Inventions: Evolution of Ideas Board Game | My Solo First Impressions
Transcript
hello everybody Welcome to toally tabled my name is Shaggy and today I'm going to give you my quick first impressions of inventions evolution of ideas I made a full solo playthrough of invention so please go check that out if you haven't because in this video I'm going to assume you've either watched that playthrough or you know how the game works I've only played inventions four times and they've all been solo so please keep that in mind as you listen to my thoughts also keep in mind that I'm a huge fan of heavy Euro games and vital lerta heavy Euro games in particular so I'm kind of hardwired to enjoy inventions and no surprises I absolutely love it in fact in my opinion this is vital serta's best game for solo play to date it's certainly my favorite clearly his games are designed around a multiplayer experience first with solo being a second mode and personally multiplayer is my preferred way of playing lerta games all things being equal I'd want you know four players for kban and you know maybe three for the gallerist and venos and probably two for Liz boen on Mars two or three all of his games play great at three I think weather machine was maybe the first time where I felt like solo was on par with multiplayer for me personally now with invention
solo is my preferred way to play you know and you have to keep in mind again I have not played it multiplayer so you take this with a grain of salt but the reason I say that is due entirely to you know what is the star mechanism in Inventions which is the action chaining system this system lets you take an action and then spin a chain token in order to take another action but each action allows you to chain into other actions in different ways some actions like inventing or sharing an invention don't allow you to chain it all right they're they're kind of dead ends and some actions let you take other actions without needing a chain token at all like presenting an idea or the Eureka action for example and you're limited in how many chain actions you can take right the number is tied to your influence so you need to be building up your influence over the course of the game in order to perform those super turns where you're just taking chain after chain after Chain by the end of the game it is very possible to be taking six or seven actions on a single turn and when you pull that off it feels amazing you really have to think of your turn as a journey of actions often times I know where I want my destination to be but there are usually multiple Journeys that can take me there right like I might really want to invent an idea well if I have two chain tokens I could
probably come up with an Epic Journey of actions that will end in inventing depending on where I'm able to place my pillar unlike a lot of worker placement or action selection games where you know you're going to place your worker in this case a pillar onto an action and then that's going to be the action that you take here your pillar action is just the beginning of that journey and I really like how the pillar restrictions work because you know other than the first round of the game you're limited to eight of the 10 actions and then six of the 10 and then four and because your opponent isn't blocking you you're just blocking yourself you're able to plan all three of your pillar movements at the beginning of each era obviously changes in the board State might change what you want to do but ultimately you're in control unlike a lot of worker placement games you can make long-term plans or at least you know era long-term plans and then pivot tactically and I really like that and when you couple the pillar system with the chaining system there always seems to be a way to get around being blocked from an action there just always seems to be some Journey that you can take to get you where you want to go but finding it isn't always easy or obvious one of my favorite things in board gaming is comboing and coming up with these com convoluted unexpected ways of
accomplishing goals especially when you can set those things up in advance and in Inventions that's a fundamental part of the design it's Central to the game for me I can't ask for anything more which is why I was surprised to read a bunch of comments complaining about the chaining system and most of those complaints centered around just how much AP players can get trying to come up with those Journeys because it's not good enough to just take an action right you need to take multip actions and that can definitely lead to a ton of analysis paralysis in a four-player game that would be unbearable but that's the great thing about playing solo there is no AP there's just a and you can analyze to your heart's content because there's nobody waiting for you overanalyzing and pondering your turn is one of the joys of solo gaming and the chaining system encourages that it's a boon for solo play but it's definitely a detriment to multiplayer play particularly for those first games where reading the board and seeing those Journeys is really going to take a lot of time now that goes away after a few plays you start to see those Journeys much more easily they make sense you understand where Journeys need to start where they need to end and
honestly the design of the game works really well to make that information really visible and easy to read once you know what to look for once you have a little bit of experience under your belt I think a lot of the negative comments I was reading were probably mostly first play opinions and overreactions and honestly like I'll be blunt I just don't care about your opinions after one play like yes this is a heavy year game your first play is going to be rough like no kidding those thoughts just are worse than useless and they might give someone the false impression of what the game feels like you know once you get over that initial learning curve I'm giving my first impressions of games after you know three to five plays four plays in this case even that's not enough for me to be comfortable calling it a full review so just know that this chaining system the AP comes better but still this is not a game I'd want to play at fourever or even three really just as a quick little side note here an example of what I would consider to be a first play opinion that you may run into out there I'm not sure is this idea that the inventing action is weak somehow or not as strong as some of the other actions and it's funny because you know I felt the same way in my first play but then the game opened up and I saw how everything fits together the fact is
inventing is critical to filling up your board your your progress board and scoring those wealth tiles and completing goals and getting those tech tiles which again seem weak at first but once you get a little bit of experience you see just how extremely valuable those can be they're letting you take multiple core actions so that's so that's the kind of stuff I'm talking about when I talk about first play overreactions and similarly I think calling this you know one of his more complex games is also maybe a little bit of that first play overreaction there's a lot of rules you know that's par for the course first play is going to be a little rough I think the rule book is extremely well done there's a few small you know issues here or there that's again to be expected after a few games it really comes together together things start to make sense and in my opinion I found it easier to play more streamlined and more straightforward than many of his games now again that's coming from someone with a lot of experience playing these games but the way you score points the way you get those tiles your goals the way an idea gets invented and then gets innovated upon and then gets shared that whole Cy that whole Evolution it's pretty straightforward especially
compared to something like kbon where you know getting those cars out and and the designs and testing the design and all that stuff that's a much more convoluted process and once again Eno tool has done a fantastic job of laying everything out the icons the the graphic design everything is is really really visually clear apart from just a couple of things the steps of each action are laid out both in icons on the board and then in words with these little play raids off to the side again after those first couple of plays it really comes together and makes sense the complexity really lies in the chaining in the idea that okay I understand all these 10 actions but now I'm doing four of them I'm doing five of them one after the other so to my mind I think this one is easier to pick up than say weather machine or even on Mars for that matter I also find that the theme helps I I know what people are going to say they're going to say that this game isn't thematic that it lacks some of the Thematic connections that are I think Hallmarks of L certo's earlier designs and I'm not sure that's entirely true I think what's different here is that in so many of lta's games the theme is typically zoomed in you play as a worker
in a car factory or as the owner of a gallery or as a wine maker you're often one character moving around it's very zoomed in here we've zoomed all the way out you know no more attending meetings and getting yelled at by your boss no we're covering the scope of human history you're no longer a character but rather you know one of the Godlike forces that we get to play in so many different board games and so because of that it definitely sort of feels less thematic but I think the theme actually helps to learn the game and to understand the systems the idea of getting these mil stones and using those to create ideas that then get invented the way these things travel around the world I don't know as abstracted as it is I found that I really enjoyed the theme but be aware for you and I think for maybe many people this is going to feel like a much less thematic experience than the typical lerta didn't bother me but it might bother you and I think the last thing that I'll talk about here since I've been babbling on for quite a while is I found this to be a much less tight and confrontational game than a lot of his others you know I never really found myself getting too angsty about what they were taking where they were going what actions they were taking now part of that is because again you're not
being blocked on that main action board with your pillars you're blocking yourself so you have so much control and if you go to one of their spots you're just giving them two points you know that's no big deal occasionally it' be like oh I really want to invent that idea or I really want to present that um invention not ideal I really want to present that invention so that I can get that particular wealth tile so there's definitely moments like that but because of the chaining because of how open it is I always felt like there was a way no matter what they did there was a way that I could make it work do what I wanted to do even if it took me a extra turns no big deal now that's very different than some of lta's other games like kbon I always go back to kbon because it's my favorite but you know that is a knif fight in a phone booth every move that your opponent makes you know you're living and dying by it so this is a very different vibe and that could be a negative for some people or a positive depending on what you're looking for if you're maybe a couple that really likes heavy games but you don't want it to be very confrontational and a little bit more Live and Let Live then this might be exactly what you're looking for to me you know I like both you know so uh I don't necessarily have a preference one way or the other it was kind of nice as a solo experience because it meant that I could kind of really get into like doing the comboing and and sort of getting exactly the combos that I wanted and I wasn't feeling like you know the randomness of
the solo opponents were kind of getting in my way arbitrarily or in a frustrating way now that's not to say that the game is easy because it's not it's really difficult although I think I'm getting better I'm getting better I'm learning I also think the solo mode is very well done you know you're kind of running two opponents but Kronos is so easy entirely predictable literally takes 10 seconds once you learn how to do it very easy hephestus is more difficult more lengthy of turns right much more like a regular player but also straightforward there aren't like complicated decision trees that you have to parse out right you just sort of flip that card they're going to take an action they move to the first place where they can take that action it's not like you're having to decide what's the best place for them and then they just go through a series of steps again you know it's you're not really having to make decisions for them and I just found the cognitive load in running them was very easy the most annoying part was really when they get one of those progress tiles they can't double up and so you have to check to make sure they don't have that one and then if they do you go to the next one and so that whole process is like a little fiddly it would be great if they could just like grab one real quick and it it was really simple but that's a minor complaint I think the solo mode works great the only last thing that I really want to mention is a warning about replayability because
I know a lot of people conflate replayability with variability and what I'm about to say here is true of every ler game I think the replayability of his games don't necessarily come from extreme levels of variability with inventions it's always going to be the same puzzle just different right I recently talked a lot about void fall another heavy Euro game and in that game there is so much variability there are so many ways that you can change that game and make it a very different experience it's like a new different puzzle not just the same puzzle but different inventions is much more along the lines of something like Halls of hegra again a game that every time you play it's the same puzzle but different for me desite that lack of variability I still find lerta games to be incredibly replayable because I enjoy the core systems and mechanism so much I enjoy the Tactical decision-making that you have to that you have to go through but I know for some people they're going to want the sort of the Void fall the Robinson Caruso type of Replay ability where you can have vastly different games game after game it really depends on what you're looking for I like both types and I plan on playing inventions dozens of times and I doubt that I'm ever going to get tired of it but it is something you should be aware of I can definitely imagine a lot of people feeling like the
the replayability is lacking so there you go I talked way longer than I meant to you can't get me started on some of these games I just talk forever but until next time thank you so much for watching and goodbye