Black Forest Rulebook Analysis (Rosenblog May 2024)
Transcript
hello everyone and welcome back to the board gaming doctor my name is Phil and I'll be your board game doctor today in this episode for the Rosen blog for this month I figured I would go ahead and analyze the rule book that was dropped for Black Forest now this is the upcoming game for Uber Rosenberg as well as Tito lawren that is slated to release later this year during Ashen Spiel and a few days after I had posted my video on the board game geek page and image analysis of the back cover and anything that was available there of course you know within a couple of days they dropped the actual rule book so in this episode I wanted to finally go ahead and read through the rule book I've already done that and kind of highlight some of the uh game highlights that I think are going to be features that make this game either stand out in comparison to Glass Ro or make it feel the same I'm not going to go through every single rule and highlight every single point like you would see in how to play video This is is just going to be the highle stuff that I think make this game stand out first thing I want to point out are in the components in the setup portion of this rule book from my previous video I was concerned that the buildings would be static each time you set up the game similar to cavna now we know that each building is assigned a number according to where it's placed on the board but that each small building has two sides to it you place all buildings on its a side and then randomly flip over uh 10 of them to their b side so each game could feel different based on what buildings are available and it's also
possible to map out your whole game to a degree strategically based on what buildings you have available from the beginning after looking at the appendix as well it seems like each side to the building seem variable enough that each side has a different cost and different functions to bring to the table there aren't they aren't wholly similar one from another and so the randomness that you're getting from flipping these buildings is great I think and I like this also have note that the large buildings which are the ones that take up two slots on your template only have one sign but as in fields of ARA they are there are a number of backup buildings that you randomly choose from at the beginning of the game so there's a little bit of variety from game to game with bees akin to the variability with certain colored buildings from fields of ARA in addition the worker placement spots are mediated by trades people tiles these take the place of the action cards in glass Road each trade person or worker placement tile is separated into five different Clans or families and you randomize where they are placed but a family tile must be placed on a printed space on the board so the randomness of where you can move your worker was corrected was correct based off of the image on the back of the box next the resource Wheels function very similarly to Glass Road any zero space and basic Goods section is automatically filled by turning the dial and creating upgraded Goods it's non-negotiable in this game one thing that is different are the provisions that are located on the upgraded Goods side on the cooking wheel they are bunched together and there are
two of these markers in that section so it feels very similar to the fields of ARA uh food tokens where you're keeping track of both food on the same overall track and you can kind of split the difference if you need to among those I see that the wheel I can maybe see the wheel being hard to balance not only to use those Provisions to move around but also potentially getting that dial stuck so you can't produce more of the upgraded good of commodity which is located there too more on that a little bit later also related to the resource wheel are jobs these tokens are shuffled and revealed as soon as you move your resource dial over two spaces on that cooking wheel these are extra resource conversion opportunities that you place based on placement rules in different spots on the board whether it's in a village or in a loc a specific spot on the board that you can move to to take advantage of during your turn they're kind of like a mix between the one-time effect and production buildings from glass Road and this new mechanism and new opportunity to do resource conversion feels very unique to this game next let's talk about what you can do on your turn you must move and you can choose to move to another location that is open in the village that you're currently in or you can move to another Village by paying the provisions to do so as we had predicted based off of the image if the final destination is occupied by other players you must give them a basic good of your choosing you can take one or two of the actions depicted on by the trades people worker placement tiles that are adjacent to your pond or you can complete a job if
it's there one or the other if you can't move you must beg and it's not like begging in ag gria you place your Pawn in the middle of the village and gain one provision but that's your whole turn a new mechanism is that you can switch around the trades people tiles which is very interesting not only are the trades people worker placement actions randomized at the beginning of the game but they can be changed from within the game to different spots so back to that commodity upgraded good if you spay uh spend one of those you can switch the place of a trades person with the traveling Merchant and this traveling Merchant resembles the supplier from glass Road where you can choose two of one basic good to gain and then everyone else gains one of that good the rules for building out your own Tableau are very similar to Glass Road the same rules apply to building buildings way that they work are very similar as well so I won't go into much detail here however two new things are added to this game you can keep livestock as designated by Stables on your board and different buildings can interact with them also on your board you have a glass hut when you take certain actions or buy things you can progress up the left-handed track that is on this piece and once you get to the top you and progress further you relocate it adding a second board adjacent to your Tau called a small estate and you place your Hut there this essentially opens up space for more Stables as well as opportunities to build your own tableau even further it's very similar to the mechanisms that you see in AA at labora where you are expanding your Tau in One
Direction in this black forest game but in multiple directions with orid labora so it's really cool to see this come back there are 12 small state tiles in the game so technically I think you can keep adding to your estate if you progress far enough on the Hut track multiple times instead of the game having predetermined rounds the game end is triggered when someone has one or more provision good uh tokens cross a c spot on their cooking dial it's located about 3/4s of the way through completing the entire circular path of the wheel so I guess this is the mark of why this game takes 1 to two hours to play you score points in the same way as glass road for the most part in addition to the livestock that you've accumulated and where your short dial is pointing on the cooking wheel so you can get some points for that too and I won't get into the solo game very much but it looks like you play the game pretty much in the same way but you place five workers back to back and play over five rounds to try to be your own score so more on that in a future video but overall I really like what this game has to offer it gives us the foundation that glass Road set and the mechanisms the resource wheel the Tableau building the buildings building tiles but tweaks it in a way that still offers some interaction between players that is very familiar in the form of worker placement which many games have but there's a lot of positive interaction where resources are given and gained simultaneously in a similar fashion to Glass Road albeit you don't have the same mind game interactions that you have with action cards but that's what makes black forest different the competition for buildings remain and
this time it feels I think even more competitive since the buildings don't refresh during the game so what you see is what you're given and so there may be a little bit more of a fight for some of the better buildings in the game I'm a little concerned that it will take longer to play I think based off of the time listed on the box it's definitely uh meant to be played at a longer time frame than last road but I think it's a minor setback if the game is fun then it's going to be just totally fine and so I'm really looking forward to playing this game once it comes out later this year so that's my overview and Analysis of the rule book let me know if I got anything wrong or if you found anything additional that you want to mention and do so in the comments below thank you for listening or viewing and hope you schedule an appointment with us real soon take care