Tapestry: Plans and Ploys Expansion Review
Transcript
tapestry for being so young is a storied and divisive game while the critical response was overall fairly positive there was some legitimate criticism that had to do with its balance and some fair though a little bit more subjective criticism of it being underdeveloped and over produced for my part i enjoy the game i like the polish and presentation i dig the core mechanics and while i recognized the balance issues as a real thing they didn't impede me from having fun and it helps that the balance was patched via errata so now that we've addressed the anachronistic elephant in the room we can get onto tapestries plans and ploys you know the peepee expansion as far as i'm concerned the best things that tapestry has going for it is the huge amount of variety and interaction and things and also it has a pretty great solo mode and this expansion recognizes and leans into those elements it hardly adds anything new while fleshing out all the elements in the original more sieves more tapestries more dope-ass buildings one of which looks suspiciously like magneto a couple cosmetic upgrades in the form of tokens and a bag more solo opponents sieves and five automa scenarios the one new major mechanical element that's in the expansion are these cards that correspond to the new buildings that are
drafted by each player at the beginning of the game fill out its condition and boom you got yourself a new building in your capital what it really does is gives you a nice secondary focus on top of your sieve for a direction to lean early game it's simple it's effective i really like it but i guess we should talk about the other stuff in here on the mechanical side of things the biggest content updates are the sieves and the tapestries the sieves themselves are on the whole more complex and as a product more interesting you have tricky things like assigning yourself bonuses based on landmarks you've received incentivizing covering normally impassable spots in your capital or getting bonuses and expanding your territory based on the geography surrounding you probably my favorite of the new civs is the advisors who hand out unsolicited advice your opponents go to draw a tapestry card nope you give them one of the many from your hand instead on the whole these are on par with the most dynamic and interesting of the original factions feeling powerful and versatile encouraging certain styles of play and the tapestries are cool too again increasing your agency and encouraging certain types of play for the era they're in effect though some are downright incredible like engineering making your new tech and her play already upgraded granting you the immediate bonus probably the most dramatic update is several new trap style cards that can be played in response to conquering but have the alternate effects from running away to capitalizing on defeat to flat out out trapping a trap i'm a
big fan though more and more tapestries and their usefulness feel like the driving factor for much of your success in the game making a sieve like the aforementioned advisors feel really powerful or despicable if you're on the receiving end of garbage cards as for the cosmetics we get little tokens to mark whether a landmark has been claimed or not i guess i can see this from an accessibility point of view but tapestry is already kind of a chore to set up we quickly decided to leave these in the box also we got ourselves a dope burlap sack to put our tiles in which is nice especially if you are already inclined to use bags for just this purpose lastly the back of the book has a list of patched updates for existing factions for balance look this is nice to have but if one of the major accusations of the original game is related to this issue maybe i don't know print up some stickers or some new cards or something that would have been nice but i guess this is still better than nothing the last aspect of this expansion i haven't touched on is solo which is still really good and the new autumnus is are more interesting because they introduce new challenges like the hucksters who collect tokens and cards that count as additional landmarks for their scoring but when you take an action that gives you one of these cards or tokens or whatever you can take it from them instead of the normal draw pile as for the auto scenarios they are cool and add new challenges to how you play
though keep in mind that while i do like tapestry as a solo game it's one i already often have to refer back to the manual this adds a new layer of scenario specific rules and stuff to remove from your game but the new challenges are inventive such as the first one which makes you identify a favorite track that you get to jump start on but your ability to progress on the other tracks is gated and only goes up if you progress on your favorite so new challenges but new overhead too and that kind of represents this whole box i mean by design this is a more stuff expansion and nothing in here is going to change how you feel about tapestry overall like i said earlier i enjoy the game and the variety is a big part of that so i'm more inclined to like this expansion but i'm sure that the trickiness and versatility of the new civs and tapestries will undoubtedly invite more questions about their balance in relation to the originals and each other that said nothing about them felt too overpowered and the games that we've played since integrating them and incorporating the balance changes to the originals have been relatively close my biggest criticism is that nothing about this really feels essential tapestry already has so much variety just rammed right in there and it's not really wanting more and the things that this expansion does add doesn't really
address any of the issues people had with the base game by introducing this you are introducing more variables that can call into question the balance more stuff to manage more stuff to remove during solo play and more stuff to put away which you won't even be able to consolidate to one box unless you ditch the inserts or allow your new buildings to get mushed into a hole which is exactly what i've done so if you dislike the game or you're kind of ambivalent on it you know you could take it or leave it or maybe you have it on your shelf but you only break it out occasionally then i don't really think plans employees is worth it for you but if you're like me and you really do like the game and you love seeing all the different potentials of the sieves and the interaction of all the different variables in the game in spite of its faults or maybe you really love the quite good solo mode that was developed for tapestry then plans employees like the original itself has enough good stuff in there that it's worth diving into and that's our review thank you so much for watching i've been jack for the cardboard herald if you enjoyed this video we have all kinds of other reviews interviews and recommendations via writing podcasts and video here on our channel and website cardboardherald.com our content is audience supported so if you want to show your support please visit our patreon thank you so much for watching this has been the cardboard herald