Oathsworn: Into the Deepwood | Solo Thoughts
Transcript
hello everyone welcome I'm Robert and today I want to discuss o sworn into the deepwood this is a campaign boss battler and I played the first three chapters worth of story and encounters I used the retail standy Edition and I tried almost every class except the Witch and The Grove Maiden my only prior experience with boss Battlers is Kingdom Death and now let's get into what I liked about the game the first thing that I want to highlight is the amazing flexibility that the system offers so when it comes to resolving combat and skill tests the game offers Decks that you can use to resolve these or uh you can use dice so for people that love to roll dice or for people who hate dice you have both options which is awesome when it comes to how complex you want your experience to be when controlling a character the game offers a full character option where you will use the battlef flow system and you're going to have a full character dashboard with uh a a hand of cards that you use uh to uh play their abilities but if you want to keep it simple for each character uh you can use this companion system which will distill the experience of controlling characters to just a couple cards however the game does still require you to control four characters but you can mix and match how many uh companion characters you want to use and how many full-fledged characters you want to use in your party composition another cool flexible aspect
that this game offers is that you can swap characters at the start of each chapter and you're probably going to be compelled to do so because there's just so many classes and you're probably going to want to try all of them the game also offers multiple difficulty levels to cater to various styles of gameplay when it comes to the story part there's also another cool element where uh you have the full analog option with the story book but you can use the app driven narrated story if you want to go that route but there's also this a summarized version of each chapter's story that you can opt to use uh if you don't want to focus too much on the story that will still offer the important story beats and the tests uh that are required to prepare your uh characters before the boss encounter uh that will allow you to just Breeze through the story and just focus on the boss fights so yeah I really can't emphasize enough how flexible this system is to cater to various uh people's needs and I cannot imagine how tough it must have been to try to balance all of these moving pieces together but they somehow pulled it off and in my experience I think it worked out really well I tried all of these different flexible options but the only thing that I skipped was the option to roll dice but I did try the companion full characters the quick Story the ab narrated story The Analog story all right moving on the other thing I really liked about the game is how many classes it offers and like I said I tried all of
them except two and they all felt very distinct and it offers various complexity levels among those characters which will cater to different players next is the battlef flow system which I found very very interesting however I'll say that uh if you want to control more than one full character uh I'll say that for a solo player it can lead to a bit of analysis paralysis the battlef system will have you control a hand of cards for each character akin to Gloom Haven uh but rather than cards going away permanently like in Gloom Haven uh they go around your character's board and they cycle So eventually these cards will come back to your hand um and it's a lot of moving pieces uh even if you have multiple companion characters so it'll take some effort to try to parse all of your options uh to play the most effectively for a solid player and while I appreciate it being flexible in letting you control as many as just no full characters so if you don't want to use a battle flow system you could skip that completely basically um I think that the game would be too shallow if you control uh anything less than two full characters but the downside of that is yeah um it can be a bit too complex it can be a bit much piloting to full characters because you still have to take care of the Companions and and you know handle the AI and all of that another thing I liked is just the combat system in general and how um damage is resolved so uh I opted to go for the uh
non dice option so you draw from these Decks that have different colors and depending on how powerful your character is and how many cool weapons they have uh they'll draw cards from a specific color so uh it goes from white yellow red to Black so black being the uh most powerful deck that you could draw from for maximum damage and there's these combat tokens that will manipulate uh which decks you draw from so you can boost your damage so normally an attack that would have you draw from the white deck the weakest attacks uh you could use combat tokens to draw from the um other colors the higher damage decks so you can manipulate um you can manipulate draws like that to increase damage there's combat tokens that will have you redraw misses okay or in case that you're using dice you'll roll dice instead but then there's also the determination rule so if you miss an attack uh you can recover all of the tokens that you used for that attack and also gain a combat token of your choice for the next time that you attempt an attack so it will keep you motivated and it won't feel all depressing if you invest all of your tokens into this big attack and then it falls flat because you didn't draw uh properly another thing I really liked is the character ability cards when controlling full characters which once you wrap your head around what your characters are about it will lead to very cool combos when it
comes to the story what I experienced up until chapter 3 was very well written and it offers some spectacular set pie pces however personally I didn't find that there was a compelling overarching story that made me excited to find out what happened next maybe this um will present itself later in the story but uh up until chapter 3 I I did not want to find out what happened next or anything I found it cool and competently written and it definitely serves its purpose of you know breaking the pace in between boss battles but the overarching story did hook me in any way so it just kind of going through the potions for me the game also has a gorgeous Dark Fantasy athetic and presentation that I adored I would say that it's one of my favorite aspects of the game it has this almost like a grein dark Warhammer look to it that I just ate up loved it I also found the graphic design work really well in this game and I didn't have any issues with the component quality and the game also has gorgeous Miniatures all right now I'm going to move on to a couple mixed uh points and then I'll move on to what I didn't like about the game all right when it comes to mixed things I found that the loot was not very exciting in this game uh which also means that the character customization is almost non-existent at least within the three chap first three chapters uh but I can appreciate that at the same time uh so that's why I'm not making this like a full negative point or
anything uh because it does keep the game a bit simpler uh there is already a lot to uh you know control for a all player which I'll get into later okay so not having like um you know all of these um equipment slots for a character uh I kind of appreciated it in in this system not being too um too complex okay or too vast but uh yeah when I got loot in this game I wasn't that excited about it it's like oh okay so I get a a slightly better weapon than before let's assign it to this character that's really it I wasn't that excited about it uh you know compared to Kingdom Death monster when when it comes to outfitting your characters that um I found KDM a lot more compelling and crunchy when it comes to you know customizing your characters here I didn't really feel like there was much of that maybe this changes in later chapters but I doubt it all right the other thing is this game is a table hog okay you need a pretty big table and I actually wish I had an even bigger table just so that uh I could have the story map set up but um you know sadly my table's not big enough enough for that so every time I had to set up an encounter I had to remove all of the story stuff uh set it to the side and then um set up the encounter board uh now my last mixed uh aspect of the game is uh the fact that when one of your oath sworns die during an encounter it's replaced by a minor Ally and now I'm not going to say that this is a
negative necessarily um I understand why they did this because it it kind of sucks in these types of games where a and you know your character dies and you're just sitting around twiddling your thumbs while other players you know keep fighting which you know it's a cool mechanic the thing is um as a solo player uh this really doesn't have any value for me and it just adds to the fidl so one of my old sworns die which I'll talk about you know that whole element of how frequent it is for your old SWS to die uh so that'll happen and now you have to go through this step of adding an ally and you know setting up a a character basically so I just did not care for that as a solo player again there not a negative necessarily I think that this is very valuable in multiplayer so that a you know a a player is not completely out of the game and they can still play so I I I find that cool just for for a solo player this has no value for me I would have rather this been with how flexible the game is I would have liked this to be uh an optional mechanic and maybe instead I could just just have my old swarms be a bit more buffed a bit more powerful so that when they die they're out for good I would have rather that had been the case but yeah I did not care for this mechanic as a all player all right so now moving on to what I wasn't a fan of so um the monster AI here does offer distinct um encounters from the three
that I experience they were in you know different in their own way and interesting but uh unfortunately I just did not enjoy controlling their turns um and I think that this adds up with how much you are already controlling as a solo player with the four characters um it just it just it almost felt like playing multiplayer two-handed for me uh I just did not like the op of controlling these monsters and carrying out their complex actions because there is a lot uh when when you uh play an AI card uh there's like this chain reaction of you know things that you know characters being pushed attacks happening uh so it it sometimes it goes fast but overall every time that I had to play an AI card it just kind of flow of the game just kind of froze and I had to like very carefully read what the AI card did and each AI each boss has its own panel with all of these extra rules which I'll get into later but yeah so um I was not a fan of controlling the monster AI in this this game but obviously this is more coming from a solo player perspective uh you know in multiplayer this would not be much of an issue someone could control the monster focus on controlling the monster each game so it would help with that but yeah from solo perspective not a fan of having to control the monster I also felt that the old swor characters were a bit fragile so there's a six Health limit for old sorns and uh during the
story if certain outcomes happen your o will arrive weakened or wounded at an encounter so they'll have less than six Health probably uh so that this issue of the old sorns being uh you know being very prone to dying uh during encounters is exacerbated by you know the story making that worse probably uh and I just felt that the game kind of punishes you for doing cool things uh so you know your allur will pull off this combo and Destroy three body parts but you know when you destroy a body body part for from a monster guess what for each body part you have to draw a reaction card so your allor is probably going to uh get beat into a pulp uh for destroying those three body parts even if you destroy the last one it doesn't matter so when you destroy the last body part even if you destroy the monster completely and you kill three body parts um it'll still resolve those three reaction cards as a as a death throw and I just wasn't a fan of that I just did not like how fre frequently the olds died now like I said earlier you have this mechanic where an ally comes out if your old dies but I would have rather just the old swor was a bit more powerful and they stuck around longer and finally my biggest issue with the game is just the amount of upkeep now uh if the story and gameplay Loop were compelling enough I would be willing to put up with it I think but even with the companion system that it offers where you can have less
complex characters I just did not find the combat or story enticing enough for me to put up with the amount of upip and as a result uh I quit after the third uh en counter finished I just did not want to play so this game is going to go on my uh you know trade pile I really really wanted to play I really wanted to see it through but yeah I you know I'm not going to lie I kind of felt like almost reliev when I decided that I did not want to play through the rest of the game and uh trust me it's it's a m problem it's not a problem with the game I also wasn't a fan of the fact that with each monster you have to like learn all of these extra rules and uh I understand that they have to keep the encounters interesting I get it but um I did not look forward to having to learn all of these different rules with future monsters that I might have encountered so in conclusion uh for me I think this game totally earns its top 100 spot in Board Game Geek and yeah this game does a lot of amazing things especially with how flexible it is again I can't begin to emphasize how amazing it is that they pulled off the amount of flexibility that this game offers it's unprecedented I've not seen another game that offers this much flexibility and somehow still works you know play testing all of these moving Parts must have been a Herculean task but in my case as a solo player I did not find the game playay Loop or story compelling enough to put up with the amount of upkeep some games I think
are just meant to be played multiplayer and I do appreciate that this game is soluable and it has worked for a lot of people it's a lot of people's favorite boss battler and I can see why I would just rather play Kingdom Death monster I do appreciate that I gave it a shot but I think it's time to find in a new home but yeah folks I want to thank you so much for listening if you have any comments questions feedback go ahead and put them in the comment section and if you enjoy this content make sure to like And subscribe and I'll see you in the next one