Skip to main content
Loading video...

Nucleum - Board Game Review - Alternate Brass

Transcript 29:52

hi I'm Luke Hector and you're watching the broken me this is a YouTube channel about board games where I give reviews top T and my honest opinions regardless of the consequences get on with it if people been waiting for me to talk about this game or what this is the new release from bord and dice nucleum from Simone Lucian and David tury and I need to get a few things off my chest before I get started on this review firstly yes a review copy from Bor and Di always like to at least make that clear secondly it has to be said you know a background to the this game there are a few things that would make people go uhoh when they see me come towards it firstly Simone Luciani luciani's games have been mostly misses for me as opposed to hits and the less said about Lorenzo magneo the better but you know that being said you know there are some of his games that I have at least played and enjoyed I believe Newton and Golem would feature quite heavily in that regard but then the other thing is that this game is portrayed essentially as a kind of almost like a pseudo sequ to the likes of brass and barrage now when it comes to Brass my thoughts are kind of on the line of get out get out of and when it comes to barrage my thoughts are more along the line of no God no God please no no yeah suffice to say those two games when you tell me that this game is basically similar to those two that's not exactly putting it in the best of light for me I do not like brass at all and I cannot stand barrage barrage is one of my most hated

games I've ever played and I know there's going to be fans of both of those games that's fine I just cannot stand barrage and don't like brass so jumping into this Probably sounds like the most suicidal thing I could do in board games ever but open mind wanted to go in and see if it could still be a good fun game because you know just because the original ones aren't as good for me doesn't mean that you can't improve in a sequel doesn't mean that you know certain design choices that you omit from one and put and another could make things better and I wanted to check this out and see if it could do the trick here it goes does anyone want to get out now there's certainly a lot in this game to talk about so I'll try and be as brief as I can nucleum is effectively a game where you are trying to power up buildings all over the map that players will build utilizing coal and nuclear energy primarily nuclear energy but you got to start off somewhere and you begin with coal the idea is is that these nuclear power stations will be on the board and players will be able to build certain buildings like houses and factories and such on the map in order to set them up for lighting with the fuel but you have to connect them up to your network so you also have to use your Railway tiles in order to connect districts to each other in order to expand your network and allow you to build in different places on top of the buildings you can also build what I like to call miniature suns in the case of yellow but in this case they're basically turbine fans that enable you to use more Radioactive materal material when you need it but also mines in order

to store the various uranium pieces once you get hold of them the core of the game mechanism revolves around these action tiles where you essentially have a multi-use function for these you have one of three options you can recharge which is basically a refresh term where you get points and a few other bits and Bobs you know like money and people but the main two things you can do is with these action tiles these have actions on them of different types and you either play them down in on the board as a railway link so so that you lose the tile but you effectively expand your network or you play them above your board and resolve both of the actions that are on there if you place it as a railway link if you can match the colors to the district then you can also do the actions on there these actions range from actually building the buildings or energizing the buildings or getting more action tiles or getting these contracts which are essentially little mini objectives you can complete during the game of course you're going to be getting each other's way because some people will want to go to to places and build up there and you're going to get in their face and you know build networks in front of them but you can also collaborate on wellway links so that it's not just me that wants to go down to here somebody else can come along and go well you know what I'll finish that wellway for you and you know we both get a share of the prize never but you can also unlock Technologies which slide into your little sideboard here and these represent one-off cool bonuses or endgame scoring or Perpetual abilities that you have for the rest of the game what you're primarily trying to do is level up this Star Trek here for for achievements you get achievements by lighting up the buildings and obviously

to light up the buildings you need to use coal and uranium and power them but what you do is that you collect up these achievement stars and then as you do a recharge action you level up on this track here depending on how many of those Stars you've collected and these tracks here will have various Milestone markers which are for endgame scoring and you basically are trying to position yourself on that track in such a way that you'll score a lot of points for whatever path strategy you're following there could be some mileston on there that want you to build very heavily into factories okay fine well I'm going to build up all the factories get the Milestone markers multiple times that when I get to the end game score rign I get like seven times the number of factories I build you know some really cool multiplier the game carries on until a set number of endgame triggers are met which could be anything from 70 points on the track to having all the contracts run out to having all the action tiles run out to everybody recharging free times for Technologies like somebody getting all their Technologies out there's very ious different ways the game can end and depending on how players will play that will dictate how the game's going to end but once it happens you have a final scoring phase and of course to up the points I don't get it a very brief rule summary there because there is quite a lot going on in this game but I've already mentioned what this game is similar to brass and barrage yes it's impossible not to put those in the same boat as this when you're comparing it however I feel that the comparison to barrage is a little bit on the skewed side because honestly the only thing I got from this that I got from barrage was the fact that you're using power

plants to generate electricity that's kind of it really both games have a map that you build on and get in each other's faces but barage is super mean like stupidly mean and I hate the game for it it's so punishing so mean it's unreal this isn't anywhere near as punishing or mean as barrage is and barrage has various mechanisms that aren't replicated in here either so I don't really feel that other than from a slightly formatic perspective you're really getting much out of barrage so really it's brass that you've got to compare this to and there is a lot of similarities there the idea of building up on the board connecting all your networks putting down Railway links you know sort of half collaborating but half getting each other's faces with other players building buildings off your board in the order that you kind of choose you know yes you don't have cards anymore the cards were but the cards were dual use in the past I believe or at least you could potentially use them as a dual use with the the wild rule but here you've got the same sort of thing with action tiles except now the action tiles themselves not only have multiple actions but also multiple uses on your board or on your wellway link so there is enough differences to say that this is not the same game as brass or barrage in any respect if you own both of those and if you like both of those it's possible to like and dislike this in a different way and I would also imagine that you could own brass and own this without really much overlap there's enough differences here it's just from a feel and a formatic perspective it is borrowing a lot of stuff from

brass so you know what let's start on the highest point for me in this game and that is this action tile system I wasn't a big fan of the card system in brass there was too many opportunities where you draw the cards you don't get the cards you need and then there's a critical moment where you must do this thing or you're or you're screwed and then you realize you don't have the cards to do it and you're kind of screwed this is a much better system these action tiles firstly having two actions on the tile already gives them multiple use and I love multi-use cards multi-use tiles whatever same thing but the idea that it's not just what actions are on the tile it's also whether you're going to play them above your board in order to do the actions or whether you're going to place them on the board to connect up a raway link you you look around and think well there's a purple and a white well I mean that's multicolor but that's orange I'm only going to be able to do one of these actions but it might be a two free part raway in which case you're only going to get one action well great uh I'll do this one action in order to get a you know to build something and then I'm hoping that other people will come by and build but the idea that you have to juggle these things around and you can get more it's not that you have a deck of cards and you just draw from that throughout the game no you have a set amount of tiles to begin with and they're slightly different from other players but you then have to go and buy other tiles with an action for develop and there's several on offer and they range from you know duplicating the same action to giving you disc discounts to giving you extra stuff to Simply leveling up your tracks for income and resource generation you know there's a lot of cool things that you can do with

these tiles and it's not that you can occasionally end up with a situation where you don't have the tile to do a specific action that you really must do all your toast but it really does happen a lot more less often it's less often than it did in brass and you can see kind of ahead of time if you're failing on a particular action you look at your tiles and go oh my God I don't actually have any contract actions I can't actually take a contract there's one in the offer for the TOs maybe it'll be a good time for I actually bought one of these now I can choose to go fetch it it's up to me I don't feel like there's a luck of the draw element here because you don't draw them from a stack you know different ones will come out for offer yes but you have all your tiles available to you I don't have them say in a face down stack and then every turn I draw free and see what I can do with those free no everything's on offer the problem is Choice the game also feels a little bit more flexible then say the brass and barrage of its time with those games you were kind of restricted as to where you could go and if you didn't build up your network well enough you were kind of screwed here though from the get-go you are allowed to build anywhere on the board okay great I can do that but then obviously you can only build in certain areas that are connected to your raway links or where you already have a building placed but if you want to expand your network say across the other side of the Bard where you're nowhere near all you've got to do is place a wayway link down you just place a wway link down so let's say I'm here this is is my first wellway link and I'm connected up to these two bits I'm nowhere near this one well you know what I can solve that wellway link put a wellway link down and now I'm connected to this bit as well it's like two

separate little mini networks but that's so much more relaxed and with so much more freedom but it's not like you have free reign over everything people can still block you out of different districts and there is still a limit to how many tiles you can really shove down as wellway links before you need to keep buying more or you run out of the decent actions I mean it's a hard choice to decide which tile you're going to put down a lot of the times cuz you're like but that was a good tile and I need those actions but the colors match and I do need to go there I don't know and you know that gives you a lot of decent turn angst for putting them down but at least I don't have to feel that I'm stuck in one corner and I can do nothing for the whole game I mean if you do end up stuck in a corner and you're not putting Railway link tiles down that's kind of your own fault and you obviously have to be mindful of how many connections there are to District so that you don't get completely blocked out learning the game is fairly straightforward for a heavy Euro I'm not going to say that this is an absolute cinch but I've Tau this game many times and really the only actions that require a little bit more explanation are how networks work because they are a major deal and the energizing action itself with using uranium pieces and coal and that that requires the most explanation but a lot of the other actions are pretty straightforward I mean contract take a contract put it on your board get a bonus done um action tiles um grab action tiles go in your supply when you want to play them put them above your board you can do a contract or put them upside down stick them on a you know put them on a railway track okay nice and simple build right well you can build something from here pay the money stick it on your Network pay from here pay in

people stick it on your network there really isn't a lot of complication in this game there's the odd little micro rule but you know they're few and far between and the reference AIDs that you have for each player are pretty decent actually I mean you they're based on the different technology groups so everyone's asymmetric slightly and it tells you all thech Technologies tells you exactly how to do a recharge turn tells you all the actions in the game and a decent bullet point list of how they work and then also the like what you do on your turn and some considerations about you know completed wellway lines and endgame triggers these two reference AIDS are really good David tury has lent his uh you know usual stick with the solo mode it comes with a separate solo rule book and as you can imagine it's not the like shortest thing you're going to learn in a while however credit where it's due I you David tur is a lovely vog he puts up with a lot of shtick for me and one thing that I like in Solo modes is being able to just get it out and play it as if it was a multiplayer game without too much faf controlling something else which is why complex AI solo modes a bit like what Paul Grogan said on a recent video he did for evacuation um I don't tend to go for those complex AI ones because it's too much to control this one is an AI that you control but compared to a lot of David tur's other stuff this is probably one of the easiest ones to Pilot you go pilot something like the AI out of perseverance or something this is light and compare it to this this is like light years easier to operate yes

there's a little miniature rule book but the flowchart for what the process of their turns are is pretty straightforward the actions that the AI does is pretty straightforward really the most fiddly aspect is the fact that you constantly have to resolve a tiebreaker as to which way it will go and which path it will do which is handled by a small deck of cards which you just flip over and look at what the priority is you know highest number on the board lowest number you know start at this and go clockwise and if as long as you've got that in your head the rest of the AI is actually pretty straightforward I had some fun solo games of this it replicates effectively a two-player game and honestly I think I'd rather pull out the solo mode than play this two-player honestly the game works at two-player but I did find that maybe it's just a little bit even with the revised set of the board it's a little bit too to open and you lose some of that multiplayer interaction that you get in a three and four player game but if you're going to play the solo then be be proud that this is actually a pretty decent mode and isn't going to be one of those oh I got to spend forever doing this for the AI they go there they go there and then they do this and then flip a d flip a card and do all this and let me check the flow chart and go five miles down I mean you want a really high flow chart go play Boku oh my God but this one felt like a pretty streamlined Affair not Flawless there was a couple the times where I had to sort of like keep checking the rule book and just go hang on a minute how's that work but and certainly The Baron's wellway requirements and stuff like that is going to require a little bit of a test to get it stuck in your mind because you

know the the back reference guide is good up to a point but there are one or two things I think they could have elaborated on just to make it a lot clearer so I didn't have to check the book for those little bits but honestly I enjoyed my solo play of this and if you're worried about getting this to the table by yourself yourself don't be it's solid this is why Superman works alone aesthetically this game is not exactly a looker honestly the best looking thing in this game is the cover yeah the rest of this is pretty bland you look at the rest of this board and it is basically this like weird collage of Mucky green and then just a few little districts it's not exactly going to turn heads and one thing I've noticed is that the board has nothing to distinguish colorblindness I played this at handcom with somebody who was fairly colorblind I had to Mark specific districts on the board with tokens from a non-player piece in order to get them to realize which ones were green and which ones were orange nothing here distinguishes colorblindness and I cannot believe in this day and age we are still falling for this trap you know this would have been an easy thing to have like different iconography or a little symbol in the corner of a district to tell you that this is a particular type of District but no there is nothing here to distinguish but the rest of the game is still fairly Bland looking I mean these achievement Stars cardboard tokens you know these little Factory things they're nice but they're nothing major um I can't really give them credit for these plastic uh nucleum pieces because I

think these were an essm promo the tiles cardboard the technology boards I mean these things these are really flimsy you know they're they're pretty spindly and I'm worried that I'm going to snap one of these pieces off if I like jiggle it too hard and trying to actually get your technology piece in these things is a bit of a chore because they don't fit in quite as easily as you would hope and then your board I mean your boards are nice enough dual air board with you know bits that you slot stuff in that's pretty cool and this is probably the best component in there but yeah it's not that the components in this are bad but uh doesn't really get any brownie points either overall I would rate it a C+ okay not great there are some snny aspects in this game that I'm not a fan of the main one being the contract tiles I think this is the weak link of the game and it really does affect my enjoyment of it in a big way because you essentially have only two of each type of contract on show you've got silver and gold and there's only two of each and it doesn't matter what player count you're at that's the way it is there's only two of each the problem is is that these contracts are incredibly swingy because you have to basically shuffle them up at the start like I mentioned but then only two of them are out and you might not all of them are in the game so you might be working on a particular path like oh I happen to be building all the oranges and none of the contracts that say build on oranges come out so you've been wasting your time doing that but then you could literally have a time where somebody takes a contract that says okay I've taken this contract fine and then the next one comes out that says Ah have you built

two turbines well the next player before you has built two turbines and then instantly goes and picks up the contract and completes it and gets a cool load of rewards by complete fluke and this is quite a big deal in a 2 to 3 hour Euro game that has a decent amount of skill involved to have this swingy element because it's not like these bonuses are a small thing you take the contract and you get something useful on your board then you complete the contract and you can get money you can get people you can get Technologies you know the points for these can be quite significant and you know these leg ups are fundamental to doing well in the game so to have one literally just pop out of the deck and go well that was convenient you got it great but then you might have one where it's like well I was building a bunch of uh Factory buildings great any other the contracts of factories coming out no no still nothing for the whole game and then last couple of turns of the game oh now a factory contract comes out well it's a bit late now isn't it well that was pointless the game is a complete chore when it also comes to the setup and it's a massive table hog to boot this thing takes up so much space on the table that I can't even fit it in the inlet of this gaming table I have to have it here with the leaves on because you've got this massive board and then you've got your player board and then you've got your technology spinley tree thing wherever that's gone it seem to have lost it all of a sudden oh there it is and so you've got this on the side as well as all the pieces and oh yeah did I mention you also need this on the side this thing takes up a ton of space on the board maybe more than it actually needs to so big tables necessity please

excuse the crudity of this model I didn't have time to build it to scale or to paint it but the setup also quite a chore I mean yes it actually explains it well in the book but there's a lot of occasions where you've got to do lots of little separate this and then Shuffle this bit and then mix them together nonsense the action tiles you've got to find all the ones with dots on and then all the ones that don't then separate those out then Shuffle each pile and then mix so many based on player count and then put them into free Stacks it's like oh my Christ and then the contracts you've got to separate the silver and the gold and then shuffle them and then by player count right how many do I need to put in I need to put in this many and this many in and lay them out on the offer okay fine and then neutral buildings you have to basically go through this deck of setup cards and then lift them off and this tells you where you put this building and where you put this nucleum and where you put these buildings it's like for crying out loud you know this game goes on waffles on a lot in terms of getting the setup done the Technologies also feel a little bit like basic they're not that interesting you know normally in a game when I get Technologies to level up and I'm like oh cool I get to unlock a new tech oh new ability yay these ones feel very mediocre there are some that are worth taking and you're like oh yeah that was a cool one of bonus but the ones that give you a Perpetual ability for the game are kind of man in fact especially with the lowlevel ones I've actually found that this is one of the few games where when I get something that says you unlock a tech I'm like oh whatever um I guess this one then and that's not the feeling I want when I unlock cool abilities and texts they just don't feel particularly powerful except for some of the oneoff

bonuses the one-offs are decent but they're one-offs you do it and then it's done was it that powerful you don't really know until much later and some are certainly I think better than others I mean being able to just get eight achievement stars for Tech is pretty good going given that that's your fundamental means of scoring in the game but then there's other ones where it's like ah whenever you light a building you get a coin that's it when I go through all of this nonsense I get one coin at the end that's my brilliant technology it just seems a little bit like lackluster we can use my new invention a pointy Rock tied to a stick now I comment that I like games where they give me a lot of different parts the victory a lot of different ways to play the game try a weird strategy and all that sadly new CLM doesn't give me that though it's a very one note a bit like say barrage in fact this is kind of like the uh thing it borrows from barrage the one note means of doing well in the game this game is all about lighting up the buildings and leveling up this achievement track that is it there is no weird DOD like weird strategy you can do there's no like outof the-box scenario thing that you can do you must do well on this track to win full stop you cannot ignore this track it is the game which means that energizing stuff is the focus point of everything you want to grab a bunch of action tiles and just focus on contracts or something ain't going to score you enough points you want to you know like go down into the expensive prahar area

and build a couple of things there it's not going to be enough you want to build uh stuff off your player board and just like build every single building you've got doesn't matter because if you don't like them up they're not worth points anyway everything about your points is pretty much this which means you can't ignore it and that's a problem because you have four Milestone markers on here which you are scoring for these and honestly the one at the very bottom is meaningless you score so few points for it who the hell cares getting to the very top bit is I've not seen anybody get into this 28 Star Plus bit you get nine bonus points if you can get 40 achievement Stars I've not seen anybody get into the Red Bracket let alone get anywhere close to 40 Stars and if I was somehow able to do that I want more than nine bonus points thank you very much given that you finish the game anywhere between 125 to 200 at times it's like what do I care about nine for all that effort so you're really focusing on these two Milestones here and it's easy enough to like combine it so that I'm doing you know seven times nine times whatever these Milestones are but these are the two things that are going to score you the points which means that this track basically dictates your game plan you can't ignore this you know do I feel like building all my labs and getting texts quick well does the Milestone track say that you should get Labs no it says I should build houses well then you should build houses but I don't want to build houses I want to do this this game but it says build houses but I want to build Labs tough you're not going to score any points I do a night samp much per as I can now we got to find the holy Grill come on it affects replayability because the game

is now playing me at that point I don't get to decide how I play my game of nucleum the board has already decided this I just would have liked to maybe a bit more variance in what you can do let me do some weird strategy let me do something a little bit different you know I mean it doesn't have to be like a CER sandbox Style game but I would certainly like maybe to be able to decide right here's about three or four different paths to Victory I can take this game I feel like doing this path but nope the path is set the path is set your future is written you must adhere to this you can't deviate because you're going to lose feel free to deviate you're allowed to deviate you just won't win no you can't don't even try so nucleum has some pros some cons but people were expecting me to go into this absolutely hating its guts and suffice to say I don't I actually got a decent amount of enjoyment from this game and there's a lot of stuff I do like the game is not as complicated as can be the action tile system is still a highlight and still the focal point of the game and a really good focal point the solo mode is not complicated at that's stupidly complicated compared to other modes and there just there's a decent amount of interaction as well with players not not so much that I'm directly nicking stuff of you but you are getting in each other's way you can collaborate on wellways I'm interested in what they're doing and what action tiles they got left so I'm not playing a solitire game when I have three or four players out which is why I'd rather play

this with three or four players I think those two are The Sweet Spot for player counts so there's a lot of stuff I did enjoy that's not to say the game doesn't have flaws though I do think the technology is a pretty lackluster I do think the contract system needs reworking I'm going to try that house rule see if that improves things for me but yeah the Swingin of this is dictating a lot of people's ability to do well and you know aesthetically it's still not particularly a looker so you know and the setup is a bit of a chore it's not a short game either for what it is you know there are some niggles that I do have but overall I've enjoyed this game if somebody wants to play it at a game night I'll play it I know I will not touch barrage with a barge pole I will more than likely never play Brass again but nuclear I would play that's a step up a big step up considering people expected me to go into this hating its guts you know and granted given its predecessors there was adequate scope for me to hate this guts but no I've enjoyed it overall there are some problems and I was debating between two ratings but I think there's enough decent stuff here for me to give this one a 7 out of 10 it's good it's a good game I will play this I enjoy playing it would I keep it in the collection probably not although to be fair so many other people have this game I don't need to because frankly I think every friend I have has this game so if I want to play it it's going to be available whatever but you know I was contemplating giving it a six but I thought that would be a bit too harsh

because overall I've enjoyed my games of this the niggles that I have have not spoiled the overall enjoyment or maybe maybe come out of a game going that sucked that wasn't really worth it I've liked aspects of this and I do given that this action tile thing is kind of the meat of the game of what you're doing the fact that this is probably my highlight of the game certainly has that impact you know I wish that some of those problems could be fixed maybe in an expansion down the line or just maybe a house rule here or there but overall this is still a decent solid game just not one that I'm going to sing the Praises of it's probably not going to make a top 10 of the year but I still enjoyed it and given as I said hate one dislike the other that's got to be good Praise by itself right so that's it for me on this episode of the broken me if you like what you see then please thumb it up on YouTube and thumb it up on Board Game Geek when it goes live on the sites particularly on Board Game Geek let's go in there follow the link in the description and get a thumb on that page it would mean the world to me of course check out all the other Essen reviews I have done spell book and art Society there's loads I've done and obviously there's more on the way like cut the horror and uh series and path of civilization there's plenty more to come you know check them all out and let me know your thoughts get your comments down below are you a massive fan of this game I'm pretty sure 90% of people watching this video are fans of this game presumably you're all fans of brass and barrage as well although I be curious to know if you hate those ones and yet still like this you know maybe like you come from a background similar to mine that'd be quite interesting to

know but until next time remember regardless of whether you're going to power your buildings with coal or weird green jello it's still only a game bye for now

everyone

Progress saved