Skip to main content
Loading video...

Scythe vs. 4X Games (Going Analog: Episode 2)

Transcript 20:38

explore expand exploit externally these are the four core concepts that make up before Exxon rrah if you play PC games like civilization or master of orion's then you're familiar with the idea of starting with next to nothing discovering the territory around you extracting whatever natural resources you can and destroying only when you find along the way size is a Forex life board game that takes place in an alternate history post-world War one Europa where workers farm and mind the lamp while military forces expand to help their factions grow in power during a turn of size players can take one of the top row actions on the player map these allow players to move military units or resource producing workers on the map train a coin to gain resources like food wood oil or metals produce resources on the map or workers are located gain power of combat cards which help you defeat enemies gain popularity which leads to more points at the end of the game or in coins which convert into points for the final end of game victory in addition to or in setup the top roll action players can play resources to take the corresponding bottom row actions these allow players to enlist recruits to give bonuses like additional money power or cards build

buildings which give bonuses as well deploy formidable mechs that make up your military force or upgrade which improves top row actions and makes bottom reactions cheaper survive the players build up their forces and explore the map they can claim new territories that could use new resources have random mini - your own adventure encounters or fight other players by bidding higher in power and combat cards to be clear five is not civilization it doesn't have the same scale scope or ambition but size does provide a simplified streamlined Forex experience and is one of the most hyped for games of 2016 does it live up to expectation let's see what the going analog could have used we just finished playing sighs we could win this for a few weeks now and we're finally ready to review this game as we said in the intro this is sort of a 4x light game it's not quite like as ambitious as a civilization or massive variety X as elements of 4x and that's why we're reviewing it today and so we're going to talk about what we like them up game what we don't like in at the end we're going to roll our pointy 20s and now have any words to make our final conclusions then decide as a group if we want to give this game but no word we're not I think the most striking thing about the game is its art and it's teeming just super strong just sort of like clothes will warm one Cold War

alternate history Mac kind of thing going on it really grabs you the components are really awesome that's actually like one of my biggest likes about it is I love the theming all the way down to the character cards the board being the visual cards always awesome a little like story composite a beautiful art and little choose-your-own-adventure kind of perks the best part is it could have gone a book and they didn't yes there are no more I believe it's the in public of you just it's just they should know that everyone that ever people hate them quote and so I'm glad you didn't it's empty auto loans and overseas there's no food which is really new joke aboard new and they're happy now you borghese place it's a mansion and it's not another fish so what did you think Christina as you know the best part about this game is playing without components we're probably spoiled because we have this crazy collector's edition - but the mechs are awesome unless you have the tractor Metro no joke I have extreme another flying it's still pretty cool though because you know when you're moving your characters down there's a lot of personality I like you know the cool animal front and stuff but I get the feeling of exploring which I really like and that there's just a lot of different ways to different things when I open this game up install the metal coins that we have here and all these little realistic resources took in relay room though this is the expensive

version and chrome disclosure like we originally bought the normal edition and the developer knowing that we were going to forgive this game offered to upgrade us to the collector's edition so we have a giant sideboard it's about a 50% larger than a normal board which would be on the back of this thing but like I said the battle points realistic resource oaken's and they have a little cool storage blue train that you're putting in so it's not like you're getting 15 ziplock bags and dumping all this on the table so there's various yeah like I don't think if you have to me yeah I have a little turned on when I open up this box I gotta say it was the first thing you pointed out to me many others you're like look at how many neat and tidy the storage is if the lid snaps securely it's all nicely divided make little trays it crashed about it I want to turn to add I think the art is my favorite thing about it like everything is kind of a good talking point you click over a card you're like everyone wants to talk about who hears I got like a mech playing a farmer being a Bears like this it's also good it's kind of breathtaking it like there's this much little arguing game there's like hundreds and hundreds of paintings in this game and animal creatures are so many sweet like I'm Olga and chunga it's higher and you know this time rolls type of my best friend and anyone you should know that this Tiger cake holidays are the muskox in a bear is dead he's getting a hawk Jana came in second okay it makes up for the tractor the paintings all faced on a missionary say the same when jacob ribowsky was an

artist so the developer looking the designer became actually saw his art on Kotaku with all these necks that are kind of mixed in 1920s farmland except post World War one Europa and even like the game achievable you just basically design a game around that art so they've worked together and collaborated and it carries through really nicely and for me the gameplay I really did became played because it's so fast like on the box it said it says in power or 115 minutes which is just five minutes I of two hours but we finished today this is like we played several times on we're kind of used to rules we're getting pretty streamlined weeks if that like finish within an hour over the four of us today and so it's a quick game you only have limited moves that you can make and what's cool except for your Red Faction you once you pick one action here you don't get to pick it again until you move this off so you only have a few limited choices today and what's going on a hot pick for the players at home red it's way over power yeah it did in writer to that way like the last few times red played big one by a lot of fun day so you may have a few choice link but they're all interesting choices like but I want to move my guys are going want to collect resources or do I want to produce resources or do I want to gain power so if you only have a few moves makes up every turn that you take it just goes by oversized like my turn and ended sooner than your turn really feel super important like was your turn to pick like oh yeah I did so much compliment if you like if you wait to turn it the end of the world like

you're like ah love that okay but it's fast but really important yeah it has kind of a trapping of a deeper game that you feel like this should take 3-4 hours to play like we've been playing one or two hours and the other thing I'll add too is like if you're a more casual working or who want to get into heavier stuff I think this game of a fantastic job let's continue to begin because if limited choices through they're really quick so you're not going stuck in this F analysis paralysis mode and they make it super fun but the reference cards here will explain to you what can you do what can the characters on the board do what do your what do your opponent's how can they move across rivers and such like that play like that and then my favorite part perhaps is there's actually like a QuickStart suggestions where they list okay you don't know what you're doing is your first time like this and instead of being overwhelmed by choices do this for your first card have to turn returns and I'm like this is brilliant a great way to ease in players into your sort of heavier board game I sort of disagree I mean the presentation you're absolutely right there's ways to ease in and the suggestions are nice but I think the newer player might be really overwhelmed by all these days like Shawn really nailed it these choices are all super weighty yeah and I think a lot of times especially in the early games I would find myself just like oh I gotta do this and see what happens and that didn't really pan out like you don't understand all the choices especially with how many wing conditions and ways to get points there are at you I take can be really intimidating it does a good job of

trying to lower that barrier but actually think it's pretty dense and it's pretty complex and it's so fast the game's over so quick I mean the new players are created in today's more so in this game than any other because there's no damage there's no randomization a smart player can think they turned ahead and beginning a no one's [ __ ] with you just all by yourselves taking whatever tortures you want and as long as you think but it steps ahead which is pretty easy if you get the game you can just completely dominate and as you get better the game like this it's just like little subtle things it will make you much much better and like a new player will never have that nuclear summer I'll try to build the oil now where it's like if you play this game to jump you know I'm doing oil wood blah blah blah and I'm getting neck on turn for doing this hunter but and it will be terrible turn eight or nine or anyone's even going to be able to get in the way you're fine yo I'm saying first time anybody's came here to get annihilated by you're trying to play it before yeah okay if you're playing with people of the similar skill level I think it's great because then you can explore together and if you saw base up also and you're just exploiting together but yeah if you throw in anybody who's plated before it starts feeling like I'm just fighting against this Colossus I can't what did you guys not like I'm up case and he mentioned earlier right I do think rent a little overpowered explaining the mechanics of the game is each turn you do a thing one of your four actions and then next turn you

can't do that action again whereas red can do whatever it wants whenever it wants so or exam I produce three turns in a row whereas you might have to produce just move and then go back to produce so it's just it sounds silly but it's really overpowered in this game at least from my perspective like you just I can plan out my terms so much more efficiently something that might have taken me 12 hours have babysit yeah I have to like mix it with some like peripheral strategies that goes straight for planning the holder for sure like the internal 8:35 asymmetrical races and factions in this game and they all have different bonuses different powers different starting resources and cards and things like that but know that I played them all I feel like red is the most fun to play so that one reason is this like you just had one extra action to choose from each rest until I'm kind of a rookie of the game I might be appreciated but I think great things really really strong like Shawn in the Bakken he maxed out his orders yet every single one of them while most of us were still like rolling around trying to get some wood upgrade [ __ ] you got their start there yeah and then you just toad over yeah you rent up so quickly and I think you do have to pay play to the strengths of your faction if you've got problems with fitted factions like I've definitely played a game with an experienced player and played the black faction and he just ended the game so quickly nobody move even close though he knew the strings he dug into his life for me the thing that I find difficult doesn't seem is that I want to play it

longer so I do realize the exploring I love the encounters I want to fill the resources and you just can't follow that or you're going to lose what I have to pay attention we should have paid more attention to Shawn I'm doing a lot of his stars but I just really wanted to collect more things today I like it so much better than it looks like there's behaviors can eyeball the patient look sure cuz I wonder like other times like we all came real chatty a couple of people were like a little high a little drunk whatever and so like I think I'm taking a bit too long to get through the turns and so it's just sort of said like this game you get in the way of our conversation and the conversation was like occasionally in the wave game but like I say like most of the game you just like you're gonna do my thing out okay we're going to go so it's like today where else facially taken or turn them I don't get it kind of sweet if if you're cruising through territory control and the combat on the seals kinda tacked on because the penalty for moving combat is negligible like if I D you in this boss you elect your little base and then you're back there in a turn or two so it might be the difference between yo Mikey move that's not really that punitive and there's not that much benefit to going to combat other than getting a starter or something like way so as like they had to incentivize combat but usually one combat to be to the sake of what you win from it not just some point like a token victory how many turns you you ask me license plate game like its eNOS we have 1520 I guess any

of losing it turns pretty big but the ideal also engaging your combat means you had like motion commands into space generate resources the next phase build a mecha and ex-fix move that makeover comment so we're like four turns minimum to initiate that comment though if you can only make them lose one turn for like before you spend the defender can just gather at you kinda got a better than idea like that maybe one missions of the game is that comment doesn't have a huge reward to our top of it mortars it right on top of that ear if you are the aggressor and you've arrived out one of these workers so the non-military people use popular greater popularity impact a lot of the game including your sword multiplier at the end as well as it's a resources yeah there you're like going on baby no it's actually in that way I actually don't like fighting in this game it's kind of where to have a 4x valve game when Eve's max that are such a big part of the blouson components that you see on the Bob but you're not actually fighting that which and in the book an instruction book is actually says you'll be surprised how little you fighting so I think if your expectations are said that it's a little bit more about the resources of exploring that is both combat it in order to just not that kind of person you don't like kind of man in mix they're like concurrence kids and Vinick and out there holding each other gentlemen but it is it is kind of different because you kind of look at this is a text-based map PC specs you feel like you should be a lot of things but there's not a lot of that Mikey days it's punitive to do it like I was

looking at one of your stories are coming and still on the board we got all these resources on like man I have an ability that I could use a tunnel and get there in one move and take all that stuff oh but I would come out in this tunnel those guys are for treating us to popularity and then I come here those heads are dirty and to popularity and I'm already down on the track like is it really worth that hit for resources that I can get into terms probably not so I wind up and go and try some other strategies you're punished so hard for actually engaging and what should be beneficial for like a Forex trend taking territory yeah maybe I gave you leave your resources unguarded it's like you screwed up back miss Hammond need more guarded is definitely Courage's and not go back with you are public I have had situations where someone was aggressive and knives on Christina's thinking up on this pot I'm just like [ __ ] I can't have her take all of that and then but I've had games where someone came in knocked me out and start suspending my resources and my god release button let's get to the conclusion selves we are this is our new format control you know certainly thank you in gone somebody nice and gentle so this will give our final words your religion that's when we work you get to say to me can finally and we're going to vote whatever he is going analog the links to email or provide aa

little Oni alright I guess one would you talk nine six alright so let's take a few seconds to write that out okay we are done now remember only 24 so here are my twenty worth beautiful game fast-paced not ambitious like full 4x but that's okay mom that high drunk mentioned earlier was ending on a sled additional summer number 12 okay I use my school board say great single player game inside the friends but not so [ __ ] I had nine and I said beautiful art each G longer L of X I'm six a common finger a gorgeous art why Bollywood combat alright so now we're going to vote I wouldn't change up slightly from last episode because I sent home like this I please come so what we're going to do is this to them you love it one time if you like it once I'm now to keep don't like it and at the end if we all need an escape say we all would the game gives an award a platinum award from the colonial auction and then having it all right so our three we're going to go all in change on them credit one two three

people ask you it's a haha alright yeah I liked everything we got born like so I don't like the game we're not gonna give it an award to signs no thank you for playing and then we have some charm day two letters from buffer from episode I'll do it have you ever ended up not playing a board game because the rules ended up being needlessly complicated or the rule book was written so poorly the rules were unclear that was a question for Matthew and in the realm of dick joke writing I am one of history's greatest thinkers and even I sometimes get confused and I was playing this game called mage night which is pretty popular a lot of our viewers might have heard of it I swear to God I read that rule book five times which was like a six-week process we played the game like on the simple tutorial level and we had no idea if we were doing anything right by the time we were done why like I think we just cheated I have no idea how to do any of that thing we did so we never got around to playing that there's another one called Pathfinder adventure kit am I getting that right you Pathfinder Adventure card game where I love that game but we're ten percent sure we're cheating half the time we're like kind of no idea if I can do this you so like that's another one that maybe it's super clear we've got one from Stephanie T and she says what to do when playing with man children we have to for tantrums when they loser get attacked I'm not a trained psychologist I don't know exactly how to deal with these people but I'm a writer and what writers are good at its manipulating context so someone's thrown a tantrum what you could do is maybe take a phone call and be like what that my teenage

daughter has AIDS thank you and then you're like oh what were you upset about like you you do the spider-man lost his hit points oh yeah yeah you got some big problems buddy so I mean that's how I would handle that given em ask would you consider carving as humanity a tabletop game and I don't ah me not I think that's more of a like way for people with remedial sense of humor to communicate to each other about [ __ ] I guess nothing against it I just you know we just we in the comedy community will consider you funny when you play that is all insane

Progress saved