Skip to main content
Loading video...

ELEMENTS The Great Tournament - Lets reinevent the Wheel - Kickstarter Critique Review

Transcript 25:49

Kickstarter Critique, where I take a little different Kickstarter tabletop game project every weekday at 1:30 p.m. Eastern Standard Time. Give my honest thoughts on how the project is being ran. And today, I'm actually very intrigued to be checking out Elements: The Great Tournament. Couple reasons why. First, I was scrolling through games and I saw this one calling itself a deck-building 2.0 game. That's one of my favorite mechanisms of all time. And it's also one of the most recent mechanisms we have in all of board games, right? You know, deck-building is a fairly new concept as it is with with Dominion not being that old. One to five players, ages 14 plus, 60 to 90 minutes to play. The great So, looking at the background, I see a a big castle in the sky or something and a bunch of random artwork of a field, and I'm not impressed at all. I see languages that might get unlocked, which is fine. Um but I'd love to see a box, a player count, the time count, the age, the Well, sorry. That stuff is down there. But but components, right? Some components, some artwork, more than just this thing. I can't even see if that's a person or an animal or whatever it is.

Yeah, it just leaves a lot to be desired. More meat here. There's not like cuz your sizzle's not good. Like your sizzle's not like, "Wow, I got to check this out." One to five players, 60 to 90 minutes is nice, but I need to know more. Also, cuz uh I was contacted in advance about this, cuz apparently there's a a bit of controversy around this with some of the artwork they're using is from Magic: The Gathering, which you know, not not not smart. I mean, put bluntly, like, duh. But apparently it's only for the prototype. And yeah, if that's the fine That's fine, but then you should really mention that, I guess, in advance. And we'll get more to that when we get to the comments and updates. I'm sure some people will will bring that up. But just to put that in advance, uh for what I understand, it's nothing nefarious, just not uh knowing that you shouldn't do that, even though you Yeah, I mean, I don't know. As always, the video I'm thinking three things. Do I want it? Can you do it? How much is it? And I'm pre- I'm pre-inclined to like this. One to five players, 69 minutes, deck-building 2.0. Come on, I'm already sold. This should be like taking candy from a baby.

What does that say? What? It's so loud I didn't read. Okay. Your quest to primordial energy will get you

to grab your destiny, forge your legend. Why is this so loud? Eight cards. What if one of those cards is something that you haven't played yet? Plan your actions. Ooh, that looks nice. Okay, so yeah, I go back to that main image and how boring and generic it is. It's just a piece of artwork zoomed way out. Show me this interesting-looking player board. Show me some of the artwork. Like the iconography looks familiar but different but like show me something with the game as opposed to just Okay, it wasn't just me, Shod. Yeah, that was so loud. Okay, transmute. Okay, so you can combine cards to turn them into other cards that are more powerful. If that's the big thing, that has been done before.

Quite a few times. In various different ways, too, really, if you kind of think about it. Um which is it's awesome. I'm not knocking it. It's just calling yourself 2.0 if that's the 2.0 is uh no. Ooh, my mic is a bit quiet. Thank you. I was having some mic issues. I was messing with it, so I made sure to tweak that. Learn new spells. Same artwork from before. Ascend to new levels of power. Protect your mastery. And there's the main image. Oh, wow. I upgraded my Oh my gosh, I don't even know what to mess with here. I upgraded my my OBS and I was scared and And I don't know what these bars do.

I'll make Okay, figure that out later. All right, 21,000 bucks. It is 2/3 of the way to happening. They have 13 days left to go. And right now I'll just get close to the mic. Also, I will expect this this will fund because it's from France and France is generally very good at supporting their own. I imagine typically that that you are not doing well if France is not the number one country or very close to the United States on the community tab. We'll get to that a little bit later. I am Charlie, the creator behind Flame Games, driven by a passion for fantasy. I crafted elements to pair stunning visuals with deeper immersion and high production quality. So, we have four people over here. That's it's a good chunk of people for your first deck building game. Oh, no. I I can't scroll back. I can't go back because like I said, this was like in the 200s. I lost track Oh, I didn't mention that. I lost track of count where this was on the popularity. It was like 150, 170, then I kind of just passed out cuz I got tired of counting.

Um Elements to the Great Tournament tab, but that's also not great. That means something is really not hitting the mark here. Forge your legend So, after the video, do I want it? Not really. Not really. I saw your 2.0 and I was like, "Okay, that's cool. I like that." But with the cards that you showed me, I wasn't super excited, right? I think with that concept, iconography just for me personally as a gamer who wants to play medium and Euro and heavier games like iconography can only go so far. Unless you have a heck of a player reference card, which show me one then. Uh okay, so that's the components. What is Elements? I I saw the video, but after the video, do I want it? Not really. Looks fine. Can you do it? Zero downtime. Think and program your actions simultaneously. So, is this a programming game? Okay. Then perhaps you should put that there.

Deck building 2.0 Like Like you want to keep the deck building 2.0 fine. It got people into the door to see what you're talking about. But mention that it's a programming game as well. People love programming games. Uh Uh, way back now back now to unlock the ultimate all version of Elements the Founder. There it is. It's the box. Limited and collector's edition, not just one, but both two unlock stretch goals. Every step forward helps transform Elements to an even more exceptional game. So, probably more tiles. Awesome. We support indie art. It's all made by humans, no artificial intelligence. Okay. Like and we're getting to the point now where we're going to start looking at you pounding your chest a little bit more and be like, okay, is that why we need 30,000 bucks?

Is it because how how much we paid our artist, which is great, which is awesome, which is what people want to support. But, if we didn't would there be a different price tag? That's not $31,000 cuz that is a lot of money for a deck-building game. This is cards, cardboard, and some cardboard pop-outs that you've shown me so far. Nothing that shows me I you need $30,000 to make the game. Like, at all. So, hopefully, show me some components. Show me there's a tons of cards, or different size cards, or something. Uh, there's a charisma mini expansion. A special thank you to our founder's edition supporters. Every pledge includes the exclusive charisma mini expansion. The reason why I'm hawking on that $30,000 so much is because you bring up your stretch goals, and if you have a a a a a funded goal that seems way too high at $30,000, and then you have stretch goals on top of that funded goal, like the odds that you're hitting those just decrease exponentially, and everyone can see that, and it's just it's not a good look.

Hopefully, that's not the case here. A $6 retail value included for free with your pledge. So, we got this extra pack, cool. You get it. Premium sleeves, cool. You Oh, you get these. So, Kickstarter bonus. So, this is for buying the deluxe version, or is just everybody buying these? You're just saying you're going to buy sleeves. You do not have a choice. I hate that. If that was like, I know, $0, but I but I didn't pay $0 for them. They're bundled in. So, 150 Oh, ick. Black core cards. Yeah, there you go. If you have to go redo this, get rid of the stupid black core cards. You are paying way more money than you need to. And don't talk to me about blue core. Don't go blue core either. Go pick yourself up some nice 350 GSM plus white. Go 300.

Make 350 the stretch goal. Like but black core, it's just stupid. It's Unless unless this game has just an absurd amount of shovelware. Even even if it does, no. You are paying through the nose for black core cards. And I know that's what the magic or the Pokémon or what the fancy people are doing, but no, that's stupid. This is a deck building like no, no no no no no. Now I hate your $30,000 even more. I hate the cut of your jig even more. That is the deluxified of the deluxified. That is the stretch goal upon the stretch goal. Like there's no way we can hit it, but we might hit it kind of thing. Okay, so we get 50 acrylic gems. Wooden So we do have wooden school tokens. Interesting. So we got a smattering of different components here. Find premium aids. I'd love to know the size of those. Okay. So 49 euros, that's not a bad price though.

So and there it is. You have a decent price. You have high quality components. But what's the cost? It's You have to go to 30,000 bucks. Yeah. Also convert the currencies. It's it's just come on. Cuz most of the people here most of the time will be from the United States of America. For you it's probably going to be France. Yeah, France doing it big once again as they always do. Oh my god, France is destroying us 10 to 1. I don't know if I've ever seen that. Did this just launch? No, America just does not give a crap about Elements: THE GREAT TOURNAMENT. WOW, NO WONDER THIS IS LIKE 200th in popularity. Oh my goodness. Well, I mean look at the main image. If I'm just scrolling by, I can't even tell if this is an an I can't even tell if this is a board game except maybe for that. Like I guess that could help me a little bit, but still it's just Boy, howdy. And we haven't got to the controversy cuz there's like a controversy about artwork or something.

We'll get there. We'll get there. So, uh the price though feels fine. Like it feels like a fine price. 58 bucks, yeah, two bucks under MSRP. I'd put that on the main image, honestly. Uh 275 people said, "I got to have the game." Retail access, too. Dreamweaver pledge. Wow, 300 bucks. Let's get it there. I want you to sell it to me. Maybe I'll want it. Wait, this is the founder's collector's edition. Oh, that's the main one. Comes with Does this one come with the sleeves? Okay, so no, this one comes with the expansion. Okay, good, good, good. So, I don't have to buy the expansion. Excellent. I Uh sorry, I don't have to buy the sleeves. So, for That's fine. That feels like a very reasonable price. 260 uh become an architect of the game. Collaborate with our creative team to shape the illustration of one card. So, decent chance you can change. You can have a card art in the game. I I love that. I bet people have taken that, especially friends of theirs. Yeah, 14, awesome.

Uh the grandmaster pledge, 500 bucks. Oh, wow, 10 boxes. Yeah, one. Okay. Add-on, want more copies? Cool, like that. How to play? Here's some text. A lot of text. Hopefully there's a video. Read the rules, excellent. Read the rules in a different language, excellent. Uh oh, important note on artwork and prototypes. I'm going to guess this is where we're getting into it. All illustrations currently featured on this campaign page are original property and reflect the final art style of the game. However, please note that early prototypes sent to reviewers were produced during the development phase and contain placeholder illustrations, including some temporary AI-generated assets and reference art. The primary goal of this Kickstarter campaign is precisely to fund the remaining human-made original illustrations, and I go back to the 30,000 dollars.

And there it is.

And and that is why I one of the main reasons why I have and will never have a problem with artificially generated artwork in our hobby because it's going to lower the barrier so more people are going to be able to actually get their dreams funded and make them a reality. Now there's going to be some people like this like snooty and put their nose up and be like no no no no no I'll just do it the right way and get $30,000 instead of asking for 20 or 25 or whatever the that number may be. But everybody else who doesn't have that option or don't think don't think they'll succeed at it that's why I love it I love it. We're committed to a 100% no I yeah I got it. Here's a bunch of videos I'll get some quotes out of these that'd be useful. Especially considering they're in other languages right? Like you have all these French videos they're useless if you don't speak French but they're not useless if you put quotes next to them. You just didn't What did they say they liked? I'm sure he said something he liked.

Translate it put it there. Bottom a boom. What makes this deck building 2.0? I have not seen it yet. I still need to see it. Right now I've seen nothing in particular that makes me feel like you've played more than six deck building games. And that scares me. That's not an insult it's just if you're telling me you're selling me deck building 2.0 I want to feel like oh my gosh this person has really explored the chasms of deck building. You know? From Feudum to Clank to Dominion to to to the great ones with the Viking ones. Vikings gone wild so underrated by the way. Star Realms. There's so many great ones right? What are you doing special? I don't see it. Combining cards it's been done. Target aim for the highest score possible so here's the solo.

Um cool. It feels like an afterthought a little bit. Hopefully there's something in one of those videos that makes it feel a little less. How to play? One comment or one tag on the post. One So this is not a how to Oh the center Oh so there's energy social goals. You made it clickable, so I'll actually click it to get you on the hotness, but I'm not doing I'm not doing anything else. But, I do want to go there cuz I'm sure that'll probably have more details about whatever the controversy is cuz apparently people were taking it very seriously, which blows my mind. Um let's just let's just get this out there. If I ever shoot a video with a prototype copy of a game and someone stole art from that or something else, it's not my fault. That's not my problem. I shouldn't have to take that down. There was time, effort, and work put into that.

Period. Heavy-duty punch board. Unlock So, oh wow, your your your social goals are stretch goals. I like that. I do. Uh I don't like the gold foil. Gold foil spot UV. Okay. The final treasured printed fabric drawstring bag. Okay. Stretch goals try to deluxeify it. One new skill tile. Oh, here we go. The stuff that will actually enhance the game. The stuff that we're probably not going to hit. But, we might hit social goals. We We might get that linen texture, but a new skill tile that will actually add replayability, that will actually make the game literally better.

I don't know if we can do that one. Like, the priorities on this project feel completely out of whack, and I hate it. I hate it. Cut of the jib. Just so bleh. The schools And I love supporting French Kickstarters, too. Like, I legitimately do. I'm always excited when I'm like, "Yeah, France is crushing America." Cuz no other country does it. No other country does it but France. Big ups to you, French. French. Good go, France. Uh so this is free if you are picking it up at in friend France. Why can't I say that? Okay. The Grandmaster pledge, cool. It's free if you spend a given 500 bucks. So USA, oh they converted the currencies. Why thank you. So $21, so I'm paying $80 for your deck building game which has 150 cards.

Is that right? That sounds terrible. That that's not right. And I mean I know the shipping is for France, so it's going to it's going to suck, but it's still like it it doesn't help that I don't feel like you've convinced me at all. Like a lot of this stuff here, there's so much good stuff, so much good coverage about this game where you could have just converted some of this. Like literally, you can just you can just plug that into Google and it would give you Yeah. Wow. Why do we have this many people working on your first game? And you have you even have it on BGA? Like they put it on BGA? Now I want to try it on I love BGA like Oh boy.

Uh this is like a okay, cool. Oh what is that? That's the vision. In the early '23 after putting my professional rigor at the service of corporate projects, I felt the deep need for change. I decided to reclaim my own creativity. One morning after a game night, the realization hit me. Every time I play I feel like something is missing. Whether it was balance or the ability to truly thin a deck, I was left wanting more. I started dissecting my favorite games not just as a player, but with an engineer's precision. Um I would love to know more about that. I would love to know like the depths of like what they didn't like about deck building games and then what they improved and made better cuz I don't feel it. I don't see it. Nothing about your game felt special or unique to me. And I know like it's like you're leaning hard on your art and your art like you told me that was AI generated art be like, "Okay."

You tell me that's human art be like, "Okay." They both look nice. Ooh, I do like how they organize this like reload from colossal games a bit. What are my games are Okay, what is it? Cool. Updates, comments, give this one a grade. Oh, did we check out the rewards pages how many people took each? So, 275 took the founders, two for the retailers, 14 for the dream weaver, and then one person helped with the artwork in the game. Awesome. Updates. Projects we love, areas energy is resonating louder than ever. So, zero comments, five comments, one comment, two comments, two comments, zero comments. Let's check out the most engaging post and see what is going on in there. Five comments. Greetings dear apprentices and spectators, reaching out to address concerns raised in certain forums, Reddit, regarding the presence of certain visuals in our prototypes and promotional videos. Ah, this is a controversy. We fully understand these concerns, acknowledge our mistakes, and take full responsibility for them. Some of the current visuals are placeholders from the early stage of prototype. They were never intended to appear in the final game. However, we acknowledge that we should not have been using existing artwork or even AI even on a temporary basis, especially from other games, right?

Like from other book Like if you're stealing art from the internet, that's fine for prototype, nobody cares. You AI generate art from the internet. But like to actually like cuz I think they took some images from like Magic or something. It's like We'd like to personally apologize to Paul from Gaming Rules, to the influence who trusted us, and to anyone this situation may have been put in a difficult position. This situation is entirely our fault and we sincerely regret the consequences it may have caused. The context of the project. To be completely transparent, the first prototype of Element dates back to about three years. At that time, illustrations that inspired Charlie were selected to bring the world to life to help choose an art style, and enable the first test not with any ill intent. So, essentially they chose art they like and they pumped it in there and AI'd it away and did something different, but the people are like, "That looks like the thing. Okay, cool." I don't like the fact that they even have to address this just just speaks to human society. Like, and I say it as a throwaway line. I I don't cover a lot of Kickstarter board games. I will in the future once my daughter goes to school and I get more back into the whole like making board game content more frequently. But, I always mention, like, this is a prototype version of the game. And I never thought that anyone would ever have a problem with anything with that.

And it's like people still do. It's like, "Hey, that's stolen from another game." It's like,

[sighs]

it's like, "Yeah, that's because it was a prototype." Like, "Okay." Like, "There There's a controversy. It's cuz it's a prototype. We're not actually using it. Bye." But, but no, apparently people are mad. Our primary goal of this Kickstarter campaign is precisely to fund the remaining illustrations. I kind of want to see this this Reddit thread to see just how people are reacting. It's all in French. Okay. Elements: The Great Turn. Let's try this. See if we can just find it first time. Elements: The Great Turn. Then we'll give this one a grade. Uh actually, I mentioned this to somebody in the comments, too, probably help us out. Uh no, but it's probably on BGG. All right. Uh yeah, let's give the comments and give it a great final grade. Do I want it? Not really. Nothing about it seemed to stand out to me.

Like, there was some stuff I was like, "That looks neat." But, it's like I still would want more just from my personal perspective. And then if I think And then I try to put myself in someone who likes lighter games, right? I'm like, "Okay." But, then it's like it goes up to 90 minutes and it's just I don't know. But, do I want it? I don't feel like it's sold itself to me very well. Can you do it? Um I have some big concerns. Like, just some things that like if you did some research a little bit more you'd know like the fact that your team is this big for your first project. The fact that you're launching cuz I think it was I think it's 150 cards. Is that it? Is that how many deck building Like I want to go back cuz that's going to heavily impact my grade. 150 freaking cards. This is an $80 game set in the United States of America. It is a deck building game. So cards are important. That is a very important number in this cuz most of the other stuff are not really much. Like I guess the skill tokens do play a good role in it but still 80 bucks. This does not feel deluxeified and and it's just because you wanted to have black core cards because you wanted to to to have a whole bunch of artists because you wanted to have a larger team.

Because you wanted to make your social stretch goals stuff that are purely cosmetic. Oh, it feels nicer on my fingers. Oh, it looks nicer on the table as opposed to actual components that are going to make the game better. More skill tiles and I bet they probably will just throw them in the game anyway because they're probably just but but still just ah hate the cut of the jib. So can't you do it? I have I have concerns. I would not be surprised at all if they relaunch this and retool this. And I don't think the controversy on Reddit is why this is not doing well cuz I'm sure there's some people there like oh yeah, that's why the no. It's because you did a poor job selling something that is overpriced. It feels like and maybe it's not overpriced. Maybe it's worth all the every single penny of it but you didn't you didn't make me feel that way. At no point did you make me feel that way and when you had opportunities to make me feel that way you just didn't.

There's videos down here that I can't understand unless I want to go read the subtitles or really watch it. You could have put quotes. You just didn't. So many things you and it's just Yeah. Uh final grade is not good. It's a D minus? Yeah, before I go with this D minus, I want I want to list them all out here, right? First, using the term deck-building 2.0, you're just setting yourself up for failure. Unless you are absolutely blowing my mind, you are setting yourself up for failure with board gamers. Secondly, main image, boring, generic, doesn't do anything. Third, price, not great. Fourth, first-time publisher, lot of little tiny red flags. Fifth, stupid controversy with the AI-generated artwork, which looks even worse since you're one of those snooty, pounding my chest about how much you you love the uh the the human-drawn art kind of thing.

Like, kind of confusing pledge areas. Like, am I get Am I buying premium sleeves? I'm pretty sure I do not have a choice that I am buying the sleeves with this collector's core edition. Right? And And it's weird how they put this because it they mention the charisma mini expansion, but they don't mention the premium sleeves, but then they say the premium sleeves are free. And it's just like, okay, so I'm paying for sleeves that I might not want that are just incredibly generic. Like, there's just so many things I really dislike about this project. Along with the fact there's no gameplay. Uh let's check out the the rule booklet, though. Look at the back of the rule booklet. Hopefully, it's not art. Hopefully, it's actually useful. It is. Excellent, beautiful.

Yeah, D. I think you could talk me into lower. Um No, I think D's fine. Yeah. Yeah, like, there's no gameplay, and it's like the choice to do black core. Like, what are you thinking? Why would that be such Why would that be a good idea?

D. I'm going to go with a D before I talk myself into a D minus, but you can talk me into it. France, I'm going to give you a third of a point grade bump up because I love France. D. Let me know in the comments below what's your final grade for Elements: The Great Tournament. Also, if you enjoy Kickstarter content, please don't make me stressed out. I'm launching a Kickstarter next week try to raise $3,000 just so I don't have to take money from me and my family's, you know, personal checking and savings accounts to go to Gen Con and Origins and rub elbows with publishers and get review copies and do a bunch of other stuff. So, hopefully later this year when my daughter goes to school more cuz she's going to start going to school more at the end of the summer, I'm going to be cranking up Our's Game Corner a little bit more for year 15. But, otherwise, have yourself a good one. Bye-bye.

Ahoy there, YouTube.

Progress saved