The Lord Of The Rings Ascension - Final Grade - Kickstarter Critique Clip
Transcript
Okay. So, I We're going to give this one a final grade, but I actually want to go look at their components just so I can see once again how terrible they've done a job of spotlighting them, which is not even including pictures. No pictures. Why would you need pictures here? You have pictures of it. Why would you do this? I hate you. I hate the cutting room jig. Okay, final final grade. Do I want it? Is yes. It is Ascension, which I really enjoy. I have Ascension. I have two or three or four expansions. I enjoy them. Yes, I want this. And it could be played with this. But, you didn't make it easy for me to figure it out that I could even play my old Ascension with this. The absolute bare minimum I would expect you to do, you didn't do. You didn't spotlight the cool unique aspect of like, "Oh, it's going to have all three games. They're going to be played together. It's going to be super neat.
The boards will connect." Except for just like such a split second in like just in a nothing bit about this video, which I feel like most people just tuned out of because it was 4 minutes long. It was way too long. And it was way too long especially for what it was. If you could pack it with meat for 4 minutes, by all means bring it. And I will enjoy and I will say fantastic. That was a delicious steak. I'm ready to buy your product. But, you didn't do that for 4 minutes. You focused on the sizzle and it was the wrong sizzle. All right? You focused on how hot the engine from the delivery truck was. That sizzle instead of the steak. And it was just it was a mistake. Whoa, that was clever. Look at me. Do I want it? Yes, I do. But, if I don't like Ascension or if I don't like Lord of the Rings. Like if I'm not in love with either of those, I think you did a terrible job convincing me of that.
Can you do it? And and that's And once again, I want to go back to do I want it? They did so many things well. Like, "Hey, look at all these awards we won. Ascension's fantastic." Like they have the pledge where I can buy every single thing. They have the leather bound thing. They did so many things. They checked all these boxes. Like, that's great. That's great. Great. That's great. But, then they just the showcasing of it all of it was just so poor. So, can you do it is yes. This is hopefully something they're hoping to be a cash cow for a very, very long time. So, undoubtedly, can you do it is I just want to mute this. Can I not mute this? There we go. Uh is is yes. And then, how much is it? Now, this is one where I typically tend to go with the crowd, but I honestly feel like 178 isn't terrible if I'm going to get this from the $60 MSRP perspective, right?
So, it's 100 That would be 180 bucks, you know, for the intellectual property, Lord of the Rings Ascension on top of it. It's got these Yeah, here it is. It's got They got the three boards that can connect together. Like that shot. Like the fact that the shot of the boards not lined up. That there's just not an easy spot. And then just so much clutter and garbage. And getting to the price before you've even really gotten me ready for that price. And then just meandering and meandering. And then this thing where it's like, "Oh, hey, by the way, that stuff you were going to buy, here it is without the prices, too." And then just the choice to just tick off your deluxeified people, right? And just cuz that's going to be a huge chunk of your bread and butter is going to be the people spending five There you go. There's those three boards. Those are your unique mechanics, right? I don't see the unique components. Yeah.
Yeah. Like, here's here's what this really could use that all encompassing shot that has like, "All right, here's all the standees. Here's all the boards. If you go to the deluxeified, you can get the acrylics." Yes. Can you do it is a yes, but I feel like they did a very poor job of convincing me. And they do have some customer service issues, apparently. Like where, you know, they're not the best at customer service, potentially. Especially if you're you're not from the United States of America. Look like at least in their in their their previous ones. And then, how much is it? Cost is crazy. I can't back the uh uh
[sighs]
And I go back to what I said. I don't feel like the price is good. I feel like the price is top-end Kickstarter reasonable. I am I'm shaking away all the emotions here. And if I told you that there was a Lord of the Rings deck-building game based off of one of the most popular deck-building games of all time, and there's a $150 all-in that is going to get you the three core boxes. One of them is the Fellowship, one of them is the Two Towers, and one of them is Return of the King. So, that's 50 bucks a box. They got their own unique boards. I say once you get up to the shipping, you're up to $178. I feel like most people would be like, "All right, I'm done here." And you'd be like, "Oh, it also comes with a couple extra promo stuff and cards in a tiny little box." You say it doesn't feel like a good price. I could probably get this cheaper after the retail. And there it is. I just talked it out to myself. Yeah, I'm going to go with a third of a point grade bump up cuz I said it earlier in the video. They are up against the retail gun. And when I'm looking at this up against the retail gun, $178 for these three games feels terrible. Especially as someone who literally purchased the other three Lord of the Rings Well, this is a terrible example, but I'm going to I'm going to cut that out.
I'm I'm not going to mention that part cuz that's a whole different company. I got my my wires mixed up. Bottom line is, yeah, I expect you to probably get this after the fact at retail for for for cheaper than that. And then you can just buy it one game at a time. So, yeah, how much is it is really a pretty big sticking point there where it doesn't feel good in any capacity. And then when you do get to the deluxe version, you have clearly shot yourself in the foot by saying, "Hey, this is the deluxe version." and then not committing to it being the deluxe version. Which, you know, if I'm the target market for the deluxe version, you say, "Hey, this is the deluxe version." I'm going to be pretty dang ticked off if I find out there's a different deluxe version that I had that I can get if I just had to click an extra box to be like, "All right, I'll pay an extra bucks 80 bucks." Cuz here's the bottom line, it's might not be about the extra 80 bucks. It might be about the fact that I didn't realize I had to do that, and I shouldn't have had to do that cuz that's not an industry standard, but you would know that just yeah, ick.
Uh final grade is um all over the board. Do I want it? Yes, but uh not not really because of you as much except for Ascension's great. Can you do it? Yes, but uh I'm more just banking on the fact that you are going to milk the living snot out of this game for a very long time. As you should. As you should. I hope they get more Ascensions, they all play together, and they all can wrap each other, and we get the NHL hockey Ascension one day, and I'm serious. I want all these different versions of Ascension uh that I think that would be fantastic, and I hope that's the way that they go because I think it really does give games legs, especially on people's shelves. So, I think it's a smart company thing to do. With that being said, you just fumbled everything else. Just everything. Like the most simple of things, you just couldn't convey very well. It it makes me wonder like who is in charge of running the Kickstarter, and if they were board game fans or not, right? And I've said this so many times, I feel like over the last few years, where it feels like a lot of these companies that offer to help like just don't understand the board game crowd and what appeals to them and what things anger them and what stupid little things, those stupid little quirks that people expect.
And just [clears throat] yeah, final grade is a is a and then focusing on all the art and then the AI art I guess is not AI art, so I don't even know despite the fact I feel like that's what most people are complaining about if you go to BoardGameGeek about this game. Now, I feel like the price just I feel like it went from people being angry about AI art and finding out it's not AI art, to be like, I hate this price now. Final grade is a uh I don't understand the audience for this video. For this one, for this particular video, it is uh people hoping to run their Kickstarter projects and just to see what the industry standard looks like. I'm just looking at a company and being like, "Hey, what did they do well? What they didn't do well? What could you potentially utilize that?" Cuz I'm sure there's tons of stuff here even if to be a smaller company you can be like, "Yeah, okay. Don't do that. Do do that." Final grade is I'm dragging my feet D plus.
D plus C minus range. I just I can't get over how poorly they did spotlighting their boards and their components. And just banking on their artwork. Locking add-ons behind things. Just just so many poor choice after poor choice after poor choice. Final grade is a D plus. Let me know in the comments below what your final grade is for The Lord of the Rings Journeys in Middle-Earth by Stone Blade Entertainment. Somebody's at my door. I got to go get it.