Rear Window Review
Transcript
this video is sponsored by game toppers turn your own kitchen or dining room table into a premium portable game solution at a fraction of the cost hey everybody welcome to drive through review 752. today we're going to talk about rear window this is from funko games designed by the folks over at prospero hall now this is a three to five player game obviously based on the alfred hitchcock classic rear window which i have to say is one of my favorite movies of all time so if i have to break this game down if you've not heard of it already it is sort of like a mysterium or dixit or one of those kind of sort of abstract surrealist sort of mental puzzle games but it's definitely its own thing so i don't really want to spoil the movie here because i do recommend folks try to watch it which is it's hard to stream uh these days i'm not actually sure where you can stream it there is a movie on netflix i will say just a quick tangent i can't remember the name of it we watched it a couple of months ago uh the the the main star of the movie is amy adams and it's something rear window i don't remember the name of it but it's very much an homage to not only this movie but a lot of hitchcock movies it's a really good movie i really like it in its own regard and so this is kind of the the plot of this movie is there's a guy who has an injury i don't remember exactly what it was but he's broken his leg and he's a photographer in general like a photojournalist and uh it's kind of what he sees out the
back of his window and across the apartments across the street and so there's a lot of interplay in the movie of if there was a murderer was there a murder is the guy too doped up on his painkillers you know that kind of thing is he imagining things is he got cabin fever you know that kind of stuff so the the movie really plays around with that and then the game kind of attempts to sort of simulate that idea so uh one player will be acting as the director kind of presenting the scenes to the other players who are the watchers so you can see here jimmy stewart plays kind of the main protagonist so the other players are kind of taking on his role or the roles of maybe other people on the apartment across the street and then the director is kind of throwing scenes out there in in a lot of these other games like this the cards are very abstract and this they're a little bit more grounded in a certain level of realism but there is some sort of a level of surrealism or abstraction there to them but not a lot so it's very sort of concrete scenes so you'll be playing these cards to sort of guide them as to who is who and who kind of assists is kind of situated in what kind of role and i'll explain the mechanics there and there may be a murder and there may not be that's going to be kind of randomly determined at the very beginning of the game and then that's also going to dictate the victory condition so i'm explaining a lot up front here but it's good to know this up front before i show you the mechanics because if there is no murder in play the game does not randomly generate a murder then it's a it ends up being a
pure co-op game but you don't know it's a pure co-op game the director can't tell you oh there's no murder so we're going to do it this way although i have some thoughts about that in the review part so in that case it it kind of plays out it's different than mysterium but it plays out like mystery where it's a co-op and you're trying to sort of coach and guide everybody through these sort of you know imagery of the cards to get the right solution so that's one way now if a murder gets shuffled in then you're playing in almost a semi-cooperative way but in very much an adversarial way where one side is going to win either the director or the watchers and what happens is you want the watchers to get almost all of the clues right and get everything right except for the murder if you're the director that's the way the director wins they get almost there but not quite there and they don't get the murder right if you're the watchers you don't have to get everything right but you got to get most of them right and the murder so that prevents you from kind of you know throwing a grenade on the game and then trying to do really bad because in that case if either side ends up doing that because things aren't going their way or whatever then both sides lose although when we've played it i will say this is kind of a spoiler for the review sometimes i think one side might lose more than the other but effectively both sides it hasn't been a problem in our games but we've kind of theory crafted a little bit i'll talk more about that in the review but let's go down look at the mechanics mechanics are actually very simple and i'll kind of come back and tell you about my experiences okay so
here is how the table might look set up for the players here so as the director you're going to have this shield which i'm just going to take away and what you are preventing the players from seeing is kind of the final solution which will be on this board here so you will have different people assigned to different roles and some roles will kind of be a dual purpose i should have grabbed another character here for that and so this will this will be acting as kind of a key for this final solution here so you will see this down here let's zoom in a little bit so the director only will see this and this will be somewhat randomly determined at the start of the game and it could be that one of these instead of having kind of a generic kind of abstract personality role thing they could be the murderer but that's going to be determined by taking one of each of these tiles or certain number of these 12 of these actually shuffling them up and grabbing one of each of them shuffling them up and then distributing them here putting the rest that the director was dealt into this box which is nice to kind of hide it away and then the director will assign from one of the eight different personalities here and this tray is really cool this makes it easy to have all these things out because there's a lot of tokens there and they'll take one of each of these and then assign these and the ones they don't use again will be put in this box for safe keeping hidden away now there's a couple of ways to play it um and that would also recommend so the rules actually recommend not using these
because you can see these actually have sort of two parts with this so this one this gal here she's the athlete you know that well this girl here is maybe looking for romance with this couple or one of the people in this couple or maybe both and so in this case you kind of have to guess the whole combination so this is kind of an advanced mode to add these purple ones and there's several of these and the game recommends not using those and i would say definitely on your first couple games don't use them and i would say at most use one of them i wouldn't i mean if you want to get super hardcore with it you could have you know multiple uses of that but i think that that gets a little bit too difficult so that's the key now if we zoom up up here we'll see we have day one which i've revealed here day two day three day four and that's basically four turns okay so what's going to happen is over the course of four turns the director will have this a hand of eight of these cards and these are going to show you various different scenes right so here you've got kind of a teddy bear there's some money hidden under the bed you've got this person here which is you can see this one's in purple and then this one is gray now there is what kind of a purple person here so this is mr thorwald right and you can see that kind of goes along with him so there are cards that will very clearly indicate a person because it'll kind of match the background color and it'll have them in there whereas you have these gray cards that don't necessarily depict a player or a character but you will have some of them the gray ones that will show a portrait of one of the characters
that you'll see there and then there's all kinds of different things so there's a lot of stuff kind of going on in the cards here there's people having dinner there's a record player there's a cat drinking some milk you've got a turkey with kind of an ominous knife in there some cleaning supplies and some stuff there on a shelf and so on it's got some booze on a shelf there some kind of travel packages here some other things so what the director is going to do on their turn is they're going to play cards to certain places here again they have eight cards or spots for eight places for them to go you can put two of them face down so i can have at most two of them face down otherwise i gotta have to deal with what i've been dealt now at any time you want during the game even when it's not necessarily your turn you can discard one of these three director tokens here discard those and then discard as many cards that are in your hand at the time and then draw that many so you might get a frustrating hand of cards i mean you will and then you're going to want to make use of those throughout the course of the game so once the director has done that then the players and the players also have a screen which they may or may not use though it has kind of a map of some of the things on here all the attributes so the players can discuss and say you know this one and that one without clearly saying you know okay the girl in red with mr thorwald with the dartboard or whatever if they want to kind of try to hide their conversation because maybe they think there's a murder and the director's not being completely forthcoming they can use that so behind that screen or off to the side they will have the rest of these tokens
because remember the director took one of each that was in play and then they will have all the different characters here and then they also have the other murder token and so what they will end up doing is they will start to assign these to this board maybe discussing you know what's what assigning different people to them and so once they fill up this board here with the different combinations of people then the director will tell you okay you've got maybe two out of eight right because if we zoom out here you can see there's sort of eight different ideas you're trying to get the actual person so the person will go in these four spots and then you have the different adjectives and those so this four plus four there's eight and of course let's say there's no murder right you're trying to play co-op then you're trying to get all eight at the end of any one day now miracle of miracles you would get it on the first day i don't think that would ever happen sure it's probably mathematically possible i don't know if it's realistically possible so you'll do that so you do the first thing and say okay let's say we got two because that's probably that's probably even generous for day one because day one can be rough and then you're gonna go over here and you're gonna flip over day two and you're gonna do the same thing because the director has drawn eight new cards uh while the players are discussing and they've been looking through their new hand of cards here and then once the players are done the directors told you how many you got right then you're going to take and play these cards out again discarding any director tokens to draw new cards if you got kind of a crummy hand and then hopefully you've presented some more and hopefully this number has gone up so maybe at the end of day two you've got
five right now so you're getting pretty close so you're going to do that for four days now the only time that the other players the watchers can guess murder is on the fourth day you can't guess that previous to that and you probably wouldn't be able to honestly so hopefully the number goes up and like i said if it's co-op if there's no murder in play which the players won't be guaranteed to to know then you're just all trying to kind of work cooperatively and then get all eight of these correct by the end of the fourth day i have seen seen it where the players got it all correct by the end of the day the third day but i'll explain how that worked out there are also four over here special abilities that are once per game special abilities that the watchers the other players can use and this will kind of help hone in on some of the different clues that were provided out here on the day board i'm not going to get into the details of these the mechanics are very simple so it helps you kind of fine tune what the director was trying to do there is one of these where specifically the director can kind of be a little bit disingenuous let's say and that's this one here with lisa fremont so this one allows the director to point to a specific part of a card and and say this is the important part so you can kind of be misdirecting now this one here is a yes no on a specific you know component whether it's the person or the attribute they cannot lie about that and this other one here is about replacing some other cards that may have been uh
put out there so these are all powers that the players can use once per game so we've talked about the co-op victory which is you know both teams will win if we get all eight of these correct now the director will win if the players get six or seven correct but does not include a correct murder right so if they get seven right but they didn't get the murder right or they didn't think there was a murder or something like that the director wins the watchers will win if they get seven or eight what right and of course they uh select the murder so enough to get everything just at least seven and then they win again the director wins if they get at least six but they don't get the murder right any other condition if they get less than six you know any other combination then both teams will lose and again i've not seen that actually be an issue where somebody kind of like you know throws the game in a certain way to make sure everybody loses because they're not they're not going to lose i think that might happen but also i mean come on you're playing a game about rear window you know and it's it's a fun kind of you know not too heavy classical kind of game you know based on a classic movie i mean don't be a jerk uh but he could come up playing with the wrong person but that's that's really just the game that's it you just play the cards use some of these powers and try to deduce and kind of string along really the key here is you're going to start to see a consistency hopefully through the days of like oh they reused the same kind of imagery here and here and here so you can be able to kind of narrow it down like i said day one you're hardly going to get anything right it's just going to be a little bit random luck a little bit
dictated by the cards but as time goes on over the days you're gonna start to be able to narrow your focus and then get down to the crucial moments of day three and four okay so that was a quick overview of rear window let me walk through my pillars of review here let's see plate time we'll talk about that this says 40 minutes i think that's probably perfect amount of time it's going to take you half hour so not too much longer that it really won't get up to about an hour maybe with your first time rules explanation that might push an hour and that's including the game and the rules but yeah so 40 minutes seems good now player count the box is three to five i've played it with three up to six actually and i think that's fine so you always have one player that's the director playing the cards you need you know you need at least two other people to play the other side you could play with two i know i don't i don't see that would be too much trouble maybe i'll talk about this in more in a minute but maybe you might play just pure co-op with two players and just leave it at that and uh and so there you have that so but up to six it obviously goes over the recommended player count you know you could have up to 10 people as watchers i think honestly that would be too many because it'd just be too too much discussion but i think you can stretch the bounds with that five when we played it with six it worked it worked fine i thought i thought it worked great so i could see you pushing maybe seven eight you know if you really really wanted to um
you know with five it gives everybody kind of a power that they could probably use but the powers are collective so it's not a big deal um so yeah i think you can play at any count really two you can try two up to infinity you know now as far as what is this game like i've already kind of mentioned that it's kind of like mysterium and dixit where you're playing uh and your communication is all driven by cards in this case the imagery is not really abstract or surrealist or anything like that it's a little bit more concrete although it kind of tinges on the surreal just just ever so slightly the kind of juxtaposition of images is i'm sure there's some fancy art term for that but it's it's it's kind of a collage-y you know mindscape of surrealism you know can you kind of think you're seeing something that maybe you aren't seeing or you're not picking out a particular detail which is really a lot of what this movie is about which is really great movie which i recommend everybody go see um but this is a different beast now some of these other games that are like this are like mysterium i've had success with the family and with uh the gamer group this one was not a super success with the family i think it was just a little bit too nuanced now granted we only gave it a couple of plays um and then it just it just didn't really they really just didn't get it i mean they got it but i think it was just a little bit some of the the sort of subtleties in the metagame and stuff were a little bit lost and i think because of that sort of implied adversarial role it just made it that much more difficult i'll get get
that in a second but me having played it now i've only played it as the uh as the director i've not played it as as the watchers but i think i can speak to that experience i've talked to you know my family and my other friends about that experience i have a good feeling of that um the subtleties and some of the nuance of how you can kind of meta the thing i think it requires a couple of plays so for example one of the things you do is you randomly get the attributes but then you can select the people the faces that go with those attributes so you can you can already kind of start to cook the pot a little bit in that regard and start to make suggestions that way um and be able to more easily steer people down certain paths and things like that so there's some subtlety there um there's a consistency with how the cards are are put together like i showed you some of the cards are colored with different background colors which directly match the person and so you can kind of stay away from using those if you can to suggest the attribute when you're trying to suggest the person so there's some interplay there there's some real interesting interplay with the powers and as the director knowing how the players might use that power even if you have a murder in play and how you can try to use that to sort of manipulate them and trick them into thinking one way versus another is another thing so a lot of these kind of things are are pretty subtle and they're going to require a few plays to get into
and so i don't think this is really i was honestly i was a little bit disappointed i'm not that disappointed in it because i thought this would be a good family game but i think it kind of depends on the family i think you know it's not just like an easy call as a casual game i think there is some subtleties here it's like a kind of a gamer's mysterium if i had to throw that stupid phrase on it um you know i think it kind of is though i think it's kind of just a little bit kind of a notch up or something in terms of the subtlety that's all that's all i want to say about that but that being said it's really really cool like when this game really hits and fires on all of its cylinders and the players are second guessing you know you know they might be sure there's a murderer but they're not it's got to be this one be based on some kind of misdirection you did with one of the powers or something you know it could be this one it's got to be one of these two people and you're going back and forth going back and forth and then as the director you're like oh god and then they pick the other one yeah pick that one and pick that one in your head but you don't want to get too excited and and telegraph that that's the one you want them to pick and in a way i mean that's just amazing to me because it fits this idea of not just this movie but like just mystery movies in general where they you know the movies try to effectively you know throw in that twist at the end and that's in the movie-making process that's just got to be a difficult thing to do because you can't just throw something out of left field and everybody goes oh i didn't see that coming i mean you have to be able to see it coming a little bit you know what i mean you can't just throw it out of the
left field and be like haha surprise and be like that doesn't make any sense you know he has to make sense when the twist is revealed and that's kind of what you're doing here and that's just a really really cool thing that is just a really kind of an amazing kind of achievement that this game is the perfect movie to base that kind of idea on that it's really does achieve that now i think there's just i wouldn't call it a barrier but i think this is something you have to play a few times to kind of develop a little bit of a meta game not only with your group but just with you know how everybody understands the game and you know what's kind of possible with it and then you can start to play around you know you get some actual material that you can play around with and you can kind of jerk people's chain a little bit just purely through the imagery of the cards that's just really freaking cool that is just a neat neat experience but you got to put in a little bit of time you're going to have to go through it a little bit now it's not a long game i'm going to throw 30 40 minutes so you can get in and play it and all that stuff so each play has gotten better for me i played it four times each play has gotten better and better and better as i kind of understood what the cards are how the powers can interact little sort of things that you can throw out to misdirect and then some of the things are just going to become a little bit clear so one of the things that i was really hung up on after my first game was i we had an attribute of the athlete and i looked through all the cards and i'm like there's nothing in here that says athlete to me
there's a couple of cards with like a baseball and a mitt like off to the side real tiny and then there's a couple of them that have like trophies on a shelf you're not really sure what the trophies are but you could use those as an athlete so that's kind of good in a way because they have to kind of pick out the subtleties and i like that but i was like in that case we were it was ended up being a co-op game and i was really trying to get him to guess the athlete and there was just no freaking way that they would do it because there was just too many other things that other parts of the image were also tied into so it was very frustrating but again after a couple of plays you kind of see everybody starts to zero in and knows that those things are there like you kind of learn what items are on the card and like i don't even see that there because it's so small you know and so there's that part of it now i will say because of my experience i would say in my opinion and i could be wrong about this i would say 100 percent play this as a pure co-op the first time take the murder tile out say there's no murder we're going to play this co-op you don't have to second-guess me because i think that's just a little bit extra weight on the whole process than that needs to be there for your first game i really think this is this should be in the you know the rules don't say this but i would say you got to do this so play co-op and just try to do it and everybody can kind of see that you can discuss and go okay got it and then we can keep going and then you can start throwing in the murder or or not on purpose i mean you could if you want but i wouldn't obviously tell anybody because that kind of ruins it so but after that you just say okay now there could be a murder in play and you know you got to get somebody right and the
murder so i would say you really really got to do that and definitely the blue tiles like i showed you in the walkthrough the rules even say don't put those in right away and i would say don't put those in for a couple of games because if you got like the murder and that that's it it kind of swings the difficulty a little bit too much towards the director and being in favor of the director winning in that case uh of course if there's no murder get shuffled in then it's just you know difficult everybody but i would say yes you know don't be shy about kind of slowly stepping into the game because i think it's important for people to understand the metagame with this one especially so if there's any kind of knock on it i would say there's a meta here and you know in today's sort of climate i don't know this is a thing that's posted online it's like people play games once and you know throw them away or whatever don't get this game if that's the kind of thing you're going to do this one's staying in the collection you know we'll maybe talk about at the end of the year we'll see um but this is one that i'll definitely hang on to at least for a while longer because i think there's really a lot to explore and i kind of want to play as a watcher and not just to play as a watcher i don't think i'll really get anything new out of it but i want to give other people the chance to play as the director because i think that's really really fun i had a great time with it and i enjoyed seeing people go back and forth and all that stuff so i really recommend this it component-wise it's really cool i think it's pretty cheap i think it was like 35 or 40 bucks on at target or amazon even has this tray and stuff which makes things really easy to organize because there's you know there's a lot of pieces and they
all kind of look the same and probably easy to mix together so this is nice there's little spots for that little hidden chest in here everything fits in here really good so it's a great like production all around uh you know and so and i'm glad it was this movie because i've this made me like make myself try it more since the first game honestly i was like this is just not what doing it but then i'm like they picked this movie for a reason like this is not like a popular movie in 20 000 2022 like you know this is not i'm like this who pulled this thing out you know of the ether and said let's make a movie about this somewhat obscure hitchcock movie and i was you know which i love but yeah so it made me try it again so i don't think you need to know last thought you don't need to know the movie at all um if a lot of that stuff kind of made sense of what i talked about with the whole you know projection of images and mystery and all that stuff if you like that kind of thing you don't even know anything about the movie this will be right up your alley so i definitely highly recommend this again just small cabinet give it some place get everybody kind of into it and then i think you'll have a great time thanks
you