Skip to main content
Loading video...

►►► Exclusive rules update in this video makes it a keeper!

Transcript 11:18

Hey everybody, the following is an excerpt from the monthly Roto Rounds Up and if you'd like to see the rest of the round up, you can hit that eye up in the top right corner of the screen or if you'd like to know more about the game, you can follow the link down the show notes. And with that out of the way, let's talk about Moon, which uh I know I'm way late to the party on this. I think everybody else has covered this game a couple of years ago, but I finally got my hands on it cuz I've wanted to play this for a long time. Because uh designer artist Håkon Gaarder, uh I'm a big fan of his. His two previous games in this series of small box Euros were Streets and oh, what was the other one? Oh, Villagers. Both of which I've covered on the channel, both of which are wonderful little games and so I had high hopes. Plus I'd heard nothing but good things about Moon over the years. So anyway, finally got my hands on it, finally got to try it, think it's great. Probably the best of Håkon's uh you know, trilogy of games.

But there's one problem with it, but I'll come to that in a second. First off, let me tell you what I love. This is game where we are competing to be the best at building up a moon base um by you know, meeting the needs of all our astronauts so that they will give us basically thumbs up. We earn hearts uh in this game for how well we meet their needs. And this is a close hand card drafting game. I got a big old hand of cards. I'm going to pick one for myself. I have several different things I can use with it. I'm going to hand the rest of the cards over to you. You're going to hand them to me. We're going to go back and forth, back and forth and I'm hoping hey, I'm going to build this card now because it'll give me what I need for the other card and I hope it comes back to me on my next turn so I can complete, you know, Seven Wonders, Sushi Go style stuff. This uh is a great mechanism. I'm always a fan of it and um you know, it's it's very well done here.

These multi-use cards that you've got, you know, because you can always trash a card for a resource or you can build it. And over the course of game, you start off small, but by the end of the game you've made huge um investments in your moon base bringing in tons of resources at the beginning of rounds having tons of access to attributes that you can you know combo together in lots of different ways you know there's like four or five different types of cards there's one time you know anytime you want actions there are passive abilities there's in game scoring cards and there's just a ton of variety and every time you play you're going to get you know a lot of opportunities to best develop um oh and then also every time you play it's got a very nice objective system in a two player game I believe there are going to be nine objective cards that players are racing to be the first to complete all of this stuff is phenomenal it all has a great look to it as well a clean elegant aesthetic to it that Haakon's games always do so there's a lot here I love I really enjoyed this game and it really should come in much higher on my monthly ranking there's only one problem in addition to the structures you build you know whether it's you know water reclamation plant or or a hot dog stand you know there's a real sense of humor to the game as well you you also focus on building toilets for your moon base in addition to those cards that we hand back and forth you know in the close hand draft each player has a what do

they call them an expedition card it's the card from earth that brought all these elements to the moon that we are then kind of drafting between ourselves and so we hand these expedition cards back and forth this is a brilliant system because you know these cards are a special power we get to use so every turn a new special power shows up in my hand in addition to hey whatever one of these cards I'm going to use to build or you know whatever I'm going to do I'm also going to get to use this special power and there's a wide variety of them and on the fact that every time you play you're going to get access to different special expedition cards is going to mix it up even more. That sounds great, right? Here's the problem. One card will always be in every single game. It's the card that actually determines who the first player is and it gives you a special power which is trash one of the cards in your hand and then draw a new card so that oh if if what's this in handed me and I get that power and like oh there's nothing good in this hand. Well, okay, I guess I'll get rid of one of these cards and maybe I'll draw what I really like.

That's fine. What it means is oh I have more flexibility. When I get this card I've got basically an extra card I can choose from to decide what I'm going to build. That's a great power you know along the lines of what the other powers are like extra production and all other kinds of things. Here's the problem with it. The fact that you have to trash a card and in a two-player game this card is always there. Every other turn you will get this power and you want to make good use of it. But here's the problem. I'm looking at a hand of five cards. Okay, these three cards I want these to stick around. These are all great. But I want to draw a new card cuz I maybe I'll get something even better than one of these, right? But that means I've got to trash a card. So these other two cards that I don't care about well I should trash one of these. Which one am I going to trash? Whichever one you need desperately.

And that's going to happen every in a two-player game cuz you get this power every other turn. Every other turn I need to look over at your board and say oh boy, it would really suck for you if this card got trashed, wouldn't it? Boom, it's gone, trashed. Every other turn, 50% of the game I spend my time looking over and saying boy, you really need this little rover, don't you? And this is the only way you can get it, isn't it? Trashed. And now I'm going to draw a new card cuz I don't need this card but I know you do so I'm just going to burn it. And maybe I'll get what I maybe I'll get something new. Maybe I don't even care. The fact that 50% of this game is a two-player now at a higher player count. If I were playing a four or five player game, it would be only be one out of every four or five turns I would have to do it and maybe I would find it acceptable.

You know, but as a in a two-player game when I only have one other opponent, it is very easy to at a glance see what my opponent wants. See what type of building what you know, because I can see what the objectives are. I can see how close you are to getting that objective and this is the card that would let you do it. Burned. I hate this. Why is this here? It's just a constant omnipresent Hey, how can I screw my opponent every single time because there's always going to be cards I want to keep of the cards I don't want to. THE ONLY WAY I CAN decide which of these ones to get rid of is which one is most valuable to you and I wish it wasn't here. I wish this card, which again is a useful card because hey, it means oh, when I get this card, good. I have one extra card to choose from. Why couldn't it just be that?

Hacoon, why couldn't it just be hey, when this card says oh, draw card from the top of the deck, temporarily add it to the hand so I've got one extra card I can choose from and if I choose not to use that card, just discard that card. But no, the rules go out of your way TO SAY NO, THAT'S THE ONE YOU CAN'T discard because you must trash something before you draw. And it's LIKE OKAY, SO YOU'VE designed it in a lab to be as impactful to my opponent as possible and the fact that I have TO DO IT THROUGHOUT the game. It's just I drove me nuts and you know, you know, my wife too. She was like, why do we have to keep making this choice? Why is this here? Good news everyone, it's not here anymore because I heard from Hacoon, the designer and he has come up with a beautiful, simple, elegant little home brew variant that as far as I'm concerned is official because it's from the designer. It's not just some rando with a YouTube channel coming up with a solution. This is a game saver for me and Jen. Moon will now live on my shelf because of this very simple rules change. It makes it just better across the board. Here's the deal. When you're setting up that expedition card that's supposed to be all about trashing a card every round to draw a new one, leave it in the box. It stays on Earth. We do not need it on the moon. And instead, every new age, all players draw a new expedition card. This is a huge

improvement because it means at lower player counts, you're going to see more new expeditions instead of half of the game, one of the expeditions being the same every single round. So, this is better across the board. Hakon, that's why you're the professional and I'm just a professional bellyacher. Nicely done, sir. I highly recommend this to everybody. Now, let's get back to me bellyaching. And it just you know, broke me down. And it breaks my heart because everything else about this game is top-tier, best-of-class stuff. The presentation is great, the sense of humor is great, the engine building is incredibly rich and satisfying, the variety from the cards I get and the the combination of objectives we're chasing after. It also has a really great little expansion, the Valkyrie expansion, that adds these up Doesn't matter. All this stuff is great, but at the end of the day, if I'm spending 50% of my turns trying to figure out, right, what do you need most in life?

Then, it's not a keeper for me and Jen. Sadly, heartbreakingly, that is what brings Moon in to number 11 of the month. If that card were just the tiniest bit tweaked, this would totally be a keeper. This would probably go into my top 10 favorite blind what do you call it? Blind drafting, you know, along with Seven Wonders, Sushi Go, those types of games. I've got a bunch of these games I love, and this would have been one of them. But all those other games, they don't constantly put me in a situation where I am trying to figure out, right, what is the best way I could destroy your chances at happiness. I'm over exaggerating. For Oh, sure, yeah, I mean, it's not going to set you back. Yeah, I got rid of a card you want. But for me and Jen, the you know, the omnipresence of it just wore us down, and in the end, uh that's what brings Moon in to number 11.

But again, I can't stress enough, this is a phenomenal design. And if you don't mind, or if you're willing to make the simplest little tweak, uh you know, a very easy to implement house rule, um man, this is, like I said, best of class stuff. Number 11, Moon. Oh, wait, and before we move on, one thing I forgot to mention, thanks very much to Sliker Drips Tom Heath for doing a great run-through of Moon. I have not covered it on my channel, but Tom was there for me. Um there is a link down in the show notes so you can go check out his full run-through and decide for yourself how much fun this game looks like, and was I talking crazy talk? Oh, man, Moon, you're good stuff. M O O N, that spells Sliker Drips. Thanks, Tom. And thanks for watching, folks. If you enjoyed it, please like and subscribe.

It makes a huge difference, believe me. But with that out of the way, if you'd like to see some more over in the left, you can find a playlist of a whole bunch more Rado Rapid Reviews. Up in the top right, there's the latest thing that's been added to the channel, and in the bottom right, you've got something YouTube recommends. Okay, folks, thanks for watching.

Progress saved