The REAL threat to reviewer integrity?
Transcript
today the real reason why you shouldn't trust anything I say isn't this hey there I'm Chaz Marlar from pair of dice paradise I'm a tabletop gamer who periodically posts his thoughts about games and the gaming industry here on YouTube and you know as someone with both an opinion and the misconception that people out there want to hear it it is crucial that I retain my objectivity when making those opinions known because viewers out there actually put their trust in me me whose life decisions to date have led to making videos on the internet about toys so good luck to you with that but you know what as one whose product opinions could potentially influence the purchasing decisions of consumers I have learned that much like the people who I play Magic the Gathering with nobody out there likes being cheated so whether I declare a product to be fantastic or abysmal viewers out there need to trust that what I am saying is my own personal truth alright but then what happens if say a company comes along and offers to pay me to evaluate their product you know to produce a paid review for lack of a better term well if you spend as much time as I do online searching for new suckers to swindle up magic then you have inevitably encountered discussions about the ethicality of these paid reviews accusations that some media makers are secretly selling positive
feedback and the negative impact that all of this has on our gaming community and the industry as a whole I mean after all why would I say something nasty about a product if I'm being paid to present it it it makes sense and nobody out there including me wants to be deceived I mean it's the same reason why I no longer see my daughter school plays I mean I know that that's not the real Willy Loman up there on stage it's that Andrew kid from her science class and he's not very good yeah that's right mr. and mrs. Kensington your son is a hack one-star so there you have it the argument against compensated content is a pretty open-and-shut case and in fact the only flaw against it that I can find is the simple fact that paid reviews aren't actually the biggest threat to an influencers trustworthiness and here's why I believe that it isn't because much like little Andrews acting career content creators who endorse products that they don't actually believe in are are going to be laughed off the playground and just like Lou Andrew they'll absolutely deserve it because if a media maker bestows hollow praise upon a crappy product without fully justifying why they're gonna lose the confidence that their audience has of them and then that audience is gonna leave soon they're gonna be left for the channel full of videos that nobody watches and I'll tell you very few youtubers out there strive to create content that doesn't gain them subscribers for some of us it just comes
naturally besides what content creator out there wants to spend their precious spare time day after day producing fabricated positive opinion pieces for garbage that they dislike instead of working on projects for products that they actually enjoy enduring that approach the content creation sounds as unbearable as Andrews amateurish portrayal of Willie's repressed guilt during the Boston hotel room saying just it's no fun for anyone and then what about manufacturers I mean let's say a manufacturer is willing to pay for a product review why would they spend the money for parts labor and shipping expenses just to provide a product to an influencer that's lost their audience because nobody takes their opinion seriously I mean well it may have cost me a hundred and twenty seven dollars to send that jazz guy my product to review but I'm sure that the twelve views that he's gonna rake in are gonna make this all worth it said nobody who runs a for-profit business on this planet ever this compromising one's integrity is the most efficient way for a content creator to lose their audience become inundated with obligations to feature inferior content about products that they hate and be overlooked by the companies that they actually do want to work with which is why I believe the paid review is not the biggest threat to media makers trustworthiness the real threat against it statements like these you know obviously influencer integrity is important
of course but many things can erode away the faith an audience has in a content creator and vague statements like these suggesting that unethical behavior is going on right under our noses while simultaneously refusing to provide any context to support that claim are one of those things this stuff isn't helpful in fact it kind of makes things worse because what such statements actually achieve is just the sow seeds of doubt against all content creators without providing evidence to corroborate such claims making them statements that ironically lack integrity hearing accusations like this make me wonder oh is that the youtuber that they were referring to oh this reviewer likes of products that I don't they must be taking bribes all this influencer reviews a lot of products by company X they must have a secret arrangement for special treatment now I completely understand the perspective that if someone is financially compensated to review a product well then it may be difficult to believe that their opinion is completely objective sure that's a definite potential conflict of interest there but what about all the other forms of compensation the ones that aren't immediately obvious like company making sure that you're always first to receive its news allowing you to reap the views and the subscriptions that come along with being first or the networking advantages that a personality has once they become established in the industry or being gifted a booth at conventions
which can cost thousands of dollars or being invited to industry events or assistance with air travel and hotel expenses receiving sponsorships for content and events that you host or access to complimentary rooms and equipment for recording content at events additionally manufacturers do donate to content creators crowdfunding campaigns they provide promos and other swag for their fundraisers they include an influencer logo award or seal of approval on their products they advertise directly with and sponsor the media that they make and ho-ho get this they even occasionally form real human friendships with content creators and many of those things can be far more lucrative than new and a paid review project ah which brings me to my point first stop casting and ruin school plays he has the charisma of a dead fish secondly a fundamental flaw with the attitude against paid reviews is that it often doesn't consider the numerous other secondary and passive income streams that an influencer can be influenced by and yet media makers manage to maintain their objectivity while benefiting from all sorts of conversation even conversation that you don't see as long as they maintain their professionalism because earning money for producing opinion based content doesn't automatically make someone a shell and refusing to accept compensation while reviewing a product doesn't automatically make someone trustworthy oh sure yes accepting payment to
evaluate a product is a slippery slope so tread carefully but I would hope that content creators would not be made to feel embarrassed afraid or ashamed of being compensated for the work that they produce because compensation itself does not dismantle ones integrity integrity is something that we accumulate or lose with every statement that we make whether being paid five figures to record a video stating our opinion or by giving it away for free on social media nobody who feels compelled to invest their time and their talents in producing content of value should feel that they are required to produce that content of value for free I would suggest that everyone who wants to monetize the media that they make should ask themselves first can I retain my objectivity and if so then what is my time my talent and my voice worth and then go do what feels right for you you