Skip to main content
Loading video...
Transcript 13:25

Hello, ladies and gentlemen, and welcome to the discriminating gamer. You know, libraries are a great place to start, but can we invent other places where people aren't allowed to talk? Ladies and gentlemen, today we're going to go ahead and take a look at The Witcher: Old World from CD Projekt Red.

In The Witcher: Old World from CD Projekt Red, one to five players take on the roles of Witchers. These are kind of genetically created and sorcery-enhanced warriors who battle monsters. So, players are going to go around the board, they're going to have adventures, they are going to engage in stories, they are going to play some poker, and they are going to fight those monsters. All right, ladies and gentlemen, this is a game that's been out for several years now. I'm not going to get deep into the weeds of the rules. I'm just going to tell you the basics of gameplay and then tell you what I think. Now, the game board is a series of locations. You have various locations that have either kind of mountains or forests or water, and these kinds of locations are going to be very important as you move around the board. But when you set up, you're also going to set up monsters. Essentially, you have kind of level 1, 2, and 3 monsters.

You're going to set them in various locations. You're going to have tokens that indicate which locations on the board they go to, and then you're going to put their monster card in a special spot on the board so you can see which monsters are in those specific locations. You are also going to set up story decks for cities and countryside, as well as kind of the basic stories that you're going to engage in. Now, each player's going to get their own Witcher. You're going to get your own Witcher board, which is kind of a dual-layered board, and you're going to have stats that you're going to put your cubes in to indicate kind of where you are. You're going to have kind of a defense cube, a shield cube, as well as, as I say, the various other stats. You're going to get your own deck of, I believe, 10 starter cards. There's a bit of deck building in this game. And these cards are going to be very important as you want to fight those monsters and do other fun and interesting things.

Now, basically, what happens here is you have three phases on a turn. So, the first thing you do is you have, essentially, for phase one, movement. How you do movement is you play a card from your hand, and generally, you're going to have three cards in your hand. You're going to play a card from your hand that will allow you to move to an adjacent location, but that card must the the terrain of that card must match the terrain of the location you're going to, as I say, either mountains, forests, or water. And so, you can play that card to move to that next location.

[clears throat]

And you can do that multiple times, as long as you play the cards. Now, when you get to the location, you can take a location action. Each of the different spaces on the board have different kinds of location actions. You may be able to increase one of your stats. You may be able to go to a school, and and like radically increase some of your stats for a price. You may be able to get coins. And critically, too, some of the locations have poker. Now, you if you go to these locations that have poker, you can play poker against the house, but if you go to a place where there's another Witcher, you can play poker against them. Essentially, you're making bets. And then with these bets, what you're doing is rolling dice. You have two sets of poker dice. So, you're rolling the dice, and again, you just got one through six, and you're trying them to to match. You're trying to make, you know, pairs or, you know, a straight or full house, and you've got a kind of a uh you know, cards that tell you exactly what beats what. But, you can go ahead, and you each roll the dice. And then, the person who um whose turn it is not, they can roll first to see if they want to go ahead and roll again, get something better, and then the initiator can go ahead, and they can roll. So, you're comparing that. Whoever gets the better hand wins the pot. Now, as I say, after you do all that, you can move again if that's something what you want to do, or you can move to phase two.

Now, in phase two, there's different things you can do. Now, one of the things you can do is meditate. Now, if one of your stats has gotten all the way to the highest rank, you can meditate. Essentially, you can take a uh trophy card for that stat. Now, trophies are essentially the way you're going to win the game, so it's kind of like a victory point. So, you're going to go ahead and move up on the the trophy track, the victory point track. That's it for that phase. Conversely, you can explore. So, like I say, you can choose to explore the city or the countryside around it, and you draw the appropriate card. And these cards often times will have choices. They will tell you, you know, you you meet interesting characters, different things you can do. You can make those choices. Now, typically, the person I believe to your right is always going to kind of read these things, and then you're going to make the decisions based on what they they've read.

And so, once you've done that, sometimes a choice will lead to one of the stories. So, you can take a story, which is often a quest um that may have you take a uh token for the uh locations. Say, that go to that location, you can fulfill this quest. So, that's one of the things you can do. But, you go through, you play through that story, you gain whatever rewards or or, you know, issues pop up from that quest or from that exploration. Now, the third thing you can do during phase two is you can fight a monster. Now, if you go to a location with a monster, you can fight them. Now, throughout the course of the game, you may be gaining trail tokens. These are location tokens upside down, and if that trail token if that matches a location where the monster is, it essentially means you can you're going to get advantages in combat. You're going to go first.

Uh otherwise, the monster's going to lash out at you. Now, again, the person on your right is going to essentially play the role of the monster during this encounter, and they're going to draw a number of uh monster cards uh combat cards equal to the value of that monster. And that's going to be their health, but it's also going to be their um kind of the way they fight back. Now, what you're doing without getting too much into the weeds here, what you're doing is you are playing your cards um to try to hit that monster. Now, you have kind of these slash marks that are that are your damage that you're dealing it But, when you play a card, you're looking for combos. Essentially, there are little tabs on some of the cards. You're trying to get that the color tab to match the color of other cards, and if you can play multiples of those, you can do some real damage here. For every hit you get, the monster's going to have to discard one of their cards.

But, the monster on their turn, they before they draw a card, they can decide if they're going to charge or bite, and you reveal, and there's different fight conditions for either the charge or the bite, and then you apply that. The witchers are going to take hits. They've got a defense value they're going to lower, then they're going to start losing their own cards. But, essentially, if the if the witcher runs out of cards, they're defeated, or if the monster's cards are all depleted, then the monster is defeated. Depending on who wins, there's different conditions you're going to do, and you are going to go ahead and reset a new monster on the track. Finally, you have phase three, which is action cards. They have um action cards that you can purchase a market off to the side of the board, and some of them have kind of have a plus one or negative one uh modifiers to the price. Now, you're not paying gold for the cards. What you're doing is if you want to gain cards, you are discarding cards from your hand.

Now, actually, the first thing you can do is you bring your card your hand size up to three cards, and then you discard a number of cards depending on where that is, and it's got a price in the bottom of the corner of the each card. Um and you're going to discard cards in order to bring that card into your hand. Now, if you bring that card into your hand, of course, that will be there for you at the beginning of the next round. But, you can get more powerful cards and really build up your deck at this time. Now, as I say, players are going around the board, and they are trying to gain these trophies. As I say, you can do that by meditation. You can also do it by defeating some of these monsters, and you can also do it by defeating other witchers. If you're in the same location with a witcher, you can choose to fight a witcher, in which case you will gain their trophy card. The first person to gain a complete set of trophies wins. The Witcher: Old World.

We'll get back to the review in just a moment. I want to take a minute to ask you to check out my other channel that is Cody Carlson, PhD, where we talk about history, books on history, military history. I even post some of my uh lectures for my classes on there. Please check that out. Please subscribe to that channel, and now, back to the review. All right, ladies and gentlemen, The Witcher: Old World. This is a game, as I say, that's been around now for several years, and it's one I've always wanted to play, and I just I never had an opportunity. And recently, I was able to reach out to the people at uh Asmodee, and through them, I was able to get a copy of this game uh to review. Now, let me just say first of all, I've not read any of The Witcher books. Um I'm so I'm not familiar with the literature at all. I did I watched the first season of the series, and I started to watch, I think, the second, and I just kind of lost interest. It kind of lost me.

But, I really enjoyed it. I liked Henry Cavill. I thought he was great. When I heard he left, I'm like, well, forget it. Uh but, I really enjoyed uh what I saw of the show. I thought it was a fun and interesting world and I was really excited to play this game. And so Ray and Chris were over the other night and we played it. Now I'll say I'll say right now there's a bit of a learning curve. Some of the ideas here were not terribly intuitive. And it wasn't bad. Eventually we got we got it figured out, but it did take a little bit for us to get into here. The game play generally is fun. This is a story game. This is a story driven game. It's a game where you go to different locations and you can do fun and interesting things and you got choices. I really enjoy these kinds of games. You know, I'm thinking of the the original Crossroads of Dead of Winter where you go to a place and somebody reads you a card to give you choices. I really like that. I really like story and immersive games that that that do that sort of thing. It's very fun and I like it here.

The the deck building here is a little different with the with the cards. You just discard cards to gain cards, but I mean it makes sense in the context of the game of it's prepping you for your next your next turn, but you may have fewer cards if you want to spend more to to gain one. So there's interesting things there as well with the deck building. Now combat here, I think was perhaps one of the most more unusual aspects here where the cards themselves um kind of dictate combat. They dictate who you are fighting and they dictate, well, not who you are fighting, but how you are fighting um uh the monsters or how you're fighting another Witcher depending on those tabs, right? Because those tabs are going to create these combos and trigger these combos. And so that was a very kind of interesting way. I mean, I I guess I'm just used to text in deck builders that that that do that, but this was an interesting way that they played off of each other there.

So um again, not intuitive, but once you figure it out it goes pretty well. And I really like the way the monsters fight with their cards and and and it's kind kind their health, but it's also their attack ability. And when you are going to attack the player, you got to say whether you're going to do a charge or a bite, and it's fun to kind of revealing that. It's like, "Oh, I shouldn't have done the other one, you know?" And that that's pretty cool. Production here is beautiful. I think the artwork is great. You got the wonderful dual-layer uh boards for your um Witchers and and moving the the the cubes up on them and leveling up with your with your characters is really fun and interesting. Artwork is amazing. I think the board looks great and and and the cards are really fun. Uh all told, we really had a lot of fun with The Witcher: Old World. Uh this is a game that I'm excited to kind of get delve a little bit deeper into. And on the Cody scale, I'm going to give The Witcher: Old World an eight out of 10.

It's really a fun game. Thank you once again for joining us today on The Discriminating Gamer. As always, we would ask you to please leave a comment for us here on YouTube, on BoardGameGeek, on Facebook, on X. We'd love to hear back from you. We'd love to hear what your opinions are. And please, if you do like what you see here, check out my other channel, that is Cody Carlson, PhD, where we talk about history, military history, books on history, fun things like that. I even post some of my lectures up there. It would mean the world to me if you would subscribe to that channel as well. And if you do really like what you see here on The Discriminating Gamer, I would humbly ask you to click on the Super Thanks button and leave a tip. You know, a lot of people are upset that all of my jokes are only in English. So, here's one in Spanish. Uno.

Please somebody help me. I'm on my feet again, AND I DON'T KNOW WHERE I'M GOING, AND I DON'T know where I've been. Please somebody help me. I'm on solid ground. IT'S A LONG TIME ONCE A YEAR I WIND UP IN THE VAN.

MY nephew told me that one, and I I thought it was stupid at first, but then I got it.

Progress saved