Hansa Teutonica Big Box Review - Chairman of the Board
Transcript
hey everybody today i'm talking about hanza two tonica big box now this is a two to five player board game that takes 45 to 90 minutes to play um it was designed originally in 2009 by andreas steading um but it's been out of print for some time hence why i haven't been able to play it but it's certainly a game i've had on my radar for my duration in the hobby because it has a lot of things that i'm interested in so andrea steading is a really great designer and this is certainly his most popular and famous game over the years but ironically it's the game that i've played last of here so no further games such as forensic the stalford dynasty goo gong and the upcoming stroganoff so this one is a route building game that takes place on this map of germany here you know set many centuries ago and the idea is that we are trying to place our little storehouses here these little trading posts in these different cities to um to build a trading route and to basically dominate the uh dominate the cities by having the most trade posts there or if there's a tie to have the most prolific trade post everything is kind of dictated by this player board here and i will say these are really helpful and explain what you can do on your turn very clearly so as you can see we've got a lot of covered up spaces on here with these cubes and disks but essentially these are upgradable and will let you do more powerful things as the game develops so for example here this part of the board here with these envelopes say that at the moment you've got two actions but potentially we can
go all the way up to five actions should we unlock all those options this one here means that you can collect three cubes back from the general supply into your supply at hand this one here means that you can move existing cubes or disks on already on the board and this one here the privilege essentially means that at the moment i can only build in white cities or white trading posts like like this one but as i get more and more upgrades i can build in orange pink or even black should i need to so as you can see again the the more difficult it is to build building certain places you're going to need those upgrades so what are you going to do on your turn and how are you going to win so it is a game where the person with the most victory points is going to win and you're going to get points in quite a few different ways so the first way you're going to get points is by basically building into these um building into these cities and then people click completing routes on either end of them and if you had a trade post in one of these cities then you are going to get points another one is by i'm building from root to root here so as you can see if you start in stendall and build all the way across and connected to arnheim then the first person to do that is going to get seven points the second person is going to get four points and the third person is going to get two points and there are other ways you can get points as well such as completing your upgrades here and finally the the kind of a very significant way you're going to get points is by using this key track here so as you can see at the moment for every
connected city i have at the end of the game i'm going to get one point but if i invest in these keys here i can get up to four points per connected city which as again which again can get you a fair chunk of points at the end of the game the end game is going to be triggered by either having 10 cities filled or by somebody reaching 20 um 20 points on the track here but that will just trigger the end of the game there are still many points to be had after that after that concludes so let's talk about the actual mechanism of the game and how it plays out so you are going to take some very simple actions in this game and i will say mechanically it is simple there isn't a lot of um exceptions or anything like that it's pretty clean on what you actually do on your turn so your board will show what you can do here so the first thing you can do is and bear in mind you get two actions to start with at least is to put one of your um squares on one of these roots here or on a couple of routes like this and so on if you ever complete the region or complete the route by filling all the squares another action you can do is to take them off like so and put them back into your general supply and put but one of those cubes will go on one of the adjacent trade posts like so so if i want to do that i could put it in the city like so meaning that i now have a trade post there then from then on if anybody completes one of these routes i will get a point as long as i am the most um prolific person there so if i've got the most cubes there or again if it's a thai if i'm the one furthest to the right uh there are some cities like these ones
down here you see these ones with the kind of golden banners if you complete those routes you can either do what i just said or you could take the corresponding upgrade associated to that route so as you can see here if you completed this region you could forsake putting your trade house here in order to upgrade your player board so again here you take one of these off put it in your supply and now you've got three actions per turn so you've got these options of upgrading as i said by either doing that one going over here and getting your route points uh extended being this one here being able to move your discs more getting the new privileges or um or doing other things additionally here in quellen you can if you have the relative relevant upgrade you can get quite a big chunk of points by going there so that's one of the main actions you can do so either put squares on the board or establish one of those trading routes by either getting an upgrade or putting a trading post down another thing you can do is that you can say i had a number of squares on the board here by taking this middle action i can currently move for a single action i can move two existing cubes or discs from the board onto another place so if i really wanted to i could move these two here and jump them straight up here for a single action and again if i upgrade i can do that up to five with five cubes should i need to another thing i can do is to simply take a bunch of cubes from my general supply move them into my supply at hand and by doing uh by upgrading here
you can do that a lot more efficiently you know because you only start with doing three initially but if you get all the upgrades you can take all your queues back into your supply with a single action um there are other things you can do um correlate correlating to the actions i've explained already so say for example a player had built here and i had built here and here and i really want to get on this space here i can spend two cubes one two kick him off and the other one goes back into the supply because i've displaced somebody but then this player as a reward for being kicked off he would get to place that cube plus an additional one on an adjacent route connecting to this one so if they really want to do they can go maybe here or here or spread themselves thinner and go like this and this so if you get kicked off somewhere you do get a an incentive and a bonus for being kicked off of spaces the discs here are important because not only do they let you get into certain um trade cities like this one you know you do need a disk here but the disks are good because if they're ever removed then you have to or the person kicking you off would have played an additional cube but you'd also get rewarded by placing additional cube and like i mentioned earlier so they're really good for blocking and good for getting those kind of displacement bonuses and that is basically going to be the flow of the game until as i said one of those end game conditions are going to be met by having 10 cities completed by somebody meeting 20 spaces i'm sorry 20 victory points
or um you can also if you run out of these um bonus tiles because as you can see some of these routes have bonus tiles associated to them where if you complete that route you get the bonus tile which can let you do some pretty strong things such as you know moving discs around in cities i'm getting bonus actions i'm just moving people out of your way for free and so on so they're pretty worth having and can give you quite a lot of stroke in the game um and a good kind of contingency plan should you need it so yeah pretty simple mechanically so let's talk about how i i think about the game so first off let's talk about those mechanisms this game is certainly a game that's streamlined there isn't any um anything here that's going to be confusing it's all pretty much um you know playing straight from the book not any exceptions any fiddly rules anything like that which is nice it's a certainly not a game that you need to keep going back to the rule book to understand and explain and the depth here is embedded in a pretty simple straightforward rule set with a lot of scope for upgrades and things because as i said the game is actually pretty concise and quite quick from start to finish meaning that you're not going to be able to get all of these upgrades but at the same time all these upgrades are really worth having um because you know if you want to go here and you want to get these discs because the desks are important because they let you get into some cities and they give you really good um you know to stop people blocking your roots or to shove them in the way in order to make people pay quite a lot to remove you out of the way that they're really a really useful tool
to have um additionally certainly towards the end of the game you're going to be wanting to get these um key upgrades because you know your route building is going to be so strong by then that you want to get as many points as you can for doing so the privileges are important because the the initial white spaces are quite scarce and before you know it you're going to need to be getting into these more expensive regions and getting the leg up on those is going to be important to um to get places faster than your opponents do the this action here to get your resource or to get your cubes back into your um your supply at hand is is really important because you don't be wasting loads of actions to bring them back into your supply um you want to be doing that you know as quickly and efficiently as you can and of course having more actions in general is going to be really important because you know if a person is taking four actions per turn and you're only taking two then naturally they're going to have a leg up on you so i really do like that everything here is an extremely strong incentive to have and um you know it's completely worth having and being kind of tunnel visioned and focusing on one can be really beneficial because you know you can be really strong at a certain thing and get the additional points but being well-rounded is equally as beneficial to um you know to be a jack-of-all-trades so i really do like that and you know bearing in mind the the scarcity of these trading posts and weighing that up with how quickly you want to upgrade your player board to hopefully pay off long term there's some really strong decisions here the uh also the incentive in terms of player interaction this this is a game where you are forced
to interact with each other it's got a little bit of a nasty vibe to it um but in a way that's not in uh or not polarizing to the feel of the game itself it's certainly a game that that player interaction of that meanness goes hand in hand with it and i think you need to embrace that when you get playing it because you know when you block roots off you know by doing such a thing like this you are not just doing it just just to screw over your opponents you're doing it because if they pay to kick you off they're wasting resources but additionally you get the additional bonus of building in the adjacent routes so it's certainly a game where that mean edge is part and parcel with what the game is all about and it isn't just destructiveness for the sake of it so be prepared that it is a game with that kind of mean edge but it's not one that's going to make you feel you know regretful or remorseful for doing anything um in terms of balance i mean i think it's really well done i mean the i said the the fact that everything is so scarce and lucrative so quickly is great you know you do want to be here quicker than other people because if you build up you know if you get the um trade houses in early and naturally people are going to want to keep getting action upgrades if you're the majority you're going to keep getting points faster and faster as people go there so you've got to bear in mind that you know i do want to upgrade myself but am i going to keep rewarding my opponents by doing so because they're controlling the adjacent cities again all the other balance of all the different upgrades are really important because they're all as equally as as lucrative and so yeah in terms of
balance and different routes you can go down different strategies and different paths um it's really well done delicately balanced and certainly isn't a stronger route that you can go down almost has a not an abstract feel but a pretty um pretty transparent vibe to it where there's not any hidden information it's all out in the open so in terms of strategy and depth and tactics that you're not going to get caught off guard by a by a cheeky move that you couldn't and uh you couldn't anticipate it's all out in the open so in terms of depth and if you like that if you like that transparency and being able to predict what people can and can't do then you're probably gonna like this one the uh the time investment is really good i mean i said the box takes i says 90 minutes to play um but you know that three three player account four player account you can probably get it down quicker than that and it's certainly another game where if you play with repeat or keep playing with the same people then it's going to um it's going to speed up because in terms of actual your actions there isn't much down time at all you know in in for take three actions you can just put three cubes down you know boom boom boom and that's pretty much your turn done and it's on to the next person so there is a good um sense of pacing here loads of um you know the uptime is fantastic you're not going to get bogged down with them analysis paralysis because those turns are so snappy yet still meaningful so it definitely strikes a good balance there of not just being mind mindless decisions but um you know being you do have the important
decisions but they're not um they're not bogged down in loads of analysis paralysis so that's that's really well done and replayability um yeah you do have lots of roots you can go down as i said are you going to build from side to side here are you just going to build a network without taking that in mind are you going to focus on getting these upgrades and quelling and getting loads of points this way are you going to um you know really focus on you know getting majorities in all the cities and stuff so there are a lot of routes you can go down and that you're going to need that tactical flexibility um from game to gain but additionally with this big box version um you do get the additional maps that were kind of sold separately initially for example here you've got the map of england here which adds very small rules tweaks but just a different layout and such so that's really nice um the balls are reversible as well as you see this is a three-player side on the other side you've got the four and five player and you've got um an additional german map here as well like so so you have got a nice amount of variability in the box and with certain you know lots of different maps to play on which is nice uh the components um i think are really nicely done i think maybe the discs and cubes are a little bit small but that's a complete nitpick the cardboard stock is really good and i will say from a from a visual standpoint i always thought this game looked um a bit bleak and a bit dry but seeing it in person i think it's absolutely
really good looking i love the way this looks it has a really nice texture to it and a nice throwback euro feel which i know this is going to be polarizing and people will probably think you know what that looks boring but for me personally this is right up my street i love the way the game looks the it's all clear you know the roads are clear there's not really much no scope for confusion or anything i think it's just really well put together and constructed um and i'm not sure if this has had a slight lick a new lick of paint and uh maybe slightly brightened up from the original version but i can only speak about this version i think it looks fantastic um the obviously in terms of theme and setting it's a a very dry euro it's not about your theme it's just one of these medieval um root building games about trading and such yeah it's got no theme here it's as dry as can be but i'm sure if you're watching this video you don't really care about that um set up a teardown time is fantastic i mean all you need to do is set up your player board um and you're pretty much good to go so in terms of setup and teardown yeah there's there's really not much to think about and you can get going in less than five minutes there's actually not a whole lot of components in general you've just got each player's cubes and the board and obviously you've got these um these discs here as well which um are used to give the bonuses etc and i should say when one of these bonuses are taken they do get replenished with new ones and they are really worth having so that's another kind of meaningful decision to go down you know you might just choose to divert to get a really important bonus um intensive progression i think it's
uh does a really good job because you are constantly upgrading your playboard getting more bang from your buck each time getting them in more the lucrative cities um and so on and you know the justing for position for um control of the cities is there trying to constantly extend your network but people getting in your way uh yeah so i really do like the sense of progression and the upgrades and the almost engine building aspect as you go along that is really strong in this one scalability as well um it it doesn't come or this big box version doesn't come with a two-player variant but i think there is a uh an official two-player variant from the initial um print um i haven't tried it i'll be honest but i think you can play with two players by putting some blockers on the board um et cetera but it's kind of a bit of a shame that they didn't come in the um in the new rule book but you know what i probably wouldn't choose to play this at two players anyway that three to five player account just works really well and i like the way that the game does come with three player boards just to tighten things up just a little bit um in terms of comparisons um this does really stand on its own i can't think of anything quite like it because as i said it does have that dry um transparent almost abstract nature to it whereas a lot of these root building games don't quite have that and yeah i certainly can't think of anything directly to compare this to but i will say it does have that throwback feel to it of one of those euros that you know didn't really care about you having to get in other place faces and didn't didn't care about getting the
claws out and you know screwing your opponents over and i think that's quite a nice approach and it's kind of rarer to see that nowadays as more euro games become more and more um multiplayer solitaire but this one i said it's more a throwback and it has a uh a bit of a timeless feel to it in that way uh and that pretty much concludes my my thoughts on hands into tonic so let's get into what my kind of final verdict is now this game is a game that's been revered it's stood the test of time people have talked about this for you know i think 11 years now or 12 years as it came out in 2009 um and i can certainly see why this is so strong it's streamlined there's tactical decisions the strategic decisions uh the the satisfaction of doing more more for your attorney as the game goes by is is really fun uh yes there's some interaction here but doing it is i said it it doesn't feel pending or just kind of just botched in there for the sake of it it's engaging it's quick turns fly by um and it's just engaging from start to finish it really does have that vibe of a game that's going to stand the test of time which has already been proven and certainly a game that isn't going to date and age like a lot of games do nowadays it this i said it's 12 years old and it still feels extremely fresh um just those simple clean actions that are easy to teach um but with some real deep strategic gameplay and for me that is just um all those kind of games are becoming harder and harder to come by
um as more and more games come out and that is just a massive praise for uh this design now i do generally like andrea stead in games you know a lot of his designs have gone down really well for me um and this one is um noticeably his best design at least in my eyes um maybe maybe close with forensic but i would give this one slightly the edges i think it's just a slightly cleaner design um with um with simple boil down mechanisms that have been streamlined to a tee without without sacrificing on any gameplay just a cutthroat game that um that just works extremely well and i'm very happy i finally got to play this one um certainly uh lived up to the tremendous hype it's had um over the years and i will say i did i did kind of feel like this game wouldn't be for me um because of those competitive or in your face um player interaction but um yeah it it definitely landed for me and i enjoyed it quite a lot um so that is that's handed to tonica certainly i think it's going to be a a mainstay or at least a long-term stay in my collection because i think it's just a timeless design and one that isn't going to date anytime soon i hope you enjoyed this review this one certainly gets my shield of quality it's just a brilliant design if you have enjoyed the review please hit like and subscribe to my channel and check out my other videos too for everyone else i'll see you next time on chairman of the board bye