The Game Makers Board Game Review - Make Real Board Games!
Transcript
Hello my friends. Today we're going to be running our own game factories, getting all sorts of different components, using them to build games or using them to upgrade and do different things inside of our game factory. And we're going to be building games that you know and love. All the ones that you find on Board Game Geek. These are real games, not parody names. You're going to see the wingspans, the sides, the code names, all the popular games and games that maybe aren't even as popular but are really cool looking. Today we're going to take a look at the game makers. This is the Bohemoth game from Bezier Games. Uh, let me show you how to play and I'll see you on the other side.
Before I get to the moment you've been waiting for, I wanted to tell you about finding your grill game at Noble Knight Games. Grill games are games that you've always wanted but are no longer in print and very hard to find. Hence, finding the holy grail. Noble Knight buys and sells pre-owned games and developed a condition grading system from 30 years of experience from buying and selling games so you know exactly what you're getting. Maybe it's the top 100 game mechs versus Minions and you don't want to wait a year for the next printing. Or maybe the slipcase version of the classic game Acquire from the 1960s. So go on your holy grail quest at Noble Knight Games by clicking the link in the description of this video or on the eye up there in the upper right. Now, the Game Makers is all about making these games, and there's all sorts of games in here like Canvas and Calico and Carnegie, and you know, Cgraphers, D-Day, Chronicles of Crime, Code Names, Fractured Sky, and many, many more of all different genres. And speaking of those genres, there's four different genres of games. Like in the upper right, you'll see a gear and some orange. Those are the engine building games. And you'll see ones like Ark Nova, Brass Birmingham, Castles, and Mad King Levig. and they all have different costs in the upper left and some bonuses and goals and points in the bottom.
Or maybe you're looking at set collection games which have the blue banner at the upper right like Everdell or um Hombra or Potion Explosion. Again, having different scoring opportunities at the bottom there. Or maybe you're going to focus on cooperative games like Forbidden Island or the Seventh Continent or Green Team Wins. Again, all of the co-op ones have different types of goals at the bottom as well. you're trying to get cards in your display case on the edges in the columns or maybe war style games like Black Orchestra or dominant species or Eclipse and they have the red sort of swords in the upper right and these have different ways that will score different things at the bottom as well. Now, each player is going to get a display case and over the course of the game you're going to be gathering resources, spending the resources that are at the top of the card to actually create that game and then putting it in your display case. And there's all sorts of different spatial things you need to pay attention to for a lot of the different scorings on these. Now, some of these cards when you build them just get you more resources or sometimes resources and points, but other ones scored depending on what else is in your tableau.
Like green team wins get you one point for every cooperative game in the right two columns. Uh like this one and this one. Where seven kind of gets you points one point for every card in the first right two columns that have cards as part of the cost, which in this case is all six of them. where dominant species will get you a point for each red war card on these specific spots in your tableau. And you can kind of link a few of these together. Or you might get a point for every column. They have at least one card that has at least cards needed. So all these have very different ways of scoring, but this is mainly what you're trying to do in the game. Now, each player also gets a massive player board, and most of the scoring at the end of the game happens off this as well. For example, for the engine building games, you're going to get one point per column that you have at least one engine building or one point for every two of the set collection games.
Or you're going to get a point per uh co-op game if you have at least one and every other player has at least one. You get a point for every one of those other players that has at least one, but you'll get more points if you have three or more. You'll get three points per person that you have more war games than because you're waring against them. And you're also going to be planting trees. you'll be getting two points for every two trees that are planted. But not only are those points, in addition to the ones that the cards give you at the end of the game, you're also going to be moving up these marketing tracks because the points I just mentioned get multiplied by how far you go up a track. So if you don't get to at least the first level, it's zero. But if you get at least to one, you'll get there, but you can get up to a multiplier of five for the different tracks to help you on the multiplier scoring for the ones I just mentioned. Now, this is all facilitated by an interesting action selection mechanism where each player gets their own set of forklifts of their color. And these are sort of like metal hot wheels, those old little cars. And each one's going to get three of these.
And it's all facilitated with this amazing board that is a round board with all the pieces that sort of fit around it. So, let's show you how this works. Now, if you've played Formage before, this uses the same action selection mechanism. And hey, it's designed by the same designer, Ben Rosset, one of my favorites. Now, what you're going to do is simultaneously everyone's going to take one of their forklifts and move them either to the first one, the second one, or the third one. If you move here, you'll get tiles. You'll get a level one tile, which looks like this. If I move my guy here, I'm going to be getting wood. So, I'm going to get some workers, level two worker. If I place here, I'm going to get plastics, which is a level three structure. So, it actually shows you what you're going to get here. It also shows you what's going to be coming up in the turns after that. Uh, but then people put them up all at the same time. It's all simultaneous. Now, as you're placing here, you're actually gaining this right away. And this is the coolest, one of the coolest parts of the game is everything is a multi-use component because let's say I got a level two worker. I could put this here to use it for a component. Keeping it there until I have the right amount of components to build Carnegie. It would be in my hand where I need a level two worker and a level three tile. So, all I need is a level three tile and I'll be able to build Carnegie into my display case. Or you can put your worker in the break room. And this is going to allow you to sort of give you some ongoing abilities or one-time use abilities like seeing more cards when you draw cards or moving up some of those marketing tracks for the the uh multiplier scoring or getting different resources if you match it up with a single worker. So I could for free go like this and this put my two workers and get either two cards, a level two tile, level two worker, a level two dice, or a level two
structure. Now when you get tiles, of course, everything you get you can use to keep for components to make the games with. But if you have tiles, you could place them in your assembly line. And if you ever get three of the same type in a row like this, well, you've just gotten yourself uh, you know, an extra bonus where now anytime you have to pay cards to get something to to build a game, you could do it with one level less. And if you ever make a diamond shape in these, you get to get any one of these tweenies, which gives you a reward, like a single tile or a level one die, and you end up just putting it here because you used it. So, it lets you get some extra bonuses that way. And when you gain structures, again, use them for components or you can start placing them on things like this conference room, a level one and a level two. And look at this. Now I've unlocked this. I get two points uh for every two cooperative games in my display. Or if I complete the billboard, I could put a level one worker here and move up two on a marketing track over there. Any any any two spaces once or one marketing track twice here. I when I if I did this, I'd be able to gain a level two worker every time I put a cooperative game in my display case. And if you get a dice, you take the level of dice and you roll it and you get to move up any track that much. So I go one, two, three. I could move this up three. And the larger the dice, the better the levels, the higher the numbers that are on that die. And that's all happening simultaneously.
Once everyone's moved, this awesome little Brody wheel, which is like magnetically attached to here, moves like this. And then everyone does it again. Now green gets to go twice, yellow once, and red once. Sometimes you'll have a turn where you don't do anything because all your people are sort of further away. And now you can get a level three cards which is getting three cards in your hand which again you can put as components or you can keep to try to you know uh you know build those as soon as you have the right uh the right things and again simultaneously once everyone's done it and now unlocks level three a wild one. So that's pretty much how it works. Now eventually this moves around. You'll get your workers back and you'll get the use them and such. But from a higher level mechanically this is how the game is played. Now I do want to show a little bit of the storage solution. So, you have the board on top where where all the wheel is and such. Under that is the card tray and all the trays that sort of go around that round wheel. Under that, I have the bags. I kept the tiles in the bags and everything still fit. Uh, but yeah, here you can see all the trays.
Essentially, they all slide out. They all have all the pieces there. This whole piece lifts out. Now, we have all the display case boards. Then, we have all the player boards that are folded. Then, we have all of the player pieces that have these sliders here. the Brody wheel, some extra trees, all the cards, everything fits in there just like that. Before I get to the moment you've been waiting for, I wanted to let you know that Game Toppers is known for their highquality game mats with over 38 styles and 12 sizes from some of the top artists in the industry like Vincent Duty and Ryan Lockett. They have the perfect storage solutions for all your mats like mat bags and mat racks. In September, they'll be launching the Game Matts Bazaar crowdfunding campaign, which will highlight the greatest mats on Earth, including the new Victorian Steampunk Mat, and many others. Visit gamet topperslc.com for a free limited time. Receive 15% off existing stock using discount code gameboy geek 15 off.
Okay, I first want to disclaim that I did do a paid preview for this game when it was on Kickstarter. That has no bearing on my uh opinion on what I think about it now. Um, and I do not give opinions in any paid videos, so you won't see an opinion in another video. So, here is my thoughts. Let me first talk about what I liked about the game. The game is just an amazing production. I mean, this thing just looks amazing. It looks great on the table. So, so much thought went into so many things, even the storage solution and how everything fits and just there's a lot of attention to detail here. Amazing production. Um, generally speaking, now Formage, Formage was a game that came out a couple years ago. It was my strategy game of the year. This is designed by the same designer, Ben Ross. One of my favorite designers because he's done Search on Planet X. He's Between Two Castles on Mad King Levig. Uh, he's done a lot of great games. Forage is one of them. This is I call this Fromage on steroids because it does share one main mechanism with that game, which is the action selection wheel, which is just awesome.
And it brings me to that. Now granted, this is a very different game from from Formage, but how you use your workers and how many turns it takes to get them back is pretty much this a similar mechanism and everything else is different, but that action selection is it just worked so well in Fromage and it works so well here where like you've got you've got to figure out what you want and when you want it. Do you want a level one, a level two, a level three? Well, if you want the level three, you got to wait three turns to get that worker back. Well, I know I want to get something that's going to be available next turn, so I'll just go one this turn. and I'll get him back and I'll be able to get the level three of the one that's just coming into play. Like there's all this like future future planning on what you do and it's just it's just really clever. It works so well. I'm surprised more games aren't using this after Fage did it in such a great way. Um and so yeah, it's just really great. Simultaneous play is this g one of this game's best assets because it doesn't matter how many players there are. Everyone's doing things simultaneous. Now granted, you got to trust that everyone's doing the right things and paying the right things and doing this and that. Sure, once everyone knows what they're doing, you just got to trust your group. But man, does it make the game speed along at a great clip. Now granted, once in a while there'll be one player needs to think a little bit longer. Everybody will be waiting for them, but it doesn't happen that often. And simultaneous play is great in this. Well, we all love multi-use cards, right? This another big key thing with this game that makes it really stand out are the multi-use components. It's just such an interesting thing. It's like, do you use the cards to use as components or do you use them to actually those are the board games you're building the dice components or do you roll them to move
up tracks for the multipliers? You know, the workers, do you use them, you know, what do you do with them? Do you do you put them on and have some special abilities? There's always different choices that you have in the structures. Use them to build the the board games or use them to upgrade your factory. Same with the tiles. use them to build or use them to do this little tetrisy polyomino lining things up to get extra bonuses and giving you discounts. And it's just so interesting that everything you get, you've got two choices. Build, you know, hold it for a component for later or do something with it now. It's just it's really what makes this game really stand out. The spatial puzzle that uh of putting those games in your display case is just fun. It's, you know, you're trying to get things in columns. You're trying to get things like some of the blue games, the the the set collection. You're trying to make them go in certain certain directions and lines and things like that. Um, or the special special spatial thing, setting up those tiles and getting the little tweenies with the little bonuses. Just lots of different things to think about. This game, I'd say, is definitely heavier than Fromage.
If you like Fromage, that's why I say this is kind of like Down Steroids because there's just more going on, more to think about. Uh, and it's, you know, it's it's higher in the cognitive load stuff. Uh, you do do drafting those goal tiles at the start. So, you're always going to sort of set like what kind of little bonuses you want, but also like a a longer term sort of strategy for your for your goals. So, overall, I got to say this, it just has so many things. If you like mediumweight EO games and you liked the action selecting in in Formage and you like the theme, which how could you not, this the game the theme is just crazy cool. Uh, and I do like the tiebreaker is like the highest game on board game. Uh, I'm really impressed with this game. I love it. It's it is gonna be one of those heirlooms in my in my in my game collection. It's a big box. Uh, but it it it deserves a space in in my collection. So, now no game's perfect. So, I'm going to bring up some things. A lot of these are little nitpick things, not big deals. Um, number one, there was no guide on how to put everything back in or get everything set up for the first time in the box.
Now, with that being said, um they did just recently release a video which I watched and really helped me. Thanks, Jay, for doing that. Uh watch that and that helped me put everything back. But there really should have been a guide either on the inside of the box lid uh or a little insert that helps you because it's kind of hard to figure it out. By the way, I did fit uh the bagged tiles underneath the card tray uh eventually. So, I didn't have to take them out and put them back in every time. They they still just fit that way. Um, the other thing is this does not bother me, but it might bother you. U, they don't fit all of the cards sleeved. Now, granted, this is the the uh the completionist version that has I think 540 cards and I think because a lot of cards got added, they no longer fit when they're sleeved. However, I did see that someone in Board Game Geek said that yeah, they got these Titan sleeves and sure, they they had to, you know, put they put them in other places in the box. So, they're still able to get the lid the lid down without lid lift. Uh, but they just had to basically put some cards in three different little deck boxes, I think, that they that they got and they put them there. So, you they can fit if you do the thing, but some people uh you know, you I I don't sleeve cards, so it doesn't bother me. But you you should know that if you do get the completionist reward and you want a sleeve card, you're going to have to get some little small deck boxes and and put them under the top and under the insert as that player as that person said. Uh the purple co-op scoring, it's not hard to understand. Uh but the way it was worded and the icons aren't great. I mean, there's been a lot of forum posts and and I don't know, it could have been
a little clearer, but it's pretty simple when you think about it. Hey, if I have at least one purple, I'm going to get points for every other person has at least one purple. And if I have three, I'll get even more points. It's pretty simple to explain, but the icons iconography isn't that clear. The the whole like team versus solo thing. And there there was some confusion there that could have been cleared up a little bit. Hey, scoring in this game is great, but it also takes a while. You got to figure it all out at the end. It would there's a there's a like, you know, there's a trend in this industry that we're like there's all these scoring apps now uh where you just take a picture of your tableau or whatever and it just scores everything for you. This is a game that could really use that. Maybe there is one and I don't know about it. I know Bezier Games does a lot of in-house development. Uh maybe they're working on it or maybe it's already out. I don't know. But if if they if it's already out, I missed it.
If it's not out, it's a great This would be a great game for that. Uh the game is a table. This thing takes up a ton of room on your table. The playerboards fold out on twofolds and then you have your display case. So, I have pretty big pit tables and it was really hard to fit uh five of us at the table. In fact, we had have some of our boards show off to little sideboards. The game takes up a lot of space. Uh, but it does look great on the table as well. There was one little minor misprint on the player aid with the the the engine building games. It said horizontal row engine building. Uh, but I think what it meant the icon showed vertical uh columns. So, I think there's a little mismatch there. But these are all little nitpicks. Uh, I'm trying to be as fair and and unbiased as possible here and giving you positives and negatives because I do love the game. With that being said, you should know if this game is for you. Uh, by the way, I did just see on social media that Bezier Games is offering $25 off the completionist version of this game. Only the first day of Gen Con. So, that's the Thursday next week when this video goes live of Gen Conzier Games. If you buy it at their booth only, you get $25 the completionist version. Uh, you can check that out. Uh, for all these reasons, it is keeping a space in my library, which means I get to get rid of like two or three games because this box is huge.
Uh, so with that being said, let's uh let's kick this thing off and duct it properly with a sax one serenate.