Skip to main content
Loading video...

Scythe Strategy with a top-ranked player! - The Mill

Transcript 37:07

hello and welcome to the mill I am your host dusty crane and this week is my week off that's right for the first time ever I am handing the mill over to another host and that person is none other than faux mauve if you are at all familiar with sight digital edition you are very likely familiar with foam off he's got something like over 1300 games of size played scythe played he is an avid streamer a youtuber and at one point he was ranked as high as fourth in the world for the game of size and so I really could not think of a better person to approach about putting the other a scythe strategy video in it does you don't have to be a high end player to get anything from this video you can be right there at the beginning and just really great stuff I can talk about how good it is all day long but I'm just gonna go ahead and hand the reins off to foam off I'm gonna go ahead and share his channel information and his links in the show notes so you can find him do subscribe do click that bell because you are not gonna be sorry with any of the content he's got full-length games aside but he also has he's starting a new series where he's looking at factions and mats it's terrific stuff he's already started it you can check it out on his channel without further ado take it away for mob hey guys Foam off here I want to thank dusty for giving me a chance to do a guest spot on his show let's talk some size strategy there are only two ways to win a game of side one is to race the game the second is to stall the game what do I mean by each of these racing

the game is just what it sounds like trying to be the person who places six stars first and placing them in the fewest number of terms possible the advantage to racing the game is the point you get from your six stars and from your early territory spread can be enough to win the game with a small number of coins I've won a game with a racing strategy with my total number of coins in the high 30s and when I say coins I mean total points but it's far more normal to end a game with a race strategy with your point total in the low 50s to low 60s your target number of turns for a race game is anywhere from 14 to 17 turns and while you will see race games that go faster than four it turns once you exceed 17 turns you're not really racing the game anymore your spread is going to happen most of the time toward the middle the end of your strategy but earlier than the other players because hopefully you're going fast enough but they're still working on their mid game and they're and building their economic engines while you're getting ready to end the game so what if you draw a faction in that combination that you don't think can race the game or rush the game quickly well then your option is to stall the game what does it mean to stall the game it means get ahead in total number of points of that racing player and stay ahead so that they can't in the game or that if they in the game you win there are a few

factors you combine to successfully stall the game one is to have a robust coin engine another is to get an early good number of territories and third optionally but ideally get into tier 2 popularity early what this allows you to do is get a substantial number of points you're hoping to stay ahead of the player racing the game long enough that your point total gets into the high 50s high 60s before the racing player can end the game and therefore he can't went in the game the racing player is going to hit a point ceiling at some point if you stay ahead of him long enough you'll reach a point where the racing player just can't get any more points can't win the game and then you've dragged out the game long enough for you to place your six star in a stall game you're looking to end the game in about eighteen to twenty two turns anything longer than that and another player stalling the game is going to place that six star before you and probably game so how do you race the game or stall the game the first thing you want to do is plan out your stars want to talk about the Stars inside in order of what I believe is the priority and talk about the strengths and weaknesses of each one the number one star in priority to me is the workers star some people may disagree with that and it may surprise you that I list it first but I list it first for a few reasons the first one is you're going to

get it in 95 percent of your games or more if you win the game and the reason for this is that any viable strategy inside is almost always going to employ five workers anyway which means it just takes you one more action to get to hate workers and lots of strategies inside involve eight workers from the get-go so it's going to take use Eero to one extra turns to get the worker star and anytime you can get a start with zero to one extra turns it's a great bargain additionally the largest source of points in this game is not coins it's not resources its territories and eight workers synergizes with the point system of side in that the more workers you have the more territories you can occupy by the end of the game and the more points you can score having the workers star gives you that maximum number of territories to take advantage of the largest source of points in the game of side there's no reason not to get the worker star I try to get it in every single game the second star I would list is the one that a lot of people might have listed first and that's the enlist star and the reason for this is pretty simple enlist are overpowered they're incredibly strong see an example of this you just have to look at the combat card recruit recruiting the combat hard recruit will give you to combat cards from the bonus

right off you can then get an up to an additional 11 combat cards off of your own enlist and the enlists of your neighbors this totals 13 combat cards what would it take to get 13 combat cards if you didn't enlist well you would spend at least one turn upgrading your combat art bolster and then you would have to turn around and spend at least 5 turns to get 10 combat cards that's six turns to get 10 combat cards when conversely you could get 11 combat cards from one bottom row action that's incredibly powerful also look at the coin enlist if you get it early enough you could get four coins from your own mechs and four coins from each of your neighbors mechs totaling 12 coins we said in a race strategy your total point value might be in the low 50s to low 60s that means one bottom row action could be responsible for as many as two winning percent of your total points in a game that's from one bottom row action additionally the power and lists can give you several additional power points that can get you to that power start without an additional bolster saving you a turn and the popularity of Lists is vital to any strategy where you're going to build buildings and try to stall the game popularity if your neighbors build

buildings and you get buildings as well you could be looking at a tremendous amount of popularity off that one bottom row action lists are incredibly strong it's rare if ever that you'll get to six stars and have a successful winning game without getting this a big exception to this the Bears mentioning is playing with the faction Saxony it's true that many cases Saxony can efficiently get in lists but they don't have good early access to food so in a lot of games Saxony is better off rushing the game by getting mechs workers one or two objectives and then two or three combat stars just getting the combat card in lists if possible to buff their combat cards and to more easily get their combat stars but most factions with most mats are going to get the enlist star every single game the next star I would mention is the combat star you can get two of those unless your saxony and then you can get as many as combat so you can win the combat star is rated as highly as it is on this list because of its ease in obtaining it you can get two combats in one turn just by moving there's no other way to get two stars in one turn well you can have turns where you get multiple stars for instance could produce with the patriotic board getting yourself to eight workers and at

the same time enlist getting your fourth enlist and that would give you two stars in one turn but what are you doing if you do that well you've already produced several times to get yourself to at least five workers before or or five workers before producing to get to eight and you've already produced several times to get three and lists so that two star turn is really just a culmination of a lot of other terms combat stars and give you a true two star turn where one move action can give you two stars that's a high concentration of stars per turn and you're not going to find it anywhere else in the game what's the next star the next star is mechs and mechs are important for two reasons one they give you those combats and two they allow you to move workers and expand out into territories making them extremely powerful it's going to be hard to get combats without mechs so you might as well get the next star in most games there are some faction and map combinations that employ necklace strategies they're very risky and they can be very difficult to pull off this makes the mechs are a highly sought after highly ranked very important star the next one on my list is the objective star and the objective star is valuable because of its ability to be obtained in zero to one extra turns take an objective like foundations of the Empire where you have to have six units on one particular space since you're going to

be going for the worker star in almost every game usually when you go for the worker star you either have four or five workers and you produce an additional four or three workers in either case you're going to have at least six units on one spot and you automatically get foundations of the Empire another one that's very easy to get is get rich or cry trying if your strategy involves getting 20 coins throughout the game you're going to automatically get your objective they're also territory based objectives like three farms three mountains three Tundras three forests these can be combined with movement actions that pick up combats objectives are the most commonly obtained star along with combats in turns that involve picking up three stars in a single turn any time your objective is gonna take you more than zero to one extra terms you need to seriously consider whether you should go for a different star like the power star the power star is a great star because it synergizes with two other very powerful stars combat stars and the max star because obviously it's much easier to get the pop it's much easier to get combats if you have a lot of power let's look at this patriotic board that's down here at the bottom of the screen we know that deploy is a very strong star and bolster is above deploy so if we're going to be making for max with the patriotic board and we should just look at that the amount of coin we get from making them that means we're gonna

be bolstering four times well with an upgraded bolster three times four is twelve plus the two power we're going to get from our enlist bonus that's fourteen plus our starting power with most faction it's us 216 now we're going to lose some power along the way producing but even with a few enlistment bonuses from neighbors doing upgrades it's not the Power Star is not going to be out of reach very often with the patriotic Oh so when am I going to get it if I can get the Power Star by only spending one extra turn bolstering when I don't need to deploy it's going to be worth it if I can't easily get my objective I would rather get my objective if I can move out take three farms and pick up two combats in one turn that's much better than bolstering one more time to get to sixteen power and then moving to pick up two combats or a combat and an objective but if I can't get two combats or I can't get my objective spending one extra turn getting the Power Star is definitely worth it it's not going to work with every board the patriotic board is one where you might find yourself getting the Power Star because bolster is over a very useful star deploy additionally the mechanical board also has bolster over deployed so you it's not uncommon to see people get the power star with the mechanical board but you would never see the someone get the power star with the militant board for example where upgrade is underneath bolster it's just not worth it because

one it's going to take you six different turns to get the upgrade star so you don't want to upgrade that much into with the militant board you don't even get any coin for doing it another board where you're not going to get the the power star is the innovative board we'll talk a little bit more about the innovative board in a bit but basically you're not going to want to ever build with this board which means you're not going to be bolstering much and you're not going to be getting the power star in the vast majority of games one more board where you might often get the power star as the agricultural board you see bolster is over in list and we already talked about what a powerful bottle brew action in list is which means we're going to be bolstering a lot an upgraded bolster action means that in a lot of games we can get the power star by using one extra bolster and or getting a little bit of luck by getting power from upgrades from our neighbors so what's our next star our next star is the build star and we're a ways down our list now we're getting close to the bottom why is the build star rank so low it's ranked low because it's an awkward star to get worker has to be in the place you want to build you have to have wood to build and then you have to build you can easily spend two to three actions per building lacing the build star now there are ways to get around this one is to have a lot of workers and

produce enough wood from multiple buildings at one time what's an example of this an example of this would be the mechanical board consider the mechanical board with Crimea if Crimea has one upgrade on the build then it just costs one wood plus a combat card to build a single produce that gives them for wood wood then give them enough wood for all four buildings the movement action being over build means they can dispense a worker and put it where they want it and then immediately build on that worker that saves them having to move and build move then build because they can do both in the same turn another board that has moved over build is the industrial build but you don't see people often build with the Industrial bill because not only is building slow but it doesn't give a lot of coins with the Industrial so the industrial board ends up being a board that more often than not gravitates towards brushing the game another board remove is not over bill that you will often see people build with is the engineering board the engineering board as bolster over build which means that once you built the monument and enlisted the build recruit bolster in to build gives you two popularity return that's incredibly powerful for someone looking to stall the game and get into a high tier of popularity so it's not that you'll never use the build star it's that you just know it's probably not going to be

incorporated into a race strategy building is going to happen more times than not when you're looking at a longer game and are trying to maximize your points because building allows you to get popularity building also allows you to have a higher number of total exes claimed because once you build a spot built on a spot you control that territory even if you move your workers to other areas so what's the next star the next star is the upgrade star and this is a bottom-feeder star that you're rarely ever going to get because it takes six bottom row actions to get it it's incredibly turn consuming and it's not going to happen very often when it does happen it's going to happen with a board like the patriotic board where movement is under upgrade and you're moving a lot either because you're an IFA faction slowly marching your way toward the factory or you're Palani are running around grabbing encounters I have gotten the upgrade star as Palani in numerous times with a board like the patriotic board because the encounters kept giving me oil and a few times I stole well when I was moving and then I got an encounter that gave me an upgrade for two dollars and sure enough I got the upgrade star but most of the time when I get the upgrade star it's just something that kind of happens I don't set out to do it I just reach a point in the game where I have three or four upgrades and I start to ask myself would it make more sense

to go for the upgrade star than should try to get different star but most of the time you're not going to set out to it the upgrade star you're gonna let it come to you which leads us to the last star and that's when you should never intentionally go for the popularity star it's just not worth it it takes too many actions and popularity is too hard to get in this game to make it worth it to go for the popularity star now you get a popularity Factory card you bounce around the board grabbing encounters and you find yourself at 15 or 16 popularity your neighbour builds you can get the popularity star in zero to one extra turns okay you may go for it but if that doesn't happen if you ain't if you can get a six star in any other way you're better off going for something else in the popularity star if you find yourself two turns away from the popularity star and there are no better options four stars there's a good chance that you could have played more efficiently to put yourself in a better spot so we've talked about the stars and their priority now how do you go about getting those stars well one piece of advice I would give you is to distribute workers to match your bottom row actions in the beginning you need to decide whether you're going to go with 5 or 8 workers why do I say 5 or 8 well mathematically the best number of workers are 3 5 7 & 8 why is this the case well 3 is the greatest number of workers you can have

and not pay power 5 is the greatest number of workers you can have and not pay popularity 7 is the greatest number of workers you can have and not pay coin a workers gives you a star you don't see seven workers very often in this list because it takes the Sun the same number of produce actions to get 7 as 8 and 7 doesn't give you a star so going for 7 just adds an extra turn to your game because you're going to need to get that worker star eventually so let's take 7 off our list and unless you're Tagawa 3 workers just isn't enough to run an efficient engine the vast majority time so you're probably going to go with 5 or 8 workers 5 workers is good for rush & stall strategies where you're trying to maintain popularity so let's talk about how we might distribute our workers if we have 5 the Industrial Board gives us a really good example we would put at least 3 workers on metal and we would put 2 workers on the farm that allows us to produce straight in to deploy and then trade for to food combine it with the to food we already have for producing to immediately enlist let's see what we're doing we're setting up our workers so that when we perform a top row action we can immediately perform the bottom row action if you're producing but at least three workers on a mountain don't have to workers on a mountain don't get a mech every two or three turns you produce deploy every time you produce if at all possible let's look at the patriotic board enlist

is under produce so if you're going to produce have workers on a farm and had at least three workers on a farm also I want to mention that sometimes players are reticent to over produce resources this can actually be a good strategy to overproduce resources a lot of times you'll see experienced players put four workers on a farm with me or well why would they do this because after three productions they've produced twelve total food and spent nine out of three and lists this means that they have three foods sitting on the board which is exactly as much as they need for one list this means they can move there for workers to something like metal reduce metal and use the three food they have leftover to get their last and list there for combining their last enlist into their first produce for metal anytime you can do something in one turn that normally takes two terms that's incredibly efficient so don't be afraid to over produce resources also keep coercion in mind if you're playing with Crimea and you're distributing your resources let's look at the industrial board again Hermia has two options they can put two workers on metal and three on food trade for something other than food and then use a card for their fourth food and a card for their third metal or they can put three workers on metal like we talked about and two on food trade for

food to enlist and produce to deploy keeping their cards for combat so you have different options with Crimea get creative with coercion don't feel like you have to use the faction ability there are great strategies that involve not spending cards as Crimea but keep in mind it changes worker placement when do you consider upgrading when you're placing your workers consider getting an upgrade when it can reduce one or more produce actions take the patriotic board for example if I get two upgrades that would allow me to upgrade my move which is very powerful and upgrade my bolster which is also powerful but the big thing it does is it makes my deploy instead of costing for metal costing too that's going to save me a significant number of production actions down the line which is why it's often worth it to get one or two upgrades with the patriotic board so what's my next piece of advice avoid naked --mx what do I mean by a naked neck and naked mech is a mech that has no workers on it mechs just exist in this game for two reasons besides being beautiful and awesome edible one is combats two is claiming territory workers actually serve a role in combat and I'm not talking about people's army what I'm talking about is that people are more reticent to attack a mech that has workers with it than a mech that is

by itself a mech that is by itself is the dream for a player in tier 2 or tier 3 popularity they can find the character or mech with no workers on it that is their number one target because they can get that coveted combat star with losing popularity what if I'm in Tier one and I don't care about popularity well if I've gone to eight workers and a lot of tier one strategies will if I bump all your workers there's a good chance I can't produce anymore so I can't attack your Mac I can't risk losing all that popularity because I still have to produce so keep those workers with the Mac for combat reasons but even more than combat reasons keep those workers with those Mac's because those mechs exists to spread those workers across the board and give you territory which we've already said is the biggest source of points inside a mech that's away from workers all by itself as a mech that has to move back to workers before it can move and distribute workers there are a few exceptions to this one exception is the last move of the game when you're spreading out and getting the maximum amount of territory you can just throw those mechs willy-nilly all by themselves just to grab those extra spots the only other one that really comes to mind for me is that if your engine is still running and you don't want to move your workers off the spots they're on but you see an opportunity grab one or more cheap combats it can be worth it to move a mech away from your

workers to grab those combats but in general eat workers with the Mac's because that's what the mechs are there for moving the workers the next thing I'd say is be mindful of coins but don't let coin control your strategy completely there are some people who say look at your mat figure out which actions give you the most coin and do those actions over and over again the board that resembles this the most closely is the engineering board where upgrades can actually pay off and buildings can actually pay off pretty dramatically but even with the engineering board if you have an economy based faction like rust Fiat they're probably not going to go for the build star just because it's so slow but the best example of when you shouldn't let coin count control your strategy is the innovative board the innovative board is the best and strongest board in the game or one simple reason reduces over deploy and is over enlist the two most powerful top row actions are over the two most powerful bottom row actions this means your ideal game with the innovative board you're producing deploying moving in and listing producing deploying moving in and listing you don't want to bolster it all you're trying to pick up two combats off your starting power plus what you get off the enlist and you're looking to minimize trades as much as possible

innovative Russ Viet can it consistently in the game in twelve turns you know I've seen innovative Nordic in the game in 13 turns the innovative board is incredibly fast but what do you notice about it if you're looking at coin count build and upgrade are your greatest source of coins so you might think like the engineering board you're going to be building and you're going to be upgrading it's a trap but the innovative board do you ignore the coins you go for your it max your enlist your combat your objective and your worker you rush the game all it a day there's not a whole lot of viable alternatives when you're playing with it is possible to run an economy game in tier 2 popularity but that's just not the strength sport the next thing I would say is don't over value Encounters encounters can be incredibly strong early game but towards the mid to late game they lose most of their power let's take an example $2 for for food is incredibly strong when you have 2 workers and the most you can get out of the trade action is 2 resources of your choice why is that well one coin with the trade action could get you to food but two dollars with or for food essentially allows you to take to trade actions in one turn saving you a turn that's incredibly strong if your encounter can translate into an entire turn for King it up well once I get my

engine running and I get eight workers on the board if one produce action gives me 4 metal and for food that's a lot stronger than paying to popularity for to metal and to food which is another counter option so don't spend the whole game hunting those encounters unless your Polonia because Polonia has meander of course and can pick two of the options on the encounter cards la dia can functionally run an entire game engine out of encounters if there aren't too many players in the game and they're able to map anywhere from you to 5 total encounters but even Palani will find that at some point in the mid to late game encounters aren't really going to offer Palani at any additional why well once you have enough metal for your mechs and a food for your list you decided you're going for to combat your objective your worker star but else are you looking to get out of an encounter maybe a little popularity but if you've already got the tier of popularity that you're looking to get you're not going to get much more out of any honor exceptions we already alluded to if you just need that one more popularity go up its here sure go ahead and grab it better to move and get an encounter than just trade for a single popularity but other than that you want to get encounters early in the game but toward the middle to late am don't over value don't place that much stock in them they're not that great

the next thing I would say and this is in valuable skill and has a lot to do with going from mid tier to a high tier player and that is learning to bluff combat new players will throw 12 in every combat they intend to win with one unit and throw one power in every combat they expect to lose well there's a problem with this approach and that is if I know you're gonna throw one I'll jump right in and hit you with a unit and throw to power or three power or a four card and then you've just let me get off with a completely cheap combat you let a saxony player do this and they'll in the game before anyone's had a chance to move very far out of their home pace so how do you Bluff combat always be looking at what the other player stands to gain out of playing a little bit of power or stands to gain out of calling your bluff a player with very little power might not be able to afford calling your bluff and you might be able to Bluff and very successfully a player with a lot of power might be able to afford it calling a bluff and it might be difficult to defeat a player who has a lot of power by playing very little on your part so you want to look for a few things how is the player handled combats thus far in the game do they go all out when they want to win and go very low and they

intend to lose see what their patterns are also look for players who nearly have the power star someone sitting on 13 power with an upgraded bolster might not be willing to throw power in a combat they expect lose so you see a character all by itself on that mountain tunnel and the player has 13 power and an upgraded bolster send three units to it and then drop a four card and see what happens there's a good chance that player threat just throws a card and saves his fives if you play it successfully and you get a little bit lucky you just got a combat without having to dig into your I'm back card or your power reserves significantly at all so send multiple units to bluff target players with high power as well as PAP players with low power to Bluff talk about a few specific numbers we already mentioned four is a great note why is four great number or is great for anybody you expect to play a card but don't expect to spend power because someone who doesn't spend power most of the time is not gonna throw five now don't count this as a given if the player has zero power and a bunch of cards but typically players hold their fives and don't throw more than a four if they're just looking to cycle cards six is often one of the defender might play if they expect that an attacker is bluffing if throw maybe one power to five card or two power and a four card thinking well if the attacker throws nothing but a card I'll win so sometimes attackers

throw six expecting the defender might expect them to Bluff and they're trying to catch a bluff so some defenders throw seven trying to beat an attacker you throw six and so forth luffing is a head game and it's complex you'll see experienced players randomly thirst seven or eight or nine because they're expecting the player across from them to throw one of the numbers just below look thing you can look at with players is how much power they can spend leaving themselves at least one power why does this matter take for example a player who has three workers on a village and looks like they're about to produce to get the power star well if they're sitting on five power and they spend five power they're going to have to spend a whole turn bolstering to get that power back before they can producing it the worker star so calculate that they might not spend more than four power and a five card so maybe you would throw nine in that scenario taking a little bit of a risk ten could guarantee it for you but if it comes down to it you might be able to get by with assuming that you're the defender is going to hold on to it some power to produce don't get trapped by this if you're looking at a Tagawa player with three workers they don't need the power to produce but always keep in mind with the incentives of the other player are when it comes to throwing power or holding power and you're engaging on that getting good at predicting other

players in combat is the difference between a good player in this game and great play this game my final word of advice to you is lay the game there are 47 different faction mat combinations in everyone plays a little different it's an asymmetrical game where the experience is widely varied as the faction you get Matt you get paired with it one of the things that keeps me coming back to this game over and over again is how much variety there is and you find a strategy you like write it down it doesn't mean you have to play it that way every time but the very best players at this game get good at this game in large part because they find on in optimizing and perfecting ideal strategies and sequences and moves so don't be afraid to keep up with what you're doing and always try to improve it finally have fun play the game and have fun it goes without saying that players who burn out and stop playing the game don't get better at it the point of playing the game ultimately is to enjoy yourself and I hope you enjoyed this video until next time catch you later all right hey what did you think about that there was just there's a ton to think about I already told them I'm gonna watch this thing two or three times so leave a note in the comment hit him subscribe his channel hit the bell

make sure you're finding out about all of his streams and all the stuff that he's doing and watch those those videos he's putting together the faction and mat combinations you're not going to regret it thanks to him again this is probably one of my favorite videos and I'm barely gonna be in it but that's probably gonna make it everyone else's favorite too so until next week take care of yourselves and each other thanks for watching bye

Progress saved