Tokyo Tsukiji Market Review | Pocket Board Game Series - Part Three
Transcript
fish the salt of the sea once mighty kings and queens of all water now just a mere flap in the ocean but did you know that fish are also great economists in tokyo tsukiji market you will be competing to see who is the best fish salesman around you know this isn't about fish that sell it's about people that sell fish i'm going to have to rewrite this entire script welcome back to the pocket series a six episode arc of board game reviews that feature the best board games that can fit in your pocket in previous episodes we covered sprolopolis an excellent 18 card game about building cities and the shut up and sit down nonsense box the game that puts the party into charades party whilst the previous entries were all about delivering the most game in the smallest footprint today we have something different welcome to one of the world's finest fish markets where the everyday hustle and bustle of slimy deals fills the air with a heady aroma smell fish yes tokyo tsukiji market is an economic simulator where you'll spend money on boats and fishing licenses catch barrels of fish and sell them to your competitors and here's the catch this box has as many components and as many ideas as something like this or even something like this but conform to a size that would
allow it to be dispensed by a japanese vending machine better yet these tiny feebles are adorable not only does their diminutive size make them cute and in the case of fugu fish also deadly but they're not just a carbon copy of the same board game pieces we see in every german box of wood look at this eel better yet look away from it and let's look at this octopus instead did you know that octopuses have free hearts brains inside of their tentacles that make them behave independently from their body and attack peak and finally the scientific name for this cutie is opposite uthis adorabilis which as far as i'm concerned is just nature's way of saying that pac-man ghosts are real don't get fooled by these fresh bits if the cold colors of the minimalist design haven't given it away yet tokyo tsukiji market is as mean as it is lean and when i say lean i don't mean box size because it's actually quite chunky for that type of box before we dive into the deep end of the rules pool we thought it would be well worth mentioning that tokyo tsukiji market borrows quite a lot from container also a game of boats getting cargo and selling it to other players at whatever price you think the cargo is worth but unlike container none of the values of what you're selling are obscured and everything that you sell has its own individual rule set mackerel behaves differently from squid and squid behaves differently from salmon which makes sense because we all know that
squid are well-behaved good boys and salmon is a neon rebel if you want to learn more about container you can watch the shut up and sit down review with the caveat that we didn't love that game nearly as much as they did and they themselves have recently said that further place didn't make it shine that much either tokyo tsukiji market revolves around a simple principle each round you can do two actions out of a list of three you can either go fish buy fish or visit fish markets if you decide to go fish you will once again get two boating actions and once again you will have a list of three possibilities if your boat is docked you can send it out to sea which is represented by the vastness of this table if your boat is already at sea you can actually fish and then you will get a barrel of fish and if your boats have barrels on them you can send them back to the dark when you fish each fishing license you have will let you get one barrel of that type of fish so if i had a macro license and a salmon license and i had two boats out at sea with one boating action i could get a salmon barrel and also a mackerel barrel but if in that example i had three boats that third boat could not get any more barrels because i only have two licenses and i'm a responsible barrel fisher once your boats have barrels you can as an action return them to your harbour and
then whatever they have on them you have to immediately put it up for sale that's right that fish you caught isn't for you it's for the other people sitting at the table and trying to financially outplay you but don't worry because they'll give you money for it how much money well that's entirely up to you immediately when your ships land each barrel has to be placed on one of the value spots on your market so you could price this barrel of mackerel at 100 yen 400 yen and since there's a spot that lets you make up your own number seven five zero zero zero zero zero zero zero yen i don't know if you noticed but once fish has been out there for a while it will develop new different flavors and for some reason people don't like those flavors so if the round comes back to you and your fish barrels haven't been sold yet they will immediately degrade that doesn't really affect your fish in any way just yet but if another round goes by and no one buys your fish it has so many new flavors that you have to now throw it away so much of tokyo tsukiji market lies in that one moment of split second decision making how much do i value my barrels at which is a good question actually how much do you value your barrels at what are their values well to explain that we first need to explain how you
win in a game of fish you either win or you accidentally eat a poorly filled fugu and die just saying that joker made me feel like my freshness value dropped anywho to win you have to accrue the largest amount of money the game end will be triggered if you have either 5 000 yen or 50 worth of resources unless and let's say you got 5 000 yen you have less resources than all the other players on the table the same is true for resources if you trigger the game and via having 50 resources and you have the least money on the table then the game doesn't end when the game does end each resource will be converted to a hundred yen and then that's your total whoever has the most money will win but each fish on this planet has not been made equal macro for example is always only worth a single resource whereas salmon is worth 4 resources if you bought it degraded or f resources if you bought it fresh where f is equal to the number of salmon owned by players at the end of the game i know right so here's the conundrum every fish you buy from another player is essentially money but money you can't spend on buying things like bigger boats or new fishing licenses which brings us back to pricing up fish let's say you bring in a barrel of red snapper and at the moment it's worth 6 resources you know you probably shouldn't price it at 600 yen or higher
since no one's going to give you money for nothing you reckon that 400 yen is probably a reasonable price so you go ahead and wait a minute what if no one's gonna buy it what do i do then of course every time i take a boating action i can just reprice it but then everyone's going to know i'm desperate and then my snapper's just going to snap away but if that decision might seem nerve-wracking let me tell you that's just the tip of the iceberg like we mentioned before every fish has its own rules so red snapper is worth 6 resources right except with every red snapper purchased the value of all red snappers goes down which means that anything between 500 yen and 100 yen could be either a great and or terrible price it's basically schrodinger's fish value this exact moment in tokyo tsukiji market is the source of all highs and lows and i am here for it you'll gasp when someone sells an eel for way too lower price you'll gas when someone puts up a mackerel for 7 000 yen and then you'll realize they probably just didn't want anyone to buy it your personal markets are the dispenser of drama and friction they're the unbelievable moments that bring tokyo tukiji market to life they're also the reason why we wouldn't recommend this game to a majority of our viewers now before you get upset that we dedicated one of the six slots of the pocket series to a game
that isn't going to be a surefire hit and a game that frankly isn't going to remain in our collection i'm gonna tell you that i think this could be someone's favorite game of all time and i'm going to tell you why but first let's analyze some of the problems we described the first of the three actions going fishing in detail the second action is perhaps the simplest one in the game buying fish from other players when you choose to buy fish you can buy any amount of fish from any amount of players for the listed prices simply giving them the yen and converting their barrels into an actual fish what you do with that fish is entirely up to you let's say that you bought eel which looks a little bit rude what can you do with it well you can go back to the eel market and sell it how much for the price of eel depends entirely on what you do in this game every time someone fishes eel the value of eel goes up and as soon as someone sells it it dramatically plummets down making eel the russian roulette of fish by eel early in the game and you can get it for an easy 200 yen then sit on it wait for more eel to get fished and sell it for a fortune unless of course someone fishes a bunch of eel brings it back home on the same turn and immediately puts it up for sale the next player then buys it all and sells it to the eel market plummeting the price and then you're left with worthless eel
which is i believe how britain ended up with jellied eel because what else do you do with it this is again all very compelling stuff each type of fish is a puzzle to solve framed against a backdrop of a cutthroat economics game except for these puzzles to hold weight you have to have a fantastic framework for that economics game to support them considering that no matter how many fish you fish you will always have to sell them at something less than they're worth because otherwise who's going to buy them which makes selling fish bad business and buying fish good business which brings the question why fish fish in every game of ttm i've played the person that won was the person sitting directly to the left of the person who got overly excited about fishing because as soon as they brought in the boats the person sitting next to them immediately bought everything up leaving none fish for the other players whilst their economy is flourishing because they're buying and selling buying and selling why would you be the person that fishes a lot well the game makes it tempting first of all you need money and you can make a lot of money by fishing plus there's all these cool tools that let you be really what's the word efficient come on you knew that had to happen anyway here's a barge barges are neat because unlike other boats they don't fish themselves they just sit in the ocean and whilst you or other boats
fish the barge immediately hovers up all the barrels letting you fish fish and deliver them with a single step of the fishing action if you buy the barge you will make a monstrous amount of money very fast and probably come in second because whoever bought the fish made more money than you did tokyo tsukiji market is a game that is only as strong as its weakest link if one person starts pricing things at silly low prices because they misjudge the mathematical puzzle the person next to them will win if one person pushes the phishing button too hard the person next to them will win and so on okay then this is a game that benefits from experience right with savvy plays surely there's a good time to be had well here's the thing the name of the game is buying and selling and if everyone's coy about selling then there's also not much buying with savvy plays this fast-paced wet slap of cold bucks grinds to a screeching halt and whilst we generally avoid comparisons to similar games i can't help but invoke container here because whilst they absolutely load the secret values of goods you're buying and selling at least there was a sense of mystery in tokyo tsukiji market halfway through the game it's plainly obvious who's going to win it's the person with the most things you can try and edge them out but the only way you can do that is by having them not buy things and the way you achieve that is by not selling things not fishing
and then how you're gonna make money but here's where we'll throw tokyo tsukiji market a fishbone the third action in the game is to visit one of the games many markets and when i say many i mean look at all of these possibilities not only is every fish market a new idea that you can't wait to explore but also there's external markets which spin the game into weird unpredictable directions from aquariums they'll let you sell fish that you otherwise wouldn't normally even be able to to banks that not only will let you take out loans but also buy out other people's loans every one of these markets is a tantalizing injection of possibilities better yet each game you will only play with a selection of different fish and external markets meaning that every game of tokyo tsukiji market is a decadence now but afka i hear you say isn't over fishing really bad for the environment don't worry tokyo tsukiji market has you covered first of all none of these are real fish second it has an overfishing mechanism which obviously isn't going to solve the world's problems of sustainability but it has an overfishing mechanism it's a nice touch thematically simulating the dangers of wanton capitalism but also it's an interesting gameplay twist anytime you overfish a type of fish that market will be removed from the game and a new one will be introduced spinning the game's plates one more time to offer
a surprising twist on established strategies and i can absolutely see that there will be a group out there who will persevere through the rough edges and then find themselves in an endless troll of exploration but for us i think we're gonna have to close the lid on this box before it gets a little bit too you know framing this game into a success requires a group that's not only as steady and calm as a rock but also has pitch perfect timing to strike at opportunities to paraphrase to have fun with this box you have to play it in a nest of vipers but because it doesn't have a strongest structure as something like root you also have to carry that nest of vipers whilst you're wearing stilts finally this box says right here that you can play it with two players and it's about as good a two as tin mackerel i love macro well do you like this game with two players no then you don't love mackerel that's it for part three of the pocket series which will return soon but not immediately we will be injecting a regular mpi review in between in our next installment we'll be coming back to another one of button shy's wallet games tassie masi i can guarantee you that there's no better color game in the world that is about the art of victorian flower giving if you're enjoying the pocket series it's brought to you by the power of our patreon supporters today's patreon shout out goes out to lars hoffman who's been supporting us for months and it's because of people like lars that we get to explore these kooky strange games and tell you all about
them