Carl von Linné Review - Beautifully Intricate, Strategically Satisfying
Transcript
Hey, I'm Alex Rack from Board Gameco and today I'm reviewing Carl Vonlin from Patreon. Carl Vonlin is an intricate Euro game for one to four players in which players are doing a whole lot. There's a whole lot to get into. Lots of actions, lots of things change together. I will give you a general overview of how things play, but this is definitely not going to be a rules overview. Please do not take it as such. Uh before we dive into it, this channel is sponsored by Allplay. More about them at the end of the video. In Carl Vonlin, you're doing a lot of things. You're doing a lot of things. is you're trying to do a lot of things across five rounds when you take three actions each round, but actions have a degree of escalating significance, level one, two, or three as far as how strong the actions are, and you're doing it across all the various areas of the game. You're going to be going to this area of the board in order to gather various specimens and samples as you move along different areas. We'll come back to that shortly.
You're going to be going over here and planting various flowers, both for area control as well as the various benefits along the edge, as well as the benefits that you cover. Uh over here, you're going to be trying to uh be mindful of the various tracks and the scoring that they provide by trying to move up the tracks and be good at the things that require you to score well. And then over here, you're going to be moving your ship uh down over here on your own personal ship cards. You'll be moving your ship along these voyages to both get the benefits as well as getting to the end of the track and getting recurring income. And then you'll be going over here to gather various letters, collecting various letters, and sending them out again for a variety of bonuses. You're doing a lot of things for a lot of points. All of it comes together very nicely. The way you do this in the game is you're going to have your actions. You have these actions over here that should actually be locked over there. You have your five basic starting actions. You're going to spend an action in order to do various things.
For example, I'll just show you each of the five actions. Then I'll tell you some things how it all changed together. And then we'll go to my review over here. For example, let's say we went into this one spot. First, we'll get the bonus underneath it, which means we're going to move this one, two, three. This basically is how we're going to upgrade our lenses at this lens market over here. These are basically slightly stronger actions. Slightly is the key word. They're not crazy strong. They're the same action you can already take, but with a few extra goodies for doing so. But you're going to want those lenses, which means you're going to want to upgrade this little rondelle. And one of the ways you do it is whenever you go to the one action spot, again, you have three actions per turn. One action is go there, take this action one times, and get the effect underneath it, which in this case is moving our lens there. So over here, now we can move our boat. Our boat starts off on this card over here, and we can move to one of these zones. Well, I guess only this zone. This is the only adjacent zone. We'll move over there. and then we'll take a crate and we'll add it to our supply over there.
That's going to be an example of a ship action. When your ship gets to the bottom, if you both get to the bottom and have unlocked enough samples to uh publish a book over here, then you'll get this as an ongoing income every single round. So, unlocking ships and publishing books early on is great cuz the two together give you an ongoing income. Until then, you just get the various things you pass along and you get this when you get to the end. And you're also paying attention to the color palette because the round kind of gives you a multiplier for each of these being stronger depending on the round you're in. For example, right now, blue is the strongest. If I were to move there, I would be able to move my lens 1, two, three, again, getting high on the track and then getting an upgraded lens, which I can use for future actions. That's basically the idea of the ship action. From there, let's go ahead and take a letter action. When we go to the middle spot over here, we're going to first get one of those rewards.
I'll take this over here. And then we'll put there, and we'll do it twice. twice means we have to do the action two times. The same way we just moved a ship once over here. If we had done it to a level of two, we would have been able to move it an additional one, which might have been worth it. That would have given us an early upgrade right off the bat. Maybe that's the right thing to do. Either way, I'm just showing you how this plays. So, we can do the letter action twice. The letter action is one of two things. You either take two letters from the uh board over here. So, you look over here, you gather two letters for one action. Sorry, you take one letter for the action. So you're going to for an action you either take one letter and you get the reward on top of the space or alternatively you publish two letters. Now the way that works I'll pretend I'll have a few letters in front of me. Let's pretend I have these two letters over here. Let's pretend I have uh let's pretend I have yeah let's have these right now. If I have these two letters in front of me for my first action I might go ahead and take this letter which means I'll get the one coin. I'll take a coin over there and I'll get this letter add it to my supply and then I could publish two letters. When you publish a letter I'll pick this letter to publish first. I'll publish it and I'll get the effects on that letter and then I'll publish another letter and because it's the same color, I'll get both of those effects.
So, I'll get those effects repeated. You can create a stack of up to three of the same color, which means you get stronger and stronger as you publish more letters. And then this one, I'll save for later and hold on to that. That's the way letters work over there. letters. You're trying to collect letters, getting the effect above the letter, and then you're publishing multiple letters in order to go ahead and gain the rewards from cascading bonuses as well as endgame points because over here you get points for having more letters of different colors published. There's four different letters and full sets will award you with seven points per set. That's action two. Action three, going back to our player board over here, action three, maybe we'll go ahead and take a planting action. This will allow us to do it three times and also it's going to have us placing our token onto the board to take our turn order or bonus. I'll go last in turn order and I'll get a crate for doing so. That's what I'm going to choose with that and I'll take the planting action three times. Planting involves one of two things. You either place a t a tile onto the flowerboard or you can cultivate it if you can afford to do so. So over here, for example, I'll take this letter. I'll take this plant. Let's take a level three right now. I'll take a level three over here.
I'll place it down over here. And that will allow me to cover that. When I do that, I cover that. I move around this little rondelle again. And I can do that three times. So I can place out another one. Maybe I'll go over here. and then I'll be able to move up on one of these tracks. That's what this one does. And alternatively, you can cultivate. And when you cultivate, what you're going to do is you're going to be paying for cultivating. So, you have to go ahead and pay these tools to go ahead and cultivate. And then you're going to flip one of these, add it to a stronger side, and also getting the rewards in the column. Both of these rewards because of the well, the row, not the column. Both of these rewards I'll gain as well. That is an example of a planting action. So, over here, you've seen three of the five possible actions, and you've seen the idea that actions come in different strengths. So you could do a times 1, x 2, or x 3. The two actions you did not see are going to be moving around the world map. So over here, let's take this token over here. If we went over here to a times two, keeping in mind, we can't go there right now. That spot is occupied. Let's pretend we hadn't done those spots over there. If I go over there with that, I can move on this map over here. And when you move on this map, you're going to go to spots. You're going to place a marker at one of these spots when you visit that for the first time. So spreading around is helpful because the more you move around the board, the more you get those onetime bonuses. I'll go ahead and take those $2. And then you can either take the location reward over there. Or alternatively, you can pay crates to take the specimen tile, which can be incredibly helpful because as these go into your grid, you'll not only get the benefit in the corner where it's touching your explorer right away. So I'll be able to move up again on one of these tracks, but as you move your explorer around the grid, you'll also cover those benefits. Right now, I'll cover that because I I already activate it. And that's going to bring us to the last action shortly. But before we do,
uh, when when you're moving around this grid, you also sometimes have to pay monetary costs to cross certain borders. But then also sometimes you're going to get things like this. If I moved over here, I would get one coin and I would get this as well. And those are going to be very helpful for publishing books later on. That brings us to the last action which is moving around your own personal journal. The last action, we can go ahead and move. So let's say we move one. That's going to move us two up on this tableau. One, two. We move closer towards an upgraded lens. We can go ahead and uh we can put down another flower. So we can plant another flower. We cover that bonus. We'll take a flower. We'll put it down over here gaining a point. And then lastly, we cover this. And that's going to give us one specimen of that type. Whenever you see those little hexagon symbols, that's going to give you specimens which you can use to go ahead and publish books. Books will require spare specimens. We have a starter book. But then we also have more advanced books you can draft on the display over here by paying tools in order to do so. By paying a tool in order to gather a card and that's going to allow you to publish these, which will both require having those symbols from getting them around the board, but also having these in order to cash in.
You can see require certain colors and you'll get the rewards on there. That's a highlevel idea of the five actions you're doing in the game. You can once again to do a quick overview, you can publish, you can plant various flowers onto this grid. And this grid is going to give you both the immediate effects as well as the effects when you cultivate them as well as area control. When an area is filled is going to be area control bonuses in terms of uh in-game bonuses and points you'll get. You can publish a variety of letters over here. Those will give you stronger and stronger bonuses as you publish more of them, but you have to invest into it. You can move around this grid over here in order to gather various samples in order to put them into your grid as well as getting these as well in order to go ahead and publish them on the books. And then you can also go ahead and move your ship to get a variety of bonuses here. And you can move your adventure around this grid in order to get the bonuses over there. There's a lot of other things going on here. There's going to be the various scoring goals. Again, on this track over here, you're trying to get a multiplier. As you move up, you'll get multiplier as well as some in-game effects as well. Some like things as you cross them. And that's going to be for how well you did in certain areas. And then these are more of a first come first serve that as you go on these ones, the first person to achieve such one of these will get more and more points as you go through the grid.
Meanwhile, you can get a variety more uh more boat cards, you can get more book cards, and on these you can unlock on various zones as you as you move along the journey over here. You can gather these and these will give you various in-game scoring. If you've done X, you get a bunch of points as well, while also giving you one of the requisite things over there, which can again can allow you to help publish a book, which can then give you the income you need in order to go ahead and get those on an hour on a recurring basis. There is a lot going on here. There's a lot going on as far as how it all comes together. It is not the most complicated game, but it is a lot to go ahead and uh pick up on uh what's basically an overview plus uh plus review video, which I guess brings us to the review part of things in terms of what I'd like, don't like, and can see others not liking. remembering that I try to give you a general overview in as relatively short as possible, but there's a lot more to get into. Let's go ahead and dive into what I like about the game. The multiplying actions is one of the things that makes Carl Vanlin stand out. Uh I'm not saying it's never been done before, but the idea that you have uh five different core actions you can do each game, and the fact that you're going to be multiplying some of those actions.
You can go ahead and take one action at level one, one action level two, one action level three, and the fact that you want to do every single last action at level four, and you can't do any of them level four. There is no level four. But everything in the game, you're trying to do as much as possible. You have five rounds of play which means only five times three 15 actions granted at different strengths because of the multiplier but that system over there forcing you to choose between the the what what action is stronger for you this round. Are you really leaning into publishing letters? Are you leaning towards exploring the board? Are you trying to get as many of these specimens as fast as possible in order to get that recurring income from from going on journeys and publishing? There's a ton of different ways to push the various levers of this engine. And that's before we even get into the uh the upgraded lenses because there are a bunch of upgraded lenses over here. And while the upgrade benefits are small, they have two main benefits. The first is it gives you something else extra. This one over here, this boat, for example, lets you multiply whatever the multiplier for the round is, you add one. So instead of 1, two, or three, it's two, three, or four as you acquire various bonuses on this grid. That can have a strong effect.
Everything in this game has a small effect that turns into a strong effect because the nature of the game. The other thing that having those special tiles lets you do is it lets you sometimes do multiple actions more than once. Maybe you're really leaning into a whole lot of ship exploring in the game and that one ship tile even at times three is not good enough. Also, [clears throat] one thing I didn't mention is over here on your personal board that times three gets locked each round. So, whatever action you put in the times three, you can't use next round. So, having more of these can really help kind of give you more opportunity to do something at times five. You can do a times three and times two, but then also have that times two back next round, whereas the times three is locked. So, having multiple tiles of the same type, keeping in mind you have a limit of six tiles in your display. You can only have six tiles. So you kind of have to pick and choose what's going to work for you as you try to figure it out. And the actions cascading into other actions. Everything you do in the game gives you something else that works for something else. Letters is going to be the most obvious. Letters and planting flowers. I'd argue these give you actions that come from every area of the board. Planting flowers as well because of the bonuses on the side.
Bonuses that change each game as well as the fact that every one of these spots give you different actions. They give you a ton of different ways things. But even as you move on to over here, there's a lot of side benefits on these regions as you explore. So those are going to give you things. Then as you get these over here, when you turn around and publish a book, you get to activate the ability on those, which can cascade you up tracks, get you income, get you tools. Everything you do in the game cascades into several other things. So you don't have to focus on all five areas of the game. Is it five areas? It feels like five areas. It's five actions, but it's not really five areas. Whatever. You don't have to because the letters are kind of not really a area. They kind of cascade to everything else. Point is, you don't have to do everything in the game. You could choose the three things you're really good at, and you'll manage to get a little bit of everything from those three things. And combine that with the upgraded lenses and you have this cascading wheel that manages to give you more and more in what is otherwise a very tight engine.
The letters in particular I find particularly satisfying. Uh it's one of those things where again I it's one of those statements that I need more plays to be sure of this, but it does feel like you either need to lean into letters or cultivating in every game because the cultivating the flowers the flowers and the letters are kind of the uh most jack of all trades. They're the ones that most give you a lot of other stuff that you can get. And so if you lean into one of those two areas, you have lots of things coming your way while you focus on the other core actions. While you try to get your hands on books and on ships and move around the board and get all those rewards and upgrade your lenses so you can pay less to move around the board or get extra things when you move around the board. Everything cascades nicely. And there's always a way to do what you want. Use it to find your particular avenue, what you're trying to do this game, and possibly combine with asymmetric characters. We didn't really talk about it, but these characters, there are a bunch of asymmetric characters in the game. You can play with the basic side or you can play with the advanced side which gives you a few less starting resources but give you a lot of ways to get more resources in the engine. And I have not played with all of those yet.
I've played the game with the characters but I have not played with all the asymmetric characters. But the ones I have have been very satisfying in terms of when you try to figure out their unique puzzle and how it's going to give you more. I highly recommend starting with either the asymmetric characters or even just the drafting resources as a different resource uh starting thing just gives you a little more to do than the basic game. game. And in a game that feels this tight, having that draw more to do is meaningful. But basically, everything in the game comes together very tightly. This is a very heavy game. It's a very tight game. It's a very satisfying game. The fact that you can all again, you can almost always do something. If you have enough money coming your way, you can pay six money for an extra action. That is something I've done in every single game I've played. I've done that at least once, sometimes a few times. If you have your money engine working for you, getting that one extra ship movement, which will give you that one extra tile, which then lets you get to the end, which lets you get your income that round. It just has cascading. Every small way you can push a little further, a little earlier in the game lets you do more with the engine and it can be incredibly satisfying. As far as what I don't like in the game, the biggest thing for me, I think, is probably the well, there's a few small things. Nothing too nothing too crazy. The flowers in the game do seem underpowered unless everyone goes for them. This whole market where players are going for flowers because of the fact that I mean the area control points you get, you'll get that at the end of the game. Meaning, if you go for an area, no one else does, and then the game will get the points. So, that doesn't matter. But the actual in-game benefits, those you won't get. So getting these extra rewards are so much stronger if everyone's going for flowers versus if players aren't, if you find that you and one of the player are going for it and the other players aren't, it can be a lot harder to eat those extra bonuses out of it. Which means for me
personally, I have found that letters, as I mentioned earlier, that letters or flowers, you kind of want to go for one or the other. And while it's true, both of them give you bonuses. And I still go for flowers. Every game I've played, I've definitely gone for some flowers. But I do find that unless all the players are spending a decent amount of time completing those areas, you just get less rewards out of flowers. So if you play a game where you go for it and no one else really leans into it or it's you and one other person and it just doesn't happen enough, you just get less benefits, which means to a certain extent letters are a safer choice. It's not even that they're inherently better. It's just that I find they're safer. They don't require anyone else to come along and join you for the ride in order to get those bonuses. And I don't love that because that means I'm just less likely to go for flowers if I don't know if other players will go for flowers. So there's there's that aspect of things. Also, the tracks capping out at five. That's going to be these scoring tracks over here. They have a limit to the multiplier being at five. So if you do really well at this thing, get all the way to the end, you get your markers to the four multiplier and you really lean into getting a ton of those. Even if you add 10 of them, you can only do a multiplier times five. Each track caps out at 20. And the problem is I find most of the time you're getting between four and five anyway, unless you really lean into it. Meaning you don't have to try that hard to get to four. Let's say I find getting to five requires a little bit of effort. But because of that, because that like the default for most rewards, again, at least in the games I've played, the default level is going to be you're multiplying however high you got times at least four generally, sometimes five without even trying. And yes, you could try. You could really focus on that thing and then get it to seven or eight or nine, but there's no incentive to do so. Which means to me, this track over here, these three tracks are more about just moving up than
actually doing well at the thing. because doing well at the thing might be the difference between four and five. You can almost always get to four without trying significantly, at least based on the experience I've had playing so far. And I don't love that. It kind of takes away from the satisfaction of really leaning into a track. I'd rather they took the to take the take the gloves off, allow players to get times 8, times 9, whatever you do, you want to lean into it. To me, it almost feels like they tried to make it less broken by just putting an artificial guard rail around it, but the artificial guard rail made it less satisfying because you're probably getting the minimum score or close to minimum score either way. So, a small complaint, but definitely one that affected things. I'll say the variable scoring on a similar but different note, the variable scoring is not as variable as I'd like to begin with. Meaning, you basically have these seven things you're going for and they are double-sided so you can move them to different areas.
But because you kind of basically have them in play all the time, it's just which track you get them on. The game is basically saying do a bunch of stuff and just do all those things, you get points for them. Sure, there is a difference in terms of the red ones. The red ones are first come, first serve and that matters a little bit, but it wasn't like there's like five things out of seven every single time or five things out of 10. There's seven things and all seven things will give you points in a fairly controlled region, a fairly controlled manner. So I found that aspect of variable scoring not as satisfying. Contrast it, for example, with these blue tiles that are different every game. These are constantly replaced as you take them, but these are the rewards you get for cultivating a flower in a row. Those can be incredibly meaningful and majorly change up the game that you're playing every single time. Those have a big impact. So, I found there's a lot of variety to the game. Some of it feels like it really changes the way you engage with it and some of it a little bit less. So, as far as I can see, others not liking the game. The randomness of the available uh species and samples is definitely a factor. what shows up on this grid as far as what you replace them with as far as when you replace these various tiles both over here and here. Sometimes you just really need a set of combination of things to get that book and you don't have a match. You don't have the book you need in the market for what you currently have on your board or you don't have on this board what you need to fit what you have what you need to get for the book.
So like sometimes you just do have that luck of the draw aspect of the availability of things. And yes, the game does allow you to do things like paying two money to convert one type to another type. Uh that's a lot of money. Meaning two money might not sound a lot like a lot of money, but you need every single thing in this game. So, if you have what you need and I have to spend four money to get it, that just feels like it could be a little bit of yes, you have to plan around what you can get your hands on, but sometimes the markets don't always give you what you can get your hands on. You can also pay a coin to refresh basically every market in the game, but again, you are paying to do so. So, while they do give you mitigation around these things, you still end up being the person who's paying for it when your friend across the table seems to be getting everything they need. Getting the right books to line up for the species, again, the same kind of problem. You either have to pay to convert a lot of things or you have to pay to refresh the market hoping for the best things to come out and you might pay that coin once or twice or three times and not even get the books that line up with what you need and you end up having to pay coins to swap things around. Again, that's going to be a generally frustrating experience. I'll also say that if you don't plan things well, you can get resource starved very quickly. This is a game that is fairly tight as far as happening. It can be very satisfying, but if you don't plan around making sure you have your tools, your crates, and your money, you might find yourself just stuck. Yes, there's always ways to get them, but if you spend a bunch of actions to get things that other players manage to synergize into their engine, that can just be a less satisfying experience all around.
As far as final thoughts on Carl Vonlin, the game is incredibly well done. This is a very strong Euro game that does a great job with the multiplying actions, how everything cascades into every other region, how you always get benefits from one thing or another, how you have those uh the the one, two, and three multiplier, the upgraded lenses, the variable asymmetric player powers. There is a lot to like about how this works and how it all comes together. If you're looking for a very tight, very satisfying Euro game, I think this one did a great job. It's a four out of five for me. As far as other game recommendations, definitely check out Encyclopedia if you're looking for something a little bit on the lighter side that's also going to be very satisfying as you collect various specimens in a slightly lighter game. And if you want something that's kind of, I think, similar weight class, but for me, one that I enjoy even more than Carl Benlin, check out Darwin's Journey for an absolutely incredible experience that uh hits on all cylinders. Same idea. Uh there's a lot of similarities between the game in terms of the theme, in terms of what's happening, very different mechanical execution, and for me, both games are very, very strong.
Darwin's Journey I just find I prefer more. I mentioned at the beginning that All Play is a channel sponsor. If you're looking for other games that have a lot of clever interactions and ways that things all synergize as you build up your own asymmetric development, definitely check out Galactic Cruise from one of their partner publishers. If you go to allplay.com, you can find games both from Allplay as well as partner publishers and get $4 flat rate shipping for anything you get. And Galactic Cruise definitely checks a lot of the similar boxes that you get out of Carl Janlin. In any case, until next time, I'm Alex Radcliff from Board Game Co. Hope you enjoyed this video and as always I hope you have a good