Skip to main content
Loading video...

Gloomhaven Review - JonGetsGames

Transcript 43:38

welcome to jacket's games today I'll be reviewing glue Haven this game was designed by Isaac Childress and inside this massive box lies an expansive fantasy world full of dungeon delving tactical car based combat fully cooperative play and an epic campaign consisting of almost a hundred different scenarios first I will briefly overview how the game plays and then I'll jump into my review before we start I would like to mention it as an option you can click the link right up there in order to watch my full playthrough of this game not spoiling any of the campaign stuff also you can look up there to find in the Official Rules video but for now we can go ahead and start and the first thing you're gonna do in gloom Hammond is begin your campaign and as you can see there is there's a big campaign book and it is full of almost a hundred different scenarios and after you have started off on scenario one every player is going to be building their own character in this case we have started up a brute and it is worth noting that this is the first edition version of the game it not the second so there are a couple tweaks here and there one large one is that the health and experience tracks got turned into dials but anyway now we have our brute and they need a reason to go out questing so they're gonna get a personal goal and they'll get two of these and get to choose one of them and it is their reason for finding things in dungeons and going into forests and the specifics on these things are going to tell them to do various things it might be killing a certain number of a certain type of enemy to sing a different variety of vistas or having certain types of gear but once they have satisfied all the conditions on one of these goals then this character will retire and the

player will be able to start a new character but that is not gonna happen for a great many scenarios next up each player will get their characters sheet in which case they can name the character and then track things like experience gold and a variety of other notes that will be very important to as they go throughout the campaign and then they will go into gloom heaven potentially spend some money on items and then go out into their first scenario but I'm going to jump ahead to a little fake scenario right here so that I can explain how this part works so in this case we have a two-player game it's the brute and then the tinkerer and perhaps they start right over here in this little dungeon down here we have all of the enemies that we will be fighting in the scenario in this case I have bandit archers and a bandit guards which are kind of generic enemies in this case and it is worth noting that this is a square card that is tucked into the sleeve and this dictates the difficulty level of the scenario you'll notice we have this one showing right here that means this is a difficulty level one scenario but if we wanted to make it easy we could just slide this in right there and make it a zero and if we were completely insane we could go all the way up to a level seven and as you increment these up the overall difficulty of all these enemies is going to increase before we take our first turn there are two last pieces of setup I want to explain the first is you're going to gain a battle card you'll draw two from the top of a deck and then you will secretly choose one of these in this case this says loot no money tokens throughout the scenario and this one says be the first person to kill a monster in the scenario well I might take this one and then I don't tell my companions about this so this is a bit of a secret objective that I have

and if I am able to do it I will get a checkmark at the end of the game which will allow me to strengthen up my character over time and this might cause me to do less optimal moves that my companions don't necessarily like because we're trying to achieve this goal and then the other thing is we are going to customize our deck for this game in particular when we look at our board we see this number right here that is the number of cars that we have and it's less of a deck and more of a hand at the very beginning of the game with a level 1 character you will have this number of cards so 10 plus 3 with these little X's so we could customize around and remove three that we want to or we could just remove the three with X's and now we are ready to play the game the first thing we do on our turn is go through our entire hand of cards and choose two of these cards and this is fully simultaneous so our tinkerer friend is also doing this at the same time and you'll notice that each card has a top half and a bottom half now you're choosing two cards and that means that when you actually evaluate your turn later on you will do the top half of one of the cards in the bottom half of the other but you always ignore half of the card when you activate these also you'll notice this number that is in the middle of each card this is the initiative value that you will be going at when the actual action starts and these values go from 0 up to a hundred and the smaller the number is the faster you will be going and so in this case I think maybe this is a pretty good plan we could take these two cards right here and we have already decided that down here is pretty good it says Moo three well we're out here and we could move each movement takes us to one of

these hexagon spaces and we noticed this actually says jump on it so that means we can jump over the obstacles that are in the room so normally we could go one two three but in this case we can go one two three jumping right over on that a little pillar right there so that's nice and then we could land and do this attack so you'll notice this icon right here the gray bed is where the actual brute is and all of the red bits are where he can attack with this sweeping blow so hypothetically we could jump one two three and then hit all three of these characters that seems like a pretty good plan but now the last thing we have to do is to decide which one of these two Initiative values is going to be the speed that we go on this turn and I think after talking to the tinkerer player that we probably want to go as fast as we can with the plan that we have so what we do is we put the 54 which is smaller on the bottom we put this just like that on the table and once we have decided and the tinkerer I've decided we can reveal these cards at this point you might be wondering why these cards are put down in secret because this is a fully cooperative game so why wouldn't we just show these to our partners and that's because the game it tries to simulate the active atmosphere that's going on in this area these enemies are advancing on us they're running towards us China draw their swords and whatnot so there's only so much we can actually talk about before getting into the action so mechanically what that means is we are never allowed to tell each other what our initiative value is that we're gonna be going at we can hint at it by saying well I think we're gonna go about medium speed and the tinkerer says well I want to go after you so I'm gonna go kind of slow ish medium speed but it's up to us to figure out what that realistically

means that hopefully their version of slowish medium is actually slower than our version of medium we're also not allowed to explicitly explain all of our plans we can say I could tell the tinkerer I'm planning on two jumping over there and doing a lot of damage to those things hopefully fast enough I cannot say well I'm gonna jump exactly three to this exact location and then I'm gonna do a two damage attack to all three of those that is the kind of specifics that just are not going to be communicated in a fast-paced action environment so you have to be somewhat vague with your partners and now once all of these have been put down we can flip these over and we see that their version of slow medium is 61 and our version of medium oops is 54 and that means that we are going to go first so that plan worked out pretty well for us even though we have now revealed our action cards we cannot evaluate them until the enemies also reveal theirs so they don't combine two cards instead we simply draw the top card from these shuffled specific decks to the different enemies and we see what they're gonna do in this case we see that the archers are gonna go at Initiative 56 and the guards are gonna go at initiative 50 okay we're now ready to evaluate these actions and we start with the lowest number in this case 50 is lower than 54 so that means these sneaky guards are able to activate before we are so our great plan of jumping over here and doing damage to everything is going to have to be modified what it actually becomes our turn because they got the jump on us so now they're gonna take their turn and we look at this card in a little bit more specific and we see there is a move in an attack and you always evaluate from the top to bottom in this case it says

plus zero plus zero that just means this is a generic attack and move for the guard and when we look at their stats up here we see that on the gray side we have a regular bandit on on the gold side we have the elite ones well out here we have an elite bandit and a regular one so both of them are going to be happening in this specific phase and we could see they have a different health amounts different speed amounts with the little boot icon and different damage amounts right here so since there's no modifier to the boots we see that the regular one moves three and the elite one that moves a little bit slower at two when it comes to activations the elite one moves first and the first thing they're going to do is target on one of us and their priority is whoever is closest so we can count one two three hexes to the tinkerer and one two three four hexes to us that means they are going to fixate over here on the tinker and they will move one two and then do their regular attack evaluating this attack is pretty easy we're gonna start by looking at the attack value of our elite bandit it is three then we add to that and you modifier on this card which is zero so we're still at three and then we draw the top card from this modifier deck that is associated with the monsters you can see with the M right there and then you add this modifier so in this case and say plus one two three so it's a four damage attack this will go into the discard pile and if you look into this deck you can see that it could have been a variety of other things like a 2x bolt so that would have been six damage which had been really bad it also could have been minus one minus two and potentially a complete miss which I think we would have liked a lot more but in this case

our tinkerer took four damage so definitely not a good way to start off the scenario next up the regular bandit activates and if we look over here we see they have a movement of three they are going to try to figure out who they're gonna attack and we see that's one two three four two the tinkerer and one two three four over to us the brute so now there is a tie breaker because we're the same distance away so in this case we look to the initiative values of the cards that we picked we went faster than the tinkerer which is gonna break the time which means this bandit is gonna come after us so they are gonna go one two three just like before they draw from the top of this deck we see they got a minus one so that is gonna be 2 minus 1 or just one damage for that attack which brings us down to 9 and we definitely would have rather been the one taking 4 damage instead of the tinker but that's the way that evaluated with all the guards having activated we can now move on and we see that the archer is at 56 but we are at 54 so now we can take our turn in this case we originally chose these two cards that we could jump over here and do damage to all of the enemies but you know what in battles sometimes things don't go to plan so we can now change things up because we did not commit to doing the top of this card and the bottom of this card all we committed to doing was that these two cards at initiative 54 so we can mix things up now and do the top half of this one in the bottom half here so in this case we can evaluate this we are at the great spot and we can hit two adjacent locations unfortunately the enemies in bunch up like that but we could do an attack 3 and it is worth noting that on the top half you always have a default of a two attack and the bottom half always has a default of a to move but 3 is bigger

than 2 so when we do this to the 3 damage attack we're gonna go to our own personal attack modifier deck at the beginning of the game it is very similar to the monster deck and this can get modified as you level up your character putting better cards in here and removing some of the worst ones but in this case we resolve it just like the enemies we flip over the top card we see it's a plus 0 so we know we did 3 damage there so 3 plus 0 is going to be 3 damage total and when we look closer at the bandit we see this little one which indicates this is bandit number 1 when we come back to the bandit card area we see that this leave has all these different numbers on it those are associated with the different bandits so we can put the three damage right there to show that they've taken three damage and we look here we see it takes six to kill the bandits so three more will kill off that bandit and it's worth noting that there are a variety of other conditions that can happen for instance if that attack did a poison effect we can put this poison token down so that we'd remember that man at number one was poisoned and all these are gonna come into play through a variety of other abilities that various characters have the last thing we have to do when evaluating this attack is gain our experience this little one with a star around it is one experience which means we go up once on the track and is important to note that this is the main way you get experience in this game is evaluating abilities you don't actually get any experience for killing enemies off with that attack done we are now done with half our turn we can now do the bottom half of our sweeping blow card and in this case it says we can move three and when you move you can move through your companions and this accounts for the enemies to they can move to each other but not through

us as adventures so we could go one two three if we wanted to or we could just go one right here you don't have to go up to the maximum because in this case this card has a special ability of push one target all adjacent enemies well when you push it has to make them go farther away so we could push this guy back right over here but there's no way to make this bandit go farther so the push does nothing with that and now our turn is done so the archer can now take their turn in this case when we look at the archer specifics we see that it says attack - one target - which means it's going to target up to two of their enemies but it does not have any movement on it at all so they have no way to move on this turn although where they are a ranged character and they wouldn't move if they had people in ranged already when we look at their stats we see that their range is 4 and the tinker is 1 2 3 4 away and we are 1 2 3 away so in this case their target 2 means they will attack both of us and it is important to note that with ranged attacks there is no a line of sight blockage with enemies or companions or even obstacle so they can easily shoot straight over this pile of rubble right here at this point I'm not gonna evaluate the rest of the actions because that you understand the basics now and once everybody has taken their turn they will take it their cars that they used and they'll put them over here to the left side of their board which it means that they are in their discard pile we can go into the next turn in which case we will choose two cards from this hand of cards which is now smaller than before and as you continue to play the game and you continue to play two cards on each of your turns you're gonna have less and less options until you finally get to the point where you have no

options in your hand and at that point you are going to either take a short or a long rest and I'm not going to talk about the amount of specifics between the two but when you rest you will actually lose one of these cards into the lost pile and then bring the rest of the cards back into your hand and any cards in the lost pile are completely removed from the entire scenario so as you continue to go deeper and deeper into the scenario you're gonna have less and less cards in your hand as you cycle through your hand repeatedly if you get to the point where you actually don't have any cards you can play anymore because they are all in the lost pilot because you've cycled through so many times then your character becomes permanently exhausted and they are out of the rest of the scenario but the game is not necessarily over in fact as long as a one of the player characters is non exhausted they will continue to play and fight on to try and achieve the scenarios objective more often than not that will be to just kill off all of the enemies but if at any point every single one of the player characters becomes exhausted then that will be a loss for the scenario and the players will have to replay this one again in order to move on in the campaign at this point there's one last thing that I'd like to explain and that is this elemental board right here so if you remember we were hoping to do this jump action earlier on in the overview and it had this little wind icon down here now if we had successfully done this action it would have activated a wind into the room and we'd push this all the way up to the strong level and that means that anybody taking an action after ours but did not ourselves within that given action can consume this wind

to do bonus abilities and if it is not consumed at the end of a turn it'll slide down by one for each turn so perhaps in the next turn we play this card right here which makes earth energy so this is now strong in the air and this is waning but as our top action we played this skewer up here and if you notice this icon it shows the air with an X over it that means that we can exhaust the air from the room in order to our the air elemental icon from the room in order to get a +1 and a Pierce effect so this is how the elements work they kind of jump up once activated slowly sifted down it through a couple turns until people use them in order to benefit better from their actions and it is worth noting that some of the creatures can bump these up and use them as well so you have to be careful of those elements and with that you should now understand all of the very basics to bloom Haven but don't worry there is quite a lot more going on in this rather complex game let's now begin the review for gloomy Haven by starting with a few positive points and the first of these has to do with the innovative card action system that goes along with every single term in this game now on a broad level it looks kind of simple you're just simultaneously with your teammates choosing two cards out of this hand of cards to evaluate on the turn but there are several things going on into that decision process that make it feel somewhat special to me so the first part of this is that the cards are two parted there's a top half and a bottom half and you're gonna choose two cards and you were only gonna evaluate the top half of one of them and the bottom half of the other one so you have this puzzle of all of these different

options in your hand depending on where are you on the game maybe you only have four cards maybe you have seven or eleven cards and you need to figure out something good to do on your turn while communicating the thoughts and plans that you have with your teammates through vagaries like you're not allowed to say I'm gonna do this much damage to that person I'm gonna be doing exactly this at exactly that time all you could say is I'm gonna move somewhat fast and I'm gonna try and take out that skeleton over there and your teammate says well I'd really like to go before you because I'm gonna do a thing that will make you do more damage so now I want to go after my teammate but before the skeleton but we need to figure out I'm going kind of fast and my teammates going kind of fast too well it would be really unfortunate if I ended up going first and so that's just the thing you have to thread the needle with and in fact with that Court decision prospect you might decide you know this is a really good action but maybe I'll do this other card instead so now I'm going medium speed so that I pretty much guarantee that I'm gonna go after my teammate because it's really important that I get that buff or maybe they're just standing in the exact spot that I need to stand so they've got to move otherwise my plan completely unravels and so that goes into the card selection process but when it comes to those vagaries of you know what you can tell your teammates and then also after you've made the selection only then do you flip over all of the enemy cars to see when they're gonna go sometimes that original plan you had is just not gonna work anymore because of things you could not have controlled or maybe a risk that you took that I did not pan out for you and that's the last great thing about this system is that you are not committing to doing the top of this card on the bottom of that card you're just committing to those two cards and that one initiative a number so once it

becomes your turn you then have two options you can do the top of this card in the bottom back card or the top of this card at the bottom of that card so every single turn when you're choosing these two cards you're effectively coming up with two plans usually one of them is the one you really want to do and the other one is definitely a backup but you have these two different options that you can do on your turn and of course at the end of the day you could always just do a two damage attack with the top action in a two movement with the bottom if just everything completely goes to bus and I think all the stuff works really well it's definitely a lot more than it seems at first with you just saying well simultaneously choosing two cards so I really love this system for positive number two let's now talk about to the different characters that come in the game and there are 17 different ones in the box although you only start with and having access to six of them but every single warm limb has their own unique deck of action cards that they're working from they start at level 1 with a specific starting deck situation and every time they level up they had a new card into their their deck but they always have a choice from two different options so every time you level up you could do this or that and every single one of those choices comes from their unique deck of cards just for that one specific character and that is just an incredible amount of uniqueness that comes into this game and even though you only have access to those six at the beginning of the game they do feel significantly different from each other and there are a couple similarities to typical high fantasy tropes like you have a scoundrel which is much like your a standard rogue character you have the spell Weaver which is much like your standard mage character but they still have their own personality and their own feeling and I just really love the way that they feel

so different from each other as you are playing these things out and then as you are playing the game you're leveling them up they're becoming more your specific character you're feeling them out but it's and eventually they are going to retire and they'll be removed permanently from the game because they're done with their questing they've achieved their end goal and now you can play a new character and you will be able to start dipping your toe into that large pool of eleven other characters that you realistically don't know anything about and going into those and seeing the kind of options that are in there has been one of the joys of this game and I do think that it's definitely a huge strength for this game just how different all these characters play play from each other and just the wide variety of them next we have positive number three and for this one I'd like to briefly discuss the choose-your-own-adventure moments that happen when you are outside of the scenario and specifically this is the city and Road events that happen when you are going into gloom Haven or leaving gloom Haven and I love the world-building that these bring into the overall experience around the table because for these you just reveal a car from the top of their deck you read the blurb at the top and then you collectively need to make a decision about what you're gonna do based off that as a group and I really liked that discussion sometimes it's just like okay we're obviously doing a right and sometimes there's really a heated discussion that happens around the table like one or two people want to do a one or two people wanted to be and we've actually had like negotiations where were in the city and in order to do it we have to spend money and someone says you know what I'll just spend I'll just pay for it entirely myself but if it's good I'm gonna get all the benefit and we say okay you know that's the risk is

now on you even though we are a party you can kind of negotiate those types of things and I just love those experiences and I just like the variety it brings to every session as we're sitting down to play the game specifically those Road events are not necessarily good but they can definitely be quite harmful and you might have a situation where you hear wolves howling and now you need to decide are we going to stand our ground or are we gonna go try to find cover and maybe based off the decision that you made you are now going to start the scenario poisoned and that's a definite handicap you did not want to have going into it but I just like the feel that it adds to the overall theming and attention that it brings to the experience of you know just when you're gonna reveal that card it's gonna be good it's gonna be bad but it's always an enjoyable thing like I'm always looking forward to doing the city and Road events I just think it's a wonderful addition to the overall experience positive number four I don't like to discuss the difficulty and player scaling that comes into each scenario as you play them so this is a large campaign type game and oftentimes with those situations you want to stick with the same player count the whole way through but gloom even allows people to hop in and out with surprising ease so from the majority of the campaign that we've been playing it's been three players but occasionally a fourth player has jumped in with their character and suddenly we're playing a four player experience and the game just scales right to that even though I'm IP level 7 and that person is level 5 and this person is level 2 you just kind of do a little bit of math and then set to the difficulty setting for the dungeon to

accommodate for that and in general it seems like that's really worked out like it's not been a problem having somebody come in and out and having vastly different levels between the different characters although at the same time we have not lost this game very much we've played 22 scenarios at this point I think I've lost 3 or maybe 4 times at this point so in general there is a big bias towards actually winning games but at the same time I've almost never felt like it was a cakewalk like there's always tension and there are many situations where I felt like oh man we almost lost that one but then I look at my record I'm like why keep saying we almost lost that one but the same time I enjoy winning and I don't necessarily want to do that overall scenario over again so I think it really does tow that line of difficulty surprisingly well and it's worked out really well for us at positive number 5 I like to discuss why I think the combat modifier deck is a wonderfully elegant alternative to your standard dungeon delving fair where you are usually just rolling a bunch of a different colored and shaped attack dice and defense dice and then kind of cancelling them out and adding these things up and all that well you don't have that include Haven at all instead you simply have a little deck of cards and every time you do a combat you flip over the top card and see what happens and those cards will be maybe a negative one or a positive 2 or very rarely it'll be a critical hint in which case you do double your damage and with the same amount of rarity that might be a Miss in which case you do no damage at all and I think that the amount of tension and suspense that comes from this little deck of cards is a wonderful addition to

this genre in general like I'd like to see this in they're games because it mitigates the randomness of rolling the dice because there's only one miss in that deck so you can't miss multiple times on a turn because the miss will now be in your discard pile but it's also so easily modified and customized like sure in your standard game you can swap out a red die for a blue die and given how your equipment works and all that kind of stuff but in glue Haven it lets you really customize down to what your character is good at because every time you level up it you can modify that deck you might add some more plus ones you might remove some negative twos you might also add a card that has a poison effect to the next attack that you do and maybe that works well because you are the rogue and the rogues do a lot of poisoning attacks and instead of having to have like a poison die that you roll with everything else you just slide that in with the rest of the deck shuffle it all up and it's just there you never have to make a dice pool like you just always have that little deck of cards and it encapsulates your skill as a fighter in the dungeon and I just think it's great that as you level up that deck is gonna modify and get stronger with you so not only do you have a better cards in your hand to play out but a more adapted and stronger combat modifier deck I just I'm so enamored with that mechanic I think it is absolutely wonderful and it works so well with this game alright let's now move into a few neutral points and the first of these has to do with the monsters that you're fighting with in the scenarios so on the one hand I think the way they've been designed is absolutely brilliant because almost every monster in the game has its own customized deck of action cards that

you're going to shuffle up and then reveal the top one in every single turn and that deck of action cards is going to show the personality of those monsters like maybe they heal themselves or heal their opponents maybe they move faster move slowly maybe they deal damage to themselves maybe they occasionally do a large area of effect kind of damage on the player board and the first time you find those monsters is a wonderful discovery as you try to figure out what kind of thing you are going up against but then the third or fifth time you find those monsters it might be like oh we're finding those again but you're not going to be too boned about it because you really know how they work and you can strategize better and work around their strengths and weaknesses because you fought them a bunch and that just makes a lot of sense but on the other hand the issue that I have with the monsters is that this is fully cooperative games so they had to develop an AI for these monsters to move around the map without any intelligence player actually making it happen and those rules are surprisingly complicated and convoluted and I have played this game over 20 times at this point and I can safely say that I have made multiple monster moves every single time I play this game and I know that because there's actually a little quiz that somebody built and that's out on BoardGameGeek that allows you to that presents you with a bunch of situations like the monsters here the people are here well the monster go to a B or C and I took that quiz and was amazed at how many of those I got wrong and that this is the person who has taught the game many times played it over 20 times and I'm still making a lot of these mistakes and I think that's less about me being

bad at understanding rules and more about the rule set for this being very complicated but the reason this is not a negative point is because the game has still worked like I've played over 20 times it's been fine the difficulty has felt tense every single time I've been playing the game and I think it's likely that there is a bit of an emergent slightly modified rule set that my group understands as being correct that is not actually correct and we wouldn't actually know that if I hadn't taken this quiz or maybe if I was to go and play the game with somebody else I'd be surprised to find that they're moving the monster slightly differently than we did but at the end of the day it still works so even though it is complicated and especially to teach and to understand for the people around the table everybody kind of collectively figures out where the monsters are supposed to go and occasionally when we're not sure we just kind of figured out to collectively together and say well what do we think it makes the most sense for the monster to go in this situation that we can't quite figure out the exact correct spot and that has in general worked out well for us for neutral number two let's now talk about the scenario goals and this is something I've heard many people talk about and that is that the vast majority of the scenarios that you're playing have a goal of just kill all of the monsters in the scenario and occasionally there is a boss monster that you also have to kill within the given scenario but I would say that over 80% of the scenarios that I played so far have just had that be the thing like you start the scenario off you read a bunch of story and then it's like okay we win when everything is dead and from a creativity perspective I especially earlier on in the campaign felt like man I really feel like there

was more variety like do this and that like hit that button and this button and that button down there instead of just killing everything in the scenario but as I played this game over and over and over again I found that it is not felt samy like even though so many of the missions are just kill everything in the area the the puzzle and the way that the different enemies work together within the given environment has worked out surprisingly well and I will say as a non spoiler that most of the scenarios have unlocked at moments like when you go through a specific door suddenly you read a little bit more of a blurb and now maybe the rule suddenly change for the overall scenario and so even though the general goal at the end of day is to kill everything within the dungeon or the forest or wherever you are at the game has done a surprising ability to make that not to be as much of a detractor to the experience as I expected it would be going in now we have neutral point number three and for this one I'd like to talk about the amount of bookkeeping that must take place in order for the game to work so there are two main places where this comes into play the first is the monsters and the health and the conditions that they are dealing with I think that it is really it's a really great idea to have the monster sleeves kind of hide all the information you don't need to see and then also have slots on them where you could put little damage tokens down so you know just how much health that monster has and that monster has out there on the map without having like a big pile of health tokens wandering around the map with that monster but the same time somebody has to do that bookkeeping like you have to put little damage tokens on that specific one and is it you know wolf

number 2 wolf number 3 that's well number 3 okay putting that there and then you put in conditions down like oh they're disarmed or they're immobilized or maybe they're poisoned and then you have to remember that all those things are down on there and specifically look down there and realize like oh shoot they shouldn't have moved at all they were actually stunned so let's undo that little thing and you know these aren't this is not terrible and when you're playing with you know at least three people around the table it's better because you can have certain people kind of task out to specific bookkeeping things usually it's about two people dealing with the monsters and the third person dealing with the magic board so this is the other thing I was going to talk about from bookkeeping perspective and that is that you have the different magic essences that get activated whenever certain things happen and certain cards are played and then they kind of fall down the board as you go from turn to turn and this is something you absolutely have to pay attention to and it's very easy to be like oh did we move those down last turn ah I'm not really sure and so in the game the the the scenarios that we've been playing we've just given that board to the player who is the spell Weaver because every game I played so far has had a spell Weaver and since they do so much magic related stuff it's kind of on them to deal with the magic board and then the other players occasionally dabble with the magic and I think that it's possible specifically with the magic board that it could have been designed to be a little bit less fiddly on the bookkeeping side but it does work and fortunately you can kind of task these bookkeeping things out to multiple people around the table but I figured it was worth mentioning that it is a little bit of desk work that you have to do while you're playing the game lastly we have neutral number 4 and this one is

pretty simple the game just has a ton of rules and you have to know that going in that it's going to be quite a little process to learn the game and then to teach that game to the people around the table I think that this is a neutral point and not negative because these rules are necessary like there's a lot of complicated moving parts to this game so you need to have all of them and the rulebook is surprisingly well done it's a very long rulebook I can't remember exactly how many pages but it took me a couple hours to read it from front to back because I was really going slowly trying to make sure everything made sense but the rulebook also has a wonderful index so you can surprisingly quickly get to the exact page and the answer that you need when you are in the middle of the scenario and you will be doing that many times through the first many scenarios that you are doing and maybe even when you are 20 scenarios in like we are because maybe it's been a month or two since you've played last and you don't remember specifically how this one thing works in one way or another so it's just worth noting that it's not the easiest game to learn and teach but fortunately there are some really good tools out there I know that Paul Grogan from Gaming rules made an excellent how to learn video series and after I read the rulebook I watched those videos and I definitely helped solidify this stuff into my head and also as a little bit of a plug I did a full playthrough of the game that does have some rules mistakes in there but I tried to put corrections but that is something that you could also to get an idea for the flow of the game so there are some good resources to make learning the game better but it is a significant thing that you're jumping into okay it's now time for us to move

into a couple negative points and the first of these has to do with the amount of time that glue Haven asks from your life now this comes from a couple different perspectives and from a small perspective this has to do with how long each scenario is from my experience it's been about two hours for each scenario and that means that we've essentially always played two scenarios every time we have all gotten together to play glue Haven and that process has been about five hours total because you have to set the scenario up and then in between those two scenarios take down one and then rebuild another one and then of course take the game down at the end of the time so that means you're spending four and half to five hours to do two scenarios and the overall campaign I've heard is like 50 to 60 scenarios long which is a lot and I think that is wonderful like there's that much content in the game and I've been really enjoying the campaign and the way the story has twisted and turned and branched in a couple different places I've really liked the writing that goes into it but I want to be farther in like I've played 22 scenarios at this point and I'm not really at the halfway point yet and I think part of that is because the the scenarios themselves are so long like I wish that's the average length of a scenario was more like 90 minutes or maybe even like 75 minutes as opposed to being 120 and I'm not really sure how the game could have been designed to have the overall tension and experience of all the stuff going into it and still be that much shorter but I do wish I could wave a magic wand and make that happen because if that had happened well maybe we'd be 30 or 35 nari O's into

this overall campaign and really gotten into even more of the complex wonderful stuff that's going on there and you know I have you know a life I've got a job but all my friends that I play this have jobs and so we have to work around those things and the last thing I have to mention is a bit of a nitpick but when you retire your characters most of them you just retire them and then you start a new character with the next scenario but some of them have a quest line that gets unlocked you have to go through in order to have that retirement happen and out of our starting the three people we've been playing the campaign with so far two of us had those kind of and objectives and the first one we finished was three and senarios long and the second one we're in the middle of it looks like it's probably gonna be three scenarios again and so and while it's really great that there is this custom quest line just for that character to complete their personal life quest at the same time three scenarios is a session and a half of time that we're just trying to retire a character as opposed to working our way through the campaign more so I wish that these specific retirement scenarios situations had been like two scenarios where maybe like one big scenario or something like that instead of three but I think all this would be fixed if all of the scenarios were just 30 to 40 percent shorter but there's really not much I can do about that it's just something you have to know when you're going into the game next we have my other negative point and for that I just like to talk about storage for this game so first of all the game box is gigantic it weighs 21 pounds and I don't feel like it should be less weight because there's just so much stuff in there to play through but at the same time it is

a serious challenge to figure out how you're going to be storing and organizing all this stuff you've got hundreds of little cardboard chips you have I think thousands of cards in the game box and you know I've seen lots of creative things online where people have done custom foam-core cutouts for the different character pieces I've seen people with lots of bit trays and I can tell you what I've done is I copied what I saw somebody else do online and I got I went to tackle boxes for a lot of the little modifier chats and whatnot but then I bought a bunch of CD sleeves you know CDs like nobody uses those anymore but I thought I found some that had clear facings on him and I put everything that was needed for a specific monster type into that sleeve so all of the chit's and all the cards and then I wrote the name of the monster on the top of the sleeve and I kind of just put them in alphabetical order in the box so it's somewhat easy to find and resore tall these things and you know that if you are trying to you know fight a living corpse you just find that sleeve you pulled out and everything you need is in that bag but of course there's a process of pulling it out and putting it back into that bag and sorting everything at the end of the day so I think that my storage situation has definitely worked for us but I'm not sure if there's actually a good storage situation for this game there's just so many of these bits and then you know the cards I pretty much just left them in the little trays inside the box and every single time I play I kind of pull this out and pull that out and I do have to tell you a very quick horror story the way I have this game set up you can see in the photo is not vertical proof and I forgot about that once and I put it in a backpack on its side and I took

public transit to a friend's house and I came to the place I opened up the box and I found that my thousands of cards had become just this jumbled up mixed-up mess and it was it was horrible it took us a bit to sort it all out I think everything is fine again but but the challenge of kind of store this game is a steep one and it's definitely something you should know going in all right let's now talk about the variability for clim Hammond and it should come as no surprise that I have found it to be way way above what you would expect for your standard game like this now I guess it is a campaign scenario style thing and this game does have that in the box but this game honestly feels like it shipped with the first two full expansions in there already like having a campaign last 60 or so scenarios out of 90 or so potential stars you can go to because some of them are branching path type situations is just crazy like I think if the game had shipped with a 25 to 30 game scenario most people would still have been completely satisfied with that situation and then you have 17 different classes that you can play from there are I think 34 different enemy types that you're gonna be fighting and there's just so much variety the way all this stuff can mix and match together means that in general no two scenarios have felt the same for us and I think a part of that is also that there is a wide variety of room types and bit types like double sign little hexagon pieces where one side is like a broken pillar and the other side is a bush for if you're out on a forest floor and it could be a little bit fiddly to set all that stuff up but once you've set it all up well in one game you're gonna crypt another one you are out in the sunny rolling hills

and it does feel like those two situations and all that stuff managed to fit inside this rather large box but it all comes together with just being one of the most variable games I've ever played when it comes to player account glue Haven plays a 1 to 4 players and I've never experienced the one player game although I do know that it's just like the two-player experience is just one person playing both of the players so there's no uncertainty about what actions they'll be taking and I think that's probably great but I can say that two players have plays great three plays great and four plays great if I am forced to pick a preference between all those I think the slight edge goes to the three player game because the more people you have around the table means the more monsters that you're gonna have to fight which means the game goes a bit longer at the four player experience versus the three player experience but you have the add a variety of a fourth friend around the table who's doing cool stuff out there in the dungeon and I've just really enjoyed those four player games so if I had to give a slight edge it would be three just because it makes the scenarios a little bit less but I personally don't shy away from playing four player games at all and at two it's definitely the quickest way to play the game with a friend around the table and it did work although I think it does lack a little bit of the variety like if you have you know a healing class and then a another support class or something like that that's not really gonna work like you really have to make sure you have like somebody does a lot of damage and somebody who can support that by like absorbing the damage or healing or something like that I do enjoy being able to differentiate the party out as much as possible which of course means more people around the table in conclusion I've played it 22 different scenarios of glue Haven up to this point and I can definitely say that

this has been one of the better board game experiences that I have ever had this game is absolutely amazing and it is not perfect like I have definitely had some negative things to say as well as a lot of positive things to say but the overall experience that it generates at the table has been wonderful and it's something that we have obviously kept coming back to over many months now it's been like nine to ten months or so and I'm hoping to play this one again at some point in the next couple of weeks because I want to see what is gonna happen next if the game provides you with these wonderful puzzles with the cards that you have in your hand trying to figure out how are you going to deal with each individual turn and it does a surprisingly good job of making it not feel samey and I think part of that is because every time you level up you get awesome new cards that come into your arsenal that really can drastically change how your character feels like a level one character is gonna be significantly different than a level five character not just because they were weaker and this one's stronger but this character now has strengths and weaknesses that are significantly different than that level one that maybe you didn't even see coming in and seeing that emergent gameplay for that specific character has been a wonderful experience for me and my friends around the table so I just think that the combination of the tactical card play that's going on within the given scenarios as well as this wonderfully expansive campaign has made something that we want to keep coming back to and the biggest negative that have about this game is that it takes a little bit too long to play and I want to be deeper into that campaign and I feel like after playing so much and seeing so much already

I want to know more like I want to be over halfway through this thing as opposed to being not even halfway through this thing because I want to see how this ends and I have to admit I am a little worried that we might never get there like you know time goes on and maybe at some point we will burn out after 30 or 40 scenarios but even at that point we wouldn't necessarily have seen the conclusion of this campaign so this game is gonna be absolutely perfect for any group who is into playing games over and over again specifically people who have an inherent enjoyment of maybe a diabolo style hack and slash video games like this definitely has that feeling out there on the table with your friends and um I feel like I would just be rambling if I kept talking anymore so I heartily recommend you give this game a shot if you think it would work out for you it is a brilliant experience as always I'd like to thank everyone who's been supporting this channel through patreon including all of these producer level pledges if you two would like to directly support the channel you could do so at patreon.com slash John gates games and I'd really appreciate it also if you like to see more in depth board game reviews like this one as well as full game playthroughs and vlogs please subscribe to the channel thanks for watching

Progress saved