Ask The Chairman - Board Games Q&A 4
Transcript
hey everybody and welcome to another episode of ask the chairman this is a board game related q and a session where you can ask me anything you like now as always thank you to everybody who submitted questions on the last video and if you want to keep the series going then please be sure to leave your questions below this video and I'll answer them on the next episode before I get started on the questions I want to give a shout out to the show's sponsor keyienda dot Co dot UK who are my go to online retailer and if you use the link in my show notes or the QR code then you can get five percent off your first order but let's get cracking because we have quite a few questions here to get through first off frog on boards has asked do you enjoy playing co-op games now generally speaking I haven't played too many cops and what I have I have enjoyed the lighter variety and also more party driven co-op games and there's not that many more involved co-ops that I tend to really enjoy um you know I've had my fun with games like pandemic but I'm kind of over it now and I tend to lean towards more competitive games uh he's also asked which medium medium weight co-ops would you recommend again there aren't too many I I enjoy um most of them are of the party type and just a few examples here the kind of co-op games that I do like um I like games like letter Jam Co-op word game
um just one there's a game called lock that I've really enjoyed recently another party one maybe the heaviest of the bunch is one called switch and Signal which is a kind of a logistics train game that is purely Cooperative that's one that I did enjoy quite a bit add back to the party variety um crossed Clues is um one that I really like as well um so thank you for the questions that frog on boards um your life has asked what are some good games to start a games night with friends who don't usually like board games and he's put a player range of six to ten players now I have written a few examples here and there are tons of games that actually fit that bracket but again you're gonna have to lean towards that kind of lighter party style of game so skull is a really good kind of bluffing game really good for non-gamers I get just one for a second mention spicy another nice bluffing card shedding game if you like social deduction games the resistance Avalon is a great one to cater to to those Higher Play accounts I'm sure of Nottingham see a lot of bluffing games here and for more trivia star games at wits and wages is a fantastic one where you can actually bet on other players answers so you don't actually need to be too good at general knowledge yourself to still get a lot out of this one no thanks is a great card game six nymphed a detective Club um also when I dream I put Dixit on here
and also telestrations so generally a bunch of very accessible party weight games there for you to have a look at if um if you want some options there so thank you for your question John has asked do I still play a legendary Marvel no I don't I'm John I actually sold my copy maybe a couple of years ago now the main reason I sold it was because it was so bloated you know I did fall into the Trap of buying all of the expansion material and it became so unwieldy that it did not get played anymore um he's also asked do I still feel like the mechanisms in legendary Marvel still hold up to other deck building games and I think they absolutely do yeah there's a ton of keywords there loads of variety some cool synergizing mechanisms in legendary and I think it's a very solid uh game and probably still in the top two or three deck builders that I've played so I think probably my favorite deck builder at the moment is you know in a more traditional Center for deck builder something like the Quest for El Dorado canizio racing game it's a bit more simplistic for me and more self-contained which is what I want from deck builders nowadays so you know I like the idea of deck builders but I generally find them a bit too a bit too much to sort through and it becomes a bit a bit of an obstacle to get it to the table for me but as an isolated game I think legendary is still very good and it's obviously got a certain degree of quality because they keep bringing out
material for it and it's probably one of the most expanded games um out there but thank you for your questions uh John Tony has asked how has my taste in board games evolved over time so I would say that I have my tastes have evolved quite significantly so naturally when you get into the hobby you kind of um start to explore the Heavy Hitters the more popular games so I started off with legendary actually then I went into games like a on games like Patchwork um or tons of them out there even games like dead of winter which I wouldn't play nowadays um and then I recall playing my first Euro game which was actually sulk in the Mayan calendar at a friend's house and that really got me diving into the Euro game Space and I think the more you start really kind of um engrossing yourself into the hobby you lean heavier and heavier and heavier to try and test where your limits are and for me at that point kind of the more the better you know I liked every rule Under the Sun in a board game so I was playing games like you know Through the Ages I was playing very heavy style euros and then I started realizing that these games are quite difficult to get to the table so I started to appreciate more kind of refined games from you know 20 25 years ago maybe 15 to 25 years ago um where it was kind of the forefathers of the Euro genre there's more kind of
beige era games games like you know ra um games like the starry Series against like algorande and those kind of more pure simplistic style Euros was still a ton of depth those are the games that I'm ready to start to enjoy more and appreciate more and that's kind of where I'm at now now I I also started to appreciate kind of um distinct things in games so games that made certain titles stand out on their own because of course there are so many games out there you like to have games with their own identity to find their own place on your shelf so I kind of started to appreciate like simple card games with clever mechanisms in and more and more um or something that's becoming more apparent to me and probably one of the strongest metrics to me now is something that I can get to the table without having to completely relearn the games if I can just skim through a rule book and just pick up on a few a few of the um key points and then memorize the game that for me is a huge Advantage so even though there's tons of break heavy Euro games out there that I would still recommend my taste of change to games that I can pull off the shelf and get played pretty quickly and without too much pre-work to be put in so I hope that kind of explains where I'm at now um kind of like more pure and simple games but still with that depth of decisions rather than having every mechanism under the sun which is probably where I was at maybe two years ago
um Tony has also asked what was a recent news spin on a mechanism that I thought was clever there are so many but I've written a few Downs here on some semi-recent games um the oldest of these games I've written is probably uh the bidding mechanism from need of Alia I thought that was very clever where you're using these fixed tokens to acquire cards but the tokens that you didn't use are kind of multiplied with each other and we'll give you a um a stronger token to use in the future so kind of a short time sacrifice for a long term gain that was very clever I like the worker system In Darwin's Journey where you are building up they're certain skills to make them more appropriate for certain spots on the board that was very cool as well and even something as simple as the telem dice grafting system where the action or strength of the action will be on one side of the dice or the die and sorry the resources you'll get from the um die would be on one side and the strength of the action would be on the other so if you're taking say five resources you'd get a strength two action if you're taking six resources you've got a string from one action very simple but very pure and it just works fantastically so there's a few examples for you there it's asked if there are any one-term words or one word terms that would turn me off again um I thought again I thought of a few here terms such as story um campaign that Legacy so all kind of the same things there I like Standalone games um thematic I'm not a theme person I'm a
mechanisms man so normally when terms like thematica used I think it's going to be a bunch of flavor texts and weak mechanisms I could be wrong there but that's how I feel uh Miniatures not interested and also space so I generally don't like sci-fi sci-fi themes at least it's not my preference but those are just things that would would turn me off I'm not saying they're deal breakers but they would type certainly turn me off and in um in contrast to that he's asked are there any one-time words that would turn you on a game uh yes economic Euro of course I I've even put in a few designers names here like kinesia um Feld um so yeah you could probably you know if you know the kind of games I liked you'd know what things I'm looking for but there's a few examples and some great questions there so thank you very much Tony uh Diamond meeple has asked do I find abstracts dry due to the little to no randomness I don't know if jirai is the right word but I I kind of have a certain perception of a certain type of abstract game when there's absolutely zero luck I find that I stress a lot over not making mistakes you know I I find me thinking about not making mistakes a lot less fun than me just going to my gut and just trying to have fun and enjoy the process and I also feel like those kind of abstract games I don't really feel good winning because it makes the opponent feel so bad losing and vice versa because you feel like a
bit of a sucker if you lose at them so I wouldn't say dry is the right word but I don't normally extract a whole lot of fun from those perfect information style games now there are exceptions to that but that's maybe uh maybe my my mind is changing on that but that's how I've always felt about those pure abstract strategy games um over the years and to follow one from that he's asked um am I transcending into games requiring more skill and agency um I certainly don't think so um you know as I was saying those really heavy games I was playing a few years ago that's pretty much little luck in those it's definitely loads of agency loads of skill and I've kind of filtered away from that a little bit but my general appreciation for more abstract style games has um increased recently I've covered games such as a chin and Arcadia a samurai War chest these are all pretty low luck games that I think are amazing and I've enjoyed them hugely so in that respect my appreciation of abstract games has gone up but in the same vein I've enjoyed a ton of games that are very luck dependent you know games such as the number um Rapido um even spicy you know these bluffing games I love all games like that so I'm definitely on both sides of the spectrum I like skill games I like to like games so I don't think I lean either you know one particular way but thank you very much for the questions um Matt has asked what game have I found
the most difficult to teach so I tried to steer away from those heavy heavy Euro games because naturally they're going to be very difficult to teach because of the sheer amount of rules but these are a couple of games that despite being simple I found communicating the rule was pretty difficult because they're not the most intuitive um I think that's probably the right word and the key example of this I always give is Tigris and Euphrates so a connection classic basically an abstract game but it's a tile placement game as you're trying to compete over majorities basically and start generating ticking points to get points um the game is so difficult to explain because there's two different styles of combat um which almost work the same but work differently the combat is strange the way it resolves and it's just quite a it's just quite a hard game to process and internalize and I think after you learn it you need to kind of play it again and again for it to really sink in and I'd always kind of leave it a long gap between I played it before the last time I know it well the gaps between each player will be bigger and bigger and they're going to seems like we're learning the game again and it just it's just a very hard game to communicate I think and I always get tons of questions asked people scratching their heads about how this works even though there's not that many rules so that's a very difficult game to teach in my opinion and I think I'm good at teaching the game as well so yeah that goes to show
it's not the easiest game to grock another game which is actually a party game which is probably the thing that throws people off or maybe off center with this one is the crypto so the crypto is a fantastic kind of team versus Team pass the game that really blew up at the time where code names was huge I think this game is much better than code names but it is so difficult to teach the way the game works without actually playing it because it's a game that you're just going to fall into mistakes or making and it's it's just tricky to understand because it's again it doesn't flow so naturally but gameplay itself is so simple but you do need to play it rather than explaining it and if you played the crypto you will understand at what I mean so that is um a couple of examples there and another bunch of games I always find are difficult to teach are social deduction games because people are so scared of making mistakes um remembering all the different roles and how they interact with each other they're more games that you need to learn by playing I think and just front loading the rules is always so jarring so um that's um I hope that answers your question uh Matt thank you t-ball has asked what game would I bet on myself to win so great question um and I kind of used data that you know my winning percentages are really high on um I don't think I'm particularly great at these games but I suppose I'm in a position where I don't make too many mistakes um so maybe that's you know that gives me a good footing and
some games here are mandala I think I play mandala quite a few times I've only lost once I think um and again it's not a it's not a massively skillful game but I just tend to not make too many glowing errors or glowing errors El Grande is you know my favorite game of all time I've had tons of close games of it and generally I do quite well so I like my odds on that one again I don't always win but I'm good at it raw is the same vein I played raw quite a lot got tons of black in the game but I tend to know how to hedge my bets and know when to make the right decisions uh Cryptid which is um kind of a pure deduction game I'm not generally that good at production games but my winning percentage on crypto I think is perfect I don't think I've ever lost prepaid weirdly um Hannah makoji is a game I got very good at after a while my skills have definitely um decreased and diminished since then but I could probably get them back up Patchwork um and wits and wages you know my general knowledge is generally pretty good and my winning rate with um with wits and wages is pretty good as well so there are a few examples there but thank you for the question t-ball that's a really interesting one a Brett has asked are board games getting too expensive this is a mixed bag I think at a face value maybe they are because you know you can buy a deck of cards now it's going to cost you 20 quid but you've got to understand that that's not just the raw materials it's also the development work the artwork all this stuff so I can
understand how it does start to mount up but and it's a maybe a bit of a stereotype or a bit of um a bit of a thing that people lean on is that comparing it to different medium it's probably not too expensive because you can play the same board game 10 times if it costs you 40 pounds that's four pounder play that's like four pound for a couple of hours entertainment so in that in that respect it's pretty cheap but as you start obviously building a huge collection maybe the value isn't so good but it depends you know sometimes you can get a relatively cheap game like for example where I've got um Acropolis there it costs about 20 pounds I played it to death and I still love it we'll play it loads more in the same vein I've bought games that are 100 pounds and I played them twice before selling them so again we are there's a big um scoping difference there I think sometimes you get Great Value just through the amount of enjoyment you get from it sometimes not great value if you're going to play a game a couple of times it just depends and although it's expensive I think the good thing about this hobby is that a lot of the games hold their value so even though that has a high upfront cost you can normally recuperate a big percentage of your money back and invest in new games in the future so I think once you've got that ball rolling it's quite manageable but but yeah of course things are going up they're getting more and more expensive and sadly that's just a sign of the times we're in uh Mr J Marzetti has asked what game would I like to see a reprinted
so I've got I've done this through an unselfish means so these are games I think I'd love to sit out there um just so other people could play them um games like Vikings um I think is needs to be reprinted it's one of the best kind of medium lightweight top placement family games out there a spectacular game there's nothing wrong with it just hit the print button and get it out there again and also chin which is why I mentioned earlier simple abstract game very difficult to get hold of and it's just absolutely brilliant at Evergreen for sure I suppose a lot of the games that um I wanted to see reprinted have been reprinted you know games like Bruges was reprinted recently at shipyard's being reprinted Calamar is being reprinted so there's definitely going to be a lot more um I think it's gonna be fewer games out there that need that reprint button because you know people are struggling for ideas and they're going back to the old ones and getting them back out there you know even El Grande is being reprinted so um you know everything is coming back is also asked what is my Grail game so if you don't know what that means it basically means a game that I'm kind of hunting high and low for to find a copy because they're very rare and hard to get hold of um I would say my girl game is a game called witness which is an older game actually one that um it's kind of like a deduction murder mystery game as you're whispering in each other's ears and everybody gets a different piece of the information I've wanted to play that one for such a long time since I've gotten into the hobby that I just cannot find a copy anywhere so um hopefully one time one day I will
get a copy of it and most games I've previously had on my grill games list I've managed to get a hold of now I'm gonna go Bora Bora was a girl game for me for a long time and I managed to get a copy um if St Petersburg was a girl game for me I managed to get a copy so no fingers crossed I'll get a copy of this one as well so let's move on to the final sheet of questions here then um I think this is still the same yeah this is still Mr Marzetti he's asked what who are my favorite board game uh content creators generally speaking I don't consume too much more game racing content because I prefer to create rather than to consume um and I trust my own opinion more than anybody else's but there are a few that I do enjoy front number one Luke uh Hector from the broken meeple I think he's a very just a unique voice out there we have very different tastes in games but I appreciate his authenticity which I think is um the most important currency we have especially on you know YouTube and stuff like that um you cannot you can't make up for that and you whatever you think of his content you cannot deny that he is telling the truth at least his you know in his own opinion he's not sure if you go to anything and I like that about him so yeah I watch his stuff even though I don't necessarily like the same games as he does because I think he has um I think he's a credible source and Mackenzie Franklin from side game NLC you know he is a yeah we are friends he comes on my channel we do content together I think he's very articulate
very knowledgeable um and he can he can explain games so well I mean he is he's I think it's a specialty he's a teacher so he's good at that kind of stuff um again very positive but still he can critique things very articularly and he means what he says and says what he means um despite having a positive polish on things so I think he's massively underrated and he should be it should be one of the biggest YouTubers and some other ones I really like are takai Joe so Tia I think she's called um she she and I have very similar tastes in games actually and she's not scared to tell the truth she doesn't like a game she'll tell you but still she's very Charming um get great takes on games and yeah I think she's fantastic at what she does um so the podcast I did used to like that don't make content anymore at least not as they did was uh a a podcast called back of the Shelf now these are friends they have great chemistry a really good fun podcasts and to be honest the board gaming was kind of a side part from their chemistry they're so so interesting and fun to listen to and they just talked about old board games games that they've played tons of times and they wouldn't really care about all the new hotness and stuff they've just talk about the games that they loved and I really thought they had a great thing going but I think they've stopped what they were doing which is a bit of a shame and I suppose one of the long-term podcasts that I've dipped in and out of was board game barrage which I think are one of the biggest ones at the moment
um I know that one of the most successful podcasts out there I think they're great they're really good at what they do and again despite their popularity they've never really give me any science to doubt their credibility either if they get given review copies they won't give they won't give a damn saying that this game is rubbish and I like I like that about them and again they've got great chemistry which is a huge thing very authentic people so yeah there's a few examples there um but that's pretty much my scope of what I listen to or what I consume because I'm making my own stuff and I make my own opinions um he's also asked what is my player color what player color do I choose and if I can I'll always choose yellow if yellow isn't an option I'll choose the next brightest color so normally orange or white and that's because I am severely color blind and I'd like to choose the brightest color on the board so I know who's me that's pretty much the logic behind that but thank you for your questions uh and finally Keith has asked how much time do I spend searching for games to add to my collection and how do I do it I don't actively spend time spend time searching through content and trying to pick out games I might be interested in it just kind of passively happens maybe if I'm browsing Board Game Geek something the hotness will pop up that will catch my attention or maybe a geek list about what's coming out at Essen or Gen Con and that might get my attention as well go through designers back catalogs of games you know if if I know I find a new designer that I like I'll go try it all
games out and see if they're as good as the other stuff he's putting out and of course recommendations from you guys as well you know loads of my games in my collection have come from direct recommendations from my viewers because they know the kind of games that I enjoy and more often than not they they land for me so that's generally how I um how I find the games that I that I add to my collection um he's asked what commonly gets my interest when it comes to um the board games I I assume it means what kind of elements you know what common things do I look for I suppose um I've put here something unique you know as I said there's so much repetition in the board game genre at the moment so if you interviewed something unique I will at least check it out I might not like it but I at least appreciate you are trying um something different I don't like certain visuals you know I tend to like my beige style games I like medieval style games like kind of age of Discovery style games those just I don't know they just feel comfortable to me I like those that visuals and the games that are normally wrapped up in that skin are what I look for so those are just a few things there and if you find a question or questions uh what games have I took a chance on and either liked or disliked um so I'll start off with the light so and one of his brand new actually recently I've added to my collection which is war chest I wasn't sure how this one's gonna add to me land for me because again it is very abstract um and I did have those concerns which I
mentioned earlier about being too jarring a bit too transparent um but absolutely hit a perfect chord for me I think this game is amazing and I'm kind of annoyed that I didn't try it earlier um games like barrage which is actually a top five game for me I was somewhat concerned about that one despite loving the designer loving the idea of it um I thought it was going to be a bit be a bit too mean a bit too Cutthroat for me not the case at all I think the game is amazing um and a strange one now that sounds it sounds weird saying it because I like it so much and I've liked it for so long I took a chance on Seven Wonders Jewel so I actually wasn't a huge fan of the original Seven Wonders but I had so many good things about seven wonders Jewel picked it up and I think it's an absolute classic you know why didn't I try this one earlier it is amazing so those are a few examples there of games that I took a chance on but I liked sounds silly now because they are all amazing in some of my favorite games but some of the ones I disliked are Dark Ages was a huge kind of a sieve game with miniatures by Borden dice maybe in retrospect I should have known that I wouldn't like it but it just had a bit too much going on it was too slow but I wanted to like it and I was looking forward to it so much because I love that Dark Age setting and I like that idea of kind of dudes on the map game with some um infrastructure buildings some sieved stuff going on technology trees it sounded great to me but it didn't land it was just too slow um a quart of the Dead was one as well
could have an area control game with some communal things going on some card drafting amazing visuals I kind of like the IP um but the game itself fell very flat for me um Pagan fate of Roanoke was one that didn't land um but it could have we took a chance on it and it didn't quite work out and another one was um Imperium so if you remember a couple years ago this card game came out I think it was David tertsey and Nigel Buckle um I did not like the game at all it's kind of an asymmetric um a faction versus faction card game but I thought it was going to be a bit more Euro it's kind of a deck building like game it's just very convoluted very confusing I thought and I bounced off that one hard hard to the point where I didn't even review it because I felt so negatively about it but those are a few examples there for you thank you for your questions Keith so that concludes the video that's all the questions answered and I believe I hope you have not missed out on any um to repeat myself please be sure to submit your new questions below this video and I'll um guarantee to ask them on the next one again no questions means no more videos in the series so please get them in um if you have enjoyed the video please be sure to hit like And subscribe to my channel and check out my other content too and for everybody else I'll see you next time on chairman of the board bye-bye