Skip to main content
Loading video...

Brass: Birmingham Board Game Review - By Board Of It

Transcript 11:55

hello I'm Sally this is Farrell and we are bought a bit and today we're gonna review brass Birmingham brass Birmingham is a two sport play game based on the Industrial Revolution which took place in England in the 17 1800 s it's described as a competitive network building economic game women way don't think of it is actually fun well brasses website described as a heavyweight game we would actually argue it's much more of a medium weight game you've explains to someone in about five minutes and this actually comes from any of the six actions you can do in your turn being quite easy to understand the difficulty comes in the ways in which you can access resources where you can get them from and under what conditions and it's a game where perfectly planned moves can quickly turn into you scratching your head and having to rethink under pressure alright so I'm gonna play ironworks Godley and you can't do that you're not connected to any coal considering the theme and the area of the game we decided to look into some of

the history and for that we sent to spend our coal mine to tell us what it's really like

now the majority of the game will be spent either placing link tiles or placing industry tiles and then attempting to flip those industry tiles this is because flipped in street tiles and links connected flipped industry tiles are worth victory points and unsurprisingly whoever has the most victory points at the end of the game will win link tiles are either boat or a train depending which area you're currently playing in they will go on canals or rails to link two locations together industry tiles can be placed on the location that contains a matching industry tile the industries can be divided into two groups with coal mines breweries and ironworks all having resources placed on them when put in play and you need to remove these resources through gameplay to be able to flip them like so where with cotton mills manufacturing plants and Potteries these you need to use a sell action to flip and this will often require a connection to a marketplace that has a tile for what you're trying to sell and access to beer as many of these tiles I have this beer icon that shows that you need to consume beer to sell that item now understanding what your network is will be crucial to understanding browse Birmingham a location on the board is considered to be part of your network if

the location contains one or more of your industry tiles or is adjacent to one or more of your linked tiles each time you can do two actions and the games card base so you'll discard one card action redraw up with full hand of eight cards and when this deck is empty you play until each player has no cards left and then the current era will end this is a pretty good system as it creates a set number of brands which then creates balance also when you can no longer draw any cards it alerts all the players you're in the endgame and there's only four rounds left and these rounds become the most tense as you try to maximize your remaining turns while being terrified that another player's actions will bring all of your plans tumbling down there are six actions that you can take on your turn which are pretty simple in principle they are build Network Scout Cell develop and take away building allows you to place an industry tile on the board using a card from your hand you can build any industry at either location if you have that named location card assuming you have access to the resources or you can build at a location that was part of your network if you have an industry card that matches one of the industries at that location when you do a build action

there will always be a cost associated with building that industry tile so these are shown on your player board so the amount of money it costs and resources needed and what era it's available to be built in and then on the other side it shows you what it's worth in victory points it is flipped how much flipping this tile will increase your income marker which will gain you more money at the end of the round and how many points is worth if you have a link adjacent to it when it's flipped the following actions can be performed by discarding any card from your hand the network action is just placing a link tile down on a space service free and part of your network taking a loan will gain you 30 pounds from the bank but you have to move your income marker down three spaces return to the internet or e selling allows you to flip your manufacturing plants cotton mills and Potteries developing involves either taking one or two I'm Q from the board somewhere and then I'm removing one or two tiles from your play map allowing you access to more valuable industry tiles without having to build each one scouting allows you to swap out two of your cards for one wild industry card and one wild location card these allow you to build even if you do not have the specific cards needed for the industry or location you're aiming for due to what you're able to build

being based on the cards that you have you can in theory get unlucky and have a bad hand which can cause you to struggle to be able to build where you want but there are multiples of all of the location cards and the industry cards so you could in theory use both for the tile that you're aiming for so this has never really been an issue for us and we've never felt like the luck of the card drawing has affected the gameplay in any way you also have the Scout action so you can never really complain about being unlucky the turn order is based on how much was spent by each player in the previous round with the player spent the least going first and the player that spent the most going last we find this to be a really great system as it means that a player taking a preparatory turn like scouting or taking alone gets to go first in the next round and then in the reverse the player that spends big and builds a lot goes last so they can't then hog industry tiles and it keeps the turns nice and balanced so I've discovered that all my favourite games have one thing in common having no idea who the winner is until the very final points scored I love the competition and the tension being kept up in the game until the final seconds and I don't think any game does is better than brass Birmingham this is because the games played at the two hearts and you only score points at the end of each child meaning that for an entire half of the game at a time you

have no idea how you're doing compared to other players we've also found that the scoring at the end of the canal era is really not indicative of the overall winner because the game essentially resets between the two halves so if something didn't work in the canal era try another route in the rail era one nice thing that the game does is link the number of players to which cards are available so for example in a game the green and blue locations are not available in the deck so it forces players to fight out at the bottom of the board so it ensures that competition still exists also the marketplace tiles are placed randomly and beginning of the game altering what goods you can sell where and adding some variety every time you play this also creates some fun conflict where you race walls marketplace with other players to try and get their first or some great team-building where you'll collaborate together to create a board spanning network allowing access to everything this game is a weird one in that it can be both fiercely competitive while also promoting teamwork often within the same round the rule is is that if you don't have any color iron you have to take it from the nearest player before you're allowed to buy it from the shared marketplace so what this means is that when you're building industry trials you know that other players are going to take your resources but what it does mean is that they will then flip your tiles for you and this creates a fun dilemma of should you take tallies coal

even though it's been for a time or waste of time building your own coal mine but costing her victory points and even though you do get this teamwork going on the game can be brutal there is nothing worse than someone taking a location tile that you'd be working towards for several rounds or someone's feeling your bare right before you're going to go on a big selling spree and now you can't flip those tiles anymore the worst part of this game by far is the setup of your industry tiles on your play map it is my numbing lis boring to sort and stack the tiles one by one time seems to slow oh my god just please make a stop of course this is not the serious criticism another thing that I wouldn't say to make tit but people should know so this game is very singular every time you play pretty much all you're doing it's very weak tiles are putting industry tiles down the gameplay doesn't really change game to game some games have reply ability and it comes from turns or different outcomes or creating these water cooler moments and this game just doesn't have that you're not going to be saying to your friends hey remember that time I've got three Potteries what a game this is not not gonna happen but this is an amazing game and we in no way like it any less so if this isn't a problem for you then don't worry about it brass Birmingham is one of our favorite games

it's a very well balanced game very thematic and very pretty to look at its tense it's good at any play account and it comes with big it also doesn't know to say it's welcome you always feel like you want just a few more turns and even though it's a two-hour game it doesn't drag somehow manage to make what is a quite driving fun it's definitely recommendation from us go and get it let us know what you think about brass billion in the comments down below and we'd love it if you would give this video a like and subscribe to our Channel

Progress saved