Skip to main content
Loading video...

Cape May Discussion - Friendly Ties Podcast

Transcript 52:27

hello everyone and welcome to friendly ties i'm here today with my friends jonathan and anastasia and we are here to talk about the board game cape may not the place in new jersey but the board game uh although maybe we should go one in the same like i don't know yeah that would be really just a wonderful idea right we changed this into a travel channel um cape may is a 2021 release by thunderworks and uh it's a game where you uh wander around this board purchasing property um and then kind of upgrading that property throughout the course of the game uh meanwhile viewing birds and uh teleporting around with special action cards and then at the end uh competing for uh area control these these various um areas of this of this quaint coastal town uh we played this game because uh anastasia you picked it up so why don't you kick us off today yeah i suggested this game for us for two reasons one is yes i picked up a cheap copy and i as i often do want to see if i like a game or if i want to let that copy go but the other reason is i was really attracted to the theme of this game i thought i looked at it this is totally one of those like judge box by its cover kind of situation i was like ooh town historic houses or i guess they're not historic if you're actually building them at the time but whatever old houses

history small town landmarks i was i was in i was in i love that and i was like this looks super fun so we played this one a few times i've actually only played this one once in the stage you played with the most out of all of us i think right yeah we played it once the three of us nick and i played it once two player and then we played both of those games on tabletop simulator and because i actually did own a copy and it's got these really cool like little chunky pieces minis little houses kind of things i wanted to play it once in person so i did that with a friend of mine last week the plastic houses are very pretty they are very pretty so one thing that really jumped out to me for this game uh first of all was the board the look of it overall because you've got just these squirrely little paths with arrows on them all over the place and you know the base thing that you're doing in this game is moving around a single pawn down these roads and you're uh playing cards to do that we'll talk about that in more detail later on but really the first thing that jumped out to me was was the look of it like i i couldn't remember seeing a game that looked exactly like that it was almost kind of like a maze with just a bunch of empty lots where you're hopefully going to be investing in the town right right right i mean i've seen some criticism online and i'm going to say criticism lightly because i i've actually my opinion on this has changed playing this game but i've seen some commentary that this game is sort of monopoly plus right it's sort of like you are wandering around streets

paying to build on plots of land and placing your houses down on them essentially and you know when i first read that i thought oh you know i don't know i actually love monopoly so i don't know why i thought that was a bad thing because i think monopoly is a great game but you know i understand that there is a certain hesitation stigma yes thank you but as i played it and as i played it with a friend of mine who isn't a big gamer the monopoly comparison actually worked beautifully really helped to explain the game really helped to get the game and honestly it kind of is monopoly plus like in a great way like you do you get to wander around and build things and it is actually better in a lot of ways than just the kind of capitalistic greed fest that monopoly is but we could talk about that more yeah it's interesting so one thing that jumps out about monopoly and you know a lot of very older games is the whole idea of roll and move that you would roll dice and then move that number of spaces and then do whatever you do when you get there and this game doesn't use roll and move um it uses card play but we actually read a designer diary for this anastasia you sent this one out and it was really fascinating and one thing that was mentioned is that early on i think this was actually a roll and move game and they moved into a more interesting card play movement system and uh what do you think about that one i think the card play system for movement is really elegant and and super interesting

so just to everyone who's listening knows basically you have the cards one through seven and if you want to move on your turn you play one of those cards and move that number of spaces uh the ones and sevens cost more money and the ones in the middle like three fours and fives are free to play and it just tells you how many spaces you can move and you could spend an action to pick up all your cards but this is a really neat mechanic because you're thinking about oh i want to move here to buy this and then you're moving kind of like kitty corner around a block to maybe interact with a space that is adjacent or in the same neighborhood block uh and all of a sudden these like numbers one through seven kind of matter it's it's instead of like a rolling move it's a chosen move with with those limitations and uh it's actually it's it's cleverly implemented i think i found that i frequently was really upset with previous me like i'm sitting there thinking about my turn and i was like all right i just have to move three i already used my three yeah yeah yeah but it's fun because it yeah well you know i've talked about this before concordia is one of my favorite games of all time and i love that idea of you know select one card and play it and and it really reminds me of that obviously all you're doing is moving but the way you're thinking about what can i do and having this plethora of options to choose from that that are you know limited by the sequence of cards and the sequencing but what it also does is really cool and nick you actually did this or attempted to do this and there's some reasons why you weren't able to that word completely out

of your control but nick in our first game attempted to play like his own minigame where he never picked his cards back up he wanted to play the whole game i'm talking for you nick but you want to play the whole game basically not not picking up your cards right yeah yeah and i nearly pulled it off the way that you can do that is that there are ways to move that don't include using those one through seven cards they're kind of the special are they called action cards or do they have a different name they're called activity cards that that's that's what does that but before we jump into those i just i wanted to point out that what i realized when you were doing that nick is that this game does something very unique at least in my opinion so this is this is a it's not a lightweight game this is like a medium a medium lightweight game wouldn't you guys agree yeah like it's a step above ticket to ride but it's not it's not crazy heavy like this is a great game for your friends or family that like enjoys a like a game that like asks them to do more stuff than you know ticket to ride but not so much that they're like it's gonna be an hour teach and take three hours to play or anything like that so it just falls in that in that like kind of perfect kind of mid-weight game and yet one of the cool things about it is that if you are playing this game and say you're a nick who is obviously very good at a lot heavier games than this you can kind of vary your experiences with it so you could play it with someone who's

like just playing it very straight and then if maybe you're a gamer who likes to have your experience you could sit there and be like i'm gonna play my own mini game trying to play my cards in a certain order or do something and i just think that that's really cool and not not something that i see happen a lot in games like that you mentioned there's something in there that that to me is one of the biggest points about this game or biggest thing that i think about with this game is that you know you called it like light medium or medium on that side more than ticket to ride and i am generally a gamer who as you just pointed out prefer i prefer heavier games for the most part so i know that i'm not the target audience for this kind of game but i really like for a game to um be very honest or accurate for what it's supposed to be and one of the things with this game is that i actually wish it was a bit lighter i wish that that some of the the edges were just sanded down a little bit more uh and so that i could have um you know we've even like alluded to this earlier like almost has this mass market game feel to it it's not it's not a mass market game but uh i i almost wish it like approached that more uh because then it i i like the idea of it being this sort of like transition or gateway game you know whatever title you want to call those kinds of things um and it's it's it's it's a little chunkier than that you're exactly right anastasia we haven't really gone into much of the game and i think at a very very high level uh leading off from what you said it's good for people to know that this game has uh in addition to the card play mechanic

we talked about it's got majorities for multiple areas on the game that you're thinking about it has multiple types of buildings that you can put down that generate income that will activate at certain times throughout the game certain buildings will give you ongoing upgrades whereas other ones will give you a varying number of points based off of your efficiency and your proximity to the beach uh there's bird tokens that you can use there's teleportation activity cards you can use as well on top of that there are hidden bonuses that everybody has at the very beginning of the game that you're going to be considering and there's an event deck that is drawn in most turns of the game i just wanted to rattle all those off so people have an idea of maybe more of what nick's talking about where like at its core this does feel like it's you know on the lighter end maybe almost mass market but with all of those things on top of it maybe that does kind of nudge it out of there yeah yeah i definitely think it does and i also think we should step back and again from like a high level just like integrate this into the theme right because one of the great things about this game is how deeply integrated it is with its theme so this is as john already said you know it's set in cape may new jersey and it's about this town it technically you're playing one year in the town you go through like four seasons it doesn't have a huge impact but you're playing one year in the town and yet there's these event cards that come out basically every month if you will and a month is essentially one round and

those event cards each represent a historic event that happened over several decades in the late 1800s in cape may and each one is kind of tied to that and that's really cool so you really do get this sense of if you're reading that and kind of going into that but you are kind of building up this town and then the map that john was talking about is broken up into four sections that are that start at the beach you know it's a beach town and it's somewhat important because if you build closer to the beach it costs more but of course that's where tourism was and so you get greater income and you get more points but then if you build towards the back it gets a lot cheaper and then they've done this kind of cool thing it's very very tightly uh nicely balanced depending on how you feel about area majorities but then if you have the person who has the most in the back gets more points for the majorities and the person on the front so that kind of gives you this sense of like how all of those mechanics of john listed out are kind of tied into the the theme and the and the game that's kind of presented here yeah i mean one thing that um really came through from the designer diary that we all read was that this game was designed uh location first theme first like this is not a pasted on theme by any means and i don't want to just speak for the designer because i read their designer diary but but let's put a link to that in the description too yeah yeah it was a great read honestly and um when i first read the rules to this when i was

getting ready to to teach it so we could all play the event deck jumped out to me as one of my biggest concerns about the game uh because this is obviously a euro style game and generally event decks and euro games don't mix that well in my opinion um the randomness of flipping over a card and seeing what happens uh frequently i think doesn't work out very well in euro games but i uh for me personally i was pleasantly surprised by the event mechanic mostly because the events were just gentle nudges uh in a lot of games with event decks they can really upend the entire play experience like oftentimes events can be really wacky in generic games with events but this one in general it seemed like it would just give some people some money some people more than others or cost some people a low amount of money some people maybe more than others it almost seemed like it was this tiny little tactical nudge to kind of get you off of your strategic position i think you have to really enjoy the headline theme aspect of it learning that the ghost is here and the fire is here and it's mosquito season now um that has to be a fun part of the game for you uh otherwise you'll feel like i did which is that the event deck is toothless i think it just does not it's not very impactful to the mechanics of the game yeah i felt like we could have played without it and we would have played exactly the same game but if you like that story um it does instill some genuine history into the game yeah cause there's flavor text on every one and every card is like

a newspaper bulletin like a headline and and we weren't reading the flavor text i kind of wish i had i feel like i might maybe would have pulled me into it even more seeing the you know the specific uh uh historical notes about it honestly i we read the designer diary afterwards and i gained a lot more respect for the event deck and what it was really trying to do trying to like pull you into the theme of the game um versus you know the mechanical impact on your your purse and i think that goes back to what we've been talking about kind of where this falls into the lighter medium weight kind of the audience that this game is is really going to be for like this is a game that i would probably hold on to um because i i really i like i enjoyed this game and i enjoyed this game exactly for what it is and there are a number of flaws it's a very interesting game because it also comes with a a lot of discussion kind of afterwards about the game and and nick already kind of mentioned some of the rougher edges and we're going to talk a little bit about that but i i i really enjoy it for exactly what it is which is if you're going to get this game out with some friends probably aren't you know supe super heavy gamers we're going to get this out you're going to have a lovely time reading that flavor text when i played with my friend you know we don't play a ton of games together but we were playing it in the backyard and we were you know putting the pieces out and reading the flavor text and it was just it was just fun it was just a very wonderful uh you know play-through experience and

it was great because it's a euro i don't i don't have a lot of opportunities to play euros with my friends who aren't super deep into board gaming because a lot of euros are gotta really like games to like kind of to pull out some of the drier euros that i love to play or the ones that are very heavy so i think there's something really wonderful about that integration but you do kind of have to play that way you know this is not typically how the three of us play you know we play a game and we kind of you know we play them faster we don't we don't tend not to read the flavor text that type of stuff but for like a social evening uh with the right crowd i think that this is really fun because of those additional elements if you like history if you like those kind of things it's it's unique and it's cool you mentioned playing with your friends and actually the the kind of like the person that i want to play this most with is um my dad and my stepmom so my dad is a heavy gamer uh just like i am sorry we're all they're all they're all genetic the board game dynasty over there just so everyone knows so my stepmom is not is not really a board game player and she plays because she like wants to learn and um you know that all that stuff uh but i what i like is that i could put this table and i'm very confident that i could show her how to play and she would have a fun time because it's very cute um it's it's hard to complete you you can't just completely shoot yourself in the foot in this game as long as you're doing something you're making forward progress but there's at least enough there to like bite on to that my dad is going to be thinking

about something during the course of the game and that's going to be engaging for him as well so i i think that it's it's cool and that it it manages to bridge that uh well which is why i think as like a as like a gateway kind of piece is really where it shines the most yeah yeah exactly that ability to kind of have enough going on you know for someone like your dad and that is actually one of the things that i found really interesting about this play that i i had with my friend in person is is that we so we kind of talked about this a little bit there's these activity cards in the game and i'm not gonna lie when i was teaching uh them the game i i totally called them chance cards and they're not they're not chance cards but i was really leaning into the monopoly this game teaches really fast and and it's it's it's pretty easy to pick up but there are several mechanics going on so it kind of helped to to delineate them in that way but these cards are essentially i don't say they break the game but they they they add a lot of variety they're very powerful we said you play over a year you're going to have income phases at three different points in that year and that's when you're going to get money back for all of the commercial buildings that you built and you're also going to get two of these cards and you also start with two of these cards so you and you can draw more and these cards let you either build for cheaper they let you teleport like we keep saying to different you know kind of move around they're they're very there's a lot of variety with them and i think they're

super fun because they add a lot of different ways you can play but the reason i'm bringing up right now is actually my friend kept drawing activity cards to the point where i was like oh my god are they gonna tank their game because you know it's a euro you got to be efficient about your actions right right and they kept drawing them and then the last couple of rounds they just played activity cards because playing an activity card is an action and they built so much stuff then they were moving around and they were doing stuff and it was really really cool to see because they played the game completely different than me i was playing much more straight i was moving around using my movement cards and just i play an activity card here and there and they must have played like 12 activity cards by the end and and they only lost by like seven points or something so i just want to point these out that these these cards let you do a lot have a lot of fun and they they do change up the game quite a bit they're also flexible right because every single one of these cards gives you two options when you play them and both of them are usually good and uh well i say that they're they're always good but you know conditionally better in certain situations than others but it means when you have a bunch of these in your hand you can really be flexible with how you stitch them together but also i found them a bit dizzying like when i had like five or six of them in my hand trying to be like okay i'm going to do the top option on this one the bottom option on

this one before i do the top wait no the top of that one and then i looked over and then nick had like 10 of these things and i was like oh my gosh i couldn't even imagine trying to parse a hand that big of these cards because there's just so many good things on them every card is every activity card is excellent yeah they i mean they open your options up immensely i actually kind of wish that they were a little harder to come by because they are so bombastic and what they do which is cool it's exciting right as a player and like you know your friend that popped off or me in the first game that we've played like it is pretty sweet at the end where you're like ah i've done this and this and this and this um but like i said i really like the movement mechanic in this game and i i like i like that that that tension is there and anastasia i know you said it you like you enjoyed the fact that i like tried to avoid using the movement mechanic but because i think that that tension is creative um i wish that it was required essentially right like you you can't avoid having that be really important part of the game so that's my only criticism for the activity cards they are it is cool to look at them be like i can do this and this and hahaha like all of a sudden something a very simple game became like i could do this like crazy sequence of actions that no one saw coming yeah there were a few turns was just like wait wait what are you doing i tell a point over here like now i can build diagonally and then i go over there and i build this at a huge discount and you're just like oh my god and then it's my turn and i'm like i uh move and i build once and then i draw a card i feel lame okay

and you know speaking of you know action efficiency uh we've alluded to the fact this takes place over the course of a year there's 12 months and in each month everybody takes one turn when you have three actions all of that is essentially a long way of saying you take 36 actions over the course of this game so again hearkening back to what anastasia what you were saying earlier like you could play this just willy-nilly just you know play some cards pull them back up play some cards pull them back up have fun traipsing around town or you could squeeze every last piece of euro efficiency uh you know blood out of every single action that you have and i remember in our play i believe i took my cards up twice and the second time i took them up oh i felt so bad it's like that wasted action what am i 36 i i messed up i messed up like i wasn't like i'm actually upset with myself but i felt like you know i should have done this better i should have planned better i remember at one point anastasia you were just like i know what i'm doing for my next three rounds of the game it was like nine i did 36 actions and i just was like flabbergasted i was like i'm trying to figure out what i'm doing for my next action i think there is a good amount of of ap possibility analysis paralysis possibility here and and the ability to get a little too caught up in your plan and that's actually where you know the event deck does help because you're going to draw one of those events you know you're going to draw 12 events over the course of the game and they do take you know like john said they have little bits they don't have a lot of teeth like nick said but they do

they do cause enough kind of randomness that like you can't perfectly plan and i did in our first game in fact actually i think i've won every game of this that i played no wonder i like it um the second side we played did you yeah and also that like in that game i blocked that from my memory you had this plan and i kicked your plan in the kneecaps and you were very angry with me well actually we should talk about that so so the the randomness can kind of get in your way a little bit if you're having a perfect plan but i will admit that it is possible knowing you know when the income comes you sort of have a set amount of income and the events are a little bit toothless that you can you can do quite a bit of like i'm gonna do this and this and this but there is there can be some conflict over the spots right so only one person can build in each plot if you will and you know we should talk about that a little bit that there's there's a map for two to three actually is it two to three players it's one side of the map what what is it i think it's two and three to four two and then three to four but i mean in our experience actually we didn't run into each other a lot in our three three-player game and then nick and i played we ran into each other a little bit and yes nick screwed up my plans but i haven't felt like again that that i actually don't feel like any part of this game is overly gets in your way whether it's the event cards or even the map i don't feel like

there's a lot of conflict there um but i think nick you mentioned you you kind of wish there was more kind of competition for the spot yeah that's exactly right i i think that uh it'd be neat it was a little bit tighter if it was a little bit more of a race to get to the spots um that one time where i got in anastasia's way was because she actually ended up choosing a plan for something that i was already thinking of doing and then i said okay i just need to make sure i execute this quickly because i can see what she's angling for so it just so happened that our plans kind of like coincided um and there's generally just enough options that if someone like takes your specific plan like you can go somewhere else and do something else it's really not too hard and i i would like it if it was a little bit uh tighter in terms of the space that was available so i think i'm going to lead us into a slightly different but adjacent topic and that is the area majorities that are part of this game as we've mentioned a couple times there's four different zones and once the game is over you count up the number of buildings that each person is built in each zone doesn't matter what type of building it is it could be a victorian or a commercial building and then whoever has the most buildings gets the most points and then it goes down from there and the farther the zone is away from the shore the more points you get um which is an interesting little uh uh twist that i did not see coming i only noticed it halfway through our first game and the big reason i wanted to bring up majorities is because this is probably

actually no i take it back this is definitely my least favorite part of the game and i quite enjoyed this game overall but i have a bit of a personal uh pet peeve about games that don't really feel like area majority games that have pretty heavy hitting area majority aspects and to me you know when i'm playing this game i feel like it's got the puzzle of the movement cards and the activity cards trying to piece that together moving around the map but then once the game asks me to start counting the number of buildings of mine and buildings of my opponents in each section that i'm buying for over and over again like on every one of my turns that starts to get a little bit fatiguing and i have this problem with many games that are like this like if a game is a pure a majority game then that's fine but i felt like there's a lot of points to be made in cape may for being in the majority and i felt like i was a little annoyed that i felt like i needed to keep counting those when i just kind of wanted to focus on other things i remember the first game well i guess my only play i've only played the one time uh i really tried to focus on those and i came in first for one and second for another one and and not scoring and either of the other two and then anastasia one you got more points than any of us did and then you just said oh i never paid attention to the area majorities at all and that made me feel really silly that well i think that's because i can be like part of my issue with air majorities is yours is i don't like having to

constantly count we we all played uh coal baron a month or two ago and you know that constantly having to keep track of the majorities because so much of that scoring is majorities and i was just like i hate this yeah so the fact that it's only one portion of a way that you score points you score points for that but you also score points for the number of victorians you built the number of victorians you've turned into landmarks your end game scoring points your birds like it's one of you know there's the other it's like one of six different ways that you score so for me i was like well we'll see what happens like it's too much effort for me to to keep track of that and and and in a way like i agree with you john but in another way like these have actually grown on me more in this game i agree with you in that i'm never i'm i'm generally not a big fan of area majorities either but in this game because they're flipped like that the fact that you get more points for building at the back of town than you do for the front i actually feel like you really need it you need that incentive because otherwise everyone would just go clamber to the beach build there and then there would be no reason to build at the back of town unless you had like end game bonus cards that rewarded that and then you'd be at a disadvantage like if someone had cards that reward the sand you know it's just to me it's like it's just like a little extra incentive because it's also not a huge amount of points like the points that i think you get for being the area majority at the back of town is like eight and being the air majority at the

front of town is like two now that's i'm using the two player uh game uh as from a from memory here so it and in a three and four it's you know first person gets this the second person gets yeah but i guess i just didn't feel like the swing on that is so huge when you're talking scores that are you know easily i don't remember what the scores were in our game but i'm pretty sure they've got they go into the hundreds so like i don't know that like that one piece is you know is so crazy i just want to be crystal clear for everyone that the farther the buildings are away from the water the less points they are worth by themselves uh i think we've mentioned that once or twice but i feel like it's really important to hammer this idea home that the majorities are more impactful where the buildings individually are worth way less point right which segues into exactly what i don't like about the area of majorities it is i i think that this idea of incentivizing the back row or the gravel that the the cheaper less point buildings by giving a larger area majority creates uh what i don't like as a design mechanic in the game so something there's this concept called the penrose stairs kind of sometimes called the escher stairs where it's like you're never going up right if you were like walking around these stairs you're just like there's it's a it's a optical illusion essentially and you can never ascend and so i feel like the way the points are incentivized in

this game is exactly that they're if if i'm incentivized to do this in the back and this in the front and they're just kind of different versions of the same coin then like i don't care where i build and i would rather the game says yeah rush the beachfront property like if there's there's a land rush like go and grab it fight for it and if it's too powerful you from a design perspective i think could have tuned it down by just making the beach beachfront property more expensive um and so i don't like that the points it feels like it doesn't matter where i built and for a game where the most of what you're doing is moving around and building in places i thought that was a really disappointing result just to be crystal clear again buildings are more expensive the closer you get to the beach but you know obviously those numbers could have been tweaked even more right right i mean i hear you nick i do i just i think that when you do that you end up creating one path to play the game and i think that what this does at least in my opinion is create multiple paths i think there's a very there's viable strategies to just building staying entirely away from the sand i mean i think than most of the games i've played have been like the sams i like buying things cheap the sand is too expensive so i'm gonna stay towards the back and then that's really helped me to get more points you know to compensate for the fact that my victorians in the back of town are not nearly as valuable as my victorians at the front of town but but i but i do hear you expand the metaphor multiple

pass is fine but what i feel like is it just generates an open field do whatever and then like what does it matter yeah yeah well that actually brings me to one of my larger critiques of the game which is actually the money right so we haven't really talked about this yet but there are two types technically four but let's let's just start with two there are two major types of buildings there's commercial buildings and then there's victorians and then in both cases you build sort of a base level and then you can upgrade them so the houses start actually i think it's a cottage right it's a you start by building a cottage and then you so i'm calling a victorian sorry you start by building a cottage and then you can upgrade it to victorian which is a cute little cardboard to uh to 3d piece and then you can basically put a fence around it a little base and that turns it into a landmark so we go cottage victorian landmark and each of those upgrades costs money and and the first two give you more income and then with the shops the commercial buildings they start as shops and they give you the most income obviously because they're shops and then you can upgrade them into something else i think we're just called businesses right shopping businesses shops and then businesses you upgrade them into businesses and those give you even more income and those businesses also give you another like card basically an advantage to pick up

another type of card that will give you either an end game another end game goal or kind of an ongoing effect so the thing about this though is that you are incentivized to build businesses early in the game so you can make more income at each of those income phases but then as you get to the end of the game you don't get any points at the end of the game for money and you don't get any points at the end of the game for income and that means that the last three rounds your last nine actions there's really no point to build businesses other than for majorities or for endgame goals or otherwise and i i really don't like that i don't like any games where they just like take away something valuable that you're doing because like i would love to play this game and just be like a crazy shopkeeper and be like what if i don't build any landmarks and i just built you know i don't build any victorians like i i just think that there's some variants that do reward that i've talked about like rewarding that i'm sure this will be ongoing discussion but like i don't know i'm curious what you guys think i just i find it to be a big bummer that you're not there's no benefit at the end yeah i'd agree i remember when i played the one time and i realized in you know around the 10th round and i built something and i realized oh there's no reason for me to track the income benefit of this i guess and then i looked at the book just to double check because it seemed a little weird to like get income but but who cares you're not going to be gaining income again that that did seem a little strange to

me i agree yeah it's very much build businesses early build residences mid-game and later i think that problem could be solved if you were allowed to just like landmark businesses in this game but i i have to assume that there's something about like what constitutes as a landmark in cape may and i think that there's like a thematic reason that it's like that uh rather than sort of like allowing businesses to be that which is kind of nuts when you think about it just to go on another side because so many of those businesses at the time were like mixed-use buildings where like the family lived upstairs and those would totally be landmarks but i'm just gonna leave that little diatribe in my mind board games or abstractions yeah you can't can't dig too deep into that but but yeah um i i personally think that going forward and i'm not a big i'm not generally not a big fan of house rules but i i personally feel that playing this in the future i will add on some sort of benefit for money i'm not exactly sure what that's going to be whether it's like one point for every seven money or there is that i think it does give you one point for every 10 money no it doesn't no no there's a variant that's on board game geek that talks about doing that one point for every seven or ten money and then some additional points if you have the the most income or something yeah and you get your income one more time and i don't know exactly what i want to do but definitely i'm going to add something like that in because i just i i personally think i i want to have a benefit for keeping

track of that at the end you know in this final kind of quarter of the game um we haven't talked about bird watching at all so one of the mechanics in this game is bird watching because apparently that's what you do in cape may and the way that it plays out in the game is basically if you just walk onto these certain spaces you get to take a bird token randomly from the bag and you are hoping to draw a diverse array of bird tokens the the more diverse the more points and it could be a ton of points yeah well the thing that we've found in in our in our limited number of plays is that the person who plays birds is the winner yeah yeah that's that has been true so i really like the mechanic of the the birds and the board because it's this extra little puzzle where if you end your movement on a bird spot you gain the bird and you you're gaining points at least one point for every bird but potentially a ton if it's the right bird but in general the bird watching spots are really bad for building i think in general they're not adjacent to buildings for the most part and so that means you kind of have to have an inefficient move landing on a bird spot but then you gain this other perk now i did not take a single bird in our in the one time that i played this game and i watched anastasia take it felt like dozens i know it wasn't actually dozens it just seemed like every other action and station was getting a bird and i think it's partly because you were playing the board well like that mini game of landing on the spots but also you played

um extra bonuses and whatnot there were just other ways you managed to squeeze out more birds and some of those let you actually choose right like you get a random bird when you land on the spot on the board but there are ways to like draw two choose one draw three twos one isn't that right i think there was we i talked briefly about how when you upgrade a shop into a business you can there's this other element of taking cards that's right and there is a card that allows you to do that and there's a couple of years i think yeah yeah so you can stitch those together to help your your diverse array of bird watching well and you know we haven't talked about the end game bonus cards yet but essentially you you draw several bonus cards you get to pick two at the start of the game and they reward you for doing different things and one of them or a couple of them at least the one i had in that game rewarded me for bird watching and i was actually really excited because i was like ooh cool like i'm just gonna go around this board i'm not gonna really build stuff which is again why i wasn't really paying attention to the majorities i was just kind of building because i knew i needed to build because i was so busy trying to collect birds and you know i don't know it's it's it's pure luck and i guess if you played it and you got frustrated i'm sure if i if i had drawn five birds of the same type i would have been really annoyed but there's like nine different birds or i don't know seven different birds so there's lots of birds to pick from and frankly this is also true of the game i played in person with my friend like we just we were like

birds like it was just like it was just fun we were just like we were so excited to go bird watching which is just sticking your hand in a bag and pulling out a random bird but like i don't know they're beautiful there's endorphins there with it's kind of taps into the gambling to a certain extent you know crank the handle and and see what you get i mean like i said it's always going to be a minimum of one point i suppose uh i kind of regretted not going birds like not taking a single bird the entire game uh because well i mean you crushed me you won by a lot so when we did final scoring i was like oh my gosh i should have gone birds um but you know our data but that was total luck right like i had a i had a full set of them but but this much randomness is tends not to be your thing nick i mean the randomness of the birds is is whatever i think is appropriate for a game of this like weight and style um i just i'm i'm i'd have to play more really like way in for for serious i'm worried that the birds are are too strong the thing that i uh like about the birds is if you're broke it's very difficult to do anything at this game so you can go bird watching instead and i think that that's that's cool and it's something to do yeah yeah no but that's entirely true right like if you're on vacation buying houses or whatever um go watch some birds if you don't have any money in hand i like how it's like the theme is deeply integrated just don't look too closely am i wrong or is there one spot on the board where you can draw two birds when you land there yeah there is yeah yeah

so i remember like over in a corner in that one play anastasia you landed there at least two times if not three so like that was again your mini game you just kept i think that spot's a problem you kept landing yeah that double bird spot and it was like wow you just like loop it around the block and probably totally there are these like one-way streets in the game which is sort of interesting that kind of limits your movement which i have some there's some spots where it's like a little unclear if you can move this way or this way or whatever but but yeah you can just keep kind of looping this block and nick's right it's a double word spot but not only that around that same area i think is some spots where you can also double build right so where your spots are connected to spaces that you're adjacent to and so that corner i think seemed like must have at some point in play testing seemed like a lame corner but it's actually quite powerful or maybe that's just where they had the bird watching fair in real life because you know there is a lot of theme like they're definitely trying to bring the theme of the game into into this play i want to actually take us over to something else which is so you know we've talked a little bit about buying these buildings and and this this map but another kind of critique that i have of the game is actually the way you keep track of the prices in this game so so we've talked about the areas and we talked about all the types of buildings well each type of building and the ability to upgrade it costs an

amount and based on each area it costs a different amount so to keep track of all this they give you this very helpful reference sheet that you're right that you have to reference but you are constantly referencing it and the prices are not as intuitive as you'd hoped they'd be because not only is there the prices on it there's also the amount of income that you're gonna get so i ran into this problem when i was playing it with my friend where they were like they were getting confused is this how much it costs or is this how much income i get or do i get this like as a kickback when i buy this but not only that keeping track of am i in the gravel am i in the sand am i in the dirt it's a lot of back and forth and i gotta say that like i do wish i'm sure it would have not made this map look nearly as pretty on the board but i really wish they'd just put the cost for each spot on the board like to the point where like i've considered like do i just write them on there like just like is there a creative way to do that that's not super ugly because it's just that back and forth i thought it'd be better in person because it was hard enough on tts but it's not it's just it's just confusing and i i do wish that that was cleaner yeah i mean i just totally agree with you great great i think one of the last kind of like hanging things to talk about here is um the turn order mechanism in this game it's actually a lot less about it being the turn order mechanism in cape may and

the this design existing in a lot of games so the idea in this game or the way the turn order works is if i'm the first player on this round then anastasia will be the first player on the next round and then jon will be the first player on the round after that i can see why they do this they do this in a lot of games it's because it's more fair to rotate who's going first and i get that but it leads to these really awkward exchanges especially in a two-player game where you end up having like a glut of actions or a period of time where you're not doing anything in a four-player game if you are the first player you take your three actions every other player is going to take their three actions that round you're gonna pass the round and then every other player again is gonna take another three actions and then it's back to your turn so in a four player game 36 things have happened between your two turns and again i get why they rotate the first player for fairness but i actually think in a game of this weight just having the same first player and just rotating around the board like settlers of catan it's just like it's your turn it's your turn it's your turn it's your turn would just be a lot cleaner yeah yeah i totally agree in the in this game and i i don't i don't mind that like back back back and forth i don't even mind snake snake turn orders usually but in this game especially two player like it gets really confusing passing that first player marker back and forth and and you are essentially then just taking six actions broken up by an event and it's just it

feels really clunky just to kind of like be like okay wait it's your turn and then you're gonna have to do six things and then you're gonna have to wait for me to figure out what i'm doing like i i just wish there's a lot to think about so i just wish that like you said like it was just some more fluid like my turn your turn my turn i just think the game would play smoother um i might try it next time i play it but i i don't i don't know yeah i remember in the one play that we had in the second to last round nick you were the the first player and so you took your turn and then you just left because you were then going to take the last action of the game right because then we moved into the final act and so you you just you got to use the restroom or something and you just you just left for a little bit it was fine like it worked out but it was just like okay you're done for for a little while and like you said like it is kind of like a weird pseudo snake and it doesn't feel like that at first like it was like i think we were in the second round when we were just like wait this is kind of weird and i looked at the rule book to make sure that i wasn't getting it wrong and i've seen this in other games as well and i've had the same weirdness in other games as well and i agree i just kind of wish it was always clockwise and there was some other mechanical incentive or disincentive to maybe even out any sort of early or late advantage or issue yeah yeah well i think the last thing that i want to bring up before we wrap up is just that we you know we talked a lot about you know the event deck and the activity cards and you know there's these upgrade cards and even your end game bonus cards a lot

of cards in this game but i do want to point out that there's quite a bit of randomness slash variety in the decks which is a good thing for variability but it also can mean i think that you may just pick up cards that don't seem as cool as something else that someone else has and i actually think that this is kind of the weight of game where honestly i'd kind of encourage you just draw more pic pick maybe not as you're playing but like end game bonus cards just go through them and pick some that are fun like it's definitely that kind of game where you could just have fun with it you don't have to like adhere super strictly like when i was playing with my friend i know that they they did some of the income wrong and we just went with it like i just didn't point it out because it's not that type of game like it's just that that's what i really enjoyed about it i guess this is kind of my wrap-up thoughts it's like i just i just it's just a breezy play sure it's got some flaws and there's some rough edges and maybe a couple of things could have been lifted out but it's just like it's a it's a nice real game that has like a nice casual vibe to it and i and i like that quite a bit about it yeah i think i've been thinking about that a decent amount as well in that i enjoyed it i enjoyed it more than i expected to going into my one play i played it less than both of you did but i i just thought it was kind of a cool movement puzzle a lot of things were working together in a concerted way to make for some pretty compelling

decisions um i might have been a bit of a bit pet peeved about to the area majorities but it didn't sour my overall experience on it at all and also you know it just felt kind of new to me in a way and i i don't know with just looping back to like the very first thing i said in this episode the map really jumped out to me with these one-way roads and these little mazy little paths working your way around almost like flowing water to a certain extent and i just haven't played that many games like this and maybe there's a bunch and i just not experienced with it but um that felt kind of fresh kind of cool and and i totally agree with you anastasia it just had a a breezy fun vibe to it it didn't feel cut throat i'm sure you could play super cutthroat gate may if you wanted to but it definitely seemed like it was more fun if you lean back in your chair instead of lean forward and then you know maybe bask in the art on your your little birds and just like enjoy it for the overall experience even though like the uh the board game critic in me might you know see certain things and like wish certain things are different at the same time i just like wow i had fun yeah and you're keeping it right that's actually high praise because i know that yeah games get punted out your door i do it fits a unique space in my collection i don't have a lot of games like this that are heavier than you know gateways and and but i still feel like i could bring to a night of you know a couple of non-gamers and and play but still feel like we're

playing you know i keep calling it a real board game that i love to get to ride i don't mean to sound disparity we're still playing like a like a euro like a like a euro with a lot of cool little things going on like like nick explained it perfectly about his dad it's enough for me to sink my teeth into but bring to a night of of non-gamers yeah when it comes to judging a book by its cover i definitely did not judge this but this book well when he first put it out and john went through the rules teach and i was like uh-huh uh and then we started playing it actually was like uh a lot i enjoyed it a lot more than i expected i would which was was really cool i do just really wish though that it was you know to your point in a stage you called it breezy i wish it was breezier i would love to cut out like just the stuff like the the area majorities the the endgame bonus cards some of the some of the extra little spaces and doodads um i find those things to be vestigial to like what's the core part of the game but that's just my preference i think no i think that's a it's a really good point but then i wonder would it still be that kind of heavier than light medium weight game would still fit that sort of unique space if you took all that stuff out i think it would be i think the fact like for instance the area majorities that you didn't pay attention to them and then like like is a perfect example of like that didn't take anything away from your experience

at all um i think that like activity cards right like what they do is give you more powers but uh without them you would have more restrictions which requires you to play smarter so i think that it would i think that it would still sit there yeah well i think that's going to bring this one to a close i think we've uh we've all said our piece about cape may um if you have any thoughts about this game if you've played it or maybe you just are curious to to throw some questions around we'd love to see comments about it um there's a youtube version of this episode you can find a link to that description of the podcast um feel free to leave comments there tell us why we're wrong or maybe just tell us you know if there's some part of this game that we we maybe didn't highlight or just didn't really give as much credit as it maybe could have had either way we love getting feedback and thank you so much for listening

Progress saved