Skip to main content
Loading video...

Great Western Trail {Solo Variant}: Discussion

Transcript 19:03

some viewers may find the following video disturbing viewer discretion is advised hey everyone welcome to the discussion for the solo variant of great western trail second edition uh and i believe if i'm not mistaken that this uh variant specifically came with second edition or at least it came in the box uh because the first edition i do not remember ever seeing a solo variant and i gotta say it is pretty damn solid like i uh i wasn't sure how this was gonna work because i'm like well i mean like there's a lot of moving parts in great western trail this is not like the lightest of games and of course there's heavier games than great western trail that do have solar variants that work out extremely well uh but there was just a lot of moving parts you know the fact that you have to manage the uh all your little disks of upgrading based off going on to you know delivering to different cities placing um placing buildings you know hiring the the different workers buying cows there's just a lot that's going on that could have easily made this solo variant extremely cumbersome to try and play and it is very very smooth like oh my god it's so easy to play i i'm really astounded at how they were able to make it like such a smooth um like smooth transition with everything and sam the ai it's it's as if it is another player

almost most solo variants i'm really just gonna have to come to terms with it because very very few of them truly replicate another player but this one's pretty close because what he does is he has a specialization in types of workers like and that's what he's focusing on so in in my random setup it was the conductor so he made it all the way almost all the way you know by doing the conductors but he doesn't have to pay money whenever he uh delivers cows and makes it to kansas city he always starts in bloomington and then just goes up like so it's kind of a race he's kind of a timer uh which the game uh itself is a timer on how quickly people want to make it to kansas city and advance the game because if they let other players you know take their time that's just giving them chances to get better cards and you know therefore more points but uh i thought the pacing was extremely well like he didn't just ramp up and then just start rushing the board immediately the way that his cards come out will kind of dictate his speed but in a few times like there's a few cards where he will just all of a sudden take four moves and you have to be like oh okay he's gonna make it to kansas city ah that's all right i'll still take my time or you might be like no i really want to place the these specific hazards or whatever and and go and go before him uh but yeah so he he basically will focus

on a specific type of worker he can get other workers and if there are none because the chances are of there being not one out then he takes one that is his second most in this case and if it's tied then the cheapest and that ended up being the um the builder which allowed him to build more buildings and then the building placement is extremely you know simple oh he just places one in front of wherever you're at and then if one has a hand so like a taxing that's the one that he picks and then if he can't place one then he upgrades a building based off the workers he does have and similar to you as a player you're most likely not going to be able to hire every worker and if you do that's kind of going to be your focus but like uh he for example never got cowboys and therefore was limited to the cards that he could buy which are essentially just level threes because he pays up to eight money so if he ever has five total cowboys then he can get uh then he can get a level four for because that's just eight money or if he has four cowboys then he can get the level five because that's six money it's just so so clean because you do the same thing like i had one building out because i never bought builders and he was able to do some building i could have done the same thing i just didn't find them worth it and they get placed in positions just like almost another person would play

them because there's no real rhyme or reason to place buildings in specific areas there's a few that want to be in like forest zones and sometimes you might want to tax people before they make it to kansas city but that's really it and he kind of does the same thing but really it's just to hinder movement and you as a player have to compensate for that by being like okay well i was gonna upgrade my hand size but there's a lot of buildings out so i'm gonna you know use that so i can increase my speed like so he and if and because the player like his his actions are just a very very thin sheet i mean it's a big technic technical sheet but it tells you this is super smart the card number so you can look at and be like oh what's number two do oh it's right here you can immediately find what that action does and just read it and then be like oh okay like you don't have to go through the whole catalog of okay so because of this he has to move this like this and then now he does this action instead of this action because of all these different criteria he doesn't do any of that he has some criteria on very few things but i'm very much amazed that they were able to encapsulate somewhat of another person uh to where it doesn't make you as the solo player just be like oh god okay i have to think about how i want to play but also retain all those weird solo rules

that are for you know shoved into a game to just try to make it appeal to solo gamers like this one is one of the cleanest i've seen hell even like i mean anachrony is still my favorite type of soul game because it does feel like another person but that's an extensive solo variant this is close enough that there are a few things you might be annoyed with because like in this one yeah you as a player have to manage money but at the same time like you have the ways to gain that you have the control over your deck you have uh if you deck build correctly you can um you can gain a bunch of money and you can utilize your own buildings like he doesn't use buildings he only does actions of his cards you get money for the the bandits you get uh like if you get points or money based off the station master tiles that you get it's so him not having to spend money and him uh basically just always getting objective cards or just slowly increasing on the track like doesn't feel like an annoyance in other games where it's like you have to really like money so tight or food is so tight and you really have to bust your ass and then the ai is just like you don't have to worry about that it's it can ruin the game and it didn't hear at all in fact whenever i was scoring like i because he doesn't score for money he doesn't go for money he doesn't

score for station master tiles he doesn't score for player board stuff or uh and that's it like that's where my points caught up because he did better than me in every almost every category um except cows because that's what i ended up focusing on because i knew he was ramping up and i was like okay well i guess i'll try and buy a whole bunch of cows and and that's the only that's the only spot that i did better than him at uh a significant amount but what's also really cool and well actually one thing that i thought was going to be annoying was i thought he had to actually meet the um the objective cards like uh based off of um you know what they are and i was like well that's a little weird because it is luck for him he just takes the furthest one and places it in there and i was like well maybe it all evened out he'll just happen to get stuff nope every objective card he gets he just scores as if it was completed so really the terrain and the bandits the bandits are just taking them from you so you don't get max money in the terrain he does get victory points for uh but yeah i mean even then i got i think i got 16 points and he got 17. so it wasn't that big of a spread um and that's just to streamline the process because that would have been kind of annoying because he would have just been weird if you had to manage his objectives

like the best part for me about solo variants hands down is do you still get to play the game like normal uh or do you have to change things about like how you play to accommodate for another weird ai player like because most of them obviously like try to uh um set the example of like two player games and whenever you have to be like oh i can't do these you know these actions because it's not another player it's an ai it can just make a solo experience i feel very cumbersome and i did not feel that at all here i got to play great western trail like normal and then basically have sam as kind of a score to beat and a timer of of the game and he never like he never took anything that i really wanted he never uh like he he never like weirdly screwed me over um and that's even what it says it says whether you're exploring the game or testing your skills which is that's a perfect example to kind of uh set the precedent for what the solar variant is if you're just kind of wanting to figure out the game this is a solid way to test out great western trail before you bring in other people so you can understand kind of how the game works or if you're just like oh i wanna i wanna try this strategy like i just wanna see what happens if you go

all in on buildings and see how that works against an ai component uh or component opponent i'm i mean the more the more i'm talking about the more i'm like it is so clean like it's and you don't have to be bogged down and memorized with every single card that's one because they're basically very straightforward he moves one and then he you know hires a worker that is his specialty and the only weird one this is kind of like when he's placing buildings but you can just easily look it up and be like okay so here's the criteria of how he's building okay that's that like i'm i'm amazed obviously you can go check out what i think of great western trail i've done this it's only first edition um but you can there's a discussion there for that and the expansion and then you can go check out the uh comparison video i did between the second edition and the first edition between component-wise um but sam is like the perfect example of a of of a bot in a game like this when i was like this is just going to be stupid it's going to be annoying i don't want to i don't want to deal with that hassle and no like so many times i would be like okay my turn's over all right let's draw oh okay he's moving and uh okay he's getting cowboys he's getting he's getting these you know these cows all right my turn and then i know what do i want to do and then you get to think out your entire strategy you get because no

one blocks you he doesn't go to places and block you it's like okay well i can go there and i can sell you know these two greens for for money and then i can pay money to remove a hazard and then all right then i'll drop that's my turn and then what's he doing oh he's moving one and he's taking this objective okay well let's fill that up like all right now it's back to my turn it's just like boom like clockwork the only annoyance really is actually terms of kind of like fiddliness um because it is just you and this really has nothing to do with kind of how the variant works or anything but it is because it's you as the only person you're the one that has to kind of constantly be getting up to you know refill the one two and three slots in kansas city and then refill the things and put his stuff out like because there's not a there's not a great way i guess you can tilt the board and have like the workers close to you but i was doing it probably for the camera so i felt like i was constantly getting up and i'm like okay he made it back here okay now i'm gonna do a couple stuff oh crap now it's my turn so that was the only annoyance but i don't that's really nothing on the game it's just how i had it set up but keep that in mind there is that might happen where you have to constantly you know you'll reach into a bag set it up and then a turn later reach back into the bag to set up the the one two and three sections um i thought initially he was going to really run the score up because he never has to worry about

that is one thing that you might be frustrated with uh other players other human players have to worry about their deck building and the hand of cards now in the second edition i think this is new there's multiple ways for you to get you know these the the draw cards and then discard to modify your deck to run through your deck quicker um but there is a chance that you could just not get the hand you need and have to go to kansas city or have to go somewhere that you didn't plan because you didn't quite get the the cows you needed to go forward it worked out for me just because i had a lot of ways to mitigate it and i ended up getting the station tiles before he could to for permanent certificates but that is one thing that other other human players have to deal with just like you do and sam never does like he starts in bloomington and every time he makes it to kansas city he will go up so there was never a time i i potentially if i then hire some certain workers i could have stopped him from getting to new york but you kind of have to plan that he's going to just get there and get uh 33 points and so grant i got 32 so it uh it ended up kind of you know really just you know coming out in the wash but if you don't like the fact that you might have to struggle with a deck and the ai doesn't then that is something to keep

in mind but like i said the final score for this was 127 to 113 and i think because of his progression is consistent progression you as the player will get to score you know for the for your own board you get to score for um the station master tiles and you get score for money so that i think that kind of just balances it out yeah yeah wow i'm completely completely amazed and i was playing him on normal i probably should have mentioned that but uh and it felt i thought he was going to completely demolish me whenever i added it all up i'm like oh that's a nice surprise and it was still really close it was a 14 point difference it was literally this place the things i'm able to score that he wasn't which i did focus on doing uh basically the station master tiles got me 12 of those points man yeah i uh i'm completely amazed you can you can have him on hard and like if you do um if you do hard he has one extra worker of each type and then he starts in peoria instead of bloomington uh and then you can let's see it's possible to further adjust the difficulty so by changing the city of sam's first delivery to a city closer or to new york so if you're wanting to lower difficulty he can go you can start in st louis or if you really if he can start in chicago so he basically he'll constantly adding stuff to new york

and and then he'll have he'll have a lot more different specializations but normal was extremely solid i think normal might be the route you want to go go with easy if you are learning the game normal if you know the game and you're just wanting to try out new strategies so i i think it's fantastic this is easily one of the best solo variants i've ever played for a phenomenal game so if it was designed so it's based on i don't know who garth is oh oh it's based okay garth must have been the first edition variant by steve schlephost with the help of will gerkin and david lavoy uh if those guys are just random people who made a variant for first edition and they implemented that it did a phenomenal job so uh i think that's i think that's it uh if you wanna know my thoughts on great western trail you can go check out my discussion on that um but on a scale of one to ten i'm gonna give the solo variant a ten out of ten it is it is for its damn near close impersonation of a human player and seamless like learning and accessibility for you to just play great western trail and not have to worry about any like really any fiddliness or stupid you know solo variant rules it's just amazing so that's another one that's my thoughts on great western trail the solar variant let me know what you think of it in the

comments below other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful with every time of day it is for you hey everyone thank you for watching i really hope that you enjoyed the video if you would like to see more of my content go ahead and click that subscribe button and the bell to be notified whenever i upload any new content if you feel like supporting the channel you can go ahead and click that patreon link to be taken to my patreon and any help is truly appreciated other than that stick around for any any other run-throughs or reviews or cool top tens or whatever i feel like putting on other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you

Progress saved