Mistborn: The Deckbuilding Game - First Impressions
Transcript
hello everyone and welcome back to the board gaming doctor my name is Phil and I'll be your board game doctor today after a brief Hiatus I am back with another review uh and pardon if my voice sounds a little raspy it's part of the reason why it's taken so long is because I'm recovering but from a sickness but uh so today I wanted to talk about Miss born the deck building game this is the new John declare game that was released this year I believe they are sold out at the moment but have some more copies planned in the new year uh this is a game by Brother wise games as well if you are familiar with their work recently they also uh they've funded and are producing The Stormlight or I should say cosmere RPG game which was a lot of fun I've had the chance to play that too and it was great but this is a strictly you know mechanically a deck building game in the universe of M born which is one of the cosmere books made by Brandon Sanderson I am a huge fan I've reread these books as well as all of his other cosmere and non-cm related books multiple times and so I'll I do have the background of those books in mind but you do not need to have them to play this game just to kind of get into it this is a pure deck building game and I want to start with some game comparisons first of all uh the mechanisms that are utilized in this game feel very similar IL to other deck building games that are
more competitive in nature in terms of fighting different opponents which are other players or perhaps even a boss that you're trying to find so it's very similar in the fashion of Star Realms as well as aons and if you're looking for that more Cooperative boss battling experience there are other games shards of infinity that kind of fall under this category but I would say that this is kind of a a very similar offshoot mechanically towards those two games that I've have played and so let's get into past the comparisons what makes this game feel unique and I believe that most of it is from the Thematic integration and application of the mbor book so and I should say that this is mostly based off of the first book in the series the final Empire rather than all of the books that are combined there are seven total in this universe and so the uh the application of how those you the the system the magic system works in that book is somewhat um uh represented here with the metals that you get to burn and these essentially are the units of energy that will power the cards that you play you do have a market of cards and the ability to uh use money to buy these cards and then so that that that is very reminiscent of a regular deck builder
but in order to power these cards you utilize these medals and so for example this uh Peter arm Ally requires petor to activate and so on my turn I would place this P token on top of it saying that I have burned this Peter to use this card's effect some cards will could require you to use two metals to burn and so you can use your one metal token to burn steel to activate this coin shot but you could also uh use another card and tip it sideways to reveal the um extra flask of metal that you have here to utilize this card and so that so there are many ways to be able to activate this card for example you also have ATM which is the god medal in in represented in this game uh from from the books essentially acts as a wild resource that you can also use to activate any cards as necessary you can also flare these medals and so for example if I didn't have uh you know a card in hand to activate this coin shot I would um burn or flare a metal rather and I would flip it over to its flared side to use as that wild type resource to activate that card and you can discard cards from your hand to uh obtain that metal again to burn other features of this game is that
you have a track on your personal board that you automatically Advance every turn uh which allows you to burn and utilize more metals and different Metals each turn as well as activate your own character's abilities and in this game I was kelsier I at first would be able to use combat points or accumulate combat points if I had burned steel at any point but then you get to activate further abilities especially if you are able to use ATM in this game you are either competitively fighting against other opponents who have other character cards such as Vin here and and Shan as well uh the other character is Marsh from the books which I don't see here you also get to advance on missions there are a collection of missions that you randomly choose three of and they are essentially tracks that you progress up to to gain various effects as you go up the track and as you reach certain tiers first and then finally you can play this game cooperatively or solo against the Lord ruler and they the Lord ruler has a deck of cards that you flip over every other turn which has allies of his that you would fight against or um let's see if I can draw one here an edict card which uh asserts his dominance further and it allow allows for a ramping up of the negative effects that would either do damage to to you or
to lose your own allies burn Metals you know flare Metals Etc and so um the Lord ruler has a certain HP limit to that you're trying to bring down very similar to a boss in a on send so that's the basic overview of how this game plays so into my review I've gone over game comparisons as well and to kind of go into the nuances of this game what makes it stand out compared to others first when I did a peer review the um you know a lot of people mentioned and and and this peer review comes from comments that are on Board Game Geek for those who have played and or obtained this game already uh the uh the ability that I wanted to point out too that makes this game feel different compared to other deck building games because I feel like everything that I've said so far perhaps other than the metal system of using uh you know how how to power your cards essentially there are a couple of things that really stood out that make this game unique one is the second player ability that everyone has which says when you buy a card you may resolve its top effect immediately then eliminate it so that gives you the opportunity to from the market of cards use the top ability of any one of these cards and then immediately eliminate it from the game you don't have to bring it into your de deck or your discard pile and then Shuffle it into your deck and make it thicker uh decreasing the chance you would have to use it again so
especially if it's a car that you would only want to use once perhaps that fits the the need uh the immediate need that you have in the game then you have that option if you've progressed far enough into the game to be able to do a onetime effect use of one of these cards and you can eliminate it and it potentially would eliminate it from uh someone else's opport to buy it for their own deck and so a lot of potential for interaction there and a lot of potential to keep your deck thin uh there are other traditional ways that you can do so via card effects and and whatnot to be able to eliminate cards from your own deck and there are also ways to obtain cards from the eliminated pile and so nothing truly feels out of the game there are ways to be able to get to the cards that you want to use and buy um and even even the the fact that you don't typically you would uh discard all the cards in your hand and if you have leftover money for example which are found mostly on these funding cards but on others as well then you would just essentially eliminate the opportunity to save up money but in this game you can purchase
cards for boxingsocialist
uh it starts with the last player uh in in turn order but if another game comparison is allowed you would think of this similar to King of Tokyo where the person who is targeted after combat resolves with you know targeted allies the player will receive the rest of the combat and then afterwards they get to choose who this target will be and that could be anyone and so there is agency to who will receive re damage next in the in terms of where this target is assigned and not necessarily everyone ganging up on a character uh there is some alleviation from from that where many people might bully a certain character if they are uh you know running rampit with their deck building so I I I thought that was an interesting way to do so however for some people despite the interesting way to Target people with combat this game did feel a little long uh for what it is at three to four players it seems to be best played at two when you once again a direct comparison to games like Star Realms where the amount of interaction and game length feels right and appropriate at a shorter you know time interval uh that's not to say perhaps what it might feel like to do a Cooperative game against the Lord ruler but in any case that is you know what some people say uh otherwise people have felt like the game is very
approachable and easy to learn very familiar because of its mechanisms and uh anyway so that's what people think now to go into my first impressions I'm going to do things a little bit differently I do have a criteria where I have set up um 10 different aspects of a game that I find the most meaningful and interesting to me and and so I'm going to go down those lists and assign the each of those you know categories and a score out of uh 1 through 10 and then add those up and that's my overall rating and score so for learning how easy is this game to learn and play I give it an eight out of 10 it's very straight for forward to learn I think it's very approachable for those who are Gamers and familiar with deck building but also to non Gamers you can use the theme to kind of get into what is going on to explain how things work and so I do appreciate that and it's I think it's fairly easy to jump into rather regardless of who you are uh there were a couple of things especially with the metal system I I had to relearn a couple of times or reread just to make sure I was doing that correctly uh with ATM as well uh and rules for solo play but uh it only took a couple of rereads to fully understand the rules strategic expression so this is how I feel like each game can feel strategically different where you can pursue different Avenues of play and I give it an eight out of 10 I think flexibility was definitely a Forefront in how this game was created and played
there isn't one direct way to win in this game there are two you can either deplete the uh health of your opponents or the Lord ruler if it's Cooperative or Solo or you can achieve all three of these missions and Advance on the track of all three of these and you can win in that way to do so you can focus on cards which thematically are very similar to how it is depicted in the book for example Iron and Steel a lot of them have to do with um combat uh tin as well can do that in pter uh but then you have more of the subtle metals that manipulate emotions and things like that and th like bronze and copper and so those will tend those cards tend to help you advance on missions and so there are a mix and match of things that you can do to win at this game and and the way that you build your deck as well I feel can really help out a certain strategy or not for for example if you do want to have a a bigger deck and a wider variety of metals that you can activate on each turn your training can allow for that to happen or if you want to focus on one or two medals and really push on a certain you know Victory condition that is feasible as well you can have a thin deck you can have a big deck you know uh it it really allows for flexibility and once again the the additional ability to be able to use these cards as a onetime effect rather than forcing them into your deck and then having to eliminate them later I think is really interesting and fun and that kind of goes into the mechanism
uniqueness and execution I give it an eight as well uh mostly for uh the ability to use these effects as a one-time deal that think I think that just allows for a lot of mechanical flexibility in this game now thematic integration is going to be a N9 out of 10 it just misses that that one point it's just shy because of the mechanism of flaring now in in the book I I don't feel like you can flare tin for example and utilize a like a a steel push or an iron pole you know for example in this game you can and so mechanically this really helps with the flexibility to flare metals to you know and burn them to help out another card when you are short uh but in my mind when I first had read this and this kind of goes to the learning like I thought oh if if a card required two iron to use and if I didn't have another card that had iron or steel depicted on it as a potential backup energy to use essentially I could use the steel to activate this and then flare it to activate a des to in my mind that thematically made more sense to do I don't know if that you know gameplay wise made much sense when it was in development but you know that was the one hiccup that I had with the Thematic integration otherwise uh the card and the art you know were fantastic and I think everything is depicted really well well uh everything is is is good there the rules and the way that the the game
plays not only you know abstractly make sense with the theme of the of the game but I love that you can still play this game and follow the general sense and story of the first book the final Empire where you are trying to bring down like ocean 11 style uh the Lord ruler as a group of uh you know ragtag allies and so I think that was really interesting but but also the competitive mode I feel like represents the the different factions of of scadrial uh that you're you know fighting against each other with your own Mis borns Etc and so I I think it fits that bill and portrays the book in a very meaningful way so very high score for that and then my scores start to drop off a little bit with variability I feel like the variability in this game is a six out of 10 for me uh and the same goes with replayability a six out of 10 because I feel like while the deck is pretty big you you still get to see a lot of these cards even after a few plays and so it's really easy to be very familiar with these these cards and so if you're always looking for something new a new card or new card combinations to pop up the probability of that happening becomes less and less the more you play this game and and that limit for me becomes or comes a lot quicker because you do get to cycle through a lot of these cards and so for me you know the the visual aspect of variability is limited the game the base game only comes with four of these characters the ones that I've mentioned before and so
there aren't you know and here's Marsh the uh so you know if you're looking for character variability it doesn't have the same um options that you would see in a game like aon's end albeit there are you know many expansions towards that as well but I feel like even in the base Gade in comparison there are a lot more options to fight against different uh with different characters but also against different bosses and in this one it's just the same uh Lord ruler that you're fighting against and so uh for me this the solo game I I've played this solo and have learned how to beat it and I mean I don't feel any desire to come back and play it again uh I don't feel like the differences between each character make it drastically different for me to feel like it would be different as well and so um so it I don't think this game for me as a in in the solo perspective would be very replayable in the long run I think it would be fun to pull out with other fans of mbor who want to play it cooperatively against the Lord ruler or to play it competitively as well you know every once in a while I think that's where it will come and fortunately it is an easier game to get into and perhaps there are some opportunities for expansion if we do want to explore the rest of the original mbor trilogy as well as the future mbor books that are in you know depicted in wax and we Etc if if you know if you know you know but uh so there probably
will be good expansion material I think there's a good foundation here but in and of itself I would love for that expansion material to be here to increase that replayability and exploration uh the solo I guess kind of Dov tales with that thought it's a five out of 10 for me while it does thematically feel very uh similar to how I felt reading the book it's fun for you know one or two plays but it it doesn't really hold up to the amount of options and flexibility that you would want for a an engaging solo experience for multiple multiple plays player interaction I give an eight out of 10 I think some people felt like this game wasn't very interactive enough I I mean you are directly attacking other folks and their allies and and their own characters as well and so I do feel like there's plenty of interaction there targeting you know others with the unique targeting system that is in place here uh purchasing cards of course there is the interaction of of grabbing these cards first before someone else does as well as progressing up these tracks uh trying to get to certain spots first before anyone else does uh and so to me they is plenty of good interaction that could lead to you really paying attention to other people's boards and what they're trying to accomplish and then finally competitiveness uh how meta relevant or you know tournament worthy would this game be is what I'm trying to get at and I think this game is quite you has quite a good potential for it I give it a seven seven out of 10 I feel like the deck is large
but you know uh short or thick or thin enough I I should say to be able to really understand these cards understand the game State based off what what is offered the missions that are available and the characters that everyone is playing a lot of people compare this to do an Imperium but without the worker placement and I think the the flexibility and the interesting cards that you have in this game uh make it interesting enough that you can really pursue different you know Avenues of strategy to therefore make things more transparent when you are playing competitively and so I think it does have that potential one thing that I did want to mention to and I think it's in my my discard pile there is a card uh it's called the confrontation it might be in my deck that is really interesting it is right here and so it's a third win condition that is only on this card if you play this card with three ATM you automatically win the game and so I love the aspect of you know trying to chase this third win objective as well um similar to the opportunities that you're given in games like seven wonders duel and a lot of the Dual games that have been made after that and so uh yeah really cool ways to pursue strategy and so therefore I feel like this game is quite competitive so overall I give it a 7.2 out of 10 I really enjoy this game right now the in terms of replayability I think it has some issues for me but in and of itself the game is excellently uh
developed mechanically but also thematically and I think anyone who really enjoys the mbor series and gaming will and would enjoy at least playing this game and reliving the first book story through the mechanisms of this deck builder so I I applaud everyone who is behind the development of this game and I think they did a great job so those are my first impressions of misbourne the deck building game by John declair uh thank you let me know if you have any thoughts if you've played this game already and and I'd love to hear that so thank you for listening or watching this video hope you schedule an appointment with me in the future as your board gaming doctor and I'll catch you on the next one take care