Elements: The Great Tournament Deep Dive
What the Community Thinks About Elements: The Great Tournament
Reaction to Elements: The Great Tournament is divided. The most critical voice is Bower's Game Corner, whose Kickstarter Critique videos judged the Flamegames crowdfunding campaign and its prototype materials rather than the game in play. The host first graded the project a D minus, arguing that an $80 deck building game with roughly 150 cards was not sold convincingly, and later settled on a D after saying they could be talked into a slightly higher grade. Their objections centered on pitch, pricing and presentation, and they stated plainly that the campaign showed no gameplay.
Gaming Rules! offers the opposing view. Paul Grogan played Elements as a sponsored two-player play-through and came away positive, concluding that the "deck building 2.0" label was accurate once they saw how much the game asks of a player each turn. That enthusiasm needs context. They later pulled the sponsored video with the publisher's approval after learning that placeholder art in the prototype had been taken from other games, and they noted that the campaign was roughly half funded when they recorded and doubted it would reach its goal.
The result is a community that is curious about the mechanics but skeptical of the campaign. Anyone weighing the game should separate the design, which the positive reviewer found rewarding, from the pitch and pledge structure, which the critic found unconvincing.
Core Mechanics That Define Elements: The Great Tournament
Deck Building Around a Shared Spell Library
Each player begins with a small, identical deck of spells, and the game revolves around acquiring new spells from the shared main library and adding them to a personal grimoire. Gaming Rules! describes a starting deck of 12 spells that players then reshape over the course of play. The central decisions are which spells to buy, which to keep and which to return. During each night phase, players can sell spells from their hand back to the library and buy replacements if they wish. Because the deck is cycled repeatedly as it changes, the composition a player holds late in the game can look very different from the one they started with.
Transmutation and the Deck Building 2.0 Claim
The mechanic behind the "2.0" label is transmutation. A player spends other cards from their hand as ingredients to turn a spell into a more powerful version, and the upgraded spell replaces the original in the deck. Gaming Rules! points out that this removes more cards than it adds. In their example, spending two ingredient cards to upgrade a spell costs three cards and returns one, so transmutation doubles as a deck-thinning tool. The campaign text the Bower's Game Corner host read aloud also describes "zero downtime" and simultaneous action programming, with players thinking and programming their actions at the same time. Taken at face value, that means no player sits idle while others act. Neither reviewer demonstrated this in play, and the critic questioned whether the game is a programming game at all, so this half of the claim remains unverified.
The Elements: The Great Tournament Experience
A Deck That Keeps Changing Shape
Play feels like constant editing. Gaming Rules! describes an early turn in which a spell was transmuted immediately, costing the player more cards than they gained, and the reviewer returns repeatedly to the freedom of trimming a deck and selling off unwanted spells. They found that the number of ways to customize a grimoire made each game feel personal, and that the game is not one where a player simply looks at a fixed deck and says "this is how this deck works." The experience rewards players who are willing to give up cards they have already invested in.
Five Schools of Magic and Divergent Grimoires
Each player starts aligned with one of five schools of magic, but spells from the other schools can be bought and learned, including spells from an opponent's school. The reviewer noted that a five-player game brings all five schools into play, while smaller games leave some out. This variety keeps players from settling into a single fixed plan, so the table rarely produces identical decks. Elements was played as a two-player game in the sponsored session, but the publisher lists support for one to five players, and the schools mechanism is most visible at higher player counts.
What Makes Elements: The Great Tournament Stand Out
Deck Building That Goes Beyond the Tagline
The clearest praise comes from Gaming Rules!, who admitted that the "deck building 2.0" phrase initially struck them as marketing language before play changed their mind. They pointed to the range of ways a player can alter a deck, including transmuting, selling and buying, as the reason the label holds. Their account suggests that the appeal lies in how many small decisions interlock, rather than in one headline rule. For players who already enjoy the classic deck building formula, that layering is the feature most likely to stand out.
Components and Rulebook Credit From the Critical Review
Even the Bower's Game Corner host, who was harshest on the pitch, gave credit where they found it. They said the base price was reasonable and that the components looked high quality, with wooden school tokens among them. They were pleased to find that the rulebook was useful rather than filled with artwork, and they called the skill tokens a good addition to the design. They also liked the pledge option that lets a backer help shape the illustration of one card. These concessions are narrow, but they show that the physical product was not where the sharpest criticism landed.
Potential Drawbacks
Placeholder Artwork and a Pulled Sponsored Video
The most serious problem is the artwork controversy. The campaign acknowledged that prototypes sent to reviewers contained placeholder illustrations, including temporary AI-generated assets and reference art. The creators apologized for using existing artwork, which reportedly included images from Magic: The Gathering. The Bower's Game Corner host noted that placeholders are normal in prototypes, but they criticized the decision to use other artists' work and called the situation a poor look for a project that promotes human-made art. Gaming Rules! was affected directly. After learning the placeholder images came from other games, they removed their sponsored play-through with the publisher's approval, though they kept their assessment of the game in place. Readers should weigh their praise with that removal and the sponsorship in mind.
Pricing, Scope and Campaign Presentation
Price and scope drew the most criticism. Bower's Game Corner objected to an $80 price tag for a deck building game with around 150 cards, arguing that the cost came from black core cards and a larger artist team rather than from gameplay improvements. The host questioned why a first-time publisher with a team that size was launching a debut project, and they flagged confusing pledge tiers, including unclear sleeve inclusion and a charisma mini expansion. The campaign's funding goal near $30,000 combined with stretch goals struck them as unlikely to be reached, and they judged cosmetic stretch goals such as gold foil and linen texture to be misplaced priorities compared with additional skill tiles. They also faulted the campaign for lacking gameplay footage, a clear how-to-play and translated quotes for its foreign-language videos. Taken together, these concerns mean the pitch, not only the price, is the biggest barrier for many potential backers.
If You Enjoy Elements: The Great Tournament
Reviewers placed Elements alongside the deck building games that defined the genre, and those comparisons show what the design is measured against. Gaming Rules! framed the appeal as a deck that evolves under the player's hand, while the Bower's Game Corner host named established titles to show how much ground a "2.0" claim has to cover.
- Dominion is the benchmark the critic invoked when discussing how recent deck building is as a mechanism.
- Clank, Feudum and Star Realms were named as the field a deck building 2.0 game must stand apart from.
- Vikings Gone Wild was described as underrated, and is worth exploring for players who want a deeper pool of comparisons.
- Magic: The Gathering is the comparison most tied to the controversy, since the critic linked the black core card approach to Magic and Pokémon.
Players who enjoy reshaping a deck during play, and who are comfortable with a premium price and a slow-moving campaign, may find the design rewarding. Those who prioritize polished presentation or a clean record of the campaign may prefer to wait for more play reports and the finished release.
What Reviewers Are Saying
"First, using the term deck-building 2.0, you're just setting yourself up for failure. Unless you are absolutely blowing my mind, you are setting yourself up for failure with board gamers."
— Bower's Game Corner
"They've kind of marketed it as deck building 2.0 and I thought, oh yeah, that's just marketing speak. But actually, it kind of is because you are doing a lot in this game."
— Gaming Rules!
"Maybe it's worth all the every single penny of it, but you didn't. You didn't make me feel that way. At no point did you make me feel that way."
— Bower's Game Corner