Skip to main content
Loading video...

Beyond Solitaire Podcast 142: Betsy Joslyn on Thinking with Wargames

Transcript 57:07

it's adbreak time I'm proud to announce of the Beyond soliter podcast is sponsored by Central Michigan University's Center for Learning through games and simulations and as usual they are up to some amazing things their next game hydr logic cycle is scheduled to come to Kickstarter on March 26th clgs also continues to offer classes in partnership with Gen Con the next course classroom game design yes we can will be taught by one of my absolute favorite teacher Gamers Dr Christian hints it begins on March 4th and you should definitely sign up for it I'll also include a final plug for myself if you like the show and want to support it you can do so by going to patreon.com beon soliter thanks to listeners like you I've been able to keep upgrading my equipment subscribing to streamyard and more but for now let's get on with the show hey Gamers this is Liz Davidson from beond solitire and this week of the podcast I have a very special guest this is Betsy Joslin another Elizabeth fantastic uh and she is a professional War gamer at Ida so Betsy I know that you can't talk about all aspects of your job but do you want to tell people the basics of your job I can try I can try my hardest uh so yeah I'm a I'm a professional War gamer at Ida which is pretty awesome um I get to make games for a living that then no one ever really gets to see but it's still a wonderful process uh working with a fantastic group of people uh so a lot of what we do um is coming together to work on obviously National Security given topics to help design some sort of tabletop exercise or War Gamers for our participants which you know come from a

a range of different Department of Defense entities uh to help them examine problems from a different perspective get them out of their bias es get them out of what they kind of know and think and talk about from day to day um and really try to get them to dig deeper and identify their own assumptions and beliefs when they've thought about these processes uh and a lot of of the the goodness of professional War gaming comes from that alone it's very very difficult to create professional war games where we're going to be able to solve problems moving forward or even predict the future I wish I could say that's what we do in professional warging all the time but that's that's absolutely not what takes place a lot of it just getting players out of their own heads getting the right people in the room to talk to each other and say oh wow I never thought about it that way before and to us that's a huge win so we're constantly working on on different ways different angles and different perspectives to do that through War gaming um but it can take a lot of different faces so it's it's a really interesting job that's awesome just so just to confirm Ida is Institute for defense analyses that is correct so some people come at us to be like Institute for defense analysis that is that is not it the C's anal Institute for defense analyses there's more than one analysis going on here everyone analysis for days so are y'all you're so you're basically like an independent company that does contract work for a number of different organizations is that so we are this uh we are referred to as a federally funded research and development center or an ffrdc um and

the what that really looks like is that we are an independent organization that has been St mandated by Congress to work for the Department of Defense as uh Consultants or contractors if you will so I when I tried to explain it to people I said you know do you know companies like deoe do you know companies like Falen were like them except our sponsor the client and the individual that we work for is primarily the Department of Defense oh that's awesome so I know that you can't give too many specifics but what types of range of topics can't you cover as a professional War gamer I think when people think about war games in the hobby space we're fighting still about whether you know historical conflict simulation of any kind can count or is it only Pew pews on Texas but I'm pretty sure that's not how yall understand it at all so when you're talking about professional War gaming what does that entail that's a great that's a great question there is a massive range to it and it's actually pretty rare that I work on a what we call a pewu game um maybe the more uh the more serious they were is force on Force games um I don't work on those a lot but it could range from any from climate change uh to emerging technology uh it could work a lot with um I'm trying to think of what what I can say that's in between that but it's not it's not necessarily about guys in camo running around or women in camo running around see what they can do with their guns it's a lot to do with if we look at this policy change if we look at this new Factor that's coming in that's eminent like climate change um

how does it affect our Logistics how does it affect the movement of things people to places um and so that right now is primarily I would say what I've been focusing on a lot of logistics games some climate change games which have been really interesting um merging technology games are very interesting right now uh but again those are a lot about not how does this tool operate in a scenario or in a you know in a time in a place with a person it has a lot more to do with what are the assumptions and beliefs and this person is bringing to the table about this thing and what are some challenges and opportunities that we should consider and think about when working with this thing in the future so not necessarily about the thing it's still very very much about the people nice and then the games that Ida is making are you making things that look like board games like there's pieces moving around the table or are you doing something that's more like I think it's the seminar gam I think it's like a model you in right right where they're role playing so like again different faces of games right I've absolutely been part of board games we've got Maps incredible maps that we've been working with pieces from you know 3D printers or ones that we've maybe purchased from out house brought in and put stickers on they're moving them around the rolling dice there's cards involved uh but sometimes might look more like a seminar or what might I refer to as a tabletop exercise where we've got um a a maybe a scenario or a situation and context that we're asking the participants to think about and then we're using lots of structured analytic techniques to help draw out different

perspectives um and different opinions about again those beliefs and assumptions regarding the situation at hand and a tabletop exercise is very different from a war game and that for us a tabletop exercise is about drawing that discussion and again identifying those challenges and opportunities and a war game has a little bit more of that adjudication to it so you've made a decision and then based off that decision something else is going to happen uh so for us War Games might be a little bit more involved and I typically see those board game pieces with our war games where tabletop exercise might have a map involved but it's much more about drawing out the right kind of discussion and conversation with the participants in the room than it is moving pieces and rolling dice that's really interesting so you've mentioned several times that part of your job is to offer different perspectives and to elicit productive discussion that maybe you can't predict the future or you know help people discover the exact right solution to a problem but you can get them to think in a different way how do y'all do that a lot of it um structured in techniques are actually a really great way to do that um because it is intentionally finding a way to move you out of your bias to get you out of the chair that you consistently think in and look at it from a different perspective one of my favorite structured analytic techniques is called worst possible idea I always joke and say I'm really really good at that uh but I will have someone come into a room and I'll say here's here's what we're doing um let's say this policy was implemented and I'm going to tell you right now like it's

not going to work right or or I want you to tell me what's the worst possible idea to get this policy done what's the worst thing that you could think of in order to do this um the other one the other structured analytic technique that I was starting to hint at is called postmortem where it's like what if I already told you this thing didn't fail tell me while it failed and so we're getting people to answer problems but we're getting them I won't call it the long way but a different way we're making them work around the problem and answer questions they wouldn't typically think about and then when all of that comes out and brought to the table all a sudden the participants start to see different things and the ripples that they've created and we start to bucket different ideas and Concepts and next thing you know there's like structured brainstorming that's gone on or there's a new rare perspective that's been shared that nobody else considered um and so in tabletop exercise specifically I would say there's lots of opportunities to just get people outside of their bias get people outside of their Norm by asking those questions and leading them there through facilitation so it sounds like this process is I mean it's partially about being an expert I know that you are researching the things that you're making games about but it also sounds like the process that you're leading people through is actually what does the work that it's not that you have to know more about this technology or I don't know a plague or whatever than everybody else in the room it's that you have to know enough to be able to like get them to do the process that's going to take them somewhere is that absolutely so the

they're the subject matter experts right I'm not the subject matter expert we've pulled people from whether it's different units or different departments or different agencies what have you because they have that subject matter expertise there's no way in the world they're going to come into the room and I'm going to tell them something that they don't already know uh and for a good War gamer and a good facilitator you're consistently working with a variety of different topics so it would be almost impossible for me to to research both a mile wide and a mile deep on all of these different topics but my job is to know what threads to pull at what time if you will um and so getting someone to say you know break that down for me why why do you think that I'm hearing you say this I'm hearing you say that how do we come to a point of Divergence how do we come to a point of consensus and what steps can I take to kind of lead you through that walk but you're the subject matter experts so I'm not going to tell you but I need to find a way to design this so that you'll tell me um and then I'm going to hopefully be able to take all that data that you've given me and then show it it portray it back to you in a way that you don't typically view it and so I didn't make this up I am collecting the data that you gave me and I'm providing that objecti analysis that you've paid me to do um and you might not like the answer but I'm going to show that data back to you and it is what it is that's really interesting so we talk about trying to get a different perspective into you know confront biases how do you know as the person who's choosing the questions and choosing what threads to pull and

holding up the mirror that you're pulling the right threads asking the right questions holding up the non-distorted mirror or the one that has the right Distortion a lot of that is done in the prep phase for sure um obviously I'm GNA have to do a little bit of research I'm surrounded by fantastic individuals at Ida usually who were like hey I do know about this thing so a lot of it is walking around through even the different divisions at Ida to say I'm looking for a subject matter expert on this who I can start talk to I find out about who my audience is and what they need and what they already know um I'm working with that subject matter expert or I'm working with other individuals that I know through the network or the field to identify what are the hard questions that people are really contending with what are the things that they already know um at the end of the day what's the one thing that everyone keeps coming back to and how do I get away from that because we don't want to talk about the same old thing we want to get that point of of Divergence right we want to go around that issue and get maybe to a different core um so in the prep phase that's really what's going to show me where I want to go what I need to stay away from what I need to be aware of in the room when people start leaning that way or they start talking about this or that um I would say one of the issues that I consistently run into for ttxs or War Games is if I'm trying to get us to think from a more creative perspective or a creative brainstorming activity to get us somewhere new and if I have someone who's just like no Doctrine says this Doctrine says this Doctrine it's like okay that's someone that I need to

help get out of that bias and move over here what they're saying is still really important but why do they keep coming back to it they want to make sure that something's being conveyed here because either a past experience or because they're really scared that something very serious is being set aside and not take it into account when trying to be creative and it's just going to make all of the efforts not worth it if we don't consider this thing so let's find out what they're trying to put here let's make sure that's been represented and then we need to move on so no knowing your audience knowing what they need um knowing what they're looking for and knowing what they're not looking for is is one of the ways that we can do that and a lot of that um comes through experience and it's still something that I'm I'm very much learning as someone who's been in professional War gaming for only three years that's awesome so how do you end up in professional War gaming if I had known that that was a career path I think I might have had a different life I I feel like whenever people ask me that I I say I trip and fell into it um and I don't really know anybody who was like when I grow up I'm going to be a professional War gamer and then they go and do that thing I also I had no idea it was a job and when I found it out I was like cool I'm gonna be doing that now um so I won't give you too much backstory here it does have a little to do with my time in the Peace Corp um so after college I had no idea what I wanted to do um I I ran off and joined the Peace Corp it was a fantastic opportunity for for me I came back um I

moved to Washington DC because it's the mecca of of Peace Corp volunteers and was really considering uh exploring or pursuing a career with the state department at the time um I loved service I I come from a military family so I knew that that was something that I want to continue to do and I was uh really encouraged to go to grad school uh so I did and I found an opportunity at American University but the National Security program that was being offered there that was eligible for the Coverdale scholarship which is peace tour scholarship was entitled terrorism and homeland security policy whoa so that's technically what my my grad school degree is in is it Masters of Science and terrorism um so it's not that I wanted specifically to go and study terrorism um it was it had much more with I wanted to do a national security Masters um and I also wanted to utilize and leverage my peace court experience as much as I could and and so I did get the coverdell scholarship which was great got to attend uh but once I got there I found out that a lot of my peers were highly interested and using this degree to join the intelligence Community um and it was at that point I found out that my time in Peace Corp actually uh not not banned me but was a challenge with that there's usually like like a five to seven sometimes 10 year kind of Gap that they ask between my time and Peace Corp and joining the intelligence community so I was wrapping up my uh my masters and was

like wow I really don't know what I'm going to do now because I'm not going to apply to any of those places um and one of my professors had reached out and said I'm thinking about reaching out uh to this company they do um War gaming online and this was during covid so she was like do you guys think that I should incorporate this into the curriculum and I was like oh hell yes please like that sounds like so much fun I've been doing you know hobby War gaming commercial War gaming since I was born my family as has just obsessed with that um and I was born and raised in that community and I was like this sounds like so much fun I want to do that what do you mean this is like a professional thing that people do um and so through that opportunity I got exposed to it as a field and then I was like whatever whatever I do in life I'm I'm willing to do that and I actually quit uh a GS position that I had at the time to take a 60% pay gut pay cut to go work as a wargaming intern for someone and then that opportunity um led me to Ida eventually which was absolutely fantastic and I'm I'm so glad I made that jump because it's it's really been worth it so it sounds like gaming kind of sparked an interest in you once you discovered that was like a thing that you could do does that have any roots in your um in your earlier life like have you always been a gamer who just found out that you could do that professionally or did you get into games because you became a professional War oh God what came first the chicken or the egg um I I don't know I will say

there's obviously a pretty big difference between professional War gaming and Commercial War gaming um and when I heard about professional War gaming I actually you know at that point in my time I didn't really know the true difference between them I was like gaming where I get paid Shut Up And Take My Money like I'm 100% going to do that and now that I'm in it I'm like they they they are a little more distinct than I thought they were I love what I do because it takes creativity um and it really requires that diversity of thought in order to create more rigorous games um and so you don't have to come into the field with a background or knowledge in commercial gaming it helps I would say from some perspective um and we were kind of talking about this earlier but I I have a lot of peers female peers specifically who want nothing to do with commercial War gaming and they're really really big Advocates of you do not have to be a hobby War gamer to work in this field and they're AB absolutely right um and I and I I agree with them I would say however that exposing myself to more mechanics on the commercial side really really helps the way that I look at designing professional war games when thinking about the variety of different mechanics at hand um one of the biggest differences I think about ah maybe it's not the biggest difference it's a difference about professional War gaming and Commercial War gaming is that we will incorporate things into professional War gaming um that have no impact on the game itself so we might be looking at if um you're representing a a some sort of regime we're looking a

regime stability is it unstable is it stable and I might have something in the game that impacts that track but just because your regime is unstable actually doesn't have any other it doesn't work backwards into the game with commercial War gaming everything is tied to each other because of this you can now do this or you can't do this which means you have to go here and professional work we might create that illusion or that Allure um but it's supposed to help it's it's be there it's there to help Drive discussion and conversation it's not necessarily there as like I don't have to do this statistical mechanic balance that might be more required in a commercial game but knowing that those mechanics exist really helps me when thinking about how to convey or portray different information in the professional side so my Commercial background I think helps my professional one not having a Comm background is is fine it doesn't necess it doesn't hurt you at all in professional War gaming um so again long long winded answer to your question but I'm really glad I have the background in gaming I don't think it's quite necessary though interesting so you mentioned different mechanisms and you also kind of we've been talking about getting at really complex topics where you have subject matter experts come in and you're trying to push them you know to these different places through a game how complicated can those games be and still have utility for your clients this is something that we talk about a lot actually in professional word gaming because some of the most amazing

professional War Gamers that I know also come from a very uh complicated complex commercial War gaming background and they can't help but sometimes bring that to the table um at the same time we're also trying to reflect reality we're trying to create schemas and relationships as it exists in the real world because if you don't you know we're creating an opportunity for negative learning which is absolutely something we want to stay away from um because of that some of these professional work games can get really really complicated and we consistently forget that our players who are coming to the table to learn don't usually have a commercial background and I have seen games where it's struggled a little bit and we'll get there you know we absolutely always get there but when we do that turn zero it's usually on the first day of the game itself we want to take aside a whole eight hours if we can to just explain to them the game explain to them the rules explain to them how to play so that we can hit the ground running the next day um and I've seen a game where it took all eight hours to get people there and it was really pulling teeth and even at the end of it they were like you know um I don't really know how this works I'm gonna tell you what I want to do and if you could just show me how that happens in Game form that would be great and it's like cool we can work with that and then I've seen other games that were still complicated but the facilitation and the explanation went so smoothly that within two hours players would like great it we've got it we're good and like they just crushed it and it was it was

fantastic um so I've seen both but I think that as a community we should continue to remember that a lot of these players don't have that background and when we're looking at either our facilitation or explanation or writing of rule books or even just designing the game in general we might need to take a step back sometimes um we don't don't want to misrepresent information but we want to make sure that we're conveying it in a very simple straightforward way so that people can actually play so we can actually gather data so that we can make analysis on the findings of the game so when you are gathering data and doing your analysis what does the data look like is it something that's sort of narrative um do you tell people oh people took this action X number of times or like this is statistically you know I mean is it numbers data or is it observational data and then how do you choose what gets presented to the client that's that's a great question we could talk about this for just like the the rest of the podcast if you want so cut me off when I'm when I'm talking too much um but it is both some of it's going to be numerical data and some of it's going to be observational um typically when we have note takers come in to help us out in these scenarios we might even split them up and say you know this group I want you to take notes specifically on the actions that are taking place in the game what player played what at what time and maybe you could even ask them a little bit of you know why and maybe talk to them one-on one they can give you their reasoning behind that action and then maybe another group of note takers are maybe taking a step back and looking at a much larger picture and saying you know

what's the body temperature of the room what teams are talking to others or refusing to work with others maybe I could walk around and get um a bigger P big picture idea of what's going on with the game and and how people are playing and approaching the game itself so that means that the end of the game though I've got miniature minut like lots and lots of data on on a very very small piece of the pie and then I've got some people can me a much bigger slice of the pie um and it's my job to kind of take all of that information together and identify all right what are highlights what was emphasized what are the big takeaways here um so usually after a war game is done we'll try to do what we call a quick look uh which is a quicker turnaround for the sponsor to say this is you know this is not our analysis yet this is just stepping back taking a big look picture at what happened here's what we're here's what we're seeing you know here's what some of the data might suggest but it's going to take a deeper dive and then we do that deeper dive and that deeper dive can take anywhere from three four months sometimes maybe even a little bit longer and we want to convey to the sponsor here's what happened in the game cut and paste black and white these are the things that happened and then we want to be able to step forward and say and here's why they happened and this is where we're looking at both the participant data what they were feeling the rational the reasoning behind it what that highlights again about beliefs and assumptions about some of the

decisions being made um we'll look at kind of a pre and post test almost of before the game what were they thinking about the scenario and the actions they wanted to take after those actions were had taken place and they saw how it adjudicated did it change so they thought about that scenario or not we collect all that information we try to bucket them again if I've had multiple participants saying the same thing maybe that's a higher highlight if I had an anomaly happen if I had like a side piece thing that happened I want to make sure I call that out I want to spend also a good part of my report saying these are the things that were not considered these are the things that we did not take into account when looking at this game so when you look at our findings right um we don't usually make recommendations but when you look at our findings you need to look at them within this vacuum we didn't consider that there could be a tsunami that happened out of nowhere and changed everyone's priorities right so we we make a a list of called constraints limitations and assumptions so that the sponsor absolutely understands things that were within and without a scope of this project um and the things that also helped framed why we looked at it the way that we do so before the game is even really developed we'll work with a sponsor to develop something called essential questions um and that again is where we highlight from the very beginning before we're even working on prototypes of the game what kinds of questions are most serious or um maybe that's not the best way to say it are most importance to the

sponsor and then we're going to build in mechanics and then we're going to build in a game design that addresses those questions so at the end of the day if you're like what about this it's like well that wasn't one of the essential questions that we discussed together so that's not something to game took into account and that's not something the game was even designed to capture so that doesn't mean it's not relevant that doesn't mean it's not important but the game wasn't designed to look at that so if that's something you're interested in then let's look at the way to modify the game mend the game maybe make a new game that does answer that question for you and then we can collect data in that way so I have seen game reports that are 250 pages long um I have seen some that are 20 pages long uh the the longer it is the less likely it is to be read so I'm a big fan of you know tightening it down as much as we can um and getting that bluff out there for our participants uh for for our sponsors but that can be hard when you're working on on a very complicated game so we we do our best we do what we can so do the same people who collect the data are they the same people who also were there for the essential questions phase and who designed the game and who led the game or do you change like staff to handle different parts and I guess how does that impact the kind of data that gets collected or yall do you feel that you train people so the data is consistent regardless that is I think something um that we are still working on is building a consistency of training for our notet

takers um I think the the war gaming team at Ida is a fantastic team but we've got a lot of Demand right now um and often I will need someone with more experience to help me facilitate or be a wh cell adjudicator for a game but that means I have less people to be note takers so I'll have to pull from maybe other departments or divisions and ask for their help but that means these individuals are coming in they might have only had one exposure to the game before um in some worst case scenarios if someone gets sick last minute I'm pulling someone who's never seen the game before to come and do note taking which can be a real Challenge and that kind of stuff happens all the time um but we are really starting to build a core group of individuals at Ida not just at uh the joint we fighting division which is what I'm at but other divisions as well who we can consistently draw on to help us with these events and the more that we have these individuals help us out we're seeing a lot more consistency um and and stability and rigor in the notes that are taken which has been super super fantastic um still you know from beginning to end having the same team can be very very difficult again whether um we start off with a core team and then new projects come in and someone has to be taken away from that project due to other PRI priorities um other people get sick uh items like that that that kind of stuff happens and so it's it's pretty rare that you'll have a single team of the same individuals who are there for the essential questions who are there for the design and the development who are there for the game itself who are there

to analyze the data and who are there to write the report um I I got brought in to help facilitate a game uh with I think about three weeks notice uh and again the game designer did such a fantastic job that I was able to just capture the game really really easily I ended up facilitating it no problem and that has a lot to do with the designer but now I'm here helping develop the report because I was there um and I got to talk to obviously a lot of the participants and I got a feeling for the room as I was adjudicating so I have data that I want to contribute and unfortunately some of the individuals who were there to help with their report have now been drawn away for their priorities on other projects so that kind of stuff does typically happen but again um there's a lot of trust which is pretty pretty fantastic um and when you when you start off with good prep work at the beginning when those essential questions were done with the sponsor when there was thorough work to to kind of lay out what was in scope out of scope what were the constraints limitations and assumptions and when you've got really clear straightforward design and and rulebook writing it just helps everything else down the line and and then you can to situations where you're pull me in with three weeks notice and the game just went absolutely fantastic I'm I'm going to give a shout out to to Cameron Swan he was a designer for that game he did just a just such a great job that's awesome that's awesome so a question you you established essential questions and kind of client priorities at the beginning but how

often do the best insights that they have from War Games line up with the questions they thought they were asking at the beginning I would say rarely and that's part of our job um we're going to get a lot of individual who come in and say this is the problem and they're not wrong but sometimes we need to say hey you you laid out a problem but it's a massive one and uh we might not have the time or the resources to adequately capture all of that so A some things we can do we can look at just this piece of the puzzle or we can back this up and we can actually do some sort of Workshop or or tabletop exercise or even just an internal discussion to say well what's the problem that caused that problem maybe we need to back it up some more maybe we need to zoom in some more um and I would say very consistently when we start develop the essential questions with a sponsor they'll start to see it from a different angle and they'll understand I can't do it all but this we can do and these are the Topline questions that I I care the most about in bulleted form and a much more digestible and approachable form um and it's really really great to work with sponsors who are open to saying I have a question and I understand that that question may change based on our discussion and that is really what our job is is to help the sponsor get there um but there's absolutely been times when they've come in and they say this is our problem and we do all of that work and Analysis and breaking down and we go you know what we 100% agree that is the problem and and we're g to move forward with that so it's all about

having a trust and good relationship with our sponsors which we are so far I've been blessed to do I I love the sponsors that I work with they've been fantastic so hopefully that that continues in the future so you clearly really enjoy your work at Ida but you also um have a gaming design and Publishing life beyond that so what are you doing outside of work that's related to games both in terms of publishing that you're doing which I think sounds really cool uh and games that you're designing yeah I feel I feel like I'm doing I'm doing a lot I'm trying I'm I'm really kicking a few things off I feel like I've got a lot of irons in the fire but all of it is still in development vment um and something that I really didn't know before especially in commercial War gaming it could take me years to develop a game um especially if the the game just isn't where I want it to be and I know it can be better uh but even sometimes just balancing my personal life my professional life and the things that I want to do in commercial gaming outside of that some things just have to be put on the back burner and because there's no you know imminent deadline and because no one's pushing me for those things to get done can afford to wait a little bit and so that happens a lot um but right now I so I am a wargaming instructor for the Moors wargaming course which I absolutely love doing I am the head of programming for the women's wargaming Network and I am the co-chair for connections Next Generation

Um I've also for the last two years been presenting for connections us and connections UK which has been a fantastic opportunity and I recently just accepted a position at John's Hopkins University I will be teaching a wargaming course next fall U on war gaming 101 essentially for some grad students which I'm really looking forward to so these different kind of networks that I've been part of have really really helped me um kind of get opportunities to do new things uh so I'm about to publish an article with Andrew Olson from CNA on training War Gamers uh specifically we're looking at what we call Journeymen who are War Gamers who have had their foot in the door have some more than maybe entry-level experience of professional War gaming but aren't considered um very very experienced yet and Andrew and I put ourselves in this scenario where we've been in war gaming through three or four years three to five years uh but we would not consider ourselves like experts on any like if you gave me any topic um that had to be in any format right I might struggle with that there's some topics I know better than others in some formats of War gaming that I know better than others uh so how can we sharpen our skills so that's something that um I'm been working on really hard with him and we're looking forward to getting that out soon I also just finished a piece with Stephanie game who's the other co-chair from connections NextGen uh we are looking to submit that piece to a journal soon so I'm sure that will still take some time because it needs to be peer- reviewed uh but it's on rulebooks

and we're really really excited about that um it's based off some of the presentations that we developed and presented at connections us and connections okay so um get excited for that because eventually it will come out and it will be awesome yeah can we get just a little spoiler about like what are some of your overall conclusions about rule books I'm just oh my gosh you're gonna get me on another rant um so we we were just looking at the Next Generation and the way that we convey information and the different ways that the next generation is actually absorbing that information um and kind of looking at rule books of the past maybe rule books from the 70s uh to rule books of the 90s and then the rule books of the future and what are things that we can take with us us we're we're living in such a great time where commercial War gaming commercial gaming in general is really expanding and we're getting like a whole new group of individuals who have not been exposed to gaming before who were super interested and want to come to the game table which we're all for especially women which I'm really really excited about however the way that we used to convey information might not be most appropriate for now but let's not throw the baby out with the bath water there's some really really good things that came from those War Games especially the story in aspect I remember growing up my my father and my brothers when they got a new game at Christmas the first thing they would do was open the rule book and we did like a book it was read like it was like it was a page Turner people don't do that anymore I recently played a cute little game I think it was um poetry for neanderthals you know just something cute and silly with my boyfriend and when I opened up the rule

book one of the first things it says was don't read the rule book this is the worst way to learn rules go to this YouTube link can check it out right um so just looking at the different ways that we have traditionally shared information um looking at what Settlers of Katon did with building an almanac versus building you know a quicklook reference guide to how to play the game versus looking at well here's the designer's background and the designer story that they want to share all in separate booklets um why did they do it that way what are the pros and cons of conveying informations in different way and as we move forward what are some better ways that we could convey information to the Next Generation so it's it's a lot it's like 22 pages I can't wait to read that honestly I'm super EXC like as a teacher I'm always thinking too like generationally what works and what do people how do people respond now I think about that as somebody who writes and now edits Rule books um oh my gosh I actually really like writing Rule books I I'm a big fan too of making sure if I can and obviously this is this is a luxury not people can afford this but if you can make it to so that the designer of the game isn't writing the rule books um I really prefer that I'm I'm helping uh with one of my peers at work right now we're writing a rulebook for a professional war game that we did because the sponsor wants a more off-the-shelf version of the game um and I'm a big fan of being like let me do what I can because you are elbows deep in this my friend um and I've heard you convey information and I've seen people look at you just like super confused and

you're like how could you not understand this and it's because you have just like you're you're so passionate about what you do but you've been the only person looking at this for months and though you're not even thinking about the considerations or questions that people who haven't seen this at all are bound to ask um so if you can get someone to play test your rule books like that's that not again not everyone has that luxury not everyone has that time um but I I've recently started doing more rulebook writing uh at work and even outside of work a little bit and it's it's a lot of fun it's super challenging but it's a lot of fun yeah I got really lucky because um David and I had wonderful play testers for night witches who asked great questions about the rule book and definitely help me make it better so fantastic play testers like the unsung heroes without home games would not be nearly as good yeah and and unfortunately too for the designer because of time and resources the the rule book is often put until like last minute or it's the last thing we have to do um and it might be even a thing that's stopping you from getting this game out there and you're like I just want it done uh and there's there's a bias there that you got to be careful of um and there's a few rule books that I've read that I absolutely wish would be Rewritten um I'm not going to name what they are I know I know one right now I know one right now that I wanted to be Rewritten and it is getting Rewritten which I'm really excited about um and it's it's just a great game the rule book is just not where it could be

um and it's not because it's bad it's just like just a little too ambiguous us and when you create Rule books that allow or permit different interpretations of the game you're not playing it the way the designer deemed uh which can be super dangerous especially for professional War gaming right so yeah I'm I'm excited about that piece coming out I think it's going to be good I think it'll be well-received so stay tuned for that um I did also recently uh finish designing a game with Sebastian Bay for the naval war College horns of a dilemma um which is on ethics and leadership in the military uh really really cool experience and I think what was so rewarding about that um was that it's actually very simple game it's nothing crazy it's no it's no loral Commander okay like it's it's a card driven game um and it's really a game like most ethical games it is meant to uh present you with opportunities for much further deliberation and discussion than is presented in the game itself um it's that you know that game table talk that really makes the magic of The Game come together despite the fact that it's so simple so many so much of the feedback that we got from the from our play testers was like nothing like this had been done in this Arena before and it was really bringing to the table Rich conversation that they're like this kind of conversation is something that we usually have to pull teeth to get or again we have to think of very different creative ways and teaching in order to get our students to this point but you were able to create a card driving game

that can do that and create off the bat um very rich and rewarding conversations about very realistic and serious events and that was so rewarding to hear that even though it was a simple game we didn't do anything crazy it had we had done something that people hadn't experienced or explored before in this Arena um so we're contributing to the field and I and I absolutely love that so um well I'm very excited to see where that goes as well neighbor World college is still play testing it with their students currently so um I think in the spring we're going to get some more feedback from them um but they love where the product is headed and that's been absolutely awesome for us so I'm glad that that effort has been checked for now um I don't know if it's done just yet um I'm trying to think I just finished designing a micro game called medic yeah it's fun so Ida is actually uh put together a a Ida micro game project which we're calling imp um and it is being led by a car barage and myself uh and we are just walking a few Ida employees and this is um we're doing it at Ida but it is being done outside of Ida working hours um on our own computers and our own resources we're just walking them through how to design a micro game which is something I'm really passionate about and is actually the topic that I instruct for the mors war gaming course um and so through that process even though I'm teaching others how to do a micro game of course I had to design one of my own for fun so it is

a a cute little game that is on triage ethics combat triage ethics so once our little project is done because this was done in our on our free time and because we didn't use Ida resources we are going to be able to publish them as individuals so that will probably go out sometime in the spring um I might have a few more people play test it but it's in a really good position right now so I'm happy with that and then I am involved in the Zenobia competition right now so what me too that's crazy so working working hard on that um and and happy to talk about that if you want me to but um it's very much a a uh in working progress so yeah I'm gonna leave that because I know you're mid- competition and I'm mid like reading proposals so we're just gonna like not worry about that part of our life right now yeah but that's been awesome and I'm I'm really excited to see where that goes as well so few different iron in the fire but I always feel like there's some more that I could could do and now that I'm wrapping up two articles and I've finished my micro game I'm like I got to do something else but maybe maybe I should just read a book and relax so we'll see what I do that's what my therapist tells me but do I no um so one more real question before I kind of ask something fun which is I've noticed that both of the games you've talked about are about ethics in difficult situations ethics of leadership ethics as a medic what draws you to ethical topics and how do you you feel that they can best be

drawn out in board game form man so I've been waiting for someone to ask me this um because I'm not thank you for asking me this I should have prepared a better answer um as of late I have really been interested a lot more in ethical games um and I think one of the reasons they might not be done too much is obviously they can be incredibly sensitive um and the last thing you ever want to do is create an ethical game that looks to measure or assess the ethicalness of the players like that's that's something we want to stay away from um however it's totally worth talking about hard and difficult situations and kind of exploring um the different varieties of Ethics that exist my ethics might be different than your ethics that doesn't necessarily mean that mine is right or yours is wrong it could or it could not and just because we have different forms of Ethics doesn't make one of us more ethical than the other and so finding um safer areas with still important and potentially sensitive topics um I think is really really important interesting and unique to do in war gaming um so you got to be careful about it but I do think there are ways to do it um I think whenever I I've thought about war gaming when I first came into professional War gaming I always said that I wanted to create you know like a Kobayashi Maru situation and I I always love that idea because it's not necessarily about the end result it was about how you maybe

held yourself or mitigated the situation that you were in and that was the data you will that we would be collecting rather than who won or who lost um it's you know how do you deal with certain death you know when facing it type thing so I kind of want to bring that same energy if you will when looking at these ethical games where they're not about winning they're not about losing but it is going to create some questions that you have for yourself and even discussions that you want to have with other people so for the medic game for instance um you are playing the medic an explosion has gone off and I've created some variability in the game that you it could be different in different locations but before the explosion even goes off you've got these four little figurines of um individuals that could be in your unit and I ask you to name them using your family uh or friends before even anything's happen and then you place them in these different zones and then I have two different shapes U for individuals that might be locals and i' I've made them not look like human Silhouettes they're just a symbol right and again that's a discussion in the game if we dehumanize individuals that we are not necessarily consider ourselves close to does that change how we might approach that situation um so then after you've placed these individuals then you roll die to see you know where the explosion goes off and that kind of lists out for you who's in what area of hurt whether it's a green zone a yellow zone or a Red Zone um and

then you've got limited time um usually in in terms of M fairs we look at as the golden hour where you really have one hour to get to someone to assess them to apply you know triage if you will uh potentially treat and then hopefully a metac unit will be there at that time or a cvac unit if you will to then get them to the next level of care uh in this game I've given you two hours and each kind of action that you do takes up certain amounts of time um but the way that I've done it is that you have limited time and you have limited resources to treat so it's all about who do you go to First why do you go to that person if they're really really hurting in a bad place or you going to choose to leave them and give care to somebody else that you could potentially save what if you do save someone that was on the brink of death what does a quality of life look like afterwards and so it's it's just to draw out these different kinds of questions and again there's no winning or losing but at the end of the game um I don't know if you ever played that peg game at Crackle Barrel oh yeah the one like you're a you're a genius n poo no rose exactly but based on the number of of pegs that you get is like your this kind of you know like a little narrative about how you're doing and I did the same thing where you tally up points based off of what the end result is um and so you're trying to beat yourself if you will and you want to go back and do the game differently to see if if you can get a little different narrative for yourself um but even at the end of the day like again if you

save someone who's on the brink of death and they're like okay well they have no limbs and they're now a vegetable um but someone who was maybe in the green zone who you ignored because you thought they were fine and they died because you didn't get to them close enough or you didn't have enough resources to help them out you know let's let's discuss about what you think about the scenario you could be very fine with that you could be like I did what I could with what I had and I have no regrets and it's like understood right but let's have that discussion and now would you want to look at it from a different perspective would you like to make a different approach and so it's it's a solo game um you're playing it against yourself good I like this I I'll love me I'll love me a solitire game um so it's it's again just there it's not to assess if you're ethical or not but again the situation that I gave you is when you're never going to be able to save everybody you don't have enough time and you don't have enough resources so it's a little bit of that Kobe ashim Maru it's not about winning you're losing it's about how you handle the situation how you feel about it when you do it are you okay with the decisions that you made are you not okay being not okay with the situation is totally an acceptable response let's talk about that um and so hopefully that's what the game's going to do but even in the game I've set up um a section for these are questions to ask yourself these are questions maybe even to discuss with another person and that's where a lot of the meat comes out of these games so ethical games might be pretty quick in terms of mechanics but really hoping that the nature of these games draws out a lot more uh serious and and rewarding discussions so we'll

see if I make some more of them but they've been um they've been eye opening to work with thus far and I'm Gonna Keep exploring them for as long as I can I think oh man I want to play this now so we're gonna talk out the show but for now um just really quick uh what what games have you been been playing for fun recently so we've talked about brutal situation games but what's been bringing you some joy as a player oh my gosh so I I will say that when when you play games all day and I don't do it every day there's absolutely some days where I come into work and I'm like we're doing eight hours of wargaming today I'm either the play testing or helping development um and those are fun days but those are pretty exhausting days um and I am very blessed to have a partner who wants to play games as well so when I come home he's like you want to play games and I'm like uh I would like a nap so I have been looking for games that um give my brain a break if you will um at last night I I played wingspan again I haven't played wingspan in a few months and it was so much fun to just be like this is light the art is fantastic you know the game takes what 40 minutes maybe it was quick it was easy it was fun um that was great but I think tonight we're going to be playing shores of Triple E which is like maybe a little more serious but still fun quick easy simple two-player game um my dad has an epic collection of of War games but they're an older time if you will so whenever I'm home I kind of use as a library experience and I'll check out a

game and then I'll return it and check out another and I recently uh borrowed his Lord of the Rings game and I also because I've been sick for last week uh purchased all the extended versions of Lord of the Rings and just watched them all so now I kind of want to play that game um my my favorite forever and for always right is Scythe I just love Scythe so much um it's it's hard to find people who want to play it with me because they open up the box and they're like this looks complicated and it's just not as complicated as it looks um so sometimes I will play that game online through Steam instead because I can't find it's just one of those games that's a lot better with three or four people it's still fun with two but um it it gets more enriching with more people so I play that on Steam from time to time um I also recently just checked out from my dad's gaming Library n503 which was like one of my favorite games when I was a teenager so I'm excited to play that game again as well um so now I'm just spewing off games that I've played no it's fantastic you know you gota if you're making games I believe in a healthy gaming diet sounds like yeah I like that I like that I like that so yeah I I took a break I think from gaming for a while um there was a certain point where I was just doing too much and it was becoming it was it was a little uh exhausting and I had a game night with some friends and it was like we were just you know drinking drinking

some beer and having some game appropriate snacks which is pretzels and don't don't want any residue on the fingers kind of game snacks and it was so fun and it was so lighthearted and I was like this is what I miss like it doesn't always have to be serious it doesn't always have to be about man I got to make sure I'm collecting data so that I can analyze these findings later like your friends I mean maybe I should start that would be like a that would be a fun blog to be like I've analyzed my friends and I game nights and here's what I'm finding um but yeah the it's all about playing when you want to play right when you're when you're in the right mindset and then getting together with some good folks um which again is a luxury not not everyone has that when they want to have that but I've got some pretty awesome friends who are always down to play games which helps beautiful and if people want to follow your work online where can you be found so I'm on Twitter I have the weirdest Twitter handle of all times it's not my fault I can explain it um back when I I was working uh doing some War gaming research for a company and I A lot of it was like I had to look up real people on Twitter to kind of see what their their tone of voice was when they were tweeting because I was helping this is before jat GPT I was helping generate um tweets to build a narrative game uh so I got myself a Twitter for research purposes only and I obviously have seen uh 1983

war games so I made a Twitter handle called Whopper uncore GTW 1983 so anyone who knows the movie War Games gets it but anyone who doesn't know that thinks that I'm bot so that's my Twitter handle I have not changed it it's still that um I I only tweet about wargaming essentially um and I feel like I need to do more of it sometimes but when I when I'm out there gaming I'm trying to take photos of it as much as I can if I'm in an area where I can um I'm on LinkedIn I I'm on Facebook I'm not on Instagram sorry guys I that's a long story I got locked out of my account can't figure way to get back in so I'll figure it out one day um but super easy way to get a hold of me is through Linkedin and Twitter um I I check those regular so if you're interested about micro games or how to get into professional War gaming um absolutely reach out I'm all about you know extending the pipeline for new war Gamers um bringing again more people to the game table always always um let's increase the diversity of thought increase the diversity of play it's going to make better War Games both both professionally and commercially and I'm I'm super passionate about that fantastic uh so everybody should go follow Betsy I can be found anywhere online is beyond soliter uh but Betsy thank you so much for coming on it's been such a delight to talk to you thank super looking forward to stuff that's coming out from you absolutely thank you so much I appreciate it all right everybody uh please like subscribe comment ask questions and most of all

happy gaming

Progress saved