We're Disappointed in You, Expeditions!: An Expeditions Review
Transcript
this game is the background character in an anime the unforgettable the forgettable extra that just exists yeah and you're like have I seen that before I'm not sure maybe what's up everybody welcome back to the channel if you are new here I'm Mike and I'm Kim and you're watching tabletop Turtle yes and today we are reviewing Scythe uh and today we're reviewing guys and today we're reviewing Expeditions the spiritual successor to sight exactly yeah Expedition is a car driven engine building game that plays one to five players designed by Jamie stagmire and published by stonemeyer games in Expeditions players spend the game moving their Max across a variety of different hexes to collect resources acquire upgrades complete quests and various other tasks all to gain as much wealth by the end of the game as possible players are mildly encouraged to explore reveal new locations and reveal New Harvest actions but HD revealed location will contain corruption which essentially acts as the bad things you encounter in these areas but don't worry you can spend the two generic resources you acquire in the game to remove the numbered tiles well sorry what I meant to say was that you use your cunning and guile to Vanquish the vile corruption that lights this ravaged Earth the player who first completes four objectives initiates the end of the game at the end of the game Hoover has the most money is the winner so what did you think about the theme of the game one thing that's the theme all right good that's true let's moving on let's get to mechanics all the actions don't feel representative of some kind of action you would take if you were
actually doing exhibition or Adventure just it's not strong it's advertised as a sort of sequel to scythe and you know like other viewers have probably pointed out it has nothing to do with Scythe whatsoever they are sure but beyond that almost nothing this game is it's so such a shame because it's the artist so beautiful but this game is Just devoid of theme and it most certainly doesn't capture the feeling of an expedition I don't know what he thinks an expedition is but this ain't it this ain't it it's saying it I maybe that's kind of like our opinion on it too it's like it doesn't have that same kind of highs and lows you know we kind of compare everything to kind of like a like a movie or a story right where you have like the lull you had your main goal like Stone upon you that's your kind of like white even going on this expedition in the first place and then to achieve it it's like you go up this like uphill down like an expedition should be like there's a bunch of winding paths and like dangerous things you encounter and obstacles you have to overcome this game is like it's like it's like a walk down a dirt road in a corn field and every path you choose just feels exactly the same as the path you were on it doesn't matter what time it's over is it doesn't matter at all it's yeah I guess no no it doesn't and there's no like there's no eminent there's no threat to revealing a new towel like part of the excitement of exploration is the excitement that you don't really know what's gonna happen that's the point of exploration you want to reveal a tile you you know what's going to be there more or less and the threat the threat the threat are numbered cubes
they're just numbered boxes that's the threat okay you can't really get like a little monster coming and attacking you okay but a lot of foods of our neck has a monster that gets revealed the monster can be completely different you don't know what it's going to be and you don't know if you were prepared for that monster or if you're not prepared for that monster so you there's dire consequences for different countries no we love that game oh I know I'm just saying that like that's that game but but there are some the field of Adventure is all I'm comparison exactly and this that we'll get into this when we talk more about the gameplay and certain areas that we liking to like for this game but like you mentioned there isn't that excitement and I think that comes from there isn't any real highs and real lows in this game no everything kind of feels like you know you're just like it's even Keel it's thematically boring as hell and even that like when you explore and you go to a new land you flip that land tile over because you only have three actions in the game typically you'll be forming you typically actually it's two move play gather a lot of times you'll be moving to an area yeah right there's one of your actions and you'll be playing a card so you don't really care what the land is underneath you because if it's something you don't want you just you can just move again and gather some and gather somewhere else nothing matters it doesn't matter well that nothing matters but it's fun it's I kind of get the idea that you know you don't have to kind of utilize what's on that tile you can just move the child and play a card that's nothing no relevance to the time at all yeah but it helps like mitigate like the luck based aspect of like which tile you are you're
gonna play the card you can still play at the same time it just makes it like less exciting I wish I had more like action specific to the type of environment I don't know what they call it tile stages but there is nothing unique about where you are no and on the map versus things you can't do I missed the part in every great adventure story where the primary purpose of the adventure was collecting tiny little cardboard exploration tokens for no for almost no reason oh sorry no not no reason if you get five of them you can have Glory but don't worry you can also have seven workers and then it performs the same function but there's so many ways to complete these like to put your star only one of the four main objectives that it doesn't feel like any of them is particularly special to put an objective child down you don't have to go back to Basecamp there is no like there is no thematic action that makes sense it's just you just find a tile with a star on it to put a star down and then you're going to get a reward for that you complete 15. great that's all that's it it is it doesn't feel very satisfying so we can cover some pros because there are there are there are mechanisms in here that are very well yeah that's the part that's strong with the skin the Cardinal plays I mean that's the game is just a card game at it's hard that's all it is that it's hard all it is good card game it's decent it's a decent card game you know you play a card uh you act use a worker to activate the special ability underneath that played card so you get even more bonuses from it and then hopefully you're you're chaining cards with other cards maybe the card that you play uh lets you activate the card to
the left of the card you just played that's like good cards that was a good cards yeah and some of that stuff's it's enjoyable but the card play it's not enough to carry the game okay the quests there's numbers on these quests okay and there's numbers on the tiles and you have to go to the tile that corresponds to the number on the quest which is the question which is like the Matic ish because like the art on the sweater matches where you are on the location it does yeah it does that's the end of the map that's it that's it there's no other reason that you know as to why you're going to the weird Forest to rescue attractions it's like yeah it's kind of there but the the you know previously Scythe had like a tiny little story would give you and you could choose an option which is fun and I don't think it bogged down yeah you don't see it in a lot of games include in this game and they expect what do you call it the spiritual successor yeah the core to your aim yeah no it definitely felt like lackluster so many people don't like it we liked it it just feel like there was no connection in quests in regards to where you go what you do nothing nothing makes more sense to repairing a damaged Mech than spending one Brawn okay boom Netflix I spent a Brawn yeah requests empty Mill repairing next don't involve any brains at all you don't need any Engineers you just need someone that has some biceps across the board I really like the
meteorites the items the items I like that the bonus actions were unique and like interesting they sometimes are really interesting it's pretty op like this one's like whenever you gain a map you make an additional brain and rearrange your location's corruption so like if you you know didn't have all the blue but yet orange things that it's useful it's really useful the part I'm unhappy about is once you upgrade your item once you slide the card and you perform the upgrade action you slide the card underneath your thing there is no real bonus all you get to do is use that um ability without spending it work permanently but normally like as you're playing the game quite a few parts you you normally already have a worker on that item yeah so there's no bonus to upgrading it at least with the meteorites okay when you okay so when you place a worker on the bottom of the card you get you get that ability right cool um but when you upgrade it's just you don't have to spend the worker it's exactly like you said but at least with the meteorite it's like a whole new ability that you unlock that's the whole point yeah that's relationship to the to the ability okay so good card play I guess there's our positive now back to the negative there are too many there are too many boring actions in this game they're actually just a hater no I'm not no I'm not I like sight I like every other Jamie stegmar game that at least at least I know I've played two top three games yeah tapestry great tapestry um yeah uh Scythe great good culture great these are all breakings I love my wine
ranking yeah that's right but this is not a great game this is a mediocre game supporting action the actions are boring like when you make a turn nothing is thrilling like you might get the odd you get you get some combos off and that's kind of fun but whatever you're going whatever you're doing it just it I'm just not interested in it okay okay for example to complete a glory point right to get a glory point on the board you've had to let's say for example collected seven of the blight tokens cool but at some point I collect those seven blight tokens and I feel that sense of accomplishment that a sense of accomplishment it's there I'm like yeah I did it I got the seven blight tokens oh but now I have to go to this spot of the board where I have to actually claim the glory for this thing that I did and this and I might do that like two turns later and I don't care I don't care it's just it's bookkeeping I'm just doing bookkeeping I've done the Great quest I've accomplished a deed now it's time for me to go to this one random spot on the board and and I don't Journal it he's a millennial he needs an immediate satisfaction kind of thing no you're not saying you get that but but I don't love it I don't hate the fact that you have to go to claim your glory once you claim that Glory you put your star down there is no instant reward so it doesn't feel like a sense of urgency to complete that quickly it's one of those things are like I'll come I like the last game I played I think I accomplished like four like five different endgame objectives yeah I only have one star guy so like I'll do it later well there is a bonus yeah your two main cards your your main person and then your pet that
accompanies you the two character Parts the more stars you have you you can get only after two stars yeah oh yeah it is only up to two so again like it's only your character card some of the other cards collecting so not your request not your item either it's only character cards so at most games I had like 10 cards sitting out here at one point in time those two cards are not being played very often because the other you know um item cards me right cards had better bonuses to solve and whatever the other word is Vanquish I think to remove those tokens sometimes right they have better abilities so I wasn't using those character pads very often so I I didn't feel compelled to put my start on because there is no for me it's like a waste of an action yeah right and so I don't speaking of wasted actions great being a wasted actions the refresh action I hate refresh actions I hate refresh actions I I hate being a worker dating worker actions there's a reason you can make everything fun well ings of elderville just steal what they did in this game just just stealing dear developers steal what they do in this game for all your games when you refresh and dwellings of elderville you're still making interesting choices that go beyond simply choosing to refresh take your back and then you get to choose what do you want to put on the cards and you get like an extra layer of actions that you get to perform do steal from this I don't like refresh actions and in this game like every game I played all of them I would actively do
my best not to refresh yeah I just I understand the Strategic advantage of refreshing sometimes because it because I get the joy of being like oh now I get to go and do all three actions hurray best part and Kim had mentioned earlier about um the the number of stars on the board and I think I I think there are okay full disclosure we played about like a like a dozen a dozen games hell yeah probably 10 but 10 or 12. but yeah we have we feel like there might be some balance issues they were wrong I don't know but it certainly feels that way I feel is unfair yeah okay so let's okay let's start to me going first typically in a board game when you go first there is I know
it is oh Mike goes first in every single freaking game we ever played and majority of the time I don't mind it's fine it's whatever you know he's selfish for school first no it's just a good way to teach the game typically it's a good way to teach a game because you can be like look what I'm doing I'm doing this because this this but but anyway it doesn't matter I don't think so but it's okay point is normally when you go second or third of course whatever it is you get some kind of bonus like a small incentive just all like compensation for going Lots right not having the first picket every turn there's none absolutely none of this game no none at all you get nothing you get nothing it sucks and not only do you not get anything okay so okay okay so there's two spots in the early game where there are workers and you can you can get those workers are really important very really important cards are important yeah but workers are super important if you're playing with two players you're fine because it's like you go to the white worker spot and I go to this one always yeah but if you're playing with five players and that and you're the last player that that sucks that sucks because now it's like well okay I guess I should probably just go and explore get something I want and then what would you explore is something you don't really need like oh maybe you go and you explore and you get the one that lets you refresh out all your cards and didn't even spend a card but there's no advantage to going last and not only that not only that but this game is is I think Scythe does this too where if you go first and you end the
game you get one more turn which means so everyone gets people don't get equal turns people don't get equal turns in this game yeah whoever triggers the ending um everybody gets one more turn but it to me makes more sensitive like you know there's one more round for everybody versus if you're the first player like you said stupid that's stupid yeah so why why the the turns are you know your turn and what you do in the game is the whole point of the game the whole part of the game is to have fun and if one player just has more turns than the other players that's that's not fun that's that's fine it just feels unfair right it doesn't necessarily take away the fun but it definitely feels like rare which then if you're not leading or winning the game it definitely ruins yeah yeah anything a lot of unfair there's a lot of unfair errors in this game there's tons of luck in this game yeah and unfairness the cards there are cards that are just like so much better than other cards but they're so similar and these are both you're not gonna see them so it's one's repair damage Mac and they want to save a lost Lumberjack okay they're both Quest cards okay both Quest cards now one of them the one that's better does have one that requires a more advanced worker it's the purple worker but they're not that hard to come by at all so in the lower the one I would call a lower tier card you gain a brain and then you get to rescue a car okay rescue a card is taking the cards from your played action in your unplayed action so it's kind of refreshing without using the refresh packs exactly you put it in your hand which is another
stupid game but that's that's fine but the other car the other one okay okay is you rescue all of your cards all other cards and when you rescue all those cards which could be like six or seven of them if if you get a if you rescue at least three of them you get three dollars that's three victory points three victory points Rescue all your cards versus one intellect and rescue one card it doesn't feel very smart and it's the same classification of card maybe it's because they expect to be dumb until you give you one green yeah where you can look at some cards like that is significantly better than this car yeah and in a card game where there's no okay sometimes in card games you have like a mechanic where let's say Through the Ages where it's way off to the right so if you really want that new amazing car that just appeared you pay for it you pay for the nose for it so if that card just happens to appear and it's the end of your turn you don't use but you're not gonna get it you're not gonna get it and then on your turn I'm sure a bunch of crappy cards will be there don't worry yep online I mean I know that's kind of the nature of card games but usually you try to do something to mitigate that like maybe the Lesser cards provide more of something else picture this four player game you've done a bunch of exploration but not everything and you've only revealed two maybe three most spots uh where you can claim your your glory and it comes to the end of the game okay you could have players just sitting on those Glory spots so now you have a player who can't get to those Glory spots they can't claim victory points and there's
nothing you can do there's nothing you can do about that town hall yeah space hog yeah I'll just sit on tile sometimes I mean as much as you can because you have to move eventually but that's irritating that's so irritating so yeah one of the things we would definitely say is don't bother playing this with one or two players I think I'd say three three the max is Comfortably can go happily have to leave it go after three it's just feels really unfair yeah adding more players adds nothing it adds nothing to this game it just when you add more players to this game it just feels like Costco on a Saturday morning that's that's what adding more players in this game feels like the only part that I think could be better with more players is that you go through More Cows quicker right because you're not able to explore myself exactly able to move past unexplored tiles so you do go through tasks when you want more things open up and cards I guess you'd see more cards and the and they open up earlier in the game so there's more you can plan a little differently but the number of types of actions don't change number of actions don't really change no so it's not really any better nope and in terms of player interaction there's not it's yeah sorry it sucks I I you have this giant Mech you need body uh you're just lately you have this giant Mac and you just kind of inconveniently get in the way of people that's what your Mech does it's just obedience to other players so the thing that angers me about this game is that I would love it if it was a game that I really loved obviously obviously but I'd also kind of love if it was a game that I just freaking hated I went a little
bit of this game just instilled some sort of emotion in me at all but it doesn't and I think because it doesn't that's what makes me angry this game is just so dripping in mediocracy it just feels so bloody average a year from now I don't think you remember you won't remember this game you will remember this game it'll be one of those games that sits on your shelf in a year or two from now and then you're like oh I forgot I owned that game I thought it was Scythe when I walked past it because the Arts is saying you're like and then you're like why do I own this game it's just so mediocre and and that's why I think I give it I want to give it a five but I don't think that's fair because some of the card play is pretty decent no the five is based on what you have played and what you enjoy right so five two to five to you for sure I think though I'd probably give it a six five point five to six let's say six I'll say six I would say it's a five to me yeah it's a five to me because it's a game that I I don't know I feel like like I said it's mediocre it's not great so I definitely don't dislike it but it's just disappointing and not satisfying yeah to play so for me it's a five because it's a possible game to play and there are some enjoyable mechanisms but it's not an enjoyable enjoyable game in a hole yeah so yeah that's about it you know I look forward to the future comments that'll let us know how we're wrong and it'll be a little dissertation to be right I don't mind I don't mind if
you tell me why exactly like you love it and you know there's some areas of the game is so unique and it I something of unfortunate for us to all agree on as well is that everyone protests different areas of different games exactly or that is for you enjoyability I don't love mediocrity and some you know someone like I really love no play attracted you gotta love average big variety of cards and that's them it's like gold standard of a good game for me those are not the most important things so yeah sorry stonemeyer Bros you know um Sun Jamie Sun you can do better you have you've done this yeah yeah he's he's like my son he's playing a little league baseball game and I'm so used to hitting him and just smacking home runs and all of a sudden it's like comes home and we're like yeah he just gets to First and you're like yes that's good
and then he'll be left stunned and then you only get you know like I don't know enough about baseball to say but like home runs from now on yeah if you watch this video which you're comfortable in anyway we do like most of the other games we just think this game yeah that's it bye thanks for watching Everybody bye bye see you the next one