Skip to main content
Loading video...

Rules Overview and First Impressions Clash of Magic Schools

Transcript 29:31

Hello everyone and welcome back to the board gaming doctor. My name is Phil and I'll be your board game doctor today and I am going to go over a game that I've been wanting to play for a while. This is an Uber Rosenberg game called Clash of Magic Schools. Here's the rule book. So, Clash of Magic Schools is a re-implementation of Babel or Babel that was designed by Rosenberg, I believe, in the year 2000 or around that time. So, this game is about 20 years old or so. And so, this game is kind of a it's a two-player game that's kind of a tug war between two opposing factions. It's set in a magical school setting. think Harry Potter. And we play back and forth uh taking certain actions, which I'll describe uh as I play a few turns of this game until someone meets a couple of victory conditions. You either need to have 15 or more trial points in front of you while your opponent has nine or fewer. Uh and uh so yeah, that's basically how the game ends. There's a thing called overtime, but maybe we'll we'll talk about that um in a little bit. So, there's so there are some caveats to how this game can end. Uh you're catching me midame as I play

these two players single-handedly. I will show you the hand of every player uh or both players as we play along. And I'll describe how this game quickly uh plays in the few turns that I will have. Just so you know, you do have a player aid uh that tells you what you can do on your turn as well as the spells that you can cast. And yeah, so we'll we'll go from there using the aids that we have in front of us and the game that has been um partway through played. So right now I am the black player. Uh so at the beginning of the game, we started here at the end of this board and we have moved ourselves over to certain arenas and these columns that we have. And when you move, you discard a card according to the uh color of the arena uh that you're moving to. So you discard a student. And I with as the white player, I moved over to the yellow uh wind arena to do so. So that's like the first action that you can do on your turn. But anyway, so at the beginning of your turn, you draw three student cards to your hand. I'll make sure you can see what I've got here. So I had one card in my hand already, and I have two fire and two yellow students. So each student will look the the same

um either way. I mean the art will be different but the their ability will be the same for every single student. So uh you don't need to memorize or understand more than what the yellow school or faction uh what their spell can do essentially. We'll go over that in a little bit. So, uh, with these four cards, I get to determine what I want to do on my turn. And, and so the first thing that I could do is move, which I've described. So, if I wanted to move to the red arena, I would discard a red card to do so. Um, I'm I don't think I'm going to do that. Uh, and by the way, when you take actions, you can take as many actions as you can and want before you pass.

So, the next thing that I could do is assign a student to a column. Now, if I were to do so, for example, um I could I'm not going to do it this turn because I Well, actually, I might Let's go ahead and assign since I'm at the wind temple or sorry, the wind arena. This is not Zelda. Uh, I'm going to assign uh this yellow student to that column there. And I I just place them right, you know, on top of the car column that was previously there. And I think that will be it. Uh, since I don't have a lot of opportunities to do much with this hand, I think I'm going to save it. As far as I'm I know, there aren't any uh limits on hand size. And afterwards, the last thing that you do before you end your turn completely is you reveal two uh t uh trial cards. So, these trial cards essentially just have a point value on top of them. This is how you score points throughout the game. And what you do is you arrange them from the biggest on bottom to smallest on top.

And you place them here on the trial column. So, uh, the black player has a lot of these trials. um what you'll do hopefully I'll demonstrate what you can do uh later on uh with those trials as well, but you do assign them there and hopefully we'll bring them into your column to add to your score uh throughout the game. So, right now, black player has three points. So, that is my turn. So, I will pass to the white player. So, the white player will draw a couple of cards. I've pretty much gotten the same amount of cards here, but let's see what we can do with them. So, um, what I will do, I suppose, is discard a red card to move my token back to the red location.

Um, and I think what I'll do next is add these two cards to the top here. Now uh what I could do now uh if you notice and keep track if if you noticed here uh my different columns in the white this farther darkness column I suppose has two students underneath it and it has to uh a trial of two uh above it. I always need to have as many students as there is the number of trials if not greater number of students than the number of trial that is on there. Uh so everything so far is according to it meets the criterion for for having the number of students. So, after reviewing the rules, so when I decide to hopefully soon pass a trial, which is to take a trial from one of these stacks, and you can choose the topmost card from either stack. So, in this case, it's going to be four on each side. I could take that as an action.

Take that card and place it on top of an existing pile that is one number less than this. Right? So, in this case, I would need a three in any one of these uh stacks to be able to place this four on top of that. Now, there is a spell that can mitigate that. And so, I don't have that available as of yet. So, I'm going to pass my turn for the white player and reveal four more. I guess I didn't or two more fours. Um I didn't shuffle this as well as I would have hoped. Let's see if we can um make anything happen here. So, I've got four red for the black player. I've got four red, a darkness, and a um air student visible. So, we've talked about moving and assigning students, which is placing them into a column. You can pass a trial, which is taking it from over here and placing it on top of an existing trial. You can summon students as well.

So, you must move the top three students from any column and move them to another column. They don't have to go to a column that already has a number on it or not. Uh, but uh your remaining column should continue to have that trial met essentially. So, this is what I'm going to do. I'm going to take the top three cards here and move them over to this column over there. So, so now I have three earth students, green earth students, and two um water students in this arena right here. To clarify, I wouldn't be able to take a level four trial and place it here because I would need a level three trial here prior to be able to move the uh trial over on top of it. So, unfortunately, I can't do anything about that right now.

But this is a great example to show the last example of of what you can do on your turn, which is to cast a spell. So, the reason that you want to care about assigning your students in certain ways on columns is to hopefully get three in a row like so. If you have three in a row, you can cast the spell of that color. you would have to discard that middle card to the to the discard pile. So in in this example, I would take the middle green person and discard them and you activate that spell that is indicative of that player type or that student type. So going through the list of what these can do. So, I mean, for example, let's do this. Let's do this. So, um, so I I move those over there, and that's fine and great. Let's discard a red card and move the dragon over to the this arena here. Now, I'm going to play, let's see, two of my fire students here.

And since I have more than three, I will activate that spell and um and do that. So, I'm just going to reset a little bit because I just noticed that I could do this. So, yeah, pretend that came from right in the middle. So, if I activate the fire spell, which is Combustio in this game, it says to remove all of your opponent's trial cards from this arena. So, what this does is I have to discard these. And according to the rule book, I place the lowest one on top of the deck like so. And yeah, so that essentially wipes out my uh arena scoring from this particular area. Going through the other factions.

So, the yellow faction, the air faction, they would be able to add your opponent's top student card, which is the one that is on the very top, and add it um of of any of the others of the same element as well, to your column of students. And so if I were to activate this, I would add all the fire students over to my side of the board or the one closest to me, the white. The earth, the green one can choose an element and then discard all of your opponent's student cards in that arena of that element type. The water one, the blue uh allows you to immediately take a pass trial action and ignore a level. So, this would be really helpful in the situation because I have a lot of trial four cards. Uh, and a lot of I have some two cards right here, some level two trials.

And so, if I had three blue cards here, I would be able to discard one of them and pass a trial to place this four on top of a two and score some more points. The darkness, the purple darkness faction will be able to steal the opponent's top trial card in this arena. And I believe it follows the same rules where the number of trial has to um supersede the one that you're placing it on top of. And then if you discard any uh student, any color of student can also have the mallet malifysio curse, which is to have your opponent discard half the cards in their hand rounded down. So you can do that with any of the factions as well. It's a secondary type of spell. And then once again, so we we go back and forth drawing cards from the deck, reshuffleling as necessary until we have 15 points showing and our opponent has nine or less on their side. Going back to some of the additional rules, uh the game ends when one of these conditions is met. You have 20 or more trial points.

So, uh rather than having 15 and then your opponent having nine or fewer, if you do reach 20, that automatically triggers the end or your opponent has nine or fewer trial points and the trial deck is empty. So, uh yeah, so that can conclude the game as well. So, I'm going to quickly end there. End it there. I didn't set up, I guess, the perfect scenario for these cards to show exactly what this game does. And I I'll just go straight into my first impressions of this game. I don't believe much has changed in the reimplementation of this game from Babel, aside from the the setting and the aesthetics of this game. But going right into like game comparisons, uh it kind of reminds me of of two games in particular. The first being Lost Cities, a RER Canitzia game where it is a two-player game very set up very similarly as as this game is set up where you are trying to u make bids for, you know, different expeditions that you're going on and trying to sequentially order cards in ascending order. onto your different expeditions to gain as many points as possible for reaching the end of those expeditions, right? And having more cards than your opponent does. And so it's a very not take that kind of game, but it is interactive in the sense that you're trying to uh play for certain areas and

certain columns very much like this game does, right? I feel like in comparison though, Lost Cities is more of an interactive like a neutral type of interaction where uh you do, you know, place cards for your opponent to potentially draw from and you're essentially just competing for uh you know, the majority of certain expeditions and columns, right? In this game with the spells themselves in in Clash of Magic schools, they can feel have a lot of uh ne negative interaction, right? You can destroy all of the arena cards in or trial cards in one arena, right? You can take students from one side, move them to the other. It can feel very punitive, right?

There's on one side you have to have three cards in a row in order to do something like the combust the the fire one, the combustio spell, which I mean imagine if I had like I think it goes up to six points, five or six. Uh if I had that on this side and completely removed it, sure I would be able to draw it soon from the top of the deck, but that that feels like a lot of progress that was made that is immediately cut down. And so, so I can, you know, I can see a scenario where using the secondary curse and discarding cards from your opponent's hand could be beneficial to prevent them from gathering the, you know, the necessary cards to have a very negative impact on your game. And on the other hand, you know, it does kind of serve as a catch-up mechanism for another player to keep themselves in the game, right?

All that to say is, and actually I'll get back to that thought, but the the second game that I want to compare this to is Bonanza, which is another Rosenberg game where the card ordering does matter. I particularly liked the fact that you could move three cards from one stack to the other to hopefully mix and match uh the like I did here, right, with the green student. So you can mix and match them to uh you know in a prior turn you might have not had enough you know of the same type of card in a row to activate a spell but now with that summoning action you could do so. And so that card ordering uh factor in this game felt very reminiscent of Bonanza and how your card order in your hand is static and you can't switch it around and and so it it adds an additional layer to the decisions that you need to make and what to potentially prepare yourself for in the future when you're trying to set yourself up for the maximum amount of success.

So, I'll So, rating this game, I I give it a 6.1 out of 10. Uh, this was a an anticipated game for myself and I I I guess I kind of knew ahead of time just based off of what I've heard from Babel that it might not be the I mean it's it's not Rosenberg's most acclaimed game. Of course, it is an interesting game in the fact that you have the ability to be very interactive

with your opponents, right? It feels very if it's not take that, it is very adjacent to a take that kind of situation. It's not, like I mentioned before, the easiest thing to pull off. You do need to arrange your cards in such a way that it kind of helps you feel clever about how you take your actions in what order. Um, with a little bit of luck involved, of course, to be able to pull off some major upsets against your opponent. So it's not like immediately negative all the time, but there is an aspect where you can really take the wind out of someone's sales, right? And so that can feel pretty bad if you play with certain players who aren't accustomed to that or don't pre uh prefer that in their gameplay. the game itself too. I think the one of the biggest hiccups is that in comparison to Lost Cities, again, I feel like this game, like one round would feel like the entire three or so rounds that it takes to play Lost Cities.

This game feels a lot longer than it perhaps should and maybe that is partly due to the negative connotations of some of the spells to hinder your opponent from progressing too far. I can see it as a mitigation for the luck factor in what cards you draw from the student deck as well as what you get from the trial deck as well. However, uh I feel like this does play about 45 to an hour, which feels really long for the weight and complexity of this game. And speaking of which, it's not the easiest game to intuit it. It's not as easy and streamlined and elegant as Lost Cities is. Uh you you know, it it does take a while to understand what each faction does with their spells. And so I think paradoxically this would lend itself to some mastery. I think understanding uh the mechanisms of this game albeit a little bit obtuse and and complex can lead to some interesting play. I think if you do place at someone at a higher skill level, right, Lost Cities, I feel like you're playing the other player.

There's an element of bluffing essentially that could as as you have secret information in your hand that could, you know, you could pretend to commit to one expedition while really having the cards for another or knowing what your opponent has in front of them, you can, you know, keep cards that they would need to progress, right? And so there's I think more of a player bluffing, you know, type of element to that game. And I think it's here too, but I feel like the the the game feels a lot more complex than it what it actually plays like. And and so, you know, I despite the low score, and this is why I'm kind of perplexed is that I I did enjoy this game. I do enjoy this game. I think it's really interesting puzzle in terms of like how much do you commit from your hand to play on the board, right? Uh if if you exhaust all of your your cards here, you have to spend a couple of turns to build up enough cards to allow for flexibility to move around and commit to certain columns in order to decrease the amount of trials here that you have in your your pile or your opponent's pile and to progress your game further.

Um, yeah, this game is is mean and that is usually not what I expect from a Rosenberg game. Um, I I feel like the interactions are most mostly neutral in that game in his games where it's like blocking someone from a work worker placement spot, right? Versus here where there is pretty direct interaction between you and your player. I will say that in recent times I've gravitated more towards two-player games because one, it's easier to um or it's faster, right, than a multiplayer game usually, depending on the game. Two, uh it's easier for me to keep track of one opponent and what their board state is rather than two or more opponents aside for myself. And so, you know, I yeah, I've really enjoyed the, you know, person versus person aspect, you know, one versus one. And uh it just adds I don't know it it makes it faster and more interesting for me to uh at a competitive level, you know, and and so this game is set up to be competitive and it uses a lot of competitive mechanisms when it comes to the spells. And I like the flexibility that you have to do a number of different, you know, sub actions on your whole turn to really help you feel

clever about what you're trying to do and accomplish on your turn. And so I I feel like there's an element to like having enough cards in your hand to be flexible, kind of waiting for your opponent to commit and react to that as well to hopefully mitigate the amount of luck as as possible. It is a lucky game in terms of what trial cards and what student cards you get in what order. And so there's always that aspect. And I I wish the game was a little bit quicker. Maybe it was it would be quicker if like for example the Combustio action only took off one trial instead of the whole pile and placed it on top of the trial deck, right? And so you essentially you discard a card to take one point off of your opponent. something like that maybe would make this game a little bit quicker and maybe there were some changes that made it quicker versus the uh original Babel, but I am interested in in continuing to play this game. I think it would be really nice to have someone and I I think in general it's this game rewards you from playing the same opponent over and over again or playing just playing the game over and over again. So, if this was on Board Game Arena, for example, this would be fantastic to really understand the the subliminal nuances of this game in terms of how to read your opponent and how to react in certain situations to optimize your chances of success against the luck of the draw. And maybe that speeds up play

a little bit. Uh yeah, I I wish it was a little bit quick, like 15 minutes quicker than the lowest time count on the box, but it it's it's a very intriguing game and I think my like fun factor for this game would increase as I play it more. Uh so despite the low score, it has a lot of potential for me and I find that very interesting. And maybe this is all inherent bias for my love of Rosenberg games. If this was from another designer, I might have given it more of a pass. And it's definitely not my favorite Rosenberg game for sure. I would rather have this, you know, player versus player experience using playing a game like Oranburg Canal or Fields of Arl or Glass Road at two players, right?

Some of those games really hit well for me at the two-player experience. And so I I don't know like I I I think this is a very interesting design. I wonder I mean I think it came out around the time as Lost Cities did. I think it was afterwards and so this kind of has that same feeling from like 20 years ago where maybe games were a little bit meaner back then. And so it it is a it was an interesting blast from the past to have this reimplement reimplemented and introduced to a perhaps newer audience who wasn't aware of these types of games back in the day. And so I'm grateful to have played it and I will own it. I I do own it and will continue to play it when I can. And I am interested in, you know, completing more games and seeing how things turn out if I play against people who are more experienced or, you know, have a winning strategy that I want to pursue in a future game. So, it has piqued my interest and hopefully that means like it will score higher with further uh plays and so I'm interested in doing that. So, that is my quick playthrough of a few turns and first impressions of Clash of Magic Schools by Rosenberg. So, let me know what you think if you've played it or if you're interested in it.

Let me know if I got anything wrong as well. And uh thank you for listening or watching and hope to catch you on the next video. Take care.

Progress saved