10 lessons i learned designing board games
Transcript
this video is brought to you by the three minute board game patrons keep us Independent by supporting us on patreon Kyoto Coto and welcome to the special video where I talk about 10 lessons I learned while getting my very first board game published Now red dust Rebellion is my very first game I've designed that's been formally published but it is far from my very first design in fact I've been tinkering with making board games since I was a kid and I imagine quite a few people watching this video are the same I also have a second game I've designed coming to Kickstarter in quarter 4 of 2024 and that game is Shadow Moon syndicates and hopefully I've taken some of the lessons I've learned from making red dust rebellion and put them into that game these 10 tips are very much based on my own personal experience making a board game and no one's experiences are the same so these aren't 10 golden rules or 10 commandments they're just 10 things I'd like to reflect on based on my experience and hopefully through my experiences and my pains my trials and tribulations uh you might pick out a gem of wisdom that helps you on your own design Journey so without further delay let's get on to the list the first point I want to make is that when you start out on this board game design Journey you are going to be terrible at it you are not going to be an expert and that's fine it is fine to be bad at board game design when you start out if you go out thinking that you have all the answers from from day
one and the first game idea that popped into your head as absolutely certified genius that needs to be patented you're going to have a very bad time you need to be open-minded you need to read you need to play games you need to listen to other game designers and other people in the field and learn from them open your ears hear what they have to say synergize it and then use that to create your own Visions because if you just close your ears walk out there and think that you are king from day one you're going to fail and you're going to fail hard and you're going to fail in a very embarrassing way one of the really important things I had with red dust rebellion was listening to the expertise of the people that were around me that were helping me become a better designer in particular I had Jason Carr who was the um line editor for the coin games for GMT there as a mentor for me all the way through the process and I learned a lot from him he didn't tell me what to do with the game he would just give me advice and steer me and keep me on track and help me become a better designer and there's so many resources out there that can help you improve uh there's board game Artisan groups in lots of different countries and there's a couple of other sites you can go to and get their perspective uh Jamie stagmire from stonem games has an amazing blog on this kind of stuff as well there is tons of advice and guidance and expertise out there so the key takea away from this first point is don't go in thinking you know everything from day one cuz you don't
uh my second bit of advice is to start small uh don't actually start designing a board game uh pick out a game that you really like in your current catalog and make a little expansion for it um make a character for a game or you know an add-on just to sort of play Within the game system without having to build a system from scratch so one of the first things I did uh back in the day was uh make characters for Battle Star Galactica uh for characters that um weren't in any of the official supplements uh so these are still up on Board Game Geek somewhere um in the battley Galactica files I made these back in about 2008 or 9 or so um but what they were it was a nice safe sandbox um I didn't have to build a system from the ground up I could play around with the established rules from the from the game itself and then I could just tweak the characters with within them um and then play test them with my group and play testing with my friends and have that sort of design experience um without having to start from a blank bit of paper and go what game do I want to build from scratch I think this is the way to go to start off is to just pick something and make house rules with it make an expansion uh play around with it and then test it with your friends and if that works then you know you're learning lessons as you go along and it's a lot easier to start doing something this scale uh and this easy to
test and this easy to sort of share with people uh that it is to dive straight into a board game design from scratch so yeah that's my advice for this bit start small you don't actually need to design Gloom Haven as your very first game uh or Europa universalis you can just start making mods for a game that you love uh my third bit of advice is prod protype and prototype as soon as you practically can as soon as you can get something down on paper uh do it and for me what I start doing is I use a whiteboard I am a big fan of whiteboarding when it comes to prototyping because say we're making a game called Space Cats on the moon and I'm like here's a moon here's Earth here's like a space station or whatever and we're going to divide uh things up there and then here's some influence cubes because we're using influence cubes in the game and boom I've got a Wii map that I can fiddle about with and do stuff straight off the bat and if I make mistakes or if I'm just uh coming up with things on the Fly I raise them and and I keep putting stuff on the Whiteboard until I've got a reasonable way into the design then I make one on paper and I don't do a fancy one until far far later in the process whiteboards are fantastic especially portable ones like this for getting early prototypes made and also just the bits just uh grab stuff from random games uh Red Dust
Rebellion score track for example for almost its entire existence uh was the score track from 51st state and uh the cubes I just ordered some from online or scaven some from my other coin games um make it out of bits but get the Prototype built get something done um use Magic the Gathering cards and sleeves and write on bits of white paper and just Chuck them in there if you're going to make cards get stuff built really really quickly because the sooner you're playing the game the better it is things if they stay idea concept for for too long that and you don't get them on paper you'll never get to the next stage because idea to prototype to develop develop develop and you've got to get to this prototype stage as soon as possible and it's make rubbish ones just make them out of crappy material because in that first stage of design you're going to be throwing stuff in the bin and redoing it throwing it in the bin redoing it and that's why whiteboards Little Bits of Paper uh random components just grab don't make bespoke stuff until you're really really comfortable with the design and tested it quite a bit go cheap go simple and go dry
Rays the fourth point I'd like to make is make something fun and something that you can be passionate about one of the reasons I picked uh Red Dust Rebellion to make as a game is because it combined my love of two things there three things really one is science fiction uh the second one is Mars in particular and the third one is counter insurgencies so my academic background is in military history and defense studies and I used to teach a paper at University about the ethics of armed conflict uh so this stuff plus my love for science fiction and in particular science fiction about independence from Earth all blended into make this this this game uh something I was very passionate and interested in and because you're going to be spending so much time with this game playing it over and over uh looking at the materials or the theme that you've picked for the game it needs to be something especially first off that you are really really interested in that you're passionate about that will keep your attention for the duration because a game can take a lot of time to go from uh concept to being published uh Red Dust Rebellion it was 7 years that's a little bit extreme but it brings me to my point in my experience which is you need something that will keep your interest for that entire time so if you're not into badminton probably making a board game about badminton's not a great
idea point five uh now one of the most ridiculous things I see uh new design is say is oh should I self-publish this or should I get a publisher to do it when they haven't even got a game Prototype built yet like don't get ahead of yourself don't think about marketing and selling the game until you actually have a game to Market and sell board games are not really get rich quick schemes it's very unlikely that straight out of the gate you're going to have a game that is such hot fire that Publishers are going to snap it up or that you're going to put it on Kickstarter and it will make multiple millions of dollars straight off the bat this has happened to some people so I'm not saying it's impossible it's just very very unlikely instead of focusing on marketing and selling the game before the game is finished I would focus on getting a good game that you can show people that you can develop that you can grow that then you can show off once you've got something to show off because ideas are cheap there are so many people out there with great board game ideas but what people really want to see is a finished or close to finished board game that they can play that they can sink their teeth into and that they can go yeah I can see this being fun and for me both my games were picked up by Publishers without me really having to sell them and no small part to the fact that my prototype seemed very complete and very well-rounded and that when I spoke about the game they could clearly see that I had a Clear Vision about what the game was about and where I wanted to
take it and that comes from focusing on the game first and and that's the lesson here focus on making a good game and if the game is good enough the marketing the deals all that kind of stuff they will somewhat take care of themselves another thing that's really important is don't think you need to do all the work yourself at least don't try to do all the work yourself get a developer developers developers developers developers developers developers developers developers developers developers developers developers developers Developers like the Developers for Red Dust Rebellion both Adam and Joe were so valuable to making that design work they ran a lot of play testing uh Joe design the solo mode and they gave me tons and tons of feedback that allowed me to tweak and change the design and they did two things that were really really really important the first one is they maintained a bit of a distance between me and some of the play testers so they could collate all the feedback and then give me the pressure points without me being immediately there because sometimes you can get a little drawn into the moment when you're hearing feedback as a designer right as the game's going on and the second really big thing is act as a sounding board they became as familiar with the game as I was and they could point out things and go hey this isn't quite working how would you feel about this idea and they' put something to me and I might take it on board and do it or I might go o That's inspired me to do something else having a good developer is a really really big part of making a good board
game in my opinion and for shadow Moon syndicates I've been really blessed to have Sam McDonald of the West Kingdom games and the sadian games uh the designer of those come on board as my developer and he's been fantastic to bounce ideas off he's come up with his own ideas to help improve the game as well and it's been this fantastic collaborative process getting a good developer uh just makes the experience so much better it makes the game better because you get someone who's on your wavelength but who will challenge you uh who will make you make a better game by giving you the right prompts by giving you the right feedback and empowering you to become a better designer and I think of every single point I'm going to make in this video getting a great developer is the single most important one even if that developer is your friend and they're doing it pro bono just get someone on board in that function it will dramatically improve your game because sometimes as a designer you cannot see the forest for the trees now there's an old adage out there that says that you should hear what play testers are saying uh and take that on board but don't listen to their Solutions and there's a fair bit of wisdom to be said in that my personal approach is a little bit different I like to take all of the feedback on board and hear what they they're saying and even look at their Solutions but then I like to give a lot of time to think and reflect on that before making changes I like to cogitate it over sleep on it and then go okay how are we going
to improve the game and then immediately test that so take on the feedback think can this improve the game by changing something if it does make the change and then get into testing it straight away and that should be a somewhat constant cycle of having play testing getting the feedback going through with a Vine too comb deciding what changes if any need to be make made and then personally testing the game and playing it yourself a couple of times to see how that works and I think that's a cycle and Cadence that works best for me as a designer is get the feedback think about it make any changes and then immediately test it's okay to take time thinking but once you've made that change test it straight away now the next B of advice also deals with feedback and it's about having design pillars for your games fundamental things that make the game what it is now there's a cliche that you're supposed to Kill Your Darlings when making a design and I don't actually agree with that I think there are some things that when you're making a design you have very specifically in mind that are the key to making that design what it is and if you take all the feedback on board from people and if you keep shifting your design based on the last bit of feedback you get you'll end up with something that's been essentially focused group to death sometimes you need to have values and Core Concepts that you hold on to to make the game what it is so for example
with red dust Rebellion it was the setting nothing I changed in that game or no change I would approve in that game should stop being logically consistent with the idea of an Insurrection on Mars 250 odd years from now if there was a rule suggestion no matter how good and it didn't feel right for Mars I would discard it shadowman syndicates has a couple of these pillars as well and when we went through the design process Sam and I the developer had a very good conversation over what was really important to me and really mattered and was core of the design and what we could fix and change and alter and I put down three big anchors and went no these are my design pillars one was how the cards work and all the interactions where therein uh second one was that it is fundamentally an area control game but an area control game where influence is removed from the board constantly and the final one was that there is an endgame played with cards you have set aside that you pick out on the final turn and start playing so that the final turn is far faster and far more dramatic and we changed just about everything else in the game and we changed those things for the better but that those three things were the identity of Shadow Moon syndicates and if we started changing those too much we'd be just making another game so case in point you're designing Katan you're sitting down at 95 you're designing Katan and someone walks up to you and goes I don't like dice well do you get rid of Dice from the game which is the allocation system or do you just go no actually the dice are a pretty important part of the game someone goes I don't like hi hexagons to get rid of those
there are some things in a game that make the game what they are identify what those are for your game and hold on to them because otherwise you could just get pulled by feedback back and forth and end up with basically a game that's a pile of goop Point number nine it takes an army to make a board game now sure there are some people out there who will self-publish a game they'll do all the art they'll do everything themselves but by and large that's not how it happens you'll have a cast of people that will be involved in the process uh whether it's from the publisher whether it's um their marketing people uh it's the artists involved um you can have multiple artists some might work on cards some might work on the board we had two artists for Red Dust Rebellion for example Marcos worked on the the cards and Terry worked on the board and uh the graphic design and layout so you've got this ensemble cast uh developers as as well uh play testers all these people involved in the process and you need to First treat them all with respect uh and secondly try to get the best you can out of each and every one of them think of yourself as the designer being the director of a movie and so the Publishers the producer they're the ones with the money and bringing all that stuff but they're somewhat trusting you um to bring your vision out and your developer and your um play testers they're like your cast
you need to manage them well you need to look after them um and sometimes I've been a little bit neglectful because I've had a lot of my mind and I'm a little bit of a driven personality and I can sometimes be a bit brusk with people and that has caused me some problems uh through various parts of the game design is just being a little blunt when I probably should have been more diplomatic and that's something I want to get better as uh better at as I go along with this is just remembering that yeah I've got a vision of what the game is but I'm I should not be a pradon about that I should spend more time trying to get the best out of everyone involved that's not to say I'm a complete Tyrant to work with but I definitely could have been better at times and I think that's really important when you go into this process is you know remember you're part of a team you you're going to be the designer you're going to be somewhat the star of the show or the director of the show but there are a ton of other people involved in the process and you need to take their feelings uh their desires their workflow uh their interest and their capacity into account uh when you're doing things not everyone works to the same schedule not everyone works with the same intensity and not everyone is a single-minded about your game as you're going to be uh which is you know understandable uh most other people have other things in their lives and when you're designing a board game and trying to get it over the line you can become quite mod and quite obsessed over it and you just need to manage that a little
especially I needed to manage that a little as well so to sum this one up sometimes I needed to chill the out a bit more and not be quite so much of an autter director type and that brings us to the final point which is be patient uh board games are like fine cheeses and Fine Wines they will take time uh as I said red dust Rebellion has taken seven years to get from wo to go and shadowman syndicates are designed in 2019 and it's coming to Kickstarter in 2024 now a large part of uh the issue with both those games was the pandemic kind of through a a spanner in the works of just about everyone involved in the board game industry and delayed a lot of projects and both Red Dust rebellion and Shadow in syndicates you know got at least a year or two bumped onto their times because of the pandemic and all the problems with Manufacturing in China and that was outside my control um now and thing about board game design especially with the contract I've got with GMT is they they pay me once the board game sells so I have received 0 for um Red Dust Rebellion yet uh because they haven't charged for all the pre-orders um so you aren't getting paid while games getting delayed which can be quite tense especially if you're thinking you know you got some financial problems like a little uh while back we had an issue with our roof that needed replacing and it cost us a fortune and
uh if Red Dust Rebellion hadn't been delayed by 2 years uh I probably would have in a much better position to pay for that roof but you've got to be patient that is just the nature of the game it's the nature of the industry you will get paid uh if you if you're publishing a game when it comes out and then you get a trickle of roties after that point um you can't really rely on it um unless you've sold a game like a wingspan or a ticket to ride uh that's consistently bringing in money um you you can't rely on it to arrive on schedule because so many things will delay your game um it could be little things problems with the printer uh problems thing could pop up in play testing and you just need to go be calm about it know that everyone involved in the project wants it to work because everyone involved in all these projects they want to get it over over the line just as much as you do you've just got to go it's be patient let's be calm and uh I've learned a lot about not worrying about timelines I mean I get my stuff done when I need it to get done so if I'm given timeline by the publisher I go boom I get that in but if things are pushed back for other reasons you just go and got to go that's just how it is so my final bit of advice is once you got a game of the works just be patient with everyone um it'll it
probably will happen it will probably come out um unless something really horrible and dramatic happens in which case I'm sorry but seven years it took uh from Red Dust Rebellion to go from concept to publish and yeah it's it's taught me the value of being patient so that's my 10 bits of advice for being a board game designer 10 lessons I've learned they were very personal ones um as I say I'm not sure they're hugely applicable to everyone out there I'm not sure anyone's going to have quite the same experience I did making red dust rebellion and Shadow Mo syndicates I'm not sure anyone has exact the same personality as me and uh we'll have these kind of things but I hope there's something in there um you find interesting or valuable or insightful or um just makes you curious any any other questions about what I've learned through this experience please leave them in the comments below uh and until next time take care everyone