Skip to main content
Loading video...
Transcript 31:09

Some viewers may find the following video disturbing. Viewer discretion is advised.

Hey everyone, welcome back to Board Games Unlocked and today I'm doing a discussion over Entropy. This is the newest game by Board and Dice with the three designers of Tomaso Batista, Simone Lucani, and Neestor Manon. I probably got most of those pronunciations wrong. However, uh this game is incredibly interesting because this was a game, at least for me, that was ran on Gamefound and then delivered like a month later. It was an insanely uh impressive turnaround time. And normally whenever that's the case, there's one of two things. one is the game is already pretty much finished and they just need funding to get it printed. Uh or B, the game is vastly underdeveloped and they just it's either it's probably a scam. Obviously, that's not the case with Board and Dice.

They're a wellestablished company. I enjoy a lot of their games, but this is going to be yet another case of this string of Euro games that I've just been reviewing lately that just had a lot of issues for me. Um, which is actually pretty unfortunate because of the three designers that are attached to this game. though. Simone Luciani, I mean, that's kind of like a household name within, especially within Board and Dice. Uh, the other two I didn't recognize right off uh RIP, but uh Tomaso Batista uh is the one that is behind [ __ ] I I literally looked it up. Um, he is behind I want to say here I'll look I'll I'll look it up again just because Tomaso is behind barrage that okay yeah he was the one behind barrage and then it was uh Neestor that was behind Darwin's Journey and Shackleton base.

Um, so I haven't played Barrage, but I know a lot of people like it. That has a pretty good following. And then, uh, Darwin's Journey I love. And Shackleton Base I own, but I haven't played personally, although I've heard very good things. This one, I mean, it's it's very weird that it has those three designers attached to it when I wonder how much all three had an input. To me, it feels like it was one person's design and then, you know, a few people threw in some ideas cuz this game at its core has a decent system to it. I mean, it's essentially this rondelle element of taking your scientist and you can move them zero, not zero, one, two, or three spaces and you can land on an inner or outer uh action spot on the ring. And it's it's pretty much a rondelle. And how far you move will either grant you a stronger, weaker, or no bonus. I actually like that system quite a bit.

And if there are other scientists at this at that location, it adds one to your movement. So if there if you move one to a spot to get the one movement bonus, but there's a scientist there, it counts as moving two, which means you get a weaker bonus. And all these bonuses are essentially just resources that you can get. That's your main crux of getting resources. Uh, and a lot of the resources you get are going to be used for the action you're going to be performing. Uh, so that that that system I I do enjoy. My overall problem with this game is it feels very uh there the the elements of this game don't justify the length that comes with it. Uh it kind of boils down to this game just runs way too long in my experience anyway to get any sense of full enjoyment from it.

And even on the box it says 90 to 150 minutes. Uh even at an hour and a half I think that should be the max time because what you are doing in this game and the way that the game ends just feels like you're going through the motions about halfway through and everyone is just trying to get the game to be over. And the reason for that is because your main action. So the the overall objectives are you need to get a level three or four star in your solar system. You need to put an asteroid in a solar system. Just your first asteroid in a solar system, not per planet. Or you need to upgrade a biome.

Those are the three. Think of like terraforming Mars objectives that people are kind of racing for, but instead of, oh, here's a set end game and these milestones are just going to be victory points at the end or other games where these milestones are going to be ways that you are going to score victory points, but the game will end after a certain number of rounds. That's not the case here. Those are the three objectives. And then the other objectives are either having 18 bacteria, 14 plants, or 11 animals on just in your solar system area. Those are other ways, but the main three that are tracks that will give you victory points. Oh, technically they all give you victory points, but that's how the game is going to end.

And to do any of those actions to either get a new planet so you can start getting, you know, bacteria or whatever or to get asteroids or to get a new star, all of those require these little action pegs. And the problem that I originally have with this kind of system is when you go to do that action, so I move my scientist to that action spot, you have to have this peg available to drop on that spot. Otherwise, you can't do the action. And the only way you get those back traditionally is you have you have to pass it. So, it's like, okay, cool. I'm going to go ahead and make my way around this this board and I want to do that action again. Well, unfortunately, you can't because you passed it and then it goes back to your board face down or sideways and at the end of your turn, you stand it up. So, that happens for upgrading a star in your solar system, that happens for getting a planet, and that happens for playing cards. And the game has all these cards that when you play them, they have requirements of icons and [ __ ] Uh you play them next to a planet, and that's another way you're going to start generating bacteria and and plants and animals and all that. So to do the three big actions that progress the game, you have to kind of do mediocre

actions. And there and the actions double dip. [snorts] So you have to there are two of them available. So if you which I mean I'm glad that they're there if you don't want to do an act that upgrade a star action until later you it's not just one spot you can do it but there were there have been so many times I'm playing this game where oh I would love to do this action oh wait I can't I have to waste my time cuz I'm set up to play cards but I don't have my playing cards tokum tokum I was going to say token and totem. Um, so I just have to go around the board until it finally becomes available to me. Now, one full rotation does give you your wild. So, you do have two options. Uh, so it it it's not just that one one piece of wood that lets you do it, but eventually it just kind of sometimes they, oh, hey, I want to do this upgrade a star action.

Well, uh, my son is there, so I can't do it. Oh, wait. I have my my wild. So, I'll pop my wild. Then this one will come back to me. So, now I can do the action. But then now I'm just kind of or this one is all the way over there. So, it just it really slows the game down when you don't really need it to be as long as it is. In my experience, you can get by doing everything that you need to with four total planets. So, two solar systems, which are what these little things are. It's a it's this piece with two planets in it and then a star. So, so you can get by with just two full sets of those because you can put some asteroids on it and then that gives you enough to be able to start putting plants and animals and all that if you're aiming for the metals. Now, the metals are the other thing I have a huge issue with, and correct me in the comments if I'm wrong, but I have not been able to find anything in that rule book that says otherwise. So like a lot of these uh types of games, there are there's the big the big metal. This is what uh you know progresses the game towards its end. And then there's all these smaller ones. Depending on the number of players, you can either get 15, 12, 9 or six. So these are kind of what everyone is competing for. Um, but if you are the one to get 18 bacteria just somewhere, then you can

grab this one. However, to get to 18, you have to get 11 or you have to get 11. It is 11. I forgot that they're all the same. Uh, the points are what go down. So, when you're aiming for those, you can generate a [ __ ] ton of points. So, if I'm able to get 11 bacteria, great. I get this small medal. Now, you can only ever have one small and one big one of the same type. But if I'm the one going for most bacteria, chances are someone else isn't going to be trying to compete with me. And even if they are, then now now it is a race. But if I'm the one that gets to 11 first, I get a 15 point marker. And then all I need is seven more, which is not hard to do to then all of a sudden get this 18 marker one. So then I get 35 points for doing the exact same thing I was already gonna do. I really really dislike this point scoring system. It it really shouldn't be I hate this box as well.

Uh that just shouldn't be possible of being able to do both and be rewarded for both. That's truly double dipping in the exact same scoring system. That'd be as if in any other game you're going for a scoring objective and you get first and second place points for doing it. So, I really don't like that system at all. And the bacteria, plant, animal thing kind of just feels almost tacked on because if uh if you are able to grab one of the big objectives, that is one of two goals that need to be met cuz the game ends whenever two out of those six uh objectives are met and then the game kind of, you know, finish out the round, one more round and then the game the game ends.

And those medals are just flat points. Uh the other three, the one where you're going up on the track of upgrading the stars and you know biomes and all that, those have different scoring elements. So you but you're also going to get points for going up on those tracks. It's just weird and I'm not a huge fan of it. Also, just from kind of a production standpoint, not that the game isn't produced well. All the components are very nice except for you. Every player has these upgradeable cards. It's an action you can actually do to make these little uh your action pegs now have a special ability when you use them. The problem I have with those is the cards slide underneath them and then whenever if you max it out, some of the cards peek out from the top. It's a minor complaint. I just thought that was kind of weird as uh only the leftmost car does that and I just don't I don't like it. I wish it uh didn't do that. But the main issue I have is actually with the solar systems is this game for all you know it's it's roughly the board and everything is all self-contained. The problem comes with the player areas because you're putting tokens uh asteroids specifically on these planets to give them different symbols so that you are able to play cards a lot easier.

But the problem is is not only do you have to play cards next to your planet so you know what planets they're on cuz plants can only have five cards attached to them, but then you also have to have a bunch of, you know, bacteria, wooden bacteria pieces and plant pieces. And you're doing this for all of your all of your planets. and it just gets very clouded and cluttered and, you know, messy that I just don't know. I mean, I guess I don't really know of a way to fix that besides making the planet tiles bigger so that if you're putting a bunch of bacteria, cuz you can only ever have five of each type on it anyway. You can have five cards, you can have five bacteria, uh you can have five plants, and you can have five animals. So that's kind of your your main your your capacity for each planet. I just wish the planets were bigger so that you know you could just put the the pieces on it. I mean I guess if you max it out at five, you could just grab one of these, you know, five tokens and put it on the planet, but then you're covering up what the planet does and you're covering up its icons. Uh and sometimes to play other cards, you need to spend cards. So, it's like, "Hey, I have my five bacteria token. Oh, wait. I need to spend two. Let me turn that in.

Grab three. Put it back." It just feels a little fiddly overall. And I mean, so overall, my my biggest gripes with this game is actually it it runs way too long for what it's worth. I don't like how to progress the game. It's pretty much restricted to your action pegs. Even though that system in and of itself is fine, it just feels like you're wasting a lot of time just to get your token back so you can then finally do something you want to do. Uh I hate the scoring system with the with the medals. So then the question comes to well what do I what do I like about it? Well, I mean I do like the scientist movement. I think that that's a neat system. I don't don't think I've really seen that before. Um, [snorts] I do like the fact that there are there there are combos you can do. So, there's another track you can go up that is the entropy track. And that so your each of your planets, not your planets, your stars have an ability on them. And when you're able to, which is for example, if you whenever you pull one of your pegs back, uh, when you stand it up, you can either a gain an entropy or b you can activate a planet. But there are some there is an actual action you can go to that lets you activate all your planets.

Now, this track you go up determines the entropy discount as well as how many planets you can ass or not planets, stars you can assign that discount to. And the more you go up on, you know, level up the stars, the more actions you are able to actually take. So that gives you kind of a way to uh to subvert the uh you know the the rondelle element. For example, the level 3B star is it costs three entropy to let you play a card. Okay. Well, cool. So, if I have my entropy track all the way up, then this is actually free. And not only does it give me three icons, which most of the cards, who the cards, who really cares on that? None of them are really all that interesting. Some of them give you some icons. Uh, hey, this one lets me draw two plant cards. This one lets me move up on the entropy and uh entropy track uh twice. the um animals mainly give you victory points.

But uh if this is my star on my solar system, then if I have a three entropy cost discount or even a one, then this costs me two to be able to play a card. So going up on leveling up your stars is kind of a must if you don't want to run into the issues that I did, especially on my first game of needing the play a card token to be able to drop to be able to do the action or my wild, whatever it might be. Uh so I mean that is cool. That is cool that okay, you might be struggling at the beginning but then you know you level up your stars in a certain way then you don't even really need to worry about that. You can just, hey, I'm going to pull this one back. It comes back. I can now activate that star. I have a two entropy discount. I'll pay the one entropy so that I can play a card. That card allows me to do whatever it might be. You can you can get into some really neat uh combos in this game. It's just it goes back to my first issue of that it's an hour and a half later whenever you're kind of doing that.

So, there's that. The biomes are neat. Again, not only do you have to manage the bacteria, the plants, the uh the animals, the cards, the asteroids on one little what I mean, like this is the size. This is the size of the the planets. Not only do you have to manage that, but each planet can have its own biome. And the biomes are kind of cool, even though they're these longass things. I just wish there was just a better way to organize it. Uh, the biomes give you kind of a passive ability. This one, for example, is every time you upgrade, do the upgrade a star action, you get an entropy. Okay, cool. And they have these requirements for the planet that these are tied to. This one needs two animals and one bacteria or plant. Once you do that, cool. The biome gets flipped, which then moves you up on the track. And now every time you do that upgrade a star action, you get a entropy and you can upgrade a bacteria into a plant, upgrade a plant into an animal or whatever you want to do. So, I like the fact that there's something that gives you passive abilities that no one else has. Um, they're relatively easy to do. some actions actually just let you flip a biome uh for free uh which can be pretty neat.

The the other issue that I kind of have with the game though is there almost feels to be a meta. you kind of need to upgrade your stars and you want to because they're going to give you more icons, uh, which you need so you can start playing cards down, which again are going to give you your resources that you want to be able to start, you know, going for the the victory points. Um the the problem that I kind of also fell into was because this game feels to be developed and pushed out relatively quickly. That rule book, it's going to sound weird. That rule book is strictly a rule book. It is strictly meant to teach you the rules. And it's like, well, yeah, obviously, you [ __ ] idiot.

What I mean by that is if you have questions of how certain things trigger, it's not in there. It's not going to be an I mean, they have an example of how the the systems work. It's a very barebones rule book. And the reason why I say that is because one of the players because each you're either what was it called? Um, yeah, you're because there's uh you're either A, B, C, or D. I can't think of the the word for it, but that's going to determine what your upgradeable action cards are. One of them is every time you play a card or when you play a card, you gain victory points equal to that type of card in your solar system.

So, for example, if I play a plant, okay, cool. There's one plant. I have seven more plants in my solar system somewhere. That's seven points. That's kind of the gist of one of the the upgradeable scoring systems. The problem that I ran into was, okay, is that ability only whenever you do the scientist action by, okay, taking your scientist, putting it on the area that lets you play a card, you then take your peg, and you put it there. Well, that's the peg special ability. So, now I play the card, now I'm going to get the seven points. Or is that just a passive ability that if I do the plant the star ability? You know the example I gave earlier, the star ability of, oh, I play I paid two entropy to be able to play a card. Cool. I played a card which is showing the icon on here and now I play that plant. I get seven points as well. I don't know. The way we've been doing it was it strictly comes from the action of where you place this because that's the the upgraded card is tied to that. It's literally underneath the peg area. So, it has to come from that specific action, but nothing in the rule book that I could find anyway specifically says otherwise.

Um, yeah, it is it is weird. there's just kind of stuff that feels omitted. Uh, and if it's not omitted, then it was it's it's hey, play it however you feel. Uh, the other thing that is also weird, and this comes from the Gamefound edition, now I've seen a few other people complain about, is there are technically add-ons or pseudo expansions that got tacked on to the game, but it's not in the rule book. It's a QR code that takes you to the the page for entropy, but not to a PDF file, not to a Google doc, not to anything. So, I am not even going to bother with them. First of all, I mean, I don't really like this game enough to ever play it again. I've gotten my plays out of it, and I just don't I like the systems that are in the game enough, and I would like this game way more if uh if it was just shorter. The And the problem is is it's not even that difficult of a game to teach. Uh the the game itself is relatively straightforward. It is a you know kind of a streamlined game, but once you see the systems, this is kind of where a lot of Euro games have fallen for me. Once you see the systems, you

know, after repeat plays, there's just not enough. There's just not enough here. All the biomes and stuff are just, hey, now whenever you do this action, and I and I don't want to be reductive, but they do boil down to, hey, once you do this, you get an energy. Okay, what do I use energy for? You upgrade stars or you can upgrade your cards, but I you don't I I never really found that the upgrading of the actions was all that great. So, h you upgrade stars. Okay. Well, I don't really want to upgrade the stars past what I have. Well, you kind of have to. That's really the only way the game ends because one of the objectives is to upgrade stars. So, hopefully everyone playing is kind of doing that because if they're not then it's going to be a very, very long game. And in my experience, yeah, people are naturally doing that. But the problem is is you have to make it to the end of that objective track. So yeah, okay, I upgraded to a three. I like my three.

I'm not going to upgrade it again. Uh yeah, of course I'm getting a few asteroids here and there, but not enough to really make it to the end. I got a few biomes flipped. Not enough to make it to the end. So you kind of have to assign almost roles to people. Hey, if we want this game to end, you start getting asteroids out. You need five solar systems. Uh, four solar systems, sorry, four solar systems, then put one on each. Um, cuz it's not just one track. Everyone has to track. And that's kind of my overall problem again with the objectives is if it was one long track, kind of like a shared goal that Terraforming Mars does of the game ends when oxygen is at its max, you know, trees are out or what the heat is at an temperature is at an appropriate level. That's what everyone is doing. Everyone is contributing to all of those here. It'd be different if, okay, there's a certain number of asteroids we all can get before that reaches the end. But nope. Oh, if you're playing a four-player game, you get an asteroid, you get an asteroid, I get an asteroid, they get an asteroid, and we've all moved up one.

It It's just I really don't like that system. Uh, so again, not a not a terrible game. I almost feel you have these three big names or these three kind of upand cominging Simone is kind of the biggest name at least to me but again you have the Darwin's Journey uh designer you have the Shackleton base designer you have a barrage designer why are all these names tied to this one game and then the other question I have that I even tried looking up in a update for this game why was it if if the game was already ready to be developed and pushed out. Why was it crowdfunded? I have no idea why this was put onto crowdfunding. I mean, it's cool that we got our game very quickly and it's a finished game and it's not [ __ ] It's not great, but it's not [ __ ] Uh, it's just weird. I I don't understand why they even had it go into crowdfunding because I I expected there to be an update saying, "Hey, here's why we're on crowdfunding. The game's ready.

We just need producing money to be able to make the game, something to be to be put out there. But I didn't see anything. And it it I feel like this game there's something here. That's the unfortunate thing is there is something here. And I think this game could just be it it needed, I think, a little bit more time to cook. Maybe, you know, too many cooks in the kitchen. remove one of these guys from the design board. Uh, remove two of them and just have it be a Simone game. Uh, I think there could there this game could have had more fine-tuning, more refinement to make it kind of just feel like a more complete game.

And uh I mean, yeah, maybe an expansion could kind of it up a little bit cuz the only thing to give any type of variety to this game is they have uh they're over there. They have different scoring objectives for the three things. It's still the three objectives. You know, the stars, the asteroids, the biomes, those are all there, but now they score differently. Uh, which I I mean, cool. That's there, but I don't really I'd rather have a different scoring uh system. Uh, so yeah, it it's just an odd kind of game to me cuz I don't hate it, but I don't ever really want to touch it again because I don't have two hours, two and a half hours to to devote to a game that I find to be uh mediocre after repeat plays. And the the player count didn't fix anything.

I've played it at two and four. It was kind of the the same overall. Uh although I will say two is just way worse. I really hated this game at two. It was better at four, but uh yeah, two was not a fun time. Uh so that's it. That's really all I got on entropy. So yeah, on a scale of 1 to 10, I'm going to give this one a five. I think it's a I think it's a fine game. It's It's kind of interesting uh in your, you know, first couple plays to see the systems, but then after that, it really just doesn't do a whole lot. Doesn't Yeah. You know, it doesn't reinvent the wheel, funny enough. You know, it's a circle. Uh, and whenever you're comparing it to other space sci-fi themed games that have come out recently, Galactic Cruise and SETI, uh, those games are just to me those are standout games. I know they're not the same theme, but they're sci-fi and they're Euro, so I I'm going to lump them into the same group. I would much rather play those games any day of the week than do this one. So, going to give this one a five. And that's it. That's it, everyone. Let me know what you think of entropy in the comments below. Other than that, like, comment, share, and subscribe. And have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you.

Progress saved