Skip to main content
Loading video...

Stonemaier Spotlight: Ambassadors deep dive into CHARTERSTONE

Transcript 35:13

hello everyone and welcome to the mill today we have our second in our Stone wire Spotlight line of videos and we are doing Charter Stone so with us today Molly's joining me for this one and we also have two more ston me ambassadors who you might know and I'm going to let Garrett and Connie kind of introduce themselves and where they fit in with ston me so Garrett you want to start us off sure I'm Garrett uh St my Ambassador um I've been an ambassador for about three years now uh my wife Ally and I do a lot of play testing for ston Meer were're pretty heavily involved in the Discord and um yeah when Carol Molly put out the call for people looking to talk about specific games I thought charterstone would be a fun one to talk about and my name is Connie vman I don't actually think I'm an ambassador but I'm an honorary Ambassador at this point if nothing else um folks probably know me from as the designer of apiary and worms span and I would really excited to talk about charterstone it was actually um one of the big Inspirations for the bump mechanism in aary so it's a game that's very near and dear to my heart I think being a ston designer kind of Ambassador thing so it's like the Ambassador celebrity thing like we have a stone me celebrity Trump s

the hierarchy she's at the top definitely all right so both Garett and Connie wanted to help us out with Charter Stone as we do kind of more of a deep dive into it we'll start with some nons spoilery kind of discussion about it and then we'll do we'll let you know when we're getting into spoilers so I'm going to try to let Garrett and Connie do a lot of the talking here because you hear Molly and I all the time but all right you guys remember I kind of took care of the one question of you know why did you choose charstone is there any other kind of reason you want to expand on why you this would be the game you'd want to talk about from Stone Meer con can go first yeah absolutely so I can I can talk about that a little bit I think that you know chartis Stone was was very formative to me as I said I was kind of starting to design apiary at the same time and that kind of bump mechanism in Charter ston if you're not familiar it's basically the idea it's a worker placement game but you put workers on a space and then the space is never blocked you know you put a worker down and you can basically bump either your own worker or somebody else's worker back to them and it creates a very different Dynamic um in a worker placement game obviously Euphoria I used that mechanism before um but this was sort of the game for me that I kind of you know saw that game and really fell in love with the mechanism um I'll say too that there's something about charterstone that I really enjoyed as well because it was such a simple game and it was so kind of easy to wrap your head around you know what you were trying to do but you also sort of felt

at the end of every game like man I could have timed that better I could have done something a little bit better you know it's kind of this game where you can really kind of see the efficiencies kind of playing out in front of you and so you kind of always get the sense of like oh man let me just try it again and see if I can just do it a little bit better um a little bit better which I think obviously plays really well into the Legacy format yeah and for me um this was a pandemic game uh we were able to get family together pretty regularly to play through it and it just it has a very like lasting impact probably because of the social aspect that we had of getting the family together during the pandemic but we just had a blast playing it it's just a very like friendly welcoming even though it's a competitive game um yeah it's it's difficult to put into words um but I definitely we just found ourselves smiling while playing this you know no matter what was going on and um another reason is because it's one of the games that I've played the most I've played at least four campaigns of it so that right there is at least 48 games is probably one of my most played ston Meer games by that fact um so that was another reason I thought it'd be a good good one to chat about cat on my left he's like roaring at me silently he's agreeing with you what about you Carol we should briefly share our thoughts because Carol and I won't necessarily both be in all of these but we both wanted to be here for Charter Stone yeah as G mentioned he he was he played it four times and one of those times was actually online async with

Molly I and a few other people so yeah this was one where uh this was the first Legacy game I actually completely finished we were playing this at the same time as pandemic season one and this was the first one we finished and I had been in board gaming for like three months and it blew my mind away at that time and then we played it online and will get to the kind of the differences probably between that between the two of them but very different experiences and yeah is that First Legacy game for me mhm for me why I wanted to be here is we said we'll get into it later but I've played through this twice and had completely different experiences and it's just a very interesting game in that regard I've never had a real time in async be so different but also Carol and I Bond over loving pretty much any campaign game so how could we not geek out over the stone Meer campaign game yes all right uh so Connie you touched on this a decent amount already but I'll kind of throw it out there for anyone uh what stood out to you in regards to char Stone's design I think a lot lot of us we've played a decent amount of campaign in Legacy games so I know County already mentioned kind of that bumping mechanism and its inspiration but Garrett M or just kind of is there anything else that really stood out to you in regards to it being a legacy game

and design of it that was memorable or you think really makes it stand out so I think um for my experience is the the fact that you have your own Charter that you're building along with the other players uh and there's a spoilery mechanism that we'll talk about in the I guess latter half of the video of why but I found myself like really focusing on just my Charter um and watching other players and their strategies develop around their Charters or other players Charters and so it was just interesting seeing that yeah exactly the various strategies that people were developing as they were building their their Town um and so that it was just very memorable for us because it's something that we're building that we'll think back on and be like I remember exactly what I did in my town I know exactly what my strategy was how it worked out for me how it didn't work out for me um so yeah I guess just like the building aspect of it was very memorable I really enjoy the sense of identity in it you pick your Charter it's tied to a resource which everyone interacts with that resource but it does kind of feel like yours the whole game and you get to name your Charter and everyone interacts with it but it's yours still you pick the buildings in it and um yeah it just feels really good to have your own chunk of the board and really feel like it's yours I do think there's something that's very cozy about tedar Stone I think this um both carolly and Garrett

touched on that a little bit that it's you know I think a lot of these Legacy games are either Cooperative games or they're you know a lot more Cutthroat and I think this one sort of falls into um a very nice kind of intermediate space where again you are competing with other people but you also have the sort of portion of the board that's your own that you're building up that you're making kind of your own and you're interacting with other players but it's often times I mean you might be you know racing toward a goal or you're trying to do more than they do more efficiently than they do but you're not really undercutting people or anything like that and so I do think it's a very it's a very good pandemic game um but it's also again just kind of a very very very positive experience yeah and even the endgame scoring is very friendly I mean with everyone can kind of get the final objective together I mean there are a couple exceptions to that but for the most part you can all share a victory um no matter what happens you're earning those other points for other reasons and that we can talk about but that it's a very friendly scoring game as well one thing I wanted to specifically call out a little bit is the kind of race element in the game um in the sense that games can go very long or very short depending on how the players are playing and I think that's always I think player controlled endgame conditions are always very interesting so you know in charterstone basically you take certain actions that kind of Advance This Time Track and then after a certain number of those actions have been taken over the course of the game the game ends and I I always think that that was very interesting from a player standpoint because you're sort of looking at this tracker and you're like okay I might get three more turns I might get four more turns I might get five more turns you

know how do I kind of play around that and sort of set myself up depending you know so I'm basically in a good situation regardless and I think that that was sort of a for me that was always a very fun puzzle so every single time we play it I'm like all right how much can I get done this game you know how much can I like squeak out it before that game in trigger hits so yeah I remember one of my strategies was to like get a lot of points quickly and then my I kind of ran out of steam and I had other players at the table that had sort of like long-term goals and I knew the longer the game lasted they were going to either catch up or surpass so then it became a race of like I need to get rid of these influence so that I can end the game quick because the longer goes on they're gonna you know so yeah that's a really interesting point that's the speed of the game is part of your strategy too where you're trying to like right absolutely and you as an individual player in probably less in a five player campaign than in a smaller campaign but you know you as an individual player can really have a lot of impact on that and you can you know make the game much much shorter if you want to which I think is is really interesting and because of that you keep an eye on the other players more than like a multiplayer solitire game if someone's cranking through it you got to start changing your strategy I will say I found a lot harder to track yes online whereas my in-person game it was just my husband and I didn't put the atomas in as that was so new to gaming it was just the two of of us so could plan a little bit more yeah and then yeah I found in the asnc games I was not keeping track of people and it was nice to have that timer still up

there but it was a very different experience it was yeah I played a six player in person where we played two games a night and it was totally different than async where our whole campaign took was it two years a year and a half it was yeah it was um I much more enjoy it in a real time sense if if that wasn't clear it was um I would still think the app is great and if you set up times to play in real time online it'd be a very similar experience to the board not still not quite as good because you can't name everything and something about Legacy game with ripping things and putting stickers on it's just special just I think there something that's that name of so many things in charterstone really gives you that feeling of ownership and just like fun for something so simple well I know we had a couple of players who would name a lot of the the cards and characters pretty goofy things and you know without getting into too many spoil spoilers a lot of those cards do end up getting passed from player to player over the course of the the campaign um and so every time you see you're like oh that's that's that guy again like it's the guy with the with the name and stuff like that so I think it just added a lot of a lot of characters so I haven't actually played um I have the app um but I haven't played an async campaign or anything like that my plays have Charter start up been in person um so I can't really speak to that element but it does seem like it would definitely lose something

yeah you don't I don't think you name anything and except maybe your land initially oh we lost your audio Garrett can you hear me yep yep you're good sorry yeah I was saying I think that you name your Charter but other than that maybe the town also yeah C like the physical board G name feels like everything yeah and there's also like multiple menus to see like to track everything in terms of like um I forget what it's called the um where you're like boasting about things you know with the hand I forget what that's called oh yeah yeah uh but like that's a separate menu and then like the influence track is I think it's a separate menu and then you kind of have to like click and drag around the board and zoom in and zoom out to see it's very hard to keep track of everything for sure so that I was kind of like I said early I just kind of like checked out at when it was my turn I was just like what thing is going to give me the most points click and all right see you guys tomorrow um but yeah all right um I'd say Pro probably before we get into our spoilery section one thing I think might be helpful is do you have any tips for people who are either going to be teaching charterstone or pting people know like hey if you like these kinds of games this one might be for you yeah I have a couple of thoughts and

one is um I think if you like fairly straightforward worker placement games this is definitely one to check out especially if you think you have the the time and the the group stability for a 12 game campaign um you know I think this starts out being very simple um and I think it it does certainly get more complex over the course of the campaign but it never never gets like overwhelmingly complicated or anything like that and so I think it's a very kind of good you know lower end of midweight um gaming experience I do have one tip though and this is a bit of an odd one and we can talk about it a little bit more in the spoiler section but I would say if you're playing with less than the full complement of six players I actually would recommend excluding the blue faction and playing with the others um again talk about why in the spoiler section but if you're totally new to charterstone that's just kind of a recommendation that I would take doesn't it's not that I think that that Charter is is broken in any way but I think it makes the game play a little bit less interesting than playing without it yeah I I don't have any teaching tips I think the game onboards really well um most Legacy games too um and and people learn games differently I I'm Rodney's video was like perfect for our group we watch we all watched that we were all ready to go um but I think the rule book is just a very good it onboards you very well especially because you're the first game you're already like peeling stickers and putting them in the book and it it just you're interacting with the rule book as part of the game so I I think it's a very easy teach

personally sense yeah I would definitely say if people are looking for a competitive Legacy game I know initially there weren't a lot of those out there it's gotten better But Connie you also mentioned earlier this one's almost more friendly competitive like you're really not going to be Cutthroat so I would definitely say people who want a legacy experience who can have a group that comes together consistently and they really don't want to you know be too backstabby or political they are then they might want to go to King's dilemma but this is yeah I said it kind of has that cozy feeling I think some I think uh the art goes with that as well like it's happy Art um any other final comments that are not spoilery for either memorable moments likes critiques um anything else that would be non spoilery in that realm before we move over to the spoiler section let's get to the spoilers I'm excited to talk about some spoilers yeah I think we're ready I'm already trying not to mess up so we may as well get to the easier half of the video all right so uh Molly will put a big spoiler thing up right now when she goes and she edits and we are going full on spoiler section so if you don't want to know anything about the campaign just

stop watching right now and join us on the next STM Spotlight yep here we go all right spoiler section hold on you guys want to start with yep guys want to start with memorable moments now that you can uh say whatever you want let me let me think about it for a second yeah start with the big question um was starting off with the spoiler I can get us going with them one of my favorite things about this game was it really felt like you get loot like it really feels like when you're opening the crates stuff is just pouring out and it's your stuff and you don't necessarily get to keep it all but you get first dibs on it and it's just really fun and things keep coming new items minions personas and I just think that's all done really well it all feels special I don't remember ever opening anything and being like Oh that one was a dad yeah they freak out the first time they realized they weren't going to get to keep all their cards oh yeah building yep yep well and then I do think that's and that's actually one of I think the most interesting things about the game is that all of because so many of the cards get returned um to the General Supply at the end of every game your Charters get really mixed up um so you know I might be the Green Charter and then all of a sudden I open a crate from the black line or something like that and so all of a sudden I have this kind of mix of Charters and I think that's creates some

really kind of interesting moments it gives a lot of the charters um know a lot of uniqueness um I do remember in particular being like outraged the first time somebody opened a minion I was like where's my minion um sorry yeah I was the Green in my first in my first uh campaign and our campaign green was the last to get their minion so you're waiting if you're excited about it you're oh yeah I was black and the ghost was the first one that came out but I remember when when the robots came out the ones that you can take a card directly from the draw I was like I built my entire strategy around that and then once people realized it they they realized kind of how I don't know if it was power but it felt powerful and when you can like keep you can keep like one minion at the end of the game or you know in your you can build up to keep more stuff you know that pool was dwindling because we were playing five out of six players and that was that was a memorable moment just like the robot Synergy that I had with like I had items going popping off constantly I had the thing the treasure that gave you like you can you could take this action without paying the cost or whatever I mean it was just items I think I think actually one of our biggest memorable moments was actually the candle um so oh yeah anyone who's listening who hasn't played the game um should probably stop but I mean you know there's there's one game that's basically played on a timer with a sort of a little felight candle I still think it was really funny this was actually before I even played turst myself but I was watching a campaign and um I was just looked over it everyone was being

really frantic except for one guy one guy was just taking his time and relaxing and he wasn't you know was not concerned about the candle at all and why well he's an Episcopal priest and then at the end of the game everyone's like why weren't you rushed and he's like oh those things burn for like hours and so I just thought it was so funny that everyone else was playing speed Charter Stone and he was just like laxidasical taking his move and that's just I wasn't even in that game and it was still like one of my like really memorable moments so that like really stressed us out in our game and it got to the point where like everybody was just like let's just it's distracting us let just blow it out nobody take the penalty let's just it was like very distracting and like uh stressful for us and then in the digital version I don't even think it was implement I wasn't sure how it was implemented like it like if you took I think ail then oh yeah it out was like yeah I think that happens in the game the physical version too that was in the physical version as well cuz I remember in one of my campaigns I I specifically did that to blow the candle out I can't remember why I don't remember what the specific mechanism was but there was some reason why I thought it was worth it to do it and take the penalty um but yeah that is how how it works in the in the you know physical yeah that was it like you couldn't actually just physically blow it out online yeah yeah that was one of those pieces was such a moment to open it and be like there's a candle in this box what is yeah I don't I don't think there's any other game that has that component I mean no it was czy I will

say in terms of the Peril tokens that's one thing that I preferred on the digital implementation maybe the only thing I preferred because I felt it was a very tedious process to like set up Peril at the started the game and those tokens were like really small and we were just making sure we had all of them and shuffling them up finding like you know like a bag or something but outside of that like definitely physical version yeah but I wanted to come back and talk about the minions a little bit because this was why in the in the spoiler section before or in the pre spoiler section I mentioned the blue Charter in particular um I found that for us at least we played without the blue Charter and so the robots came into the game really really late and I think that was a more fun campaign um and I know Garrett talked about specifically about building out the robots specifically um but it seems like there's so many buildings in the game that are specifically for trying to draw different types of cards um you know you can draw a crate or draw an assistant or Draw whatever I don't remember what all the the types of cards were as soon as you get the robots you basically place a robot and then you can pick up any kind of card you want and so it seemed like it kind of made a it kind of shrink the board in a way I mean it took out a lot of the the building spots that I think were otherwise perhaps a little bit more interesting so I don't think it's necessarily too strong but it just for me at least it was a little bit less interesting once the robots came into play but maybe it would have felt differently if I had been the one that unlocked them and had you know a robot Empire for a little while before everyone else got got access to them yeah I've always been trying to like compare sort of the power of the minions compared you know just not like mathing

it out but just like how they feel and I always felt like the cat was a trap because it's the 1 VP and I always like it seems good at first it's a cat second like obviously amazing um but I don't know I just felt like after a while I was like this isn't going to work out and then there was one that does the coin I forget which one that is the butler yeah the Butler and so I just found myself like I guess realizing or thinking that the robot was the way to go as you said because it makes things so much easier for your strategy particularly with like the buildings that have like specific card uh costs so but my strategy was built around items which is like use any resources basically to like get points and I know when I played um a second campaign I think I intentionally gave myself purple um with the suspicion that perhaps that is a slightly weaker Charter than some of the others you know every Charter kind of has their own Specialties we've been talking about and the the purple Charter is Victory point so it's just it's not only the cats but a lot of the buildings are like you get a resource and points instead of a resource and coins or two resources or something like that so it always felt like a a slightly weaker Charter um you know I ended up winning with that Charter as well but I also had more experience than the other people around me so I think if it's weaker I don't think it's you know drastically weaker or anything like that but I did yeah so in your games did you no I was just gonna say in in in your games did you have people sort of gravitate like because once you open the

the crates all the cards are mixed in and they go out to the board did you find people sort of gravitating towards their own Charter colors to build out their Charters or were people doing a mix and saying oh like at that purple building I want the points in my Charter to kind of like negate maybe the power of the strategy around the purple Charter itself yeah I mean I think that for us at least there was definitely a certain amount of like people trying to grab their own stuff back just because I think there's a certain like attachment but in all of the campaigns I I played things eventually got pretty shuffled around um yeah which as I said I think it was something I really really enjoyed about the the the campaign um just the the kind of different permutations and combinations yeah I've seen some people buy the like the recharge pack just to like make their own board on the other side not play another campaign but just kind of create a fun and there's a couple pre-built ones in the charterstone app as well which is pretty cool which I will say is pretty unique for a legacy game a lot of them boast that you can play it at the end with your own unique board and no one ever does it yeah so the fact that people do that with Charter Stone and even there's recommended like Town builds out there I think is really Co cool yeah we just we finished Ticket to Ride Legacy recently and it has that you know unlimited or the infinite game afterwards we're never going to play it again like there's just too much going on in that game but Charter Stone definitely would return too just because we you know we built our own worker placement game essentially it's pretty cool I wanted to come back to um

suspecting purple is the weakest does anyone feel how do people feel about the balance of the charters before this video I was trying to do some research search on if there were strong opinions out there and there was anecdotal ones but it didn't really seem nailed down that any were way stronger or way weaker than others which makes sense get shuffled up really yeah I didn't experience that specifically Charter to Charter but definitely like card to card ability to Ability minion to minion um those kind of would shine through uh but I don't think I noticed a specific Charter yeah we have a pretty good representation and pretty good distribution in the games in the campaigns that we played um I remember kind of going online this this goes back to when Charter snow was released um you know and people talking about you know on btg about how like oh somebody won by 100 points or something like that and I mean I have no doubt that you could Shuffle up things in a way that you know especially if there's a big skill Gap among the players that one person would build out a much better Charter than others and there's a few catchup mechanisms in the game in the campaign but you know they're they can only do so much um but you know we didn't really experience that that in any of our campaigns and the other thing that I think is interesting too and this goes back to what Garrett said um before is that you know if somebody has a much better engine you do have a lot of control over that endg game I mean you really have a lot of um opportunity to try to Speed The Campaign along or speed each game along before they can really get rolling and so I do think there was a certain you know some of the the complaints and criticisms I've seen of tur Stone I'm like oh you're you're

missing this sort of key element in that's it like if somebody's rolling rolling away with it like cut them off before they get there you know so um but yeah I mean we haven't we really didn't find that any of the charters were particularly strong or particularly dominant yeah I think I've heard some people I think because of what you're talking about with the robots here I've heard some people like they'll claim the blue one was really powerful like but I said it the buildings get so spread out I know especially online game when I would look at that display of what I could get I was just looking at the powers like at that point I'm like I don't know if this is mine or not I don't care that looks like a cool power or this I can make more use of yeah part that balancing act more powerful yeah it's really interesting just like that initial sort of how how much like an initial feeling can formulate your entire opinion about something you know 10 plays later that might have been disproven but you still had that one bad experience and it's just like that's overpowered like because of the thing you know and they don't feel versus real kind of thing yeah which deals with from time to time frustratingly from from time to time um yeah I do think that's an interesting thing just about games in general I mean I have a lot of games that are sort of on my Hit List um especially games that I played when I was first getting into the hobby that I would guess are perfectly good games but I just had a

terrible experience because of either my mood or the teacher or the other people at the table or and anything else and so I I do think that's that's it's just going to happen unfortunately a bad game with great people is a good experience you know overall so did you guys have any like frustrations that lasted through the campaign or specific moments that were like this is so frustrating the only thing that I can think of for me was um the way that you earn the Stars you have it's like an increments of 10 and there would be so many times where I'd end it like seven or eight or nine and you're just like what are we doing here like just give me the star please I'm one point away it's just it's such a frustrating like feeling not like game ruining but it just that happened fairly often and you'd always try to map that out like if I need that one last turn I'm gonna end you know at nine we need to delay because I need to end at 51 instead of 49 and actually I think I found that like a net positive overall because I really enjoy that kind of mathing in my games um but I understand like it it does feel pretty terrible to be at you know 29 or 39 or 49 or whatever I mean I do remember just like that feeling I think the only real other frustration I had was when I think somebody unlocked their first minions and I didn't realize that the minions would ultimately go into the pool um you know for everyone to get access to because I think they know they give you a game or two maybe a game um where you have your own uh your own minions and no one else can get access to them and so I was like what they get these cool Minions and I get

nothing and like I should have I should have trusted the process but um yeah think the only and actually this is weird CU I wouldn't say I was ever really frustrated until I'm currently in like game 10 or 11 of a campaign online right now and we have like three pretty difficult objectives and it's the game where you can't use minions oh yeah so you have all these minions but you can't use them so it's slower in general the objectives aren't good anymore like they're just really hard ones we can't ones we can't get right now and because it's late in the campaign there's like no buildings or boxes out top so the game's just not Progressive so the game is taking an eternity plus it's async because like I don't know a way to move this time marker forward because I can't get an objective there's no houses to build there's no crates to unlock and so it's a weird Gra that I've never said I've gone through two campaigns plus we on I think it's like game 10 like this is the first time this has evered yeah I mean this is it seems like the only option at that point is to start chucking influence and then once you're out of influence the marker will kind of go down automatically but it's also harder to get rid of influence if you can't take any of those actions either yeah it's tough to house roll a digital game to

that's what I was gonna say it being online exasperates it because like in the setup my group might have been like oh that's not fun for this game someone draw another one like oh yeah for the objectives yeah we totally would have done that yeah yeah that's the only one but yeah as you said it's mostly probably because it's online you're right we would have probably called them all again and been like those just aren't going to work well for this particular game yeah think that was it my only kind of frustrating part yeah um any other we've kind of covered a lot at this point are there any other kind of final thoughts comments experiences you w to end on here for our charterstone chat I will say I just go no no no I was just gonna say I think for me it just hit at just the right moment I mean when it came out and where I was in my gaming career and all of that that there was just something about it that was just it was so comforting and you know I think that at that time when there were sort of fewer cozy games and this is sort of a very again I found a really nice mix of it was very cozy in its feel but it also gave your brain just enough to do to be like okay can I get past that threshold of 10 can I get that extra crate open can I get that extra building built you know before the end of the game and I think those kind of two things together just made it a very unique experience yeah I definitely fell in love with the art um just like the the

design of it is just beautiful and welcoming and friendly but also you have an evil King so what are you going to do spoilers oh yeah sorry he might be good I don't all right Molly you have any other final thoughts or anything I just think I'm just trying to think of it like in a in a time when there are a lot of Legacy games it just feels like a very unique one um just building like your own little section of a town it just creates a story that like I've played twice and heard of like 20 campaigns and they all just seem different and it's just a really special little game for that and I find just enjoying the ride and not taking it too seriously it just is a really special experience it just Embrace a bit of the chaos that comes and it's a lot of fun I really liked it well car Connie thanks so much for coming on and spending some time with us and talking some Charter Stone um I think that's all I have for charstone everyone else is good yeah thanks for having me I really appreciate it yeah thanks so much for having us of course all right right thanks everyone thanks gar thank you Connie and we'll see you guys next time with who knows what cor game that we're going to

Spotlight this time byebye everyone

Progress saved