageable and fun in some way, but uh, I don't think it's that. I think it's literally just more content. So, double the stack of of these. And hell, I even found some of the some of the adjectives that you can get are kind of the overpowered ones. The one I had was what burning aura or something where it just dealt damage to everyone that was adjacent to you. So I had a pretty cool priority target build where I pop priority target stack stack a bunch of shields on me so that they'd all swarm to me and deal no damage to me and then they would all just take burn damage on my turn.
And I'm not saying you can't get cool things like that. You can get cool builds. The issue is this game lasts way too long for this kind of randomness to be any sense of fun. Um So so yeah, I I don't know. I think I think this game has something going for it. There like I said, there is a world where this this many I this stuff is cool and the the items are neat. You know, a pyro pyromaniac's kit. It's a consumable. Deal two damage to yourself and each adjacent character ignoring two armor. Okay. Deal two damage to one of the targets before the attack. A plate curiass. You may ignore this item's requirements, but during the roll phase gain one damage for each missing strength required to equip this item and you can use it to gain a shield. And these are all just the common items. So then you go to the epic items.
Wand of disintegration. Use with a magic attack to ignore one armor. Use with a magic attack ability. That ability becomes initiative enabled. Who who knows what that means. Mask of Horn of Courage. Adjacent heroes ignore engaged and surrounded restrictions on their abilities. You can use it and adjacent hero gains a heroism. Boxed basilisk. Deal one damage to each adjacent character. I mean you and you can stack I mean you can have a million items. They do have hand you can have what is it? It is Uh there's like an item chest and two-hand. So, you can't have a million items, but you can swap them in and out uh cuz you could search and see what you're fighting and then you could look and see, "Oh, we're fighting this character. Let's try and move some stuff around."
Uh the I mean, these are all the different events that you can that you can have. But so, there is the bones of this game are here and it could be a serviceable roguelike. I think the biggest issue is its combat, which I don't even hate the the combat of you know, move, you know, you're you're either engaged or not engaged. It's meant to be snappy, quick combat of just taking chips like chip theory and that's their health. The problem is unless the enemies are meant to be you know, they're they're just too too busted and you don't get busted enough to overcome that.
Uh and yeah, God forbid any of the Act 3 ones. I I just I don't know. And then the rulebook. The rulebook needs a complete overhaul to be it needs to be written by someone who is a professional rulebook writer. But uh yeah, cuz I want to like this game. I want to I want to go back to the me that did like it before I became aware of what was happening. The locations are fun to go to. There's a good chunk of them. Uh I mean, cuz there's three types. These are towns, these are these are mountains and then these are forests and then you have a very a few that are actually Doom Rock. I think it's four. Yeah, these are the different Doom Rock ones.
Uh so, you you're going to get a different variety of that and the time system when you're in the journey phase of that, dictates whenever you're going into your fight. I like that. But, yeah, it's just uh it's just an unfortunate experience, I think. So, uh I mean, on a scale of 1 to 10, Assault on Doomrock, I'm going to have to give a four. I think it is a below-average game. It's not even one that I think, unless someone in the comments tells me otherwise, uh I don't think it's one I'm going to be keeping in my collection because I don't want to struggle through the rulebook and the random [ __ ] that this game provides. So, that's it, everyone. That's my thoughts on Assault on Doomrock. Let me know what you think of the game in the comments below. Other than that, like, comment, share, and subscribe, and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you.