Board Stupid Podcast Episode 77 - Haunted Lands
Transcript
hello and welcome to board stupid the podcast that loves talking tabletop board games DND D and other awesome stuff I'm Wayne I'm Simon and I'm Tom we're just nerds talking about the things we love our worth geeking out over so Simon are you ready I surely am Tom are you ready I am I'm ready to go talk to some ghosts in a very nice polite manner to tell them to leave this town if you guys are ready let's dive in to this week's episode this week we played haunted lands we played this a series where we talk about an epic board game that we played this week and this week it's the Spectre hunting City protecting Kingdom Builder haunted lands in this episode we're going to dive into the things we liked and break down everything that makes it great because we only play awesome games and in haunted lands Who you gonna call well not you you were rubbish at clearing ghosts I came last don't call me literally don't call me a beist Ghostbuster it's a beist Ghostbuster yeah exactly uh haunted lands is a competitive Euro game for two to four players with absolutely stunning illustrations and amazing meeples you explore new lands in search of new resources to help develop your community but beware specters from ancient
civilizations still dwell in these places frightening the explorers and making your buildings unusable asers you are the only ones who can communicate with these Restless spirits to help try to drive them away from the lands and become the heroes of Kina piss off ghost basically yeah get out of here get out of here you ghosts uh haunted lands will played two to four players is designed by Leonardo Romano with art by David gerardi I think with what it says on the bo not what it says on BGG well we'll see uh published by ludus magnet Studios and plays in about 60 Minutes accurate yeah if you don't have to rewind turns but enough of that yeah it's uh it's it's standard euroair right first time you're learning it it's 50 to 100% longer yeah so I'm sure we can go F famili you absolutely be like okay yeah this then that then that you can't you can't buy this yet but if you could it'd be 49 euros I got it at Spiel cuz I'm a lucky boy and you can pre-order it you can pre-order it right now from ludis Magnus Studios webbsite uh uh for 49 EUR or your International equivalent uh and you'll get a free little mini expansion as well apparently hey which is good but yeah I have The Spar Edition and I'm super happy this is just the retail one right you don't get the didn't have the expansion funky stuff in this one now yeah uh so let's start as we always do and let's dive into the components and
art design and I'll throw over to you gentlemen ugly go I don't know such such a disgusting looking this up no it is of course quite a delight to look at it gorgeous I'm going to start with the box art just saying before we uh hit record really unique curious box art very white background which in itself is unusual mostly Things Are fully saturated in color and then this gloved hand holding a whole city in its pal which I think is just super attractive I love I love the logo the haunted lands logo CU it's got two spooky ghosts integrated into the logo the font is fantastic and you're right it's a very eye catching box art I mean I I said it's kind of like a criticism but it's also kind of interesting where you don't quite know what the game is about but it does intrigue you to want to pick up the box yes yeah it does a perfect job of drawing you in it really does what is that I I really like the little sort of like gibles um friendly like smiling ghost yeah I picked up one of the pieces they are grinning quite delightfully on the on the screen printed meeples yes they're like um what's it in Spirited Away no face no face no face yeah that's they remind me of no face quite reminiscent that yeah ratling their chains it is absolutely gorgeous I mean the art design I think is just wonderful the color the colorization the color palette is I think brilliant um it it's not super bright colors it's kind of pasty it's got that yeah that kind of nonstandard away from your red yellow
green blue um more pastel greens and Pinky purples yeah the cubes and the resources and the tiles and everything are a little bit muted just enough that it's not geish because there's a lot of stuff on the board yeah yeah and then you've got uh various hex hex tiles he hexes within hex they're called territory tiles territory tiles but they're they're hexes they're they're seven uh sorry seven hexes in a in a bigger hex that's right seven hexes within a bigger that's like a meta hex like hexes that contain other they radius two hex yeah anyway uh but they are fantastic and they have different terrains being displayed on them and again the artwork of those is fantastic what we all noticed with the terrain tiles for the hex tiles they've got lots of little I suppose like Easter eggs yeah they're sort of all reminiscent of fairy tales and little cultural references there's like a Red Riding Hood monster somewhere one looks like little Gandalf standing outside a Mountain entrance yeah there's like a dragon under a lake one there's some really really cool stuff uh just in the art design and like you say the mles themselves um all double-sided screen printed and there is meeples for the ghosties and for your player piece and for all of the buildings everything is a meeple and I freaking love it and they're really really nice quality ones they're thick wood yep Big meeples Y double screen printed both sides and VAR
and varnished yeah right and all of the buildings four different types of buildings all of the buildings also have an inset space on the top which is a really nice design element that has space for you to sit a cube in it to designate who owns each building yeah it's really neatly done it's a smart way of determining who owns what who built which space uh cuz you're going to be regularly looking out over the board at the end of each round seeing which buildings you own so you you gain the resources for that type of thing and I think it's an elegant way of pulling that off without having to clip rings around the bottom or could have had a whole set of colored buildings for everyone which would have you know bumped up the price and the production I think it would yeah you're right this way they've got the buildings are the buildings they become yours with the cube and it's so easy and so clever to just put a little Cube on there work really well I love how all of the mles including the player pieces are all different sculpts right so the buildings have their own individual sculpts for the different type of building the specters has its own shape uh your own player piece has the has its own the perceivers each of the each of the four perceivers have different art and Silhouettes right yeah different artwork as well so the art design I think is absolutely spectacular it is very like Whimsical fantasy I think we all sort of agreed on right Whimsical almost gibl Whimsical fantasy and it's it's an absolute Delight to look at I think the illustration is wonderful quite cartoony without being disneyi it's it's more of
a classic F like Grim fantasy title yes that's right there's some nice sort of little gameplay variations under the surface as well like you've got more tiles than you need for the size of the board so there's variety you can mix and match them right MH you've got a load of cards that we'll talk about and those there's all more additional cards than you actually need so you can sort of randomly seed the game and get lots of variety every time you play loads of stuff in there yeah it's just yeah absolutely delightful so we talked roughly about the art design which I think we all agree it's pretty great we talked a little bit about the production pieces so we talked about the meeples and about the cubes that you get let's dive into those cards uh like you say there is a bunch of different stuff that we're going to use for the game that will help with variety randomization helpful replayability but it's this again beautiful artwork that gives you another insight into the world of this game I think yeah so there's a loot of big cards uh you've got um all of the skill cards y that represent various passive bonuses you can get unlocked over the course of the game they've got all their individual art as well you've got a market card so you'll have a random Market card there's actually more than one to choose from that will set how the market functions for the game mhm there's Spectre cards that set how the specters behave for the game and there's three of them and you can stack them or choose any combination for different difficulties you've got your own sort of deck of I suppose they are assignment cards assignment cards that's right these will give you endgame bonuses bonus a little cat trop
mechanism which we'll dig into later really clever so we'll talk about that um and then there's the reward card which designates what you get for telling a ghost to piss off yeah which is just wonderful and that will start to make sense as we dig into how this game plays important to note on these I think it's all icons and numbers no words so you don't really there's a there's like a round overflow thing language agnostic I think that works really well might take you a moment to work out what means what but once you've got it down there's zero confusion I think yeah once I started explaining it to Tom like sorry Tom once I started explaining it to Tom he immediately went oh that means that means that oh now I know this means this and this means this the iconography is really welld designed I think yeah and there's not that many icons it's just you need to know what the four or five or six icons are and then it's just combinations yeah something to represent each of your possible actions something to represent each of the four resources and then the interactions between them really it's really neatly done so other production bits the other significant production pieces are the player boards and I suppose the central scoring track and Central board all all of which are sort of not really double thickness but they wrot yeah I wrote down not quite double thick yeah sort of one and a half but it's nice cuz they have recessed areas on your player boards to put your tokens th card on top of thick card stock so that you have a little bit of an inset so stuff doesn't slide around and it works perfectly for you need you're not regularly moving stuff around your board
it is just to keep the card tokens in place I think nice you're flipping tokens quite a lot so maybe having one that's like double thick and inset that it might be a bit fiddly trying to lift the tokens out it's quite nice I think it works very well and then of course there's the giant dice the oversized two dice which great probably the most colorful piece of the game couple of custom dice one is the rewards dice which got your your swag bags on red purple and green and then the other is the terrain dice your forests your grasslands and your mountains both of which you're rolling regularly and annoy super satisfying very satisfying and like annoying but entertainingly rounded edges so when you Chuck them they might occasionally Spin and send you on an emotional Journey which is what happened in one of our games and those those dice are like the only random element of the game right everything else is very Euro yes and then you've got the dice that set the sort of the randomized elements of the game which is which is nice we're dealing with ghosts you can't expect them to work to a ghost not going to be fantastic so there's quite a lot in the Box actually for your €49 and talking about that then how do you rate the production of haunted lands I think it's brilliant I mean for the price €49 yes just a sheer amount of wooden meatles is is a lot by today's standards on board games for 9 you probably get something that's mostly cardboard mhm this is true yeah yeah I think I I'm
happy to lead that out and say this is a five out of five fether production for me i' love the artwork is fantastic I don't think there's any art reused on any of the skill cards is there it's all those are all custom um every character's deck every one of the perceivers assignment card decks they're all unique they they're all unique they have their own art for each of the uh the perceivers they've got their own player boards that have their art on them everything's custom all of the tiles are different the tiles are different combinations of Art and like we said before they're not just a copy paste of the same art in each hex for each type of terrain they're all different so if you look at one of the tiles and there's three fields in a row they've actually drawn the art as three Fields running into one another it's actually one sort of big continuous line of field map tile rather than a hex tile yeah it's almost like they they um decided to detail out what what what they wanted sort of artwise on the tile and then worked out which terrains each of the hexes within that big tile would be yeah nicely done which is nice yeah how do you guys rate the production I think I'm going to join you with a five yeah I just uh noticed as well I'm not sure we said the score tokens are your own unique artwork pieces on a wooden tile they're called Valor tokens Valor token Valor points is victory points and yeah that's actually quite an unusual and a nice production element normally if you've got a little scoring piece it's a cardboard bit right or another cube in
your Cube yeah but this is they given you a specific bit with your artwork on it which is quite nice so fives all round FES all around beautiful yeah it's a beautiful production especially for that money so Tom as you know H Simon sorry I made a mistake there you were winning but Simon pipped you at the end Simon you won haunted lands in this particular game so valorous let's dive into the core mechanics more valorous than I am yeah much more valorous but only right at the last minute right at the last minute until then but it comes from being lost most of the game there we go we'll talk about that we will we will very interesting so we'll dive into the core mechanics then how do you win a game of haunted land Simon you are obviously a working along a victory Point track a Valor Point track um you gain point from a a wide range of things or at least fairly varied range of things first and most obvious one is build the buildings there's there's three main types of building you can build your Sawmill your Windmill and your water mill there's also the mines so there are four um each one representing then a gain of resource of said thing uh each building that you build is worth a number of points one two or three points so one of the first things I did was just start building buildings get yourself on that points track get you some points for each building you build some points straight away and it gives you some income for resources as the game goes on yeah the other main thing is increasing your skill so as we said there's four skill
different skill cards available um is that changeable per Play account no not per Play account no but there's 12 cards I think so you have a thir every time in a different comp so these skill cards give you ongoing in-game bonuses but also in unlock in that skill which again cost resources to do gives you a number of skill points a varying number depending on how early you are to unlock that so if you're in early doors you'll get more points if you come to it lateer on you'll still get the ongoing game bonus get fewer points or indeed you might not get any points at all I think Euro style you've also got points on your tracks your little engine building player board right you complete a track you get points just like every the wolves and stuff like that that's it yeah quite like the wolves the uh which which thing do I upgrade or even like the fox experiment as we've played more recently I can do more of this thing top out a track in a euro game you normally get points yeah exactly it's a good idea so yeah that's the combination of the main three and then in the last round as you Vanquish ghost you tell them to bugger off yeah you you may or may not depending on a rooll of that dice gain a few more points ASAS or you might just get F stacks of cash yeah so I mean we can we can talk about how the ghosts work right they're the they're the randomized element of the game when you remove a ghost from the board you roll the reward Dice and it'll give you a different type of reward ghosts get more difficult to uh Vanquish over the course of the game they do mhm but they also
give better rewards uh depending on how you roll like I mean Wayne rolled literally the wrong the wrong reward versus what he wanted every single time for the entire game hilariously hilariously nothing's ever a bad reward in of itself just not necessarily the one you want exactly so early rounds you might be getting loads of resources and getting resources in this game is great and in one of the rounds you got three at once which is just supp two turns in one go just for for vanquishing a go so yeah really good opportunity there you might also get points the last possible way which is via these assignment cards that you get and they're end game scoring uh and we'll come to those but yes it's basically most points wins at the end of the game let's talk about how a round works so you start the round by doing a haunt and that's always the last player which is important jumped ahead of Step what did I do uh the game structure is there's three seasons three seasons and three rounds per season ah yes three seasons and three rounds per season it's only nine turns which is it's only yeah it's only nine turns but it's important because at the end of each season there's a pretty significant reshuffle yeah maybe maybe nine turns is a thing because D's the White Castle quite famously already has those nine things 12 13 I think it's 12 12 plus a bonus on it's got four seasons in right that's right 12 plus a bonus it's the same sort of idea where you subdivide
the game not just into rounds but further into groups of rounds in this instant Seasons yeah works very well but it's yeah it keeps everything concise but yeah quite right you've got that round structure and that's important because you start each of those rounds with a haunt The Haunt is done by the person in last place they'll roll the haunt Dice and they're going to put four ghosties out on the matching terrain type and that's the first of two different catchup mechanics right whoever's in last place gets to choose where the ghosts go and they could place those ghosts in a in a way that favors them in a location for example that they could then go and easily get to that ghost if they want to Vanquish the ghost for a reward or they could place them to block someone else from doing something which is absolutely viable because they will stop you building MH uh they will also have another ability depending on how difficult you've made the game up to one from one to three different abilities by by default and what we played with was it stopped you from doing the manual harvest the manual exploit action as well yeah basically get a resource out of the ground but they stop you doing that um and uh yeah that's that's what you will do you you they will stop you doing that so you'll do it haunt and then you will yield any buildings that you've built you get resources for income income income phase super simple then everyone I love I love when they just get resources yeah it's great isn't it you got last turn I get stuff this turn it's always really
satisfying yeah you you start by randomly punching trees and pulling rocks off the ground yourself and then as things going yeah eventually eventually you have a giant industrial machine doing all your work for you which is yeah Tom basically mechanizing the entirety of Kena uh pave over the whole Kingdom then there's no ghosts but me for example I was going around doing hard work the entire game pulling stuff out of the ground I was like why don't I just make myself pull out more things out of the ground with the training montage approach I theame didn't work for me uh definitely build buildings in this game for sure you got three buildings out versus Tom's H many n you had thing three times yeah you guys smash me for building I tried a thing didn't work uh and then you take your turn and I like the way the turns work in this game I really do you've got I suppose tokens that represent all the actions you can take yeah and you four specific types of token which you have varying numbers of and you can activate in varying combinations as when yeah yeah in any order is really important so the basic one is moving uh you start with four I think movement tokens but each type of terrain you move into cost a different amount so it's not just a case think of it as sort of like a number of AC points for a given type of action right that's it you had four points of movement four four little tiles that you can flip over and you can flip them over one at a time so it's easy to keep track so into or out of the city is only a point of movement as it is with a field but you want to start climbing the mountains that's the re of your four starting action point so a real tricky decision Point like you
might get there and then you might be stuck there or you might get partway and not actually be able to proceed to the the hex you want there's a little bit of planning which we as we experience towards the end of the game you realize that you know if you want to come and go from the city um actually a lot of the spaces around the city are not easy terrain to come and go from indeed yeah we had like one easy out from the city and everything else was pretty much bit of a mission which I I think it it it's actually not a bad bit of the game and the hexes are to a degree randomiz so we could have had different setups which allowed easier exit or Ingress to the city yeah but no I think that's really cool uh the second option the second line on your player board is to shout at a ghost as we've dubbed it sh the off action call I think Vanquish sounds quite good but set them to rest I don't know Tom I think it's literally persuade I saw the word pers it's persuade uh so to start with first round tell him to piss off you flip your one persuasion taken over in whilst you're pers yeah is pers thanks Tom yeah you move into the hex where a ghost already is you flip your persuade token it disappears and you roll your reward Dice and get one of those three variable rewards that are available during this season mhm nice and simple gets more hard to do as the game progresses because you need two persuasion tokens or three persuasion tokens in it's
interesting right because it's it's the randomized element of the game you're not guaranteed the reward you necessarily want you'll always get a reward but you sort of have to do do this you can't avoid it because the ghosts stop you from building and they stop you from harvesting so you can't and more importantly there's like a little Co-op element like Crisis management element to the game because if you don't manage the ghosts and nobody manages the ghosts they eventually overflow into the City and everyone loses everyone loses which is great I love an idea like just if you you can't ignore them because they will just literally make you lose yes very clever yeah moving on what else have we got we can do on a turn time third row is your Harvest action nice and straightforward you're on a tile you can pull the resource from that so you're in a field you get wheat on a mountain per Seas interesting it locks it with an exploit token right so you only do it once per season and no one else can then use it can't just Spam the field over and over again you have to move on and farm something else the Lakes you can't move into but if you're in an adjacent hex you can Farm water from them uh or or um yeah no yes yeah just water and no I was just getting ahead of myself quite crucially in the game that we played one of the skill upgrades which you can choose to do or not Wayne got it early on and it felt super powerful is that every time you harvest you can then claim another resource of your choice
yeah which is super which when you bear in mind some of the buildings require Stone and getting to the mountains cost you three points of movement if you can harvest in a field and then pick up free Stone oh boy that's a good combo all of the buildings except for the watermills require two resources so if you can get both those Resources with one action that's a lot of efficiency it's real good it's real good and building is the fourth main player board action so you start with one you can get the opportunity to buy a second one and when you're in a hex you PID the two matching resources as displayed on a little uh reminder card that we had in front of us mhm so if you're in a wheat field you want to build a windmill there you need to pay one wood and one water which you can have picked up on your travels at some point it gains you a point gain you put a windmill out there you're no longer able to harvest in that space but you can then get that as an ongoing constant yield resource beginning of every round Y and yeah getting that combination right of the resources you need to build the building and then the resource those buildings will give you is really clever and it's kind of the the core of this game engine Beyond vanquishing those ghosts so it's kind of like a double header of a a core game yeah absolutely uh once everyone's done their combination of actions uh you've got bonus things that you can do during your turn as well which don't cost your action tokens such as if you're in the city if you're in the city
yeah you can either sell those resources that you've just gained from the C the very Central hex M that's the market market yet which will get you a bunch of money and you can spend that money in the outer areas of the city barers the barers to uh train and upgrade your player board which will get you more of those action tokens yeah better better action economy better action economy and or uh upgrade to those special skill cards that we talked about passive basically passive right passive for for the rest of the game it's sure all fantastic it's interesting because you know because we randomly seed out the skills you might get skills that work in different combinations we've been talking it we've put out the and we actually you know there a couple ofs work together well and the other ones don't really figure into it so much in fact we've got three of our four were really really useful together and the fourth one not so much use and only Wayne bought it yeah got me points but that's basically and it would have been better in a slightly different scenario maybe uh that's basically it and you would go through that flow uh three times and the game ends you do a haunt you get your income uh you'll do your actions and then you'll rest and reset super fascinating super interesting game and actually quite interactive for a Euro game yeah I was just going to say as much as it might sound like you're playing you know Sol solitier Farming Simulator you're really not as some said you've got that group management of ghosts yeah noticing that your forests are all full of spirits already yeah so
whoever rolls the next one and it's Forest again all the city's getting overrun that means no upgrades no you know very close to losing the game um so you got that interaction there and also then vying for resources you might come along into a neighboring area and just harvest the map looks big when you start but it gets small very quickly between the exploit tokens for manual harvesting stopping you from using those spaces for a whole round which sorry for a whole season which is three rounds uh and all of the buildings that stop you from harvesting in those spaces the board gets really really small does for the things that a player piece can do over the course of the game yeah looking at our end game state in front of us now there's maybe six empty PES out of about 40 yeah everything's either a ghost or a building or a ghost out a building or a ghost and a building and a player or or or it's been or the Lakes have all been harvested and there's that's it never a ghost and a building apparently you can't yeah the ghosts don't move right they s sit where they are I really thought this might be a part of the game you know I thought that when I saw all these ghosts and I thought they were gonna like move along a hex or chase a player out or I I tell you what I I like that you don't have to move them and manage that because some games like this will have like a phase where you have to follow a program for how the ghosts behave yeah in this it's actually really simple and like I said
before it works like a double-edged sword where the player who's in last gets to roll to random the terrain type but then they get to pick where the ghosts go so they can place it to their benefit or to hinder another player yeah you can choose choose a lockdown strategy unless you know the player can get rid of the ghost or you can choose a beneficial strategy I can get rid of the ghost feel part of the player's repertoire of actions rather than the game playing against you yeah absolutely and also if you start playing at higher difficulties and having multiple abilities those ghosts become a humongous pain in your imagine I mean like I said at the moment our ghost just stopped you harvesting fine but if the ghost also stopped you harvesting and cost you an extra movement to move into that space that becomes incredibly annoying yikes and then the third worse yeah and then if the ghosts stopped all of your buildings you know getting you resources that is even more of a plan specifically all of the buildings in every adjacent space to a ghost then stop producing play with all of these at you play with all of them yeah if you look at the board right now with where the ghosts are many of the buildings are still turned on it would switch them all almost all of them off like not many not many almost every building would be off it would switch quite a l of them out of like 20 odd buildings we built maybe I think that that mine yeah that that mine there next to you in the middle of nowhere that's about it that's the only one that's going to produce almost every single building would be turned off which means nobody's getting any passive income so it'd be hard
pivoting into buying oh God the the Cascade here so this is where you'll need to unlock more persuasion you have to focus more on ghost shouting more you need resources to sell to get the coins to buy the tokens which you can't get cuz there's ghost there like when we play North guard and the Wes stopped everyone from harvesting and no one had anything to do for most of the game well those North guard animals yeah whole other North guard animals are a bastard but it's super there is plenty of interaction with the ghosts a because um you're going to be placing them in places that you annoy your your opponents probably but also through deliberate harvesting and explo of you uh resources near a wall of inaccessible areas that they won't be able to give anyone any resources and they you can run over before someone's turn and harvest the thing that's in front of them then that takes away an option isn't that right Tom imagine imagine Tom imagine who would do that Tom I'm quite glad there I just wanted to build loads of windmills and I decided what I wanted to to BU was build the windmills next to Wayne yeah and then again building is another way of T of of interaction through denial yeah right that's what it is it's area denial because the spaces are exclusive one building exactly one building only one Harvest only I've said this as we played I'm quite glad that our group met is still that Tom messes with Wayne it means I get the win on this occasion it's it's it's a two-way street I largely played on my side of the board oh yeah I know Wayne is going out just Wayne's chaotic Nature by
default even if it's not targeted is going to it's probably messing with me because I'm I'm trying to meticulously plan but it's very difficult to do around Dwayne yeah Fair entirely Fair yeah so this again it's and the game is far more than some of its parts so when you explain it you're like oh it's get resources deal with the occasional ghosty but I think partly due to its beautiful artwork and design and production and also it's ease of play actually it's quite easy and Breezy it just sucks you in really well there's a lot we say it's easy to play it's theoretically easy to play you could spend a bunch of time puzzling over the most efficient way to spend your actions particularly later on when you know like I've got for example 69 like 13 actions yeah 13 Action tokens if I could manage to use all if I could manage to work out my actions in a way that I use all of my actions every turn that's great but I could do something slightly wrong and then I don't get to use something and it's inefficient and yeah you might want to rethink what you're doing or we might get halfway through a turn and then realize that actually we were doing it wrong and I have to rewind a whole term that happened once Tom but the puzzle about you know efficiency of using all of your action tokens is is one of the key puzzles of the game right it always bugs me when I'm like ah I could have I could have done this differently and I this left get use this very satisfying when you do manage to get everything in order everything done yeah absolutely the some
the tougher decisions I found were between spending the resources you've got on building a building selling them for bonus not not just a flat coin but an increasing amount of coin if you manage to get a good combo but then having that trigger one of the skills which allowed you to refresh an action yeah or using the same resources to unlock said skill because you don't have it yet and you want you want three times resources for buildings resources for skills or resources for Market to get money to buy more actions let's talk about those skills a bit because what we've really focused on is the sort of the core gameplay Loop right which is get resources kill ghosties sorry banish Vanquish talk to tell piss off yeah exactly so but these skills are ways that you'll break that Loop and break the game a bit for example in our game we had yeah if you managed to Vanquish a ghost you get to flip over a Vanquish token so you could potentially get extra one you reset little bit of efficiency yeah there was one which helped your movement a bit by making sure that the uh the central hex of the game I.E the market was basically the same as the training the market and the burs was the same thing so you never have to go all the way to the center of the city you can just run to the edge of the city and do everything there which more helpful than it sounds helpful yeah you never having to spend that extra movement movement is a premium in this game I think uh and then we also had the ability to again refresh any one of your tokens if if you did like a big sale at
the market if you sell three things in any combination at once you get to refresh a token which was great and again you can do it multiple times which I love yeah and then the other one as we've already mentioned was if you harvest you got an extra you got an extra wild resource res of your choice the only way I won the game being able to pick up Stone without going to the mountain oh my go so good and getting these in different combinations is is fantastic and I it will really help I suppose steer you towards a certain game style if you wanted to I think that's a really good point if we didn't have that exploit bonus the one where you can pick any wild resource and we maybe didn't roll well on our ghosts that gave us resources be super Stone saved very different game and everyone would have to go up a mountain yeah I built I built three Sawmills which all require stone at no point did I harvest it on a mountain no I mean I I built some mines on mountains but yeah it's Mission imagine how different this game is a lot of resource expenditure to get up to a m build line this game suddenly becomes very different without that right very very different just by swapping those skills out and like I said this is what breaks that core gameplay Loop and makes it very interesting I think really really cool kind of similar I've mentioned it before like about to um smart F you got those passives once you get it it's there forever so if you unlock this early it's like there for the rest of the game which is yeah really really fantastic but but there's more to choose from right sming has little double z tokens so it's one or other for each of the options can obviously mix and match them in lots of different ways but yeah
there's 12 different SK cards and you have four here and uh I like that everyone has access to the same though cuz sometimes only one or two people in a game might pick up or have access to a thing which then feels good luk breaking in this everyone has the opportunity for it they just get fewer points first come more points yeah first come I think if Tom had the option to get two resour every time he Harvest and no one else ever could I think that would feel like a run in the same way for any of them really yeah is there anything else you want to talk about mechanically for this game uh catch-ups ah the catch-ups yeah like you said there are two main types of catchup one being that the person in last place will always choose where the ghosts go which which could be really useful could be really good also this is really interesting where after the first and second Seasons conclude the players not in first place like everyone else except the leader will get to pick uh an assignment card or two assignment cards in the last season and they're all endgame scoring bonuses hugely game changing and and at the end of each season you check the player order because that determines the turn Order each round season sorry each round each round changes turn order depending on who's in the lead end of season gives you assignment options and only the people who are in second or third or fourth place get those choices so if you have someone who get a runaway lead early on particularly if they get a
runaway lead before season 2 starts and they somehow manage to stay in the lead past the beginning of season 3 they get no cards they get no cards which is really interesting and and players two players three might have three cards they would do they would have three cards each yeah which is I think it's really it makes you want to kind of manage your own scoring in some ways right if you're playing this game you want it to be close you want to be in a close second basically ideally you want to be in a close second or you want to be like maybe be in second place after season one and then steam ahead so you don't have to worry about the other two cards because you had I was in I was in second place I got one card then I had a big turn where I got a load of resources from um kicking a ghost out yeah um just got lucky on a roll and I got like a nearly a 10o lead mhm oh easily yeah then everyone started to slowly catch up uh Wayne had a bunch Wayne had two assignment cards son had three and at the end of the game the difference between me having one assignment card and S having three was huge I nearly doubled my entire near dou your score at the end of the game I think I was on 28 before I played before I scored my bonus cards I'm now I finished on 52 yeah yeah you jumped you jumped a good what 10 12 points ahead of me yes more than sorry more than what do you think of that as a design choice I think it's really clever I really like catch up mechanics in this sort of game I would need to play it more to see
how swingy that is because if you can keep it close and you're in a close second and you can pick up some good scoring cards you could have a massive jump at the end of the game because there is absolutely nothing stopping you in this game from knowing how and when you will score it's all public you can choose when you score points to an extent right yeah you could actively avoid scoring points you can choose not to build the building you ch you just get resources just like prepare yourself for the next turn just kill ghosties like you know you see the end of a season coming up you just go okay I'm going to stall out this last round yeah collect resources sit on them let myself fall behind yeah so I get an assignment card or two mhm and then have a big turn right in the beginning of the new season that's 100% I think a possible Strate you're L you get to pick where the ghosts go Y and you could potentially have a huge turn for match up yeah it's certainly an interesting one it's not one that I've you know it's one where everyone wants to be losing yeah or really winning or really really winning I mean I thought I had a good lead and then it just it just evaporated right at the very end you did but also I think s because you you pick your assignment cards in advance of the Season you need to pick them well you do you do because yeah I I actively chose that I would build windmills and Sawmills and then I went out and I built windmills and S Mills to the cost of any other progression in any other Factor but it works out really well doz of
points well here's a thought Here's a thought the season two assignment Cass ones at the you know at the end of season one mhm you might not know what you're going to score at the end of the game so you're mostly picking a card blind the season at the end of season two when you're picking the season three assignment cards and you potentially pick two you probably have a much better idea of what's going to score you points the difference there is probably huge but also consider this Simon was by himself at the top of the map for a good portion of the game if there was a fourth player here contesting you for that space hu so different you were contesting me in the south of the map yeah so my first bonus card was have the most buildings in a given tile I was on my own by nearly half the board I was fairly assured on that we talked about it built more and more buildings as say Sawmills and windmills the the because the action econom is quite limited particularly things like movement and you have difficult terrain stuff like that you can find that you end up staying in a relatively small region of the board yeah coming and going from the city mostly then into a various different sort of hex quadrant I went on four tiles but only onto the corner of one yeah and because the map size doesn't change with the number of players at two players you're probably going to have to be more careful about the ghosts because that's going to be a bigger element at three players there's the risk that one player gets left on their own and could have a runaway big scoring turn MH and at four players is going to get really Cutthroat and
crowded H throat and crowded exactly ghosts are probably less of a problem possibly but although with more buildings less places for the ghost to go true so it's interesting I think the balance would be very different yeah definitely with a fourth player for sure it would have been different because you're then fighting for for that so I think it's a definitely an interesting design choice I personally like it I can see how some people might not like it but I think at four players that this is probably what this game is made for I I can see it being quite swingy between two three and four player counts quite a different game again good arguably is a good thing yeah three was three was fine I I really enjoyed it still right someone get my T we need a four play game absolutely so uh BGG rates this a question mark out just to new uh and also so ahead of the game the BG page is largely incomplete so um fill in the blanks surprisingly um I again I didn't know anything about this game so I haven't I haven't seen it a mass a massive amount of popularity for it which I think is a real shame I think if anything hopefully this gets the word out a little bit is our Hidden Gem right absolutely so let's dive on from there but um where how would you rate this game in terms of complexity out of five it's three three seems right three yeah I'd say three there's a possibility that you could dive quite a lot into the Euro planning element right but that's that's to I think it's a strong three that's about it more definitely wouldn't put it above that the indidual elements
of well I move by doing this I you everything is a flip of a token so it's not complicated to learn in that sense it's just the the depth to which you want to plan and strategize quite right Simon y quite right so let's talk about that theme gameplay interaction does it feel thematic and I feel thoroughly spooked do you good it's certainly a euro Whimsical a Whimsical spooking yes Spirited Away style Frank absolutely like a like a tickle of your of your balls a ghostly tickle of the balls interesting interesting yeah spooked but wi I think the yeah I mean the key thing is that it's haunted land so those ghost are the the the USP and I think that it adds a great little touch otherwise this would be this would just be a territory control game yes Euro game I like the combination of like Crisis Management on top of the engine building Euro territory control you know um not I'm not going to say it's cookie cutter but it's that sort of game yeah yeah it's a fairly light touch I'd say I don't think the the ghost are wildly thematic it could be a number of other element on the board which stops you doing the thing yeah they could be like some sort of environmental problem or events yeah volan Beast or beasts yeah yeah yeah absolutely I like it yeah yeah I I would 100% agree with you Jens it's um light
wash but I think it's enough and the production again I'm going to refer back to that does a great job of making the theme that is on it come alive more particularly with like the artwork for the tiles and the cards that make you think fairy tale right quite Whimsical mystical it certainly helps with it you guys remember the um computer game settlers back in the day I've got a strong feeling of that like go out and explore oh you're in water you get water you're on rock you get rock Etc build things with what you've bought oh no there ghosts would have been an awesome add oh this ghost exactly it would have been great let's talk about the flow then how do you feel about the term length and the gameplay flow um I thought it was pretty good like the the I mentioned it already the way seasons and the rounds are subdivided I like I like that sort of manag to be honest um a lot of Euro games have like an upkeep income phase at the end of every round and that can become a little bit cumbersome so the way that the the way that the catchup mechanics work around that subdivision of rounds into seasons is clever I really like how that sort of fits together and it does evoke you know a a feel of Seasons right where you only get the refreshing exploit tokens so that you can reh Harvest after a season's expired um that that reduces the number of decision
points I think as a turn go round goes right as a season progresses you could get more and more bogg down in the number of options that you have except you probably won't be because the board will get more and more crowded and actually you have less options counter it yeah so the game like naturally re reduces the decision space I think it reduces it a little bit right so that you're not constantly left with okay well I started with four actions now I've got 12 yeah because actually your your actually you're probably right the decision space does push back and the crisis control element grows over the course of the game right to balance it out and you always sort of feel like you're probably trying to make the same sort of number of decisions might be a little bit trickier because there's more itations of options but I don't think it drastically increases over the course of the game because you know suddenly you've gone from being able to move four spaces to six yeah yeah yeah but in reality those extra points of movement might not necessarily be you running around all over the board they might be that you're you know you're actually not necessarily using all of those spaces up because you know there's there's actually nowhere to go yeah you can't yeah yeah I think that's a really good summation Tom and and as much as you're saying you know you go from 4 to 12 not really because the cost of things does go the cost scales you're oh you know you've you and Wayne can Harvest twice in a round well you can but good
luck getting to and finding spes that exactly that don't have a building don't have a ghost that you can reach all of these things so actually you only ever really have I'd say interesting the a couple more options per turn than you the buildings sort of alleviate alleviate some of the decision space because the buildings become automatic in income yeah it takes away the decision and you have to worry about which buildings you're activating each turn because they just activate true I I tend to struggle with games that require you to GA gather and spend resources and going oh I never feel like I've got enough resources here whack down a building I'm going to guarantee I got that whack down another building cool I'm going to guarantee so after three rounds I had or maybe four rounds I had one of each building cool start the round I've got one of each I can do pretty much any of the other options in the game because they all only require a combination of two of the things I'm guaranteed to have and for me that's a really good thing absolutely yeah I think the flow is actually really nice turns don't feel that long I mean even at four players which I have played this at it never feels that long you're never going to be spent ages doing a turn uh which is quite nice like say I wonder if I wonder if it would be functional with with everyone doing one action and then passing or you because you have to take your whole turn right and turn lengths do increase so there is more downtime as the game goes on maybe I I I could even argue that might take longer to do yeah
it might yeah than just flipping a few things over burdensome oh yeah if you if you only move and then someone else does a thing and then someone else does a thing and then it comes back to you and like oh now I can't do the thing I wanted to do which was a whole would be trickier to I think he'd forever be shut out of your options I think also the decisions that you make do also change significantly based on the difficulty you're playing because if you're playing with the ghosts that stop your buildings producing suddenly you're thinking my guaranteed production is no longer guaranteed until I go kill this ghosty or in fact me as the third player I'm going to pop these ghosts down to where your buildings won't yield y right so that becomes very different it's a strong pivot into ghost busting at very strong pivot into the ghost busting Al righty let's move into those final thoughts on haunted lands Simon what do you like the most about haunted lands I think probably I've just covered it it's that ability to up to a point guarantee what you're going to get from most of your actions in most of your turns you can within reason other players and a couple of Lucky Dice rolls granted work out roughly how your turn might play out at the beginning of a season I think which speaks really well to me for this kind of game when you are gathering and spending resources I like being able to go if I do this then I can do this and I can do this and it's not
more than about three steps it's not oh if I do this now in three more turns I'll be able to do this and then in four more turns up there's not that level of depth to it which actually I think is really good it's a sweet spot of balance of action economy and and reward yeah very nice yeah I love I love an efficiency puzzle and this one isn't too many steps right which I think mirrors what you're saying there enough there that you can you can comfortably feel like you can plan a turn and more often than not I think you're probably not going to be locked out of the thing you want to do by someone else beating you to it but occasionally you will be yeah and then there's something else you can do you can't not have a turn where you achieve something I don't think it's possible you've got nice options I I like being able to sort of look at you can look at the combinations of resources required for the buildings you can look at the combinations required for the market you can look at the combinations required for the skills and you can try and work out a rough path that you want to try and follow through the game from the get-go and see how it goes yeah I'm I'm gonna Harvest here oh I can't okay I'm gonna build here oh I can't okay I'm going to go to the market and I'm going to get a skill upgrade you have to be able to do one of those things you can't I've not seen it at all where you can't get to a space and do something so with that said and the planning element right I Think It's tricky to Pivot right you can't
necessarily pivot in this game but that is helped massively by the catch-up mechanics yeah yeah I don't think that even though Wayne was behind he ever did you feel like you were massively behind the catchup mechanic here's the thing I was partially behind by my own design right which is me doing what I normally do which is different I pick a mechanism and I go I want to try and see what this does and see if it works or not go all in on one mechanism doesn't necessarily work in Euro sometimes it works sometimes doesn't this time didn't work 100% need to build in this game I went did something else but that's fine I mean I I enjoy the process of that for me I think you know I it's almost too obvious to say that I I really love the production of this game which I think is about as perfect as it could possibly be for a game of this type I mean it's totally valid freaking marvelous and I think it really it just it drags me into the enjoyment of the game I love how it looks it's absolutely beautiful I I love how it looks I love how it feels I love the fact that um it gives you those options without being completely burdensome okay I'm thinking is I like that the board is busy without without being crowded yeah it's busy without crowded more than one thing in a space which you can interpret the game State quite easily even though there are what like 30 piece 40 mles on the board you can relatively easily interpret that I agree it's not it's not completely buried in pieces and it's it's again it's it's another nod to the production
and design of it it's excellent can't say enough I was consistently engaged and engrossed in the little world of Kina ghost chasing yeah Kina spooky ghost B ghost and yeah that design Brilliance extends to the readability the iconography the rule set Etc there was always an answer to a question you guys had a question quick click on the rule book that's the exact answer that we need fabulous uh yeah really great rule set really great design um great and interesting decision spaces but again we we'll sort of shrink and then expand again over the course of the game and also another thing that I love and I'm just rifling a few things off I love the combination of skills and how they break the gameplay Loop and the you guys haven't seen the rest of them but the combinations that you can get I had to look at them yeah and I was this would be good with this one and maybe this one would be really cool with this one really really cool uh it just brings the game to a question do this has this played very differently from the other times you've played it yeah every time cool very different that's what you want to hear absolutely it's yeah very different um anything you didn't like about haunted lands no I found very little that I mean maybe because I won this game which means I was able to achieve what I wanted to more no I I yeah I got to agree with Simon I don't think I've got any glaring downsides no major complaints I think yeah the only thing that you might question is whether or not that uh the catchup mechanisms are are right for you and I think through more play that will come apparent but I I for me I think
it's totally fine do if you can if you can very closely manage your score to be in a close second and save up points for a big swing it could be very swingy yeah yeah but I don't think it's intentionally designed to Foster that no actually quite difficult to do that alrighty so we talked about what you like the most who might this game be for people who like crunchy is Euros yeah maybe people want to take a a a slightly more than tentative step into the world of view Euro games people who like um territory territory control games and engine builders I've still remarkably sit down listeners yet to play Katan yes but does this sit somewhere in that vague area of tan has a lot more randomization in the resource production okay they don't always produce random spaces produce resources and Katan has a bit more of a social element in that you can trade with people okay but if you liked it would you like this do you think it's a Euro game oh yeah this is this is more this is a slightly heavier more Euro Euro than something like kitan is for sure um but I don't think I don't think it's a million miles away from that sort of decision space yeah I mean if you like your traditional Euro games right
which is you're farming in the Mediterranean type games this takes that to another level in terms of its production and I think in terms of really interesting game design so I think if you like any sort of game like that so actually or if you really like busting ghosts or if you like ghost of busting I think it might be a really interesting kind of sideways step for a lot of people into something they might not necessarily have initially think of but I think there's enough there from a reasonable range of Interest I think people who like Scythe will like this well I was hesitant to mention scythe I wasn't sure how much of a parallel it truly Drew I think you're right you know there is an engine here for people to build around there is Scythe is an efficiency puzzle yeah Scythe is not a war game it's an efficiency puzzle as is this I think that's a shout T yeah there there's definitely strong differences once once you own once you own a spot in this you own a spot in this nothing's going to change that but yeah I there are some parallels to be drawn yeah this is lighter by far oh yeah sure much more accessible but yeah and in I don't want to call it an oddity CU it's it's definitely with well within Realms of a normal game there's nothing wild and wacky about it but yeah really satis really satisfying absolutely since his own little space actually I quite like that about it all right so your final words then your final conclusion and your final rating for haunted lands who
would like to dive in first uh I'm going to give it can I give it h can I give it I want to give it like a four and a half really I really like this I've only played it once so I I'm I'm reserving the half because I've only played it once that's fair yeah I think that's a good thing to say it's a strong first impression I I think yeah first impression was great having looked at some of the other skill cards I can see some really cool combos that could potentially happen um I'd love to play this again and I'd be really interested to see how it plays with two and with four yeah because I think it would be really quite a different game on different player counts mhm yeah and uh final word is Ghost not literally final every time your final words plural and your final rating I'm going to mirror that I think I'll give it a four out of five a very solid four out of five yeah um agreeing with Tom I only played it the once with a three playay account so curious to see it but generally at the moment if you said do you want to play haunted lands I'd say absolutely I know it won't play for a super long time so it won't take all day which again I think is a good thing you asked me to sit down for a three-hour game I'm going to have to consider think about it my back and everything else um yeah it it's very much as I say it sits in there as a an interesting and quite unique variation on a fairly familiar formula which sits at a really Pleasant Point in
terms of gamesmanship for me love that what a great thing uh for me this is a five I love it I think uh this really speaks to me the design uh and you can yeah also listener this may be tempered by the fact that I bought it but whatever I think it's fabulous there's plenty of games that I've bought that I've not given a five out five to this is a fantastic fantastic and to be fair we don't review them yeah we don't yeah if we don't like it don't probably won't talk about it exactly I absolutely love this I think the production is like I've said it I think it's perfect for what this game is trying to do um it's very engaging the gameplay is interesting I think there's lots of options the replayability is high uh I think it's a fabulous fabulous game that needs more buzz and that's my final words on it uh five out five from me I'm really curious that this was designed by Leonardo who we know has designed the Epic upcoming exploration game that's coming out and and where the two different kind of sets of play style sit within the one brain I know I know very curious to see obviously a great designer M and actually interestingly just before we do go off on into the outro you recognize the flippy tokens thing that was also in um in that what's the game called Now requ take me a moment I revive a whole other game you just similar mechanism but obviously with a different in a different framework but with that thanks for listening to board stupid subscribe to us for updates to get future episodes of the show delivered directly to your ear
holes via your favorite podcast service you can also find us on Instagram and at board stupid UK run by Simon and also on YouTube with me and Matt video content twice a week at the moment so get in there while you can give us a subscribe and give us a like and if you got any comments please do stick it where you can stick a comment because we love talking to you and have stick it where the sun don't shine if you if you got a comment we don't want to freaking hear if if you played haunted lands actually relatively unlikely but what do you think of the sound of it it has our commentary convinced you to potentially pre-order pre-order it and I really think you should this game certainly needs more buzz and uh if you have played it did you did you pick it up at Spiel what do you think of the combination of Crisis management and engine building what skill combinations have you found to run away on your ghost busting efforts thanks for listening we'll catch you again real soon you know the German word or all the word Poltergeist come from German basically means Rumble ghost it really or noisy ghost I I think I'd heard noisy ghost before heard Rumble ghost Rumble the M that's very musical 80s movie there you go f Rumble
ghosts