Subastral Review - Chairman of the Board
Transcript
hey everybody today i'm taking a look at a small box card game called sub astral this is for two to five players and takes around 20 minutes to play on average and this one is designed by matt riddle and ben pinchback and published by renegade games so if you watch my content regularly you might know that recently i reviewed a game called stella which is from the same design team and i absolutely adored that game um however that was a strictly two-player game and since i've made that review a lot of people have been reaching out to me saying dan why don't you try up sub astral if you like stella so much because it's from the same design team and also it accommodates a higher player count and that's what i did so let's show you how stella works so first off you're going to have a big stack of cards here um you're also going to have this kind of communal row of cards numbered from one to six and on each of those um cards you're gonna have like a stack of cards which are gonna build up throughout the game which you're gonna either add to your hand or add into your scoring area and i think explaining the scoring of this game first is going to really help you understand how the game works so the idea of this game is you're trying to collect these cards of these different suits so you've got like eight different suits in the game i'm represented by the symbol on the left here and you can see here that i've collected all these different ones here and as you'd expect with a lot of set collection games you're going to score based on a sliding scale so if you collect eight different sets of cards or suits of cards then you're gonna get a massive 36 points but if you only have ever had four different types then you're going to score 10 points however that applies
again and again as long as you start from your first collected set so the order in which you collect cards in this game is massively important because you only score starting from the beginning so you can see here my first set is going to be one two three four five six seven cards for a big 28 points but my second row is going to be one two three four five cards for only 15 points and that's also going to apply for the next one so if i had another one here it's going to be another row of three but because i haven't got that first one these ones aren't going to score either so you really do have to start from the beginning each time to score those sets however there is a kind of polarizing way the game works where your highest or your most numerous stacks of cards or vertical columns are also going to score so you can see here i've got all my biggest sets of cars here are these three well i've got three three types of each and at the end of the game you're going to score your two of those um two of those stacks or your two most frequent stacks and depending on how far along they are on that row so let's just say for example i didn't i didn't have this card because it's going to make it a bit easier so these two here are my two highest stacks because i've got three of each you're going to score for this this particular column you're gonna score three six nine points that's three points each because they are the third along in that row and the same is gonna apply for these ones here they're gonna score five points each because they're the fifth along in the row and as you can probably imagine if i had i'd say
four four cards here that would be my highest stack so therefore they would score six points each if you ever have duplicate stacks like this i'm sure you've got three sets of three um you only still only score your two highest however the lowest ones to the furthest to the left are going to take priority so you are really incentivized to get those bigger stacks further along the line so i suppose we should talk about how we acquire those cards in the first place so each player is always going to have a hand of cards and all you're going to do on your turn is you're going to take one of those cards let's say i take this 5 here and i'm going to play it on the matching number or the kind of cloud number here so this 5 would have to go on the 5 here like this adding to the stack if i need to and then you're gonna have one of two choices so the first choice is to take any of these stacks to the left into your hand so i could say take these into my hand like this by giving more options in the future and then replenishing that card at random like this now if i ever wanted to take the action to the right so let's say i took i played this card in a future round put it on the number four again matching it then i can take any stack to the right of that card into my scoring area so let's take these here i'd add them to the matching sets like this or if i haven't collected that set add it to the end of the row so you really do have this conflicting mechanism where if you're playing a card you have to weigh up you know do what i need more cards into my hand to help me in the future or do i or do i just take
points available to me to the right and add them straight into my scoring area and kind of weighing up the two is one of the biggest decisions in this game because you're always kind of um attracted to take cards add them to your to your scoring area because it's going to be how you win the game but if you keep running out of cards in your hand then you're not going to have that flexibility to do what you want to do and if you don't ever have any cards in your hand then you your whole turn is going to consist of just drawing a card randomly from the stack here which again you're completely in um you know at the mercy of the game and additionally if you ever play a card on the six or the one area then you can always kind of wrap around to the other side so again if i played a one card i can either take these six cards either into my hand or play them in front of me and the same applies to the six to the one so you do have that bit of flexibility with the extremities of the board here but i do really like the way you have to manage your hand you want a good mix of high and low numbers because again the low numbers will give you a great choice of taking any one to the right for your scoring and vice versa with the high numbers will give you any of these stacks to the right and as you can see here as well as the game develops if people keep playing the same number like again the four here you got you can end up crying more and more cards on there making it more attractive for the other players to play one of the other cards on the opposite end again either to add them into your hand or to play them in front of you so you've got to be really careful about the opportunities you leave other players and again having more cards in your hand is going to give you the flexibility to get around that and mitigate that risk that is essentially how the game plays
you're going to keep just playing a card in turn order um until this end game card here is going to be revealed from the stack which has been placed um prior to the setup and then i think each player is going to play one more round and then final scoring is going to be calculated and of course the player with the most points at the end of the game is going to be the winner so let's share my thoughts on sub astro and i think the best place to start is to start with start with the scoring because i think the scoring in this game is fascinating so first off yeah at face value this is just a simple set collection game trying to collect as many sets as you can but i love the restriction that you have to start from scratch here otherwise you're not scoring anything and that kind of extra restriction adds a bit more flair to the game adds a bit more flavor um additionally i love that polarizing idea of yeah i want to keep collecting these sets because there's a hell of a lot of points to be had there but also i want to keep collecting duplicates of cards especially if they're further along my row to score those bigger multipliers if you're doing that you're probably forsaking the ability to collect these other sets so spinning those two plates is quite a difficult thing to master but really satisfying and the fact that the game is so quick it only takes about 20 minutes that tension of whether you're gonna get that pulled off or not is it just shines through massively so i think the scoring in itself well it's familiar it just does enough different to make it feel interesting different and just unique and i think that's brilliant additionally that core mechanism that the flow of the game is just so easy
just play a card from your hand either take cards to the left or play cards to the right that is as simple as it gets and anybody is going to understand that maybe the only thing that's going to take at least a half the game to understand is how the scoring works but once you've got it done this is really easy and as clean and as elegant as it gets in relation to its gameplay and that extra restriction of you know you have to play on the matching cloud and manage work with the cars in your hand just adds enough to the game to keep you focused and restricted but if you find yourself backed into a corner where you think well i've only got this card i can't even take any more cards into your hand because maybe you've got a really low number then that's kind of your fault because probably earlier in the game you had the opportunity to take more cards into your hand to give you that flexibility but you chose the point instead again weighing up those two decisions is a big part of the game and where the interest really lies for me i think the replayability of the game is generally good i mean i play most i find myself playing this game back to back to back again and again um and because it offers quite a quite a meaty and rich experience in such a small time frame i think games like that tend to stand up well for me in terms of getting to the table again and again i love clever little card games and this game falls right into that niche the interaction of the game really lies in the competition the fight to get to the particular cards that you want because inevitably other people are going to want those cards as well and new opportunities are going to keep presenting themselves because each time you take take a stack then and new ones are going
to appear from the deck so you always have something new to work with and you know sometimes somebody might be after a particular card because it adds to their column where you might need that as the next card in your row so yeah that is that scarce competition to get to the cards that you want and all the interaction is gonna or just general playing the game is gonna affect other players just whether you mean it to or not from a production point of view the game is absolutely gorgeous to look at iconography crystal clear and all the different cards have little kind of tidbits on them to learn a bit or kind of like fun facts and little factoids and the actual artwork itself is absolutely amazing um just such a clean crisp fresh visual design and yeah i've got no criticism at all with the actual visuals of this game the production as well no issues at all the card quality is perfectly fine nice slip cards and yeah no problems at all the only thing maybe that might be a bit problem is that the setup of the game is quite big because you play these six cards horizontally next to each other like this and it can be a little bit of a table hold considering how small the game is but that really is nitpicking and generally i'm very happy with the production so final thoughts on sub astral so after stella my expectations were sky high and what these guys could deliver next and i say straight up they really did deliver with this one at first when i played it i thought is this all there is to this game and then i really started to um understand the beauty of this game especially when it comes to the scoring i think this is so well done i always love it when um designers come out with
fresh concepts of board games but still without being overwrought and simple and i think pinchback and riddle have done such a good job of injecting new life into this small box genre and to be honest these games almost feel like they're tailor-made for me this is exactly my taste just clever enough to be intriguing but familiar enough to not be over raw and still elegant in their approach and that's what this game sings to me um love everything about it so simple easy to teach but just needs that little bit of experience to be good at it and understand the nuances of the game i love the progression of it as you know you keep building more and more sets and columns all at the time people are going to keep taking cards from that deck and just counting towards the end where you want to get as much as you can achieved and i'm keeping those scoring systems balanced is massive i also love this little twist on where you're going to play these cards um that key decision of do i need more into my hand in order to keep me going or is now the time to start scoring and also what opportunities am i leaving by keep playing the same cards as other people creating again creating that that lure to make people take a massive column with a single turn so everything here i love um i can't really fault the game at all i think it's wonderful so yeah also if you even scale as well yeah with more players it's going to be a bit more chaotic and you're not going to be it's not going to be as deterministic on what you want to play next because the board is going to be changing more but it still scales well and it feels like you're always involved and because you're just simply playing a card and taking some cards and refreshing and
then it's the next player um you're always going to feel engaged with this one but this is certainly one of those addictive games i'll play back-to-back and it's definitely going to stay in my collection for a long time to come because i think this is a brilliant little card game that deserves a lot of credit um just such a charming design and i'm a well worthy earner of my shield of quality so that is sub astral definitely check this one out if you like your set collection games and like your nice little tight card games just top notch with this one