Hippocrates Review - Chairman of the Board
Transcript
hi everyone today I'm taking a look at Hippocrates which is a wonderful player Euro strategy board game designed by Alan Orban and published by game Brewer this one takes around 90 minutes to play on average before I get into my review of Hippocrates I want to give a shout out to the show's sponsor keyienda dot Co dot UK where I believe you can pick up a copy of Hippocrates um and if you check out my link in the show notes you can get five percent off your first order so the main board for Hippocrates is going to look like this where you have all these tiles scattered all over the place and I should say this is the deluxe version of the game I have here where the board is of a bigger size than the standard retail one so you have a bunch of these different patient tiles all over the place here and all Associated to a different region which is essentially a different column you can recruit from and I should say the setting for this game is that we are a physician we are running a team of doctors trying to cure all these sick people you also have these additional tiles here where you have these space down doctor tasks which we can hire later in the game you also have these medicine kits and even these bonus tiles if you choose to acquire both a doctor and a medicine kit in the same round and you also have these non-region specific doctors at the top which will be recruited in a slightly different method I also have all the resources here so you've got the three different kind of medicines that you could administer you also have a personal playable that looks like this which is essentially divided into three different rows the first of which is where we're going to recruit
new patients into our Hospital too the second one um say we start to neglect the welfare of our patients they're going to slip into a bit more of a desperate State and then finally if we don't cure them by the time they leave this part here they're going to slip into this part here and essentially die and cost you negative points at the end of the game every player is also going to start with this identical Hippocrates tile and the doctor's tiles are going to look like this in general where at these notches it's going to show the different types of medicine that that doctor can administer so you can see here Hippocrates can actually do one of each type and if he ever cures a patient of those types he's going to gain this many victory points and however most doctors are going to look a bit different like this where they might not have the versatility to cure all the different types and they're also going to come with a cost to recruit them in the first place so the game is going to take place over four rounds and each of those four rounds is going to get divided into a certain amount of phases the first of which is the phase where you welcome new patients to your hospital and that's going to take place on this bottom part of the board here where you have these six Columns of patients all Associated to a different region now before you do anything you're going to roll all these Dice and place them on the corresponding columns matching their color and also the corresponding pip value that you've rolled so you can see here I've wrote a red one therefore I put the red one on that spot and I've also done the same for all the different colors here and then in player order based on these columns here you are going to be able to
select to take a patient into your hospital but you can only ever take somewhere where there is a dice Associated to it so let's just say me as the yellow player went to this column here like this but have a look where the die is and then I will take the corresponding patient so you can see here I might take this one here and put it on my little Hospital board like so and what this means is that at the end of this phase I'm going to take in a certain amount of income for kind of selecting that I'm going to help this person so this one's going to get me five coins but it's also going to get me a certain Boon or punishment based on where I've taken it from so you can see here I'm going to gain a victory point I'm going to gain a coin and I'm also going to gain a reputation on this reputation track here which is quite an important part of the game relating to turn order and also related to how much you need to pay each of your doctors under your employment and this process is going to happen three times but after each time you do it you're going to slide up your columns based on where you placed it last turn and that is going to determine the new player orders you can see here that this um this color player has gone right at the back here so they're going to take uh kind of last dibs when it comes to the next round and it's important to say that these dice are not re-rolled when you go through this process again so let's just say that the you know the yellow player jumped to this this column and took this action again then they're actually going to get three coins rather than claiming a tile and you also will not gain the bonus beneath it and you can probably imagine because
these dice do not get re-rolled that your options get quickly squeezed down and that is where these tokens come into play which let you mitigate those restrictions so you can see here that this token if I had it available to me lets me actually switch a um a die with another die next to it so I could actually do this like like this and therefore I'd have the option to take this um patient instead this one here lets me jump up or down on that column so you know normally if I went here I would now be able to go here and also this one here like this means that you can take the patient from the face up display at the bottom which is usually used to refresh the empty spots and you can also see that the bonuses that you get from these patients do range quite a bit especially as you get to the bottom of these columns where you can actually end up getting medicines you can end up losing reputation you can get some more of those mitigation tokens uh you can get a whole chunk of change there and all different things that you need to consider when recruiting different patients so after those three turns of recruitment you are going to take any offerings that these patients offer you so you can see here this offers me seven that one obviously before and that one offers me five so I'll take all that money from the bank and after that you are going to have to pay any doctors in your employment so you're going to start with Hippocrates who doesn't cost you anything but let's just say I had this doctor here in my appointment I'm gonna have to pay him a fee equal to my reputation here so you can see here if I'm my reputation is really strong I
might only have to pay two or even one coin for per doctor I have under my employment but if my I really let my reputation slip I might have to pay them up to five coins which can be pretty significant so once you've gone through the welcoming phase and you've paid your doctors you're gonna have the option to hire more doctors in your employment but but before you take them from the main part of the board here you're going to have the option to reserve one of these regionless doctors and when you do that you in turn order based on your reputation are going to place your reserve token here on one of these doctors at the top here so let's just say I really wanted this one here as the yellow player I could put my token on that and pay two coins but that does mean that I do not get this doctor yet I'll have to wait a little time before I do that as I'll explain shortly so once each player has either reserved or passed on the option of taking one of those regionless doctors you're going to go into the phase where you purchase these other doctors and you're going to turn them all face up so you know what's available to you and again in reputation order so starting with this player they're going to have the option to buy one of these doctors buy one of these medicine kits which you can see come in the different medicine types um or you can actually buy both as a single action so let's just say that this player here um really wanted this doctor and he really wanted this medicine kit then they could actually spend the 10 plus the 7 for 17 coins and get them both into their supply and when you buy both of them because you do have the option to just buy one or the other you're
going to get this bonus token as well and these bonus tokens can do lots of different things such as giving you extra extra money I'm giving you extra reputation and so on and much like in the welcoming phase you are not allowed to share a column with another player that round so you have to um if somebody selected a particular column then you have to go somewhere else and once everybody's finished recruiting their new doctors buying medicine kits or both then you're going to go back to your reserved doctors here at the top and then choose to pay for the remainder of their fee so you can see here that the yellow player did choose to reserve this one here and they paid their two coins but now if they wanted to still employ this doctor they could pay the remainder of that fee I.E five additional coins to also employ this one so this is kind of like a Reserve System but you're not quite sure if you want it by the end of the actual phase and once that's done all of these remaining doctors are going to slide along like this and any remaining ones here are also going to rotate around and start filling up these empty spots potentially pushing these ones off the edge like so so that they can make room for any remaining ones here like this so there's always going to be this kind of Shifting um economy of New doctors that are going to come out and be available for future rounds so once all those spaces are complete you're going to go into the healing phase where you're going to have a look at your patients and try to cure them of their illnesses so again you can see that these patients need a certain amount of potions um to cure them and they also need those
doctors to administer those potions in the first place so let's just say I wanted to cure this lady here I'm going to take this towel I'm going to try and match it with somebody who can administer those potions so you can see here that this guy can actually choose to administer both of those types as in the herbs and these um and these unguits here and when you do that you're going to plug it in like this and you're also going to spend the resources that you have there so you can see here this one requires three of these and one of these and it's important to say that you cannot actually do this unless you have those resources available to you so I can't just have them sitting there and once you do that again you're going to attach them like this however it is important to say that some of these doctors can only cure one thing at a time so for example this one um can only cure these ones here so therefore I might have to put this one like this um and I would not be able to put that on there however I could maybe let Hippocrates fill in the Gap there like this because he is still able to do that herb there so you can actually choose to team up with your doctors to cure someone or the more powerful ones might be able to administer all those medicines themselves so once you've worked out how you want to spread out your patients your doctors and your resources it might look something like this and then you're going to get a reputation Point based on every patient you've cured this term and you're also going to take the resources you're going to discard them and you're going to flip those patients over like
so and gain the corresponding amount of points here and this is going to be the main way that you gain points throughout the game so you can see I've also done this one here because again this doctor could administer these potions she needs to put oh sorry he needs a potion and I also had that potion so I can flip that one over as well and take those corresponding amount of points and another reputation and once a doctor has fully completed his contracts on these notches let's say I completed this one which obviously haven't done you can actually also flip those doctors over and take these victory points as well but as I mentioned earlier Hippocrates is a bit of an exception and you can use him again and again but let's say I completed this trap then I would actually choose to retire him and um and not be able to use him anymore meaning that I'd have to recruit a new doctor and at this point if there were any remaining patients in your waiter room they're going to slide down to the emergency room um just representing they're getting closer to death and they've been neglected and of course if that goes over another round they're going to go into the kind of death store and lose you victory points and it's essentially going to be four rounds of that of course at the end of the round you're going to go into a bit of admin you're going to clear off any of these remaining tiles here you're also going to refresh these um these patients here by sliding them all up you're going to be placing a coin on each patient that was neglected from the last round just to build a bit of an incentive and you're going to start again from scratch and of course the person with the most victory points by the end of the fourth round is going to be the winner of the game now there are another few little
things I didn't mention such as the ability to trade in three coins to take any of the potions if you're short and you can also choose to trade in these bonus tokens if you require them to take any of the potions of your choice or the medicines of your choice Additionally you can sell any of the medicines for two coins now also you do have a capacity on these kind of mitigation tokens you can hold however at any time you can actually choose to trade them in to take the corresponding bonus on the other side okay so let's share some thoughts on Hippocrates and I want to start with what I think is the Crux of the game and that is this whole networking mechanism of the patience uh the doctors and the resources themselves because they all do tie into each other and synergize to a really high standard to be honest and there's quite a taxing puzzle to overcome particularly when you are wrestling against the sounds of time you know you need to get the these things done because if you just neglect them too long you're going to start you know your patients are going to get worse and worse and eventually die and cost you all those points time and effort so I do love that kind of efficiency puzzle of yeah I need these resources I need them quickly um to do that I might need to increase my reputation because reputation ties to initiative an initiative is one of the strongest threads throughout this game and this might be one of the strongest examples of initiative being so important in a game because if you're always going last you are always going to get the dregs and that all ties back to this initial drafting system and I think initially this part of the game
does feel quite procedural and a bit of an admin phase because in the early parts of the game you might think you know I'll just take this patient and work towards it but in the future rounds you might have remaining um medicines left over or maybe you have the perfect doctor to cure that specific patient and obviously that's going to be a lot more efficient I mean that you're not going to have to kind of risk them falling into a worse State and potentially costing you those negative points but Additionally the um again the the pros and cons to go into these spots is not to be understated because um some of these really good spots here like you know if you're really short on cash you can get a huge seven coins here but it's gonna come with a cost of two reputation and you might be able to afford that because you're running ahead with things but maybe you cannot and that's going to mean you're going to slip further behind the pecking order and it already is again it ties back to that efficiency idea of needing to balance your funds um taking in probably um patients that are going to give you more money but the more patience you take in the bigger risk you're you're taking because you're gonna potentially not be able to cure them in time it means you're going to need to hire more doctors and more doctors means more wages and more wages means that you need to work more on your reputation now that being said I want to go back to my comments about a lot this game feeling procedural and that doesn't just apply to this part here and this is quite a big part of the game you know you do play three rounds of taking these patients in and it is quite restrictive you know you do not get a lot of manipulation to take what you want of course you can use those tokens um
efficiently if you want to or if you have them at your disposal which is important but a lot of the time you just feel like you know this this one's fine I'll take this one and we'll go from there and considering this is quite a big part of the game it doesn't feel like it's particularly fun you know it feels like a means to an end and you just want to do this get past this part to get to the fun part it feels like this could have been simplified and it feels a bit like not not over engineered but it feels a bit obtuse and a bit overdone um to the point where it could have just been streamlined to be in a simple draft maybe if you draft somewhere you'll go up in reputation maybe drive somewhere else you go down a reputation this feels like it's again just a bit too much going on for what you're essentially doing also something I didn't mention from the little demo there is how this game scales because regardless of the Play account you are going to play as if four players are playing because there are always going to be these neutral player pieces um on the board and when it comes to a neutral player's piece just as in you know initiative order based on the um the reputation track or on the order in which um things have been drafted here they are going to start eliminating tiles based on this numbering system because you can see here every single tile has a number associated to it which is going to be a kind of a priority order in which these things are going to get claimed so that can feel a little bit random at times um but it does do quite you know a relatively good job of um of replicating a higher Play account but that further kind of dwells on my um comments earlier about a lot of things feeling administrative and procedural because a lot of the time you
are just acting on behalf of these neutral players and rather than doing your own thing now most of the interaction does come through the scarcity of options based on the reputation order um again I want to stress how important turn order is in this game so naturally you are going to be concerned about what other players are doing because you want to be climbing higher than them um on that track to make sure you're beating them to the punch so let's talk about the production for this game and I'm going to talk a bit longer about this than I normally do because this is touted as the deluxe version so therefore I paid a premium for it and I expect a deluxe product and this is far from a deluxe product the only thing I suppose I could maybe make an argument or a case for is that this huge board here it is massive it's huge but to be honest and this is on me the game is the board is far too big it's a bit of a pain in the ass and far too much of a table hog everything else though is box standard if not worse than the average industry standard out there these are quite nice these um these wooden pillars uh these These are decent everything else is pretty poor particularly these dice uh they're awful they don't roll very well uh they're basically just big cubes very bad really bad um component and all the wooden tiles themselves are pretty shoddy uh to be honest they're very thin and we said even products that cost a fraction of this cost um come out with nicer components than this a lot of Corners have been cut here and bearing in mind this is the company who published gugon a few years back
that was an absolutely lavish production and it was Splendid really high quality just just a wonderfully produced game this one pales in comparison to that and they should be embarrassed to say this is a deluxe product because it's simply is not okay so let's get some final thoughts on Hippocrates and I think this game is solid in fact I think it's better than the average Euro game out there at the moment pretty much exclusively um because of this networking system I think this is a fantastic idea and it's a lot of fun it's strategic it's crunchy it's engaging and I think it's a really good piece of design however I do feel like almost every other aspect of this game holds it back it's stops IT reaching its full potential because all this feels like a means to an end to get to this part here so I'd have loved it to be this part fully focused on fully ironed out and the rest of it just to be simplified streamlined and just have all the fat cut off of it because I did I just don't think they adds anything to the experience and it could have been boiled down into say a 45 minute game um and cut out all the admin all those again all those procedures so I still feel there's a lot of potential here I feel like if they redesign this from the or not from the ground up they're redesign it around this part here then this could have the potential to be a big hit but unfortunately I don't feel this is the ultimate package for this game to take off so I enjoyed it I think we in fact we all enjoyed it it was a nice game and
you know there's something fun to be had here but ultimately I think the all this part is going to make this almost slide Into Obscurity and I don't think it's going to hold up to the sounds of time because the best designs are normally things that have had everything stripped out of them apart from the core elements of the gameplay and I don't think this game has done that so I think in a year or two this game is going to be completely forgotten about and that's a shame really because there is again a lot of potential here so unfortunately it's not going to be one that's going to be sticking around in my collection I would play it again but it's not something I'm gonna oh you know overtly recommend or keep around myself so that is Hippocrates